Advertising

s01e05 — Smoke and Mirrors

The Crown — s01e05 — Smoke and Mirrors

My Rating

4.682
MyShows
(2 117)

Where to watch

NetflixNetflix Standard with Ads
Runtime: 55 min.
Release Date: 04.11.201604.11.2016 15:00
Watched by: 35 51252.45%
1 season
s01e05
s01e01 - Wolferton Splash
s01e02 - Hyde Park Corner
s01e03 - Windsor
s01e04 - Act of God
s01e05 - Smoke and Mirrors
s01e06 - Gelignite
s01e07 - Scientia Potentia Est
s01e08 - Pride and Joy
s01e09 - Assassins

Discussion: Season 1, Episode 5
Join the Discussion

88
Follow all new comments for this episode
Instructions
Luizot
Luizot
07 Nov 2016, 02:52 #
Philip's situation is still difficult - it seems like the queen's husband, but in fact he is right - zilch! I even feel sorry for him somehow!
Shodan69
Shodan69
06 Feb 2022, 16:00 #
@Luizot: Why would you feel sorry for him? His rights are equal to those of the Queen Consort. Or is it possible to belittle a woman, but not a woman?
nens8_8y
nens8_8y
11 Mar 2024, 23:15 #
@Luizot: wasn't he and his relatives in the first episode happy about what a lucky ticket he had drawn by marrying the heiress to the British throne? He and his family did not have their own position in society, were expelled from their own country and had rather modest prospects, but were ambitious and ambitious. I was well aware of the difference in their statuses, but I still chose it for myself, so why feel sorry for him? I would have found some decent business long ago, isn't there a job in the whole empire, how to choose wallpaper or plan a coronation all year round?
sebasharman
sebasharman
07 Nov 2016, 22:58 #
I admire every episode, which of Smith is the amazing Prince Philip
krokodilova
krokodilova
11 Jan 2017, 18:37 #
Show comment
Gehirn
Gehirn
13 Jun 2017, 04:04 #
@Taksi: Why?
littlehedgehog
littlehedgehog
08 Nov 2016, 00:29 #
I looked at photos of Albert at that time, the actor and costumers managed to achieve an almost portrait resemblance!
midnight22
midnight22
10 Dec 2022, 14:22 #
@littlehedgehog: Who is Albert?
Alaska_kek
Alaska_kek
13 Aug 2023, 23:28 #
Apparently, this is about George 6, her father
Rjkktu
Rjkktu
09 Nov 2016, 04:46 #
The last scene is just ah.
irene_ks
irene_ks
06 Mar 2017, 20:30 #
@Rjkktu: Yes, the tears of the Duke of Windsor are worth a lot. It's heartbreaking.
Zoyarekomendyet
Zoyarekomendyet
12 Apr 2021, 02:11 #
Yes, it only came to me by the end of episode 5 that I was watching the movie "We. We Believe in love" about Edward and VIII and Wallis Simpson.
purumpumpum
purumpumpum
22 Sep 2021, 21:23 #
The film seems to romanticize their story, although looking at Edward's bile shown in the series, and there is also a story about a connection with the Nazis - romanticization seems out of place at all
Flegmatichka
Flegmatichka
22 Sep 2021, 21:41 #
@purumpumpum: There will be a separate episode about the connection with the Nazis, as far as I remember
Smartcookie
Smartcookie
PRO
10 Nov 2016, 12:24 #
Philip began to annoy with his claims. I saw who he was marrying, but if not, I still need to shake my rights.

The last scene is gorgeous. Throughout the series, there was a feeling that the Duke of Windsor regretted his abdication and all the sarcasm and bile against the royal family came from there.
Aggie
Aggie
19 Nov 2016, 02:24 #
@Smartcookie: I agree. I'm watching the Crown right after Victoria. and I involuntarily compare the two husbands. Victoria's husband is reliable and accommodating. And Philip is acting up like a child
Mmoloko
Mmoloko
19 Nov 2016, 15:28 #
Show comment
Not_Ulysses
Not_Ulysses
04 Jul 2018, 00:34 #
@Aggie: Victoria's husband in the TV series Victoria also showed a character more than once, you looked at it inattentively.
poiree
poiree
22 Apr 2017, 23:45 #
Show comment
tweedlecat
tweedlecat
PRO
17 Sep 2017, 20:55 #
@poiree: Only it's not his last name.
Not_Ulysses
Not_Ulysses
04 Jul 2018, 00:44 #
@poiree: This part of the family should not have ruled the country at all, Uncle David and his offspring should have. He renounced and it turned out as it turned out. By the way, Uncle's bile is from remorse. He realized that he refused to be a "god", and became a "mere mortal" for the sake of a very dubious lady. The mistake of youth comes out.

P.S. Is it not on his story that an advertisement for Richard tea was concocted, where the king was forbidden to marry, and he abdicated. I can't help but draw parallels. Who is interested, here is the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=62J67u8H_j8
darthtatyan
darthtatyan
06 Dec 2019, 07:08 #
well, not really.
* by the time of the engagement and, especially, the wedding, David had long ago renounced and Elizabeth was the direct heir.
* the mistake of youth also does not work very well, since David was 42 years old when he abdicated.

I will only agree about the dubious lady: for some reason it is silent here, but her main problem was not so much in divorces, but in relations with Hitler and his regime.
actually, because of the latter, the family avoided communicating with both of them — very logical, I think, for the post-war period..
Flegmatichka
Flegmatichka
26 Feb 2020, 04:54 #
@darthtatyan: Yes, in the movie "The King Speaks" it was mentioned that in connection with this there was a renunciation - not entirely voluntary.
The King had no right to be associated with the Nazis in any way.
ЯночкаКокуркина
ЯночкаКокуркина
PRO
13 Oct 2021, 12:12 #
@Not_ulysses: Oh, yes, I remember that video.
Langdon_
Langdon_
11 Nov 2016, 00:51 #
She hardly breathed during the coronation, and when Philip knelt, she held her breath. *__*
Edwina
Edwina
20 Nov 2016, 03:19 #
Philip's strength and power lies precisely in the fact that he sacrificed his personal ambitions for the sake of his Queen. Even now, in his late 90s, he is beautiful with real male beauty.
smetana_sg
smetana_sg
13 Jan 2017, 04:38 #
@Edwina: that's it:)
Melhiorat
Melhiorat
08 Nov 2017, 05:45 #
Comment has been deleted
Shodan69
Shodan69
06 Feb 2022, 16:02 #
@Edwina: What are your personal ambitions? The most he could claim was a career in the Navy. His "title" from birth is zilch. There is only the arrogance of a wronged boy.
KaterinaVoyler
KaterinaVoyler
29 Nov 2016, 00:24 #
David, the Duke of Windsor, is a very interesting character. Sometimes I want him to choke on his bile, and sometimes I feel sorry for him.
The ceremony is very beautiful. Philip has organized everything perfectly. And he showed it to the whole world.
FairyDream
FairyDream
20 Mar 2017, 14:48 #
Edward/David was made a completely moral freak.
I wonder how the royal family has such an interpretation of events in general?
kuroken
kuroken
PRO
18 Jun 2018, 22:47 #
I asked a similar question, but I believe that the series was made with the approval of the royal family/ its representatives, etc.
Натали_93
Натали_93
03 Sep 2017, 21:50 #
a very good series, this is how you need to show the story in schools + discussion and facts, children would know the story))))
LiMy
LiMy
16 Jul 2018, 00:58 #
♥♥♥♥♥
chch93
chch93
08 Aug 2018, 23:23 #
There is something caramel in the British accent, I look with such pleasure with subtitles.

George's stuttering looks so charming, especially when performed by Harris.
It is even somewhat ironic that neither her father nor Elizabeth herself wanted this power, and at the same time had no opportunity to give it up. How much uncertainty this young girl is experiencing, trying not to show her weakness to anyone...

How Lilibet tries for her husband, just throws all her strength, breaking this ossified system, if not completely, then at least leaving cracks.
Philip says the right things, but why is it always at the wrong time, not at the funeral of his wife's grandmother, no? If only he had more tact and less boyish impudence, there would be no price at all.
Although how hard it is to break their conservatives, like so, cameras in the church. For us, of course, all this is a bit wild now, we have been accustomed for more than half a century that from any pot you can look at any action in any corner of the world at will. And Philip argues very correctly: when the country is in such economic and social decline, it is not the time to start a pump. But what pride sometimes does not allow him to see the truth - in some things you have to give in, she should not run and persuade you, this is now your duty too. You have chosen this fate, there is no escape from it.

Eduard and his tears for the lost power here do not touch at all. You also made your choice, you followed the call of your heart, hung out with a man who destroyed half of Europe, traveled endlessly on his position as a member of the royal family, fidgeted behind the backs of those who paid your bills, and this is just a small list. I do not consider him a moral freak or some kind of monster, for me he is just a weak person who wanted to live beautifully more than anything else in the world and at the same time not be responsible for anything and do nothing.
ah_egorova
ah_egorova
PRO
25 Nov 2018, 13:38 #
A lot of people don't like Tommy. He's really not the nicest person. But how did he reject that filthy Edward/David. Fine. He reminds me a bit of Varys from Game of Thrones. He served the throne, not the kings. Tommy is the same, I think. He is devoted to the Crown. He has been at court for 33 years and clearly understands what's what. He sees people who are who. Maybe he will turn out to be a scoundrel. But he's doing great now.
Sshadow7
Sshadow7
10 Feb 2019, 07:38 #
!!!
Plus sign
He also infuriated me sometimes, but really, he did everything for the benefit of the state
justlikefiiire
justlikefiiire
28 Aug 2019, 22:16 #
It's magical. That the coronation is in Victoria, that it looks great here. Philip certainly has a very difficult character, but he will really make sacrifices and perform his duties for the queen. And yes, the moment when he knelt was so tense. Uhh.
julieinthetardis
julieinthetardis
02 Oct 2019, 02:43 #
I really liked the phrase about Philip, that his profession is to be the husband of the Queen, it is very touching at the moment where he swears to serve Elizabeth to death, the realization that he is still doing it, as they say, live long Duke of Edinburgh! Philip's criticism that he is impulsive, has a sense of pride and all that further indicates that in the series they try to show the characters as real and real people, and not cardboard characters with the same polarity

Alex Jennings plays Edward incomparably, I just want to feel sorry for him, and everything. but, probably, if a greater historical background was mentioned here about him, then the first feeling would not arise from the word vooooooo, but as he is a kind of martyr in the name of love and trampling on traditions
TsinoevaAlisa14
TsinoevaAlisa14
05 Nov 2020, 03:34 #
Actually, it reminded me of a scene from the movie The Princess of Monaco (a conversation between Hitchcock and Grace Kelly). There is also a monarchic internal conflict, because she had to give up her dream, her profession, and her acting career. But Alfred said a very wise thing, that she needed to sacrifice her interests for the good of the country and her family, and that her main role in life was to be a wife for the prince.
Perhaps not the best comparison, but Phillip is in the same situation. To fulfill his most important official duty to Great Britain - to be a husband to the queen, to give up something, and to give in to something.
Yes, it is undoubtedly hard, as a person feels sorry for him (and indeed like a bird in a cage), but still a)he knew what he was doing when he got married, b) humility in this case is a direct indicator of masculinity and fortitude.
julieinthetardis
julieinthetardis
06 Nov 2020, 01:13 #
@TsinoevaAlisa14: both the "Princess of Monaco" and the "Crown" in the context of this sacrifice once again make you think that the monarchy is, of course, beautiful, majestic, but such a thing is already outdated for the modern world
nadinsmit
nadinsmit
22 Nov 2019, 00:21 #
I really like the inserts at the beginning of the series with Edward, Jared Harris is gorgeous
nadinsmit
nadinsmit
22 Nov 2019, 00:54 #
@nadinsmit: *By George the Sixth
ogoltelo
ogoltelo
11 Sep 2022, 03:35 #
@nadinsmit: I'm also happy about them) and from the point of view of history, understanding the characters is very interesting.
jestwitch
jestwitch
07 Jan 2020, 00:45 #
Show comment
Adele_Rinat
Adele_Rinat
05 Apr 2020, 11:52 #
Philip's position is not easy, but it seems to me that it is possible not to shake the rights when it comes to the crown and the queen's reputation.

And Edward is such a terrible person filled with bile, and it seems to me that over 17 years a lot of it has accumulated, but he knew what he was doing, he knew the laws and what he was going to lose, but he's still angry at everyone. He may have given up everything for love, but the tears showed that love is not always enough. After all, he had been trained for this since childhood.
Nog
Nog
27 May 2020, 01:36 #
At the beginning of the series, how ridiculous does this magnificent crown look in combination with modern clothes.
seriesomniac
seriesomniac
03 Sep 2020, 03:30 #
And I kept thinking, when will Phillip's male ego finally crack at the seams? It's already been half a season. Married to a queen, almost a goddess, what more could you want? I don't know, the scene with his oath and worship was very touching and beautiful. I didn't see anything humiliating or degrading about her. on the contrary, such a gesture of devotion and love for his wife and queen, shown to the whole world, is worthy of respect and admiration. And this crown with a red cape is simply magnificent!
reflexenia
reflexenia
18 Sep 2020, 00:17 #
Well, it's a great episode again. Tommy is wonderful. In general, I love it when the British swear: without swearing, shouting, but these harsh intonations, this spitting out harsh words, wow. Philip and Elizabeth's quarrel is interesting, Phil can understand. The times are patriarchal and it feels like just an app without that. But it seems to me that he was moved when he saw Lisa in all this attire. At that moment, he accepted his fate and his role and the fact that he married an extraordinary woman. The coronation, the anointing, everything is very beautiful, and the Duke of Windsor is right.: It's magic. And people need that kind of magic. The last scene is strong. Perhaps somewhere in California, Harry's family also misses his homeland.
TsinoevaAlisa14
TsinoevaAlisa14
05 Nov 2020, 03:18 #
Edward playing the bagpipes is a very powerful scene. Either homesickness, or, nevertheless, annoyance and bitterness at the missed position of "God."
ogoltelo
ogoltelo
11 Sep 2022, 03:44 #
@TsinoevaAlisa14: and this mantra "I did it for love" - at first it seemed to me that it was posturing, after this episode I think it was autosuggestion. I was given greatness, but I got parties with the money I begged for)
DianaDS
DianaDS
16 Nov 2020, 21:45 #
The final shot in this episode is simply the best and very strong! 👍🏼
smilanich
smilanich
19 Nov 2020, 01:19 #
did they show real footage on TV, or was it still modern shooting?
I was very happy about the scenes with King George, I was afraid that he would not be there anymore
Шерва
Шерва
18 Jul 2021, 19:10 #
@smilanich: real shots, there you can see a real dress embroidered with the colors of all the Union republics (? I'm not sure if the word is correct)
kate-green
kate-green
27 Nov 2020, 05:19 #
And then I realized that Matt Smith was not talking to Churchill for the first time. I'm not sure about the order, I just got to the Crown now, but they crossed paths a couple of times in the Doctor
Snegnarek
Snegnarek
13 Jan 2021, 22:34 #
@kate-green: the series in which the Doctor married Elizabeth 👍
Shaffl
Shaffl
15 Nov 2022, 23:33 #
@Snegnarek: but not on this one)
mysh_krodetsya
mysh_krodetsya
27 Nov 2020, 23:53 #
The whole impression of the coronation was spoiled by the caustic comments of this envious old man.
northways
northways
16 Dec 2020, 03:35 #
Elizabeth's actress reminds me a lot of Emilia Clarke, she would be very suitable for this role too.
Cineman
Cineman
21 Jan 2021, 04:54 #
It felt like Phillip forced his body to bow, a great scene.
Catherine24
Catherine24
29 Jan 2021, 05:39 #
The moment of coronation is simply goosebumps! Very strong and beautiful 💔
tasyann
tasyann
10 Mar 2021, 18:57 #
It's a very beautiful series finale, right up to goosebumps. 💔
GossipGirl007
GossipGirl007
10 Mar 2021, 20:11 #
I haven't looked into the sources, so I can't say if this is true or a script move, but the idea of recording the coronation is very good! And most importantly, as time has shown, Elizabeth has ruled for 69 years. And Charles never ascended the throne.
ogoltelo
ogoltelo
11 Sep 2022, 03:47 #
@GossipGirl007: Historical commentary: entered )
Araminta
Araminta
24 Mar 2021, 19:35 #
It's strange, but I see a direct connection between Elizabeth's actions and the current scandals in the British monarchy. She was the first to shake the throne with petty disobedience. Either her husband is arranging a coronation, or he wants to change his royal surname. Margaret continues to undermine with her behavior. And after reading the biography, we find out that she was, to put it mildly, loving and did nothing but enjoy her pleasures. Elizabeth practically did not deal with children, as a result, Charles has a history with tampons and the biggest scandal with Diana, and Andrew is accused of pedophilia. There's no need to mention Harry and Megan anymore. That's what the butterfly effect is called.
EyeOfTheRaven
EyeOfTheRaven
PRO
25 Jun 2021, 21:43 #
In my opinion, there is nothing wrong with changing something over time, making adjustments, because time does not stand still and what used to be is not always good. Some things become obsolete one way or another, there's no getting away from it.
fb1273958
fb1273958
14 Sep 2022, 03:46 #
@vk504806: if you do not change, then you can face a new Cromwell and the executions of the King. Another question is how to implement and accept changes
shilyaevaks
shilyaevaks
PRO
03 Apr 2021, 16:41 #
The beginning of the series is cool
shilyaevaks
shilyaevaks
PRO
03 Apr 2021, 17:32 #
Phillip, why didn't you know who you were marrying!?
loremipsum
loremipsum
PRO
12 Apr 2021, 02:47 #
I can't hold back my tears, because Philip really served his Queen until his death..
Шерва
Шерва
18 Jul 2021, 19:07 #
It is a pity that the costumers did not make at least a remotely similar dress to what was at the real coronation, there is such a beautiful dress filled with symbolism..You can see it in the fragments of the chronicle inserted
berion87
berion87
PRO
08 Oct 2021, 12:25 #
The argument about worship led to an idea - to whom a man should / can kneel. Mother. Wife. Homeland (in the republic. in a monarchy, a Ruler and/or Crown are added to the Homeland).
and so the man bows down as he wants. at least on my knees all the time))) Anastasia: "Sick...".
_CAPKA3M_
_CAPKA3M_
25 Nov 2021, 19:32 #
The Duke of Windsor broke my heart in the last scene.
The finale of the series gave me an idea: how hard it is to go against those family traditions that are brought up in us from birth. And it's even harder to believe all your life that you're making the right choice, that you've made your life happier. This is a war with oneself that cannot always be won. Usually, you need a therapist. I hug Albert and hope that in reality he did not grieve for the crown as much
Shodan69
Shodan69
06 Feb 2022, 16:05 #
It seems to me that over time David realized that Wallis was not worth it, but he continued to hold on to her, continued to deliberately love her and hate his family so that no one would dare to reproach him that it was all in vain. For you can sacrifice immortality only for the sake of eternal love, and not a relationship for 10 years. He really wanted to be king, and when they watched the coronation, he just dreamed of being in Elizabeth's place. A wonderful character, so controversial.
deepressure
deepressure
26 Jun 2023, 20:33 #
According to Wikipedia, they lived together for 36 years
Birkka
Birkka
28 Jul 2022, 13:11 #
Philip/Matthew is incredible, I really like the way he plays, how the Duke's character is shown, especially compared to the restrained and prim Brits.

Well, the final scene with the bagpipes was very touching - I can't say that David is vile or envious, yet he loved Elizabeth very much, but these tears of his were very eloquent
ogoltelo
ogoltelo
11 Sep 2022, 04:03 #
A great series. Again, of course, an emotional meat grinder, I'm already getting used to it) How sorry it was for the dying Queen Mary - she whispers to her son "Don't go away", and against the background of his sarcastic comments. Even if there were difficult relationships in the past - he ended up married to his beautiful woman, what more could he want, what could he be offended by? The feeling that his sarcasm and venom are the only things he can use to displace regret and nostalgia.
The taming of the obstinate Philip is a separate song) and not such knights worshipped a beautiful lady and nothing, no one's masculinity suffered, it's even attractive, damn it)
moonchildeus
moonchildeus
28 Sep 2022, 07:20 #
And I like the way Edward is shown here. he was much worse in reality, he also complained a lot about being kicked out, that money was not allocated enough, and was also a fascist. and he wrote a lot of insulting letters about relatives. but the series is beautifully finished, you can't say anything, the actor was picked up perfectly.
Matt Smith also portrays Phillip very well. He was really very disappointed to move out of the Clarence residence, but he was upset that he would have to obey Elizabeth. He was "slightly" moody, so to speak…

I can't break away from the series at all, I generally have problems with concentration and perseverance, especially when the series is longer than half an hour, but for some reason 50+ minutes run unnoticed with the crown.
moonchildeus
moonchildeus
28 Sep 2022, 07:26 #
By the way, I was very surprised that the screenwriters did not forget about King George's stuttering!! all his life he had problems with this, at the beginning of his reign he was extremely uncomfortable, so he worked on stuttering. as a result, I almost got rid of it!
Fadelena
Fadelena
20 Nov 2022, 23:06 #
The Archbishop makes the signs of the cross from right to left, then from left to right...
Insania
Insania
05 Apr 2023, 10:40 #
Edward behaves obscenely hypocritical, and it is extremely unworthy to speak so about his own family, even under the circumstances. At the same time, his aggression against his native country, family and mother sounds exaggerated, like an attempt to convince himself that he did the right thing for love. On the other hand, at certain moments, he looks lonely, and does not want to let go of his past at all, tormenting himself (he even created a secluded island of memories in the attic).
RavenDarkholme
RavenDarkholme
22 Nov 2023, 02:42 #
The coronation was shown just great. And God, how disgusting her uncle and his wife are)
OXZZEBABI
OXZZEBABI
07 Feb 2024, 20:27 #
عخ
nens8_8y
nens8_8y
11 Mar 2024, 23:51 #
It is not very worthy of a husband, partner -- to humiliate your wife, her life's work and her achievements, calling it "royal". Especially at the beginning of her journey, when it is so difficult and so necessary for her support.
With the broadcast of the coronation, I agree with Philip's arguments, at least he is doing something right.
PinguinKo
PinguinKo
28 Jul 2024, 12:34 #
Everything is fine - how old bellows tear when new wine is poured into them, how difficult decisions are made and how not to regret them later, how much effort it takes to move even a millimeter out of a century-old rut...

I like the way the Duke of Windsor's complex emotions are played out. Letters, caustic comments, two cigarettes and this bagpipe in the fog.

I wonder how the Duke of Edinburgh really experienced this time. It seems to me that the creators of the series have turned up too much drama.

And only translators want to tear their hands off. "Smoke and Mirrors" - "Dust in the eyes", how can you work so clumsily. And I haven't heard this dubbing yet 🤦
abnoyga
abnoyga
29 Nov 2024, 19:37 #
Comment has been deleted
abnoyga
abnoyga
29 Nov 2024, 19:40 #
they have such a fucking phone
muntykooshps
muntykooshps
04 Dec 2024, 21:49 #
By the fifth episode, I already hate Philip as a man and a man.
I'm reviewing the series, and I remember that from now on it will be possible to hate him as a father too, what a disgusting person
Livida
Livida
27 Aug 2025, 23:13 #
Still, what a great idea it was to have cameras at the coronation.
id264460076
id264460076
26 Nov 2025, 15:52 #
But I don't feel sorry for Windsor from the word at all. Why feel sorry for him? He is an adult, living the life he has chosen for himself. What I fought for, as they say.

Philip *yazhmuzhik* Edinburgh... Well, really, I'm tired of it already.

The Queen Mother is such a sweet woman.
Leave a Comment:
Instructions
Follow all new comments for this episode
Advertising