s04e10 — Carnage of Krell

Star Wars: The Clone Wars — s04e10 — Carnage of Krell

My Rating

4.67
MyShows
658
Runtime:
Release Date: 18.11.2011 09:00
Watched by: 12 42754.4%
4 season
s04e10

Discussion: Season 4, Episode 10
Join the Discussion

18
baldarek
baldarek
16 Apr 2017, 04:55 #
Republic clones have more personality than Imperial Stormtrooper recruits.
mellory
mellory
20 Jun 2017, 05:01 #
Awesome series!
porco
porco
12 Sep 2018, 00:40 #
The Umbarians are the coolest guys in this whole story. Local militias in a terrible numerical minority are fighting for their homeland against alien invaders.. A dozen people in the" tracks " were killed, but they thwarted the attack of an entire battalion..
The clones then shot the wounded, by the way. The lights of democracy.
Miuki
Miuki
16 Jan 2020, 00:39 #
🤬 I knew from the very beginning that this is a complete sith schmuck!!
Finally, he was solved!
Thank you, Dogma, at least in the end I came to my senses!
Miuki
Miuki
16 Jan 2020, 00:39 #
Actually, these episodes on Umbar went very far, I didn't really chew on clones before, but now it's another matter, with each episode it was more interesting to watch.
GodComplex
GodComplex
12 Jan 2021, 19:27 #
Waxer 😭
MoldonDS
MoldonDS
20 Jan 2021, 09:01 #
This episode explains all the trash of the previous three. It turns out that this is not the stupidity of the general, but sabotage. The previous series have been re-evaluated))))
kate_archer
kate_archer
31 Jan 2021, 01:10 #
Even when he smiled, sending Anakin to the capital, I suspected him of being a Sith. The brute. The only cool thing about him was his swords, which we had never seen before.
ffantastt
ffantastt
16 Mar 2021, 23:56 #
Almost the best arch of the Clone Wars. A very adult plot, unrealistically beautifully shot, and ambiguous questions were asked during the four episodes. One of which is: the republic invades unoccupied worlds, destroys the local population, and intends to attach another system to itself in this way, and by force methods that cannot be justified by anything. The Republic, it turns out, is not much better than the Empire? Apparently, Palpatine's rule is taking its toll. Or have they always been like that, which is the scariest thing
sbvinn
sbvinn
16 May 2024, 15:02 #
@ffantastt: this is a very long-standing question - is the Republic better than the Empire, and why, in fact, do we take the creators at their word that the Republic is the good guys?
@sbvinn: The main sign: The empire is totalitarian and the power of one person, but the Republic is a democracy (oh, that's a worn-out word), and from here it should follow - there is more freedom =)

The more complicated Star Wars is thought out, the more contradictions it turns out. At first, it was still possible to portray a really cruel Emperor, against whom the rebels are fighting and want to return the beautiful Republic of the past...

But then they show us the fall of the Republic and its crisis to explain - and how did the Emperor appear in general?.. And we can already see that the Republic was not so beautiful. Apparently, in a Galaxy far, far away, there are only individual planets that you can sincerely sympathize with) And an interstellar-scale state always turns out to be rotten there.
MrJedi
MrJedi
09 May 2023, 01:02 #
Goosebumps from this episode. When Rex took the helmet off the fighter... a terrible realization. This arch is magnificent in everything, a very beautiful planet, beautiful and unusual ships, plants, wonderful fighting, ambiguous actions of the Republic, when there is no right choice, each side defended and saved itself, realizing the consequences of its decisions, and all this is terrible, the Umbarians defended themselves amazingly
The moral choice of the clones was perfectly shown, Dogma was frankly sorry, his own opinion cost him dearly. And Rex... he was ready to let two fighters be shot, waiting until the last moment for him to stop the execution, but apparently, like Dogma, he needed a "reset" of consciousness with shock therapy (Anakin was right when he said they were similar), so his final words, they already sound like Rex with a new awareness of himself. Separately, it's a shame for the Waxer(
Miloki
Miloki
07 Aug 2023, 15:57 #
Hurray!!! The vile toad was discovered and destroyed😌
sbvinn
sbvinn
16 May 2024, 15:02 #
@Miloki: outplayed and destroyed, for that matter))
BESToloch
BESToloch
30 Oct 2023, 15:08 #
3 episodes led to this. I can't say that the previous ones paid off. They tightened the arch and showed it in places extremely sloppy and improbable. An emotional scenario often has a lot of holes. Alas.
alekseight
alekseight
21 Jan 2025, 07:08 #
It's the best arch for me so far. The first two episodes feature amazing camerawork and camera movements, which only reinforce this heavy atmosphere of fighting, filled with losses.

Krell also bothered me with his yellow eyes at the end of the previous episode. However, I quickly took myself away from the thought of his dark side, because there the emphasis is more on fire, they say, he is a sadist and only enjoys bloodshed and violence.

But perhaps the strongest delight is from the motives in the series and the very difficulty of confronting it. His reputation, insubordination, and force-user behavior are on his side here. No matter which way you approach it, it's difficult to look at it, being a clone, for several far from simple reasons at once.

The only thing I hope for is that somewhere they will show us why Anakin was so pulled, and it will be something important. Because without context, there are already a lot of questions: did the Jedi Council really approve such a replacement right on the battlefield, because otherwise Krell would have been suspected and he would no longer be able to sabotage the Republic's operations; if Anakin was pulled for nothing, then again, questions arose, but to the chancellor. And while these details are missing, well, it's a scenic grand piano in the bushes. Yes, he gave me a great "inner enemy", but still.
Regisha_milk
Regisha_milk
23 Aug 2025, 01:25 #
Wait! This is wrong! And we all know that. The general makes a mistake and must answer for it. Clones shouldn't die like this! We are loyal soldiers. We follow orders, but we're not a bunch of brainless droids! We are fighters. We have to make our own decisions, especially if the orders we give are wrong!
id639106806
id639106806
04 Nov 2025, 16:53 #
Krell of filth
Leave a Comment: