Ads
Philip K. Dick's Electric Dreams — s01e03 — The Commuter

My rating

Rate
Rate the shows you've watched and get up-to-date recommendations
4.137
MyShows
(1 633)
Duration: 48 min.
Released: 01.10.201701.10.2017 14:00
Watched by: 12 46153.77%
1 season
s01e03
s01e01 - The Hood Maker
s01e02 - Impossible Planet
s01e03 - The Commuter
s01e04 - Crazy Diamond
s01e05 - Real Life
s01e06 - Human Is
s01e07 - The Father Thing
s01e08 - Autofac
s01e09 - Safe and Sound

Discussion of the 3 episode of the 1 season
Discuss this episode
70

Oropher
Oropher
02 Oct 2017, 19:26 #
So, what do we have:
1. The "divine" wormhole;
2. The "extra" people for whom it is intended to be a new home;
3. A tempting opportunity to get rid of problems and/or gnawing emotions;
4. The main character, who has the courage to make a difficult decision, knowing in advance about the consequences.
And all together it adds up to a story about the substitution of reality, about WHAT defines everyone as a person and a personality.
The series complements and expands the original story, a good adaptation, a colorful cast, a wild atmosphere is available. Gorgeous!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+158
ShumaXer
ShumaXer
03 Oct 2017, 03:15 #
It remains only to understand the essence of the series.everything else is incredibly beautiful
Reply
Show
who liked?
+36
RaDeman
RaDeman
07 Oct 2017, 02:34 #
@ShumaXer: and judging by the first comment, it is urgently necessary to read the original
Reply
Show
who liked?
+18
Voynov
Voynov
03 Oct 2017, 03:35 #
So far, the best of the 3 released episodes!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+115
emergent
emergent
04 Oct 2017, 03:29 #
@Voynov: support
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
Ba-l
Ba-l
07 Oct 2017, 03:42 #
@Voynov: +1!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+1
irishkakoroleva
irishkakoroleva
03 Oct 2017, 20:57 #
The series is just wonderful. I really like this series.
Unfortunately, I have not read the stories, but I really, really want to do it.
P.S. How Timothy Spall has aged after all...
Reply
Show
who liked?
+15
alx
alx
05 Oct 2017, 02:23 #
@irishkakoroleva: There's nothing stopping you from reading them as the episodes come out. There's a maximum of five to ten minutes for a story. For example, that's exactly what I do.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+26
sobaka2017
sobaka2017
05 Oct 2017, 04:19 #
@alx: I didn't find the stories for the first two episodes. Can you tell me where you read them?
Reply
Show
who liked?
-1
alx
alx
05 Oct 2017, 11:42 #
@sobaka2017: There were links to the collection of all the stories in the comments: flibusta.is/b/489478 — all three are there and some of the next ones will be there too.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+12
alx
alx
05 Oct 2017, 12:09 #
I transferred all three to the telegraph, in case you suddenly don't have a VPN:
http://telegra.ph/Kapyushonshchik-10-05
http://telegra.ph/Planeta-kotoroj-ne-bylo-10-05
http://telegra.ph/Proezdnoj-bilet-10-05
Reply
Show
who liked?
+48
sobaka2017
sobaka2017
06 Oct 2017, 07:15 #
@alx: thank you very much, everything opens through the Tor)
Reply
Show
who liked?
+4
id267648769
id267648769
03 Oct 2017, 22:43 #
The most creditable series.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
Gordey
Gordey
04 Oct 2017, 01:03 #
It's a hard choice and the right choice.. After all, his son is not just evil or bad, but ill.. Wasn't it easier for him like this?..
Reply
Show
who liked?
+13
GAMEMASSACRE
GAMEMASSACRE
04 Oct 2017, 18:02 #
Travel ticket
(The Commuter)
The little man slowly pushed his way through the crowd of people who filled the foyer of the railway station to the ticket window. He was tired, and you could tell by the way his shoulders sagged, and even by the way his brown coat sagged. He was waiting impatiently for his turn.
—Next," breathed Ed Jacobson, who was selling tickets.
The little man shoved a five-dollar bill through the window.
"Give me a ticket, the old one is over," he stared at the clock hanging behind Jacobson. "Oh, my God, is it really that late?"
Jacobson took five dollars.
— O.K. Travel card. To which station?
—Macon Heights,— the little man replied.
—Macon Heights,— Jacobson looked at the diagram. — Macon Heights? There is no such station.
The little man's face froze. He looked at Ed suspiciously.
— Is this some kind of joke?
— Mister, there is no such place as Macon Heights. I cannot sell you a ticket if there is no such station.
— What do you want to say? I live there!
— I don't care. I've been selling tickets for six years now. There is no such place.
The little man's eyes bulged in amazement.
— But I have a house there. I go there every night. I...
" Here,— Jacobson handed him his diagram. — Look for it.
The little man grabbed the diagram and began frantically running his trembling fingers through the list of cities.
— Have you found it? Jacobson asked, sticking his head out the window. "He's not here, is he?"
The little man shook his head. He was visibly shaken.
— I don't understand anything. That's nonsense. There must be something wrong.
Surely there must be some kind of…
And suddenly he was gone. The diagram fell to the concrete floor. Shorty was gone—Before Ed could blink, Shorty was gone.
—Holy Ghost,— he breathed. His mouth opened and closed noiselessly. And only the diagram remained lying on the concrete floor.
Shorty ceased to exist.

— And then what? Bob Payne asked.
— I went out into the lobby and picked up the diagram.
— Did he really disappear?
— Well, yes, he disappeared, — Jacobson wiped the sweat from his forehead. "It's a pity you weren't around. He disappeared as if the lights had been turned off. Absolutely. Mute. No movement...
Reply
Show
who liked?
-17
alx
alx
04 Oct 2017, 18:18 #
Why insert the text of the original story here? Moreover, it is only the very beginning. It's easier to give a link: http://lib.ru/INOFANT/DICKP/ticket.txt_with-big-pictures.html
Reply
Show
who liked?
+40
nasya
nasya
04 Oct 2017, 19:17 #
I really liked the series. The main character was given the opportunity to change his life, get rid of what makes his family unhappy. I'm still not sure if he did the right thing by refusing. After all, the son seems to have real mental problems and perhaps he will break the life not only for himself, but also for others. Of course, maybe the father thought he could prevent this or just put up with it and accept the consequences of his son's actions. In any case, the point of no return has been passed for him and we have an open finale of his choice
in front of us. P.S. it seems this is still the best of 3 episodes, everything is very harmonious and in its place.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+47
AD-Rock
AD-Rock
05 Oct 2017, 03:50 #
@nasya: this is just a closed final. It would be open if in the last frame they showed how the hero went home and ... think about it yourself
Reply
Show
who liked?
+49
nasya
nasya
05 Oct 2017, 15:32 #
@AD-Rock: Well, I guess I didn't put it quite right. I meant whether he would be able to change/help his son or not.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+6
stewardtz
stewardtz
05 Oct 2017, 01:10 #
After the nonsense of the previous two episodes, I watched the third one with pleasure.
For a long time I remembered where I saw the main character - it's Peter Pettigrew :)
Reply
Show
who liked?
+35
Basson
Basson
05 Oct 2017, 03:37 #
@stewardtz: What didn't you like about the first episode? For me, it was at least the most understandable.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+10
stewardtz
stewardtz
05 Oct 2017, 13:20 #
@Basson: nothing at all - I have a lot of questions there that no one has answered so intelligibly. All this can be read in the comments to the series.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+4
rock_dawg_
rock_dawg_
05 Oct 2017, 12:28 #
Can someone explain to me?
It turns out that she takes people to Macon Heights who are undesirable in society? But then why did she take the waitress? Or did she give up on her own in order not to suffer in the real world?
And yet, at the end of the episode, this man in a coat (who harms children) said that he tried to come back, but it didn't work out because he had no choice. But then he went and got on the train...
why do some stay there overnight and some go back?)

And the series is cool, much better than the previous one, as for me.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+40
RaDeman
RaDeman
07 Oct 2017, 02:41 #
@rock_dawg_: mb those who remain are people "who got rid of" like the main character from his son.
And the dude from the preacher, who harms children, also wanted to return his life to the way it was before the first visit to this paradise, but could not, unlike the main character
And also, I orgasm with my eyes every time I watch an intro, it's just tin))
Reply
Show
who liked?
+1
aluxa
aluxa
05 Oct 2017, 19:11 #
Each episode has its own twist, but I think this series is one of the best))
You can understand Ed why he wanted to return everything as it was, who has children (whatever they grow up to be), that is, a happy memory (as on the tapes), the first steps of the child, the first words...It's all touching
Reply
Show
who liked?
+7
riphkin
riphkin
06 Oct 2017, 10:53 #
The transfer to modern times did not deprive the series of a wild atmosphere. At the same time, the picture is very suitable, as if I'm rereading it again...
Reply
Show
who liked?
+9
korobovski
korobovski
PRO
06 Oct 2017, 14:24 #
Great series, strong plot! we were very pleased with familiar actors in new roles, namely Fiora from "The Preacher" and Riley Blue from "Sense 8" :))
Reply
Show
who liked?
+24
OlgaGorbunova
OlgaGorbunova
16 Sep 2018, 00:16 #
@korobovski: What about scabbers from Harry Potter?)
Reply
Show
who liked?
+4
korobovski
korobovski
PRO
05 Oct 2018, 02:36 #
@OlgaGorbunova: And really, he didn't admit it! thank you))
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
RaDeman
RaDeman
07 Oct 2017, 02:33 #
stairs are generally boooomba. how interesting it was to film the hero's ascent along it, and then what happened
Reply
Show
who liked?
+6
SunGato
SunGato
07 Oct 2017, 23:06 #
Everything is fine, but the only question is how such a crowd of people who go there every single day (and even if only on weekends) could not trample at least some kind of path across that lawn. Or is the grass there renewed every day too?
Reply
Show
who liked?
+12
Dark_Alice
Dark_Alice
11 Oct 2017, 01:38 #
@SunGato: It's virtual reality)
Reply
Show
who liked?
+29
Slimov
Slimov
08 Oct 2017, 02:20 #
This episode brought back faith in the series, not perfect of course, but there was hope that it would be better from now on.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+25
solnc3
solnc3
08 Oct 2017, 23:56 #
so far, the best series of the trez I've watched. I'm looking forward to the next one)) I hope you like it even more as it is rolled up.
and thanks for the link to the text of the story )
Reply
Show
who liked?
+8
deriwatiw
deriwatiw
09 Oct 2017, 02:51 #
Show comment
Reply
Show
who liked?
-88
BettyJane
BettyJane
10 Oct 2017, 00:48 #
The main character is just a selfish hypocrite. In a week, he will definitely regret his choice. Moreover, his son will definitely kill someone. Take it that way and decide the fate of several people at once on the basis of emotions!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+45
gtament
gtament
13 Oct 2017, 05:52 #
At least one sane person
Reply
Show
who liked?
+4
Dark_Alice
Dark_Alice
16 Oct 2017, 22:22 #
@BettyJane: This is reminiscent of most opinions about the finale of the Last of us game. Feelings for our loved ones are what make us human, the desire to be with someone you love. It may be selfish, but it's the most natural thing. This is the kind of behavior that people tend to have, not a sober calculation. That's why this story is so touching.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+26
BettyJane
BettyJane
18 Oct 2017, 02:38 #
@Dark_Alice: I agree, of course, with you. I just felt very sad for all the people who will be affected by his decision to return his son.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+23
dariabr
dariabr
21 Oct 2017, 00:59 #
This is one hundred percent Black mirror!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+5
VIRUS
VIRUS
13 Feb 2018, 01:45 #
Show comment
Reply
Show
who liked?
-40
PlanePassenger
PlanePassenger
21 Jul 2018, 00:28 #
@dariabr:
True: Black mirror is a fantasy anthology series
true: Electric Dreams is a fantasy anthology series
wrong: Electric Dreams "It's one hundred percent Black mirror!"
Reply
Show
who liked?
+18
Капитан_Сосулька
Капитан_Сосулька
30 Oct 2022, 14:34 #
@PlanePassenger: in addition, Black mirror, if my memory serves me correctly, is positioned as a series about how technology can change (spoil) us.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+1
Viktoriavip
Viktoriavip
04 Nov 2017, 00:17 #
There are no words, do not come off!!!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+8
luv_sh
luv_sh
05 Dec 2017, 16:11 #
I have not read the stories, I have not heard about this writer before this series, I am not looking for hidden meaning and I do not dig thoroughly into plots and blunders. I just watch and enjoy the atmosphere and music of each episode. besides, after the black mirror, I haven't seen anything like this for a long time and I consider it a breath of fresh air for myself :
Reply
Show
who liked?
+9
FRFD
FRFD
13 Dec 2017, 10:26 #
The first and second series were not impressed. They were so unimpressed that I watched the third one three or four months later. but this one brought back faith in the series and now I'm thinking whether it's worth looking at the next one or not..
Reply
Show
who liked?
+4
id4166357
id4166357
17 Dec 2017, 18:05 #
I have some kind of creepy impression of the series, such a heavy emotional pressure.. I need a break from watching now, for sure.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+11
VIRUS
VIRUS
13 Feb 2018, 01:46 #
Show comment
Reply
Show
who liked?
-34
Maybe_Karl
Maybe_Karl
03 Mar 2018, 19:10 #
now I do the opposite: first I watch, then I read.
the series turned out great, but again there was a slight residue in the form of a "prediction of the future" from madama, who does not even exist and how she knows all this is not clear.
I liked Jamie Vue's description in the story and the fact that the unfulfilled past came true. the story is much more positive, imho.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+3
MidnightRider
MidnightRider
05 Apr 2018, 08:10 #
@crwl: This madama is as real as the city and all its inhabitants are real. And you don't need to be a predictor to predict what's hotter.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+10
pretty_thing
pretty_thing
22 Apr 2018, 23:44 #
One unanswered question is why, before visiting the mysterious city, the main character's partner did not have children, and after the first visit, he had as many as three children and all from different women? How does the city have an impact on the partner's reality, he wasn't even there?
Reply
Show
who liked?
+12
FRFD
FRFD
23 Apr 2018, 01:08 #
@pretty_thing: I've been watching it for a long time (by my standards) and I don't remember exactly, but it seems that the bottom line is that reality has changed just the same not for my partner, but for GG himself, that is, he, consider, got into a new world for himself..
Reply
Show
who liked?
+12
австриячка
австриячка
24 Apr 2018, 01:55 #
@pretty_thing: Maybe GG whined so often about problems with his son that his partner was more careful to protect himself?
Reply
Show
who liked?
+13
PlanePassenger
PlanePassenger
21 Jul 2018, 00:34 #
@pretty_thing: Yes, FRFD wrote correctly, his son was not just taken away, it was made as if he had never been born, coupled with all the other decisions of the visitors, the destinies of people change significantly, forming a new reality.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+19
ОктавияКровавая
ОктавияКровавая
18 Jun 2018, 07:34 #
I didn't like the first two episodes, this series is good.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
Gaita
Gaita
PRO
12 Aug 2018, 05:33 #
Непонятно как и почему работает город, но вроде бы есть некий посыл, а город это инструмент и фон.
Город - продвинутое убежище/тюрьма для некоторых индивидов, которым не место в нормальном мире.
Решает все и играет в Бога - дочь автора проекта.
"Жизнь с Правдой VS Счастливая Жизнь", и мы смотрим всю серию в основном на частный случай одной семьи, тогда как "В рассказе несколько главных героев".
Вообщем вся вина на сценаристах.
Такая же тема была в "Футурологическом конгрессе" Лема и там она подана лучше, масштабнее.
Здесь же логика и здравый смысл пожимают плечами.
Лучше бы выставили дочь уже совершенно поехавшим полубогом, а продавца билетов тем кто прекратил бы весь этот цирк.
Reply
Show
who liked?
-1
Tony_G
Tony_G
07 Nov 2018, 15:57 #
В конце почему-то ожидал что он зайдет на кухню, а его сын прирезал мать, но хорошо что такой жести не произошло
Reply
Show
who liked?
+26
Vilgelmster
Vilgelmster
25 Nov 2019, 22:03 #
@Tony_G: тоже подумал что так и будет
Reply
Show
who liked?
+5
y13
y13
14 Dec 2018, 21:27 #
— Next stop is Willoughby!
Reply
Show
who liked?
mrrami
mrrami
07 May 2019, 04:52 #
Спасибо за шикарнейшний саунд этой серии
Reply
Show
who liked?
+1
kate_archer
kate_archer
13 Jul 2019, 02:05 #
Вот так Сполл должен был выглядеть в ГП - стопроцентная крыса! - а не таким круглым отъевшимся чем-то, как было. Гримом его только попортили там.

Что касается серии, она как раз мне меньше понравилась, чем предыдущие. Может, именно потому, что понятнее и распутаннее.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
Penis_Vocabular
Penis_Vocabular
19 Dec 2020, 15:12 #
Человек способен ностальгировать даже по абсолютному злу. Так уж устроен мозг.
Вопрос, на мой взгляд, лежит все-таки в плоскости этики, а не выбора или любви какой-то. Или просто снято так.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
ElinaRai
ElinaRai
PRO
31 May 2021, 10:19 #
Чувствуется какая-то аллегория на запрещённые вещества, как будто сейчас всё это пропадёт и окажется что все кто в городе лежат уделанные. Искажается реальность, воспоминания и многое повторяется по кругу. Но это что-то супер-глубокое
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
Neitrin0
Neitrin0
17 May 2022, 06:24 #
@ElinaRai: каждый в этом смысле примеряет своих демонов, не думали об этом?
Reply
Show
who liked?
+1
DIVbalakovo
DIVbalakovo
04 Jun 2021, 19:23 #
Отличная атмосфера у серии и истории, а также совершенно прекрасная игра Тимоти Сполла!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
Lotran
Lotran
21 Apr 2022, 15:20 #
Бородатый турист которому Эд объяснял в начале серии что тот заблудился, потом этого турист оказался в Мейкон Хайтс, а после снова на станции. Хмм.
https://ibb.co/6sSDgJC
https://ibb.co/pnhLmBZ
https://ibb.co/zHL1S3N
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
id20026503
id20026503
10 Jul 2022, 01:22 #
Не знаю, мне совершенно не зашла эта серия...
Reply
Show
who liked?
-2
Hunter_Number23
Hunter_Number23
21 Jan 2023, 07:31 #
Пока что это единственный эпизод, который не коцкает идею первоисточника, а наоборот органично дополняет её. Ибо оригинальный рассказ мне показался не до конца раскрытым.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+1
Ctixia
Ctixia
19 Feb 2023, 22:35 #
Потрясающая философская серия, в том числе о выборе и ответственности.
Reply
Show
who liked?
Sugar_Padre
Sugar_Padre
26 Nov 2023, 15:30 #
После 36 минуты словил себя на мысли, что я ощущаю не комфортную внутреннюю тревогу, и чем ближе к концу, тем это чувство всё более превращается в какое-то ощущение печали и смиренного разочарования.
Потрясающая серия, которая проникла атмосферой под кожу !
Reply
Show
who liked?
Add a comment:
Ads