the episode turned out to be quite interesting, I was glad for them that everything worked out for them, and how the kids settled down, went to school, celebrate others, etc., in general, it turned out really good ahah
It was only on stage after the credits that I realized that this was the last episode of the final season. So suddenly... I was expecting at least another third, where we would be interested to hear how three children were really able to turn around the centuries-old monarchical system. It was a touching ending, but it happened so unexpectedly that it was as if I hadn't had time to prepare for it properly.
It's hard to discuss the ending of the series without spoilers for the manga. For example, Emma mentions that you can try to change the world by making a new promise with demons. At the same time, in the slideshow, she is shown together with a small demon with an unpronounceable name (in the manga it was indicated only by symbols) - presumably, a new promise was made with him, but what? Obviously not the same as in the manga, because in the manga, Emma, having concluded it, had to lose something herself, but there are no hints of this in the ending of the anime.
In general, the season turned out to be crumpled, several interesting characters and plot moves were cut out. You stop worrying about the characters, because every time they will be saved by a piano in the bushes (or a "demon from the car", sorry for the stupid pun). Yes, the plot of the manga sinned with this after the children escaped from the orphanage, but because of the sprawl of the plot, it did not feel so much.
Compared to the intense, creepy, extremely atmospheric first season, the sequel looks weak. It is especially sad that Ray has lost his character and personality. In the first season, he was a very interesting, tragic, ambiguous character, here he is singing along with Emma, whose idealism was sometimes annoying (as if she read the minds of the creators of the anime and knew in advance that everything would be fine with them!). Again, the manga had these flaws, but it's safe to say that the anime didn't fix them.
Of course, I'm glad for the children that they managed to escape into the human world, I just wish the path to this was more difficult and intriguing. It was very easy for them to escape from the demon world compared to escaping from the orphanage. The first season raised a very high bar, which the second, IMHO, did not reach.
@Blackaster: I agree with you about the manga here, I'm very disappointed that we didn't use very cool scenes, at least with hunting grounds, I was really waiting ( and the end was described differently in the manga, I was worried while reading, and then ... Eh
@Blackaster: in my opinion, you have to pay for a promise in general, not only in a manga situation. Otherwise it would be very convenient, come and promise whatever you want.)
@Yuriykamennik: You can open chapter 142, pages 18-19, it says what promise Emma wanted to make. You can find out about the price she paid for the promise in chapters 178-181. :)
@Yuriykamennik: you obviously asked because you don't want to read, so the link above is nonsense.) According to the new promise, all dear people are taken away from Emma. But how can this be achieved if they are all sent to the human world? And that's it. She was teleported to another location on earth and her memory was taken away. In general, her friends searched for many years, eventually found her and told her everything. Happy ending)) They also did not mention that they were met there on earth by the people of Minevra.
@somebody_sss: There's nothing special to be afraid of for these spoilers. No bright turns for you. It's more accurate to say so here. It is better to read the manga from the moment when the guys got into the bunker. From there to the end. Because what was thrown here in the anime is not the coat at all. And reading those individual pages is pointless.
@Ell: your opinion, but I personally would be very upset if I read the ending of the manga from you before I had time to finish reading it myself (or even more so if I hadn't started reading it yet). I spoilt a very sad and important death for myself in the comments on the Attack of the Titans. In the end, they are so intriguing about what Emma sacrificed after all, and you just tell them like that.)
I do not agree that this is pointless, they wanted to know specifically about the promise, I threw off specific pages and chapters with a promise, no more and no less.) You yourself note that a person does not want to read the entire manga.
I don't even know why the cooperation of the creator with the director and screenwriter (and in general with the studio) turned out to be so strange. Or did the producers put pressure on everyone so that the plot would eventually come out completely sweet? The ending in the form of a slideshow finished off... The first season is still a masterpiece against the background of the second. Maybe it's a good thing that Yugo and co were not there.
To let the slideshow go, it's certainly strong. After a powerful first season, he will release such a weak second one. I hope in the future the second season will be forgotten and re-filmed.
I thought there would be a third season, where the events of the new agreement, different characters would be shown. Reality is two minutes at the end, here you go, eat
@id279797327: there will be no third season, the anime has been leaked, the manga is over. Read the original source, if not yet, there are a lot of interesting things that were not shown, including additional chapters about Chrona and Isabella.
The second season is much weaker than the first, if the first is an exciting thriller where children try to escape, and where every detail of the escape is shown. Then the second season does not meet expectations at all due to its impetuosity and very scant information about the world of demons, the capture of the main center in one episode fit and then a lot of meaningless speeches and goodbyes, the conclusion if the next season comes out I will watch after the release of all episodes
@laurenjauregu1: he didn't want to breed children, he wanted to hunt them in natural conditions.) It's not about nutrition, he's with the blood of Musicals himself.
Eh, at least the manga showed his thoughts about it to everyone, even if not very deeply. And here everyone just goes about the cropped plot with a happy ending
The only thing I liked about this series was how the survivors live in the human world, it was very pleasant to watch. The grown-up Phil was also pleased.
But the rest... Mother of God, what was that?? I kept thinking, they can't just leave all the kids on the other farms. They didn't leave, of course, but ... Hypothetically, it was not a bad idea, we take and ferry children from all farms to the human world, then no new promise is needed, no sacrifices are needed (as we have already found out, the dangers of our heroes do not take, so let's omit that it is more dangerous). But we are shown in this ~magnificent~ slideshow that Emma has made a promise after all. And here I join the comment above: which one? What the fuck kind of leg is that? On what terms, what was sacrificed? Why, if you can just transport the children? And if in the end they decided not to transfer it mechanically, but with a promise, then the question arises: why did they change the plot if they came to the same thing?
The treatment of children from industrial farms killed them in general: sorry, but there is nothing to treat, there is only euthanasia. Again, when talking about Lambda, they said that it is very difficult, expensive and dangerous to raise children on farms with the illusion of freedom, care and tests, so it is unlikely that industrial cultivation in anime is very different from the same in manga, there is not much else to come up with. How do you cure children from a completely vegetative state to what has been shown? He's playing chess!
And one last thing: a slideshow, really? Even without voice acting? I already had time to think: wow, will there really be a season, how they change the system, how they save children, they will show us the search for a demon with an unpronounceable name (for me he is forever brlbrpp), perhaps something from the carved arches, they will tell about the aristocracy, finally they will say at least something about ent (hello, ignorance how to kill demons)?? No, HAVE A SLIDESHOW!
@somebody_sss: fortunately, I read the manga, but I have a question for those who haven't read it: did you all understand what was shown there? Apart from living in the world of people and the coronation of Music, it is impossible to make a mistake there. I have some questions about the moment where Norman is hugging someone surrounded by a bunch of people (some of whom are quite grown-up). Is this the same Norman settlement, unknown to us and with unknown people, from Norman's unknown activities before his group met with Emma and Ray? What is the underground city shown below, which is probably not the same settlement? Maybe it's something from the manga that I don't remember, but I'm sorry, if you're such an independent work, spitting on manga, then at least, well, explain ~...
Perhaps my eyes, clouded with disappointment, did not see something obvious, but to be honest, I am very upset, this is a failure...
@somebody_sss: as a person who has not read manga, I will answer, I did not understand anything)))) Even the voiceover was saved 😁 I thought that in a couple of minutes before the end, the grown-up Emma, looking into the distance at the children playing, would tell in the form of a slide show how people accepted children and sisters from farms, what a new agreement was concluded between the two races, and what kind of people Norman hugged.
It turns out, either give it up or events will go as expected, but the anime will be closed and you will not learn anything, so now read the original source.
@phantasmat: thank you for your answer! I absolutely agree with you, especially about the voiceover, it would really help to understand the situation. And so they just gave a cut of it is unclear what, figure it out for yourself...
To be honest, I expected more. Now I realize that reading the manga before the anime finale was my mistake. But I repeat, like most manga readers, that the ending could have been much better. And that's putting it mildly.
I'm at a loss after watching it, I'm still trying to digest so many events in recent episodes.
Starting watching the second season here yesterday, I was already mentally preparing for the waiting mode of the 3rd. Naively, I thought that such a popular anime would last for 5 seasons. I would even agree to wait two years for a full-length film, so as not to lose the thread of a smooth narrative telling about children in the world of people and about the creation of new orders in the world of demons.
Of course, everything has already been written by the users above before me, there are a lot of questions left to which there is only one answer -to read manga. (for example, I am interested in the reason for the abrupt (at the right moment for the main characters) switch to the side of Isabella's children, and in the comments they were intrigued by the character from the bunker, etc.)
Peter Ratri seemed to know that we were going to watch a somewhat incomprehensible ending next, so he merged, not wanting to take part in it.
Phil remained a cute kitten even after he grew up. ☺️
So, that's serious, that's right serious-seriously Slideshow...just your mom's slideshow, oh, it's clear, that's how you did with a great project/work, you just inserted yourself into the ending of the slideshow EVENT FOR THE WHOLE SEASON You even put a moment with moms in the toilet, you could at least show an excerpt where Isabella talks about her mom's plans, otherwise the guitar in the corner turned out to be funny, which worked on command. I read the manga and after the bunker I realized that everything, everything, would not just be fucked up by the best charismatic characters, and after Norman's show, then the idea was instilled that "new" characters would not be prescribed, oh Just oh, at least they'd do a comeo...
I can't even believe that the ending was made up like that. We would have finished at the opening of the gates to the world of people and that's it, then season 3. But no, we decided to compress everything into a slide show, although we could show what it would be like for children to get into a society of people who are radically different from the Gracefield device. How Emma, Ray, Norman, Mujica and Sonju will overthrow the tyranny of the monarch and the nobility. Generally sad...
Aah, children in the human world are just love!!! It's so good that everything ended without deaths (not counting you know who ahahaha)✋🏻💛 even if the slideshow is at the end, it did not spoil my impression of this title in any way. And Phil at the end is just AAAAAAA, such a cutie!!!
Stupidly very fused ending, I will not write that IMHO, because this is a fact) Scriptwriters: let's make a slideshow of pictures in the last 2 minutes instead of a full-fledged season 3 Audience: What? No Screenwriters: And no one asked you) They threw a loaf of bread on the ground and told them to grab it. I didn't get it.
@-Damons__blood-: by the way, they could make another 12 episodes where they would show how the guys fit into a new human world for them, and at the end of the series Emma, Ray and Norman returned. And in season 3, show the adventures of the trinity during the timeskip P,S, even after a huge timescale, Norman looks the same, unlike Ray and Emma, what a😃
Yeah... season 1 and season 2 - Heaven and earth Imagine that season 2 did not exist And the first one just has such an open ending. Much better than such a vanilla-sugar slideshow I thought the second season was galloping across Europe, but no, the last episode proved that it was still a fairly measured development of events. Why shoot the second season at all. We could just make a bonus episode in the form of a slideshow for the first season...
Overall, the season came out crumpled and choppy. Incomplete. Only some individual scenes made an impression and touched. Unfortunately, it is not comparable with s1. I will get acquainted with the manga a little later. I want to know everything📖
I don't know what to say... everything seems to be revealed, but I also want to feel like the season came out incomplete, or something, especially in comparison with the first one. but the series is touching. 6/10, in general
Slideshow, are you fucking serious? What the fuck is his show??? Tell me, from which chapter to read the manga in order to forget about the existence of this, I'm not afraid of the word, vysera (and I'm not talking about the ending, but about the whole season as a whole)?
I'm sorry, I'm just crying. and these ARE NOT TEARS OF JOY time skip for three seconds?0?0??0???Are you serious??0?0? my God, it's scary to imagine how manga fans feel, if they did this to my favorite Attack, for example, I would have been dazed a long time ago🤟🏻
I'm the only one wondering if I forgot a frame from the Fate franchise in the final slideshow? In general, I agree with those who say that the season is crumpled and generally not impressive anymore. It is possible that if you had saved it as in the manga, it would have been longer and more interesting. But in general, it's just normal.
Oh, how beautifully this work was poured into the toilet... I've been waiting for this moment all season to see what was changed that the author didn't like so much. And what is my surprise: they did not change the N-I-H-E-G-O. It ended, roughly speaking, as in the source, but with huge disadvantages: cutting out the lion's share of chapters, characters, changing and adding some plots (which, by the way, did not change the weather at all), as well as, which was especially annoying, simplifying the plot and meaning. It was as if I was deceived: instead of the expected cool season, we were given this crude parody. I endured for a very long time and tried to come to terms with it, so that many would say that this is a new interpretation. But, gentlemen, the slideshow at the end just finished me off, huh. It's just a spit in the face. Not only did they cut out everything that was possible, but also very important events that ignorant people need to explain, they showed in pictures. Like, "figure it out for yourself, we'll show the last frame that they're already all together. And this means that they have succeeded - that's enough for you." Thanks, but I didn't have enough. For the first time, I was so disappointed with the work, because there were so many expectations :( Guys, I wholeheartedly recommend to everyone who has not done this yet - read the manga! You have to find out what this story really is. That's where the plot really penetrates to the bone, where you really worry about the characters, where they really fight for their lives and for the change of worlds... If that nonsense about the fact that the author himself wanted to change is true, then the author is a fool. To spoil your own work so much, eh.. As it is, I am very glad that I decided to read the manga at the time, as I could not wait for the release of the episodes of the second season for a long time. And after all that I saw, I didn't regret it. So read the manga, gentlemen. There you will learn this true story. He's finally going to let me go. Peace to all!
I can't believe that the author of the manga himself participated in the creation of the ending, and the season as a whole. Why come up with a story about "the author is not satisfied with the ending of the manga"? You could just say that the budget was cut. Which, in fact, it seems to me, is the main reason for the drain.
I haven't seen such a stupid and crumpled ending for a long time. Stupid because "peace, friendship, chewing gum" defeated everything, in particular, the moment with Peter Ratri strained me very much, and crumpled because it felt like they were galloping across Europe.
In general, I'm not happy with the second season. Sadly.
When the Queen was briefly shown, I had a flash of hope that they would show at least a fight with her)) But no, bummer, the whole nobility just resigned themselves and sat on the sidelines while the children quietly destroyed the old way of life and made all demons equal and independent of meat. The last series somehow looked indifferent, you don't worry about the characters at all, since no one even risked death or something like that.
@bulidze: there is no anime, there was even a "holiday" name in the manga. There was also an explanation for why they were the ones. it is connected with a deal, the meaning of which was skipped in the anime.
@bulidze: within the Seven Walls, a special place where understandable and logical laws of physics do not work, dwells the supreme ruler of demons with an unpronounceable name - in the manga it was only in demonic without transcription. So, this handsome guy - https://i.imgur.com/fuWEhe7.png - the guarantor of the treaty concluded between demons and humans 1k years ago – Julius Ratri and his brave warriors got a little tired of fighting, and Ratri found a way to stop the war – to make peace through Him. Ratri betrayed his own and went out to the demons to make a Promise - so that the worlds of demons and humans would become delimited. but He turned out to have a peculiar sense of humor: He helped end the war, yes, He delimited the worlds, but not for nothing. as a result of the agreement, the participants agreed that demons would not enter the human world, but they could grow people on their territory (the first sources of human flesh were just Julius Ratri's associates). On the part of the humans, He demanded that the Ratri clan monitor the fulfillment of the Promise until the end of time, while Julius himself remained in the territory of the demons. on the part of the demons, to establish a holiday in honor of Him – Tiferi – at which the best meat of grown people will be given to Him as a tribute. in the first case, He punished Ratri badly, in the second, He walked with a tank over the pride of the demon queen, who, alas and ah, had to eat mediocrity, not the best meat. Judging by the manga, the human didn't stick anywhere, because when Emma got to Him for the sake of making a second Promise, He just threw, they say, well, okay. the motives, why does He need a holiday and that's all, are not clear, but it looks like He just gets bored and creates game because He can.
Reality-maximality. I really thought that the line of Yugo and others could be taken out for the third season, since such rumors have passed. Like teenage children, they will be able to fight, everything is fine, the queen has been designated, go by the eyes, the third season will go great. And yeah, twice :)) But children cured from factories are powerful. Vincent Megamind squared. The consequences of the experimental farm have resolved themselves %) But drinking Ratri is fine. What is the logic of such an action? It is not clear. The first season is 10/10, the second... Well, with great love for the project - 6 at best. Sorry. Very sorry
To be honest, I didn't understand such a rapid development of events at the end, when Emma and the guys "returned" to them in the human world...Well, like, you didn't have time to blink, but everything is already fine? And how is that? o_o"
Perhaps it's really better to read the manga right away, there are a lot of questions left for the plot...
And in general, the finale of season 1 kept me in suspense, like the whole season, but this one was...well, normal, it will go ... eh, I hope that if they continue to shoot the new season, they will approach it more responsibly
Heh, all the answers to the plot questions are in the slideshow at the end of the series. It was a great idea, it was interesting to implement. They even removed the price of the new agreement, but what the hell is it necessary, really. In general, it ended even more fabulously than in the manga, then the question is, why was this season needed in principle? If you shoot like this, it's better not to shoot at all...
and this season gets the award for the worst anime adaptation ever, taking all the laurels from the Berserker and the Tokyo ghoul, let's applaud 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@nora_kauf: Well, no, it doesn't reach the "Tokyo Ghoul".) In some places it is puzzling, but non-stop yelling "Aaah, that's what's going on!!!" I don't want to.)
It is a pity that there will be no continuation, but it is no longer necessary to continue as for me, otherwise it would have become worse. This is just my personal opinion and it is strange that in the end they have not changed, and the children have become much older.
Once again, I am convinced that reading manga AFTER watching anime is the most excellent idea evar. I got the general idea, I liked it, and now I can delve into the details and get even more pleasure.
Oh, I agree with all the comments above. Although I haven't read the manga, I didn't have enough of what was shown in the season. It's true, some plot twists were obvious, the understatement was disappointing in places, and the fact that the process of saving children went like a knife through butter, so it killed in general. The narrative was crumpled up, and not badly.
If I got into the first season to the point of trembling and palpitations, then the second touched me only a couple of times tangentially.
The ending, though beautiful, is absolutely fused. They could have stretched it even for a series and shown what was going on with the new contract, the future of the children, how the demons now live in their world and on, on, on.
Nevertheless, it is a good starting point for reading manga.
I'm probably the only one who actually liked it. Yes, a lot was missed and I would like more interesting scenes and forks, but I was ready for this from the first episode of the second season, so I was not upset, since expectations were not too high :) I'm so tired of the tragic endings in all the anime that I'm even calm. By the way, those who look at the jitsu scene after the credits were cut, you will not lose much, but the fact itself. And this first scene after the credits, which I saw, seemed to be still (they wrote under other episodes). Although I have not read the manga, but from the general stories in the comments I understand how intriguing the plot could be, BUT what is there is🤷🏽♀️ I'm not upset, there was no wow effect either, it will go against the background. The first season is really very interesting 👍🏽 I will not master the manga, since it is not mine, but who did not have enough anime - read!) they wrote that there are many interesting characters there
Yeah, the beginning was promising, unlike the ending, which was crumpled up :/ I'm glad that everything ended well with them, but there wasn't enough truthfulness in the whole story.
What it was... I didn't understand at all why everything was so crumpled up. It feels like there are events for a couple more seasons, and they were just cut into a couple of minutes. Disappointment (
Excellent anime! From beginning to end! It is certainly a pity that some scenes were cut, but it is a pity only because this is the last season. I would like to see more adventures, but the way everything was done, it's amazing. I will definitely add it to my collection, and I will also reread the manga. Everything went well for me. Maybe someone won't like it. But as for me, it's better to finish and complete everything than to stretch and throw more and more challenges to the heroes, I think the kids have suffered and it's time to let them go👋🙂Anime class, watch and also read manga, there will be more of everything. Ps:But it would be a little crazy about Emma's memory loss. I understand why she makes a promise and renews the agreement with Mujica, because she should be crowned in the future, but why weave a creature with an unpronounceable name into the plot and eventually lose Emma's memory, that's out of the logic of the world and that's it. I really liked the anime, I will miss them
okay, we watched the clumsily glued teaser for the manga for 11 episodes, now you can go read the work itself 👌
but seriously, of course, everything has already been written above, but it really seems that this is such a draft when the authors write the events briefly at first - they make the frame of the story, and then add details, prescribe the motivation of the characters, the logic of events, add side branches of the plot and all that would stretch the anime for several more seasons but the screenwriters are deprived of the budget, and they cram everything they have into this season, and in the last episode they don't even have time to at least voice this unfortunate slideshow
and it seems that the season does not look quite terrible, but how much missed potential is sad
Maybe I reread the comments, but the second season is a complete disappointment.
I haven't read the manga, so every episode I felt some kind of understatement. Everything is very fast and crumpled. A couple of episodes ago, they just ran away from the farm, and now it's over.
Why adapt the manga at all if you don't do it properly?
I gave 4 stars for the first season, I immediately want to slap two. As a result, 3/5.
- and let's all run away from the farm, what are we like jerks - Emma, this is impossible. - Well, what is it?
- and let's not kill demons, why are we like jerks - Emma, this is impossible. - Well, what is it?
- and let us, 13-year-old (?) PEOPLE destroy the centuries-old way of the DEMON world, what are we like jerks ...
In general, Emma is not a jerk and she really did it, though, with a lot of pianos. And how she turned the last point, they decided not to show us at all, although it's such an amazing story - a little man against a huge world of demons. Slideshow a separate song - who are these demons, where did the old queen go, what promise did Emma make, where is the price for this promise, why did Phil grow up and the little girls from their own farm remained the same, Seongju abandoned his idea of eating "wild people", why, because Emma is not a jerk? It turned out to be a great manga advertisement, you can't say anything, there are more questions than answers, I'm going to read.
Surviving Isabella is probably one of the few advantages of the second season. In general, the last minutes of the series are not bad, and if they were in dynamics, they would be an excellent end to a great season (if there was one).
as exciting as the first season was to the point of goosebumps, so the second came out disappointing and empty, crumpled. it's obvious even without reading the manga. It was no better than this.
It ended very well and it makes me happy! A sense of completion of the story and satisfaction that everyone eventually began to live happily. A good title!
No, I don't like endings in slideshow mode.. But I suspect that there was simply no choice.. In general, I liked everything, although it was clear that the second season was weaker, alas..
I finished it in one day. I'm probably lucky that I haven't read manga - and overall season 2 was a C for me, but not a complete disappointment. I basically understood that after the brilliant chamber thriller in season 1, you should not hope for a successful sequel, because all the examples of dystopias say that as soon as the main characters break out of a well-thought-out world "over the wall" - hello divergent, running in a maze, etc. - an incredible game begins to happen.
Isn't anyone tired of participating in endless manga vs anime/book vs movie battles?
Won't it be boring to watch and read the same thing? So at least the aching ones have something to discuss, because you're looking at a different interpretation.
Why do you need a voiceover that will tell you what happened? Everything is clear enough. As many people wrote here, go to the manga for details. For example, I don't want to watch different anime on cd for 100500 seasons. A concise conclusion is enough.
As a person who has not read manga, I liked everything. But there were very few details about what they did in the demon world and how they eventually came to peace.
After seeing how season 2 was shitting, I went to read manga and oh my God... This is heaven and earth, this is the embodiment of a meme with a painted horse!! It's a shame, the first season was very cool, and then, read the original source
Well, I'm one of the indignant people who read the manga and got %$&₽# shoved into them (I don't know what word to choose even). Yes, I do not argue, there were good moments and touching in places, but no more. after all, the emotions that I felt when reading cannot be expressed in words. even if you don't take into account the manga, I remember how excited I was watching season 1. how creepy, scary, intriguing and wildly interesting it was. it was possible to do it just WELL And EFFICIENTLY, even if you decided to rethink and change the manga, but alas and ah. I'm just really sorry for what one of my favorite stories has turned into.
Tell me what you noticed in the HAPPY footage of the girl celebrating!!12!!anniversary (12 candles). And we are no longer afraid that she is 12, we are happy. Such a thoughtful moment
Eh... Those who didn't read manga before the anime were lucky. It is better, of course, to look at it first and then go fill in the gaps with the original source, than to sit like this and not understand how it was possible to treat such an interesting story so carelessly.
Those who demand a third season, sponsor the studio that is responsible for the release. Or do you think it's all that simple at the click of a button? Then you're even dumber than I thought, reading most of the comments.
What can I say... The first season was simply excellent. The pace, the plot, the atmosphere are excellent. It didn't seem to happen fast, but it never let you get bored. The ending with the Mother wishing "Good luck" to the runaway children is to tears.
As for the second season, it's all hellishly controversial. Plot twists fly by instantly, the pace has become disgusting, many scenario moves have remained undisclosed. For example, where did this evil-blooded one come from, why did Mom become a Grandmother, where did the previous one go, and Seongju's cruel phrase "Eating wild children" turned out to be a blank shot in general.
You probably can't blame the authors. Perhaps they were told that the series is limited to so many episodes, period. Naturally, choosing to make a good season, but not finishing anything, or crumple up the plot, but finish the series, they preferred the latter. And that's right. But the lost opportunities of the series are incredibly sad. He needed as many episodes as in the Attack of the Titans, then everyone would play with perfect colors.
As they say: there are no words, only emotions ... I remember watching the first season in one breath, waiting for all the plot twists. And now... It's just that I've been reaching for my face all season, plus the last five minutes of episode 11, are you serious??? it is better to assume that this season has never existed in principle :)
I won't say anything new, but I'm also upset about season 2, PROVIDED I haven't read the manga. There was a feeling that a lot of things were left unsaid, not disclosed. And with such a bombastic 1st season, the second one should have been for 25 episodes. Here only the drawing is beautiful, and so 2 (for at least some effort) / 10.
No matter how anyone says it, but even if you don't think that something has been changed in the manga, I'm happy with the anime. Good , kind , if you think about it .🤍 in the future , maybe I 'll buy and read manga and look at this anime in a different way , but for now I 'm glad that everything ended well , I don 't know how others do , but my heart ached every time thinking that something would happen to them 🤌🏻💔
The agreement was in the manga that Emma and this creature talked about what was important to her, she said that the family. He replied that he would take away her family and her memories. Emma said her terms : She wanted all the children in the farms to go to earth, including even the grown-up ones, and the second condition was that no one could travel between worlds. Emma was standing with the rest of the children, and the creature sent them to earth. The children woke up and saw that Emma was gone, and Emma herself woke up far from people, an old man found her, it was winter. And the children started looking for her. I described it as best I could, it is written in detail in the manga, I advise you to read it.
Awesome anime, I love anime in this style. I don't really like adventures, but when these adventures are with horrors. This one is already something else and I'm starting to like it.
That's why I even liked the idea. By the way, I knew about the plot even before watching the anime. And I was afraid that I would not be interested, but it turns out that the plot is not tied to what the children should learn, but tied to the fact that the children should escape and that's cool.
I don't know why, but I liked the first season much more than the second. Perhaps because there were more adventures in the second season. I've never cried, and maybe it's because I knew that none of the main characters would die. Well, either my psyche is already broken and I'm crying just because of all sorts of stuff.
I understand that it's different in the original source, but still the anime is very decent. I love this genre, intrigue and psychology. There are many characters with interesting characters. It's a very catchy story. For a non-super sophisticated viewer like me, this is amazing! I will definitely read the manga
This meme phrase perfectly describes everything that is happening. No responsibility, no karma, everyone is alive and well. Zero tragic deaths. Even Norman is cured! What the hell did he do, that he didn't have much left?
Emma was a little short of the burr in her voice and the armored car. And so - the spitting image of a revolutionary. The truth is with dreams of a pink world where everyone is friends with each other. It's a shame that the good and depressing setting of the first season was turned into a hash at the end.
Oh yes, and thanks to the creators of the anime, that in the end they made a reference to the Soviet magazine "Funny Pictures". Respect for that.
Until the last moment, I thought that the world beyond the gates was not such a wonderful one :) Of all of them, Phil liked it the most. Despite the fact that he is still small but smart and agreed to stay and wait for the elders to return for them :)
I can't call the second season bad, but compared to the first, it's, of course, a complete disappointment. A heavy, gloomy story, imbued with an atmosphere of despair and hopelessness, has turned into an ordinary naive children's fairy tale in which good inevitably defeats evil. The authors didn't even have the courage to sacrifice at least one of the older children to add at least some emotion to the finale.
Well, unexpectedly. Some kind of narrative cutoff.
The series itself is ambiguous. It looks crumpled in places. But it looked very easy. It is unambiguous for viewing. But over time, it will simply dissolve among the masses.
It feels like I watched a short retelling with endless pianos from the bushes I'm not really into manga, but this is the case when I want to know what we animeonly were deprived of by this frenzied speedrun of the plot
Even without reading the manga, it felt like a very crumpled ending to the season, as if a few more episodes were needed. Season 1 was of course much stronger than the 2nd, but it still came to me (probably because I hadn't read the manga), in principle I was glad to watch this anime
God, what nonsense. Now I understand what they were talking about about a drastic change in the genre between seasons. The first chamber thriller, detective, horror, and partly these multi-passages. Well, it's cool and original. The second one is already a banal fantasy hat with an admixture of eren on Norman the genocidal. And how interesting it is when everything ends well, because the main character is all so holy and without flaws was able to talk everyone over to her side. And of course, to forgive everyone for everything. The first season is 5/5, the second is 2/5 with a big stretch.
Discussion of the 11 episode of the 2 season Discuss this episode
140Oh, wow.
They managed to make the short post-credits scene much deeper and more touching than the entire episode.
In general, the season turned out to be crumpled, several interesting characters and plot moves were cut out. You stop worrying about the characters, because every time they will be saved by a piano in the bushes (or a "demon from the car", sorry for the stupid pun). Yes, the plot of the manga sinned with this after the children escaped from the orphanage, but because of the sprawl of the plot, it did not feel so much.
Compared to the intense, creepy, extremely atmospheric first season, the sequel looks weak. It is especially sad that Ray has lost his character and personality. In the first season, he was a very interesting, tragic, ambiguous character, here he is singing along with Emma, whose idealism was sometimes annoying (as if she read the minds of the creators of the anime and knew in advance that everything would be fine with them!). Again, the manga had these flaws, but it's safe to say that the anime didn't fix them.
Of course, I'm glad for the children that they managed to escape into the human world, I just wish the path to this was more difficult and intriguing. It was very easy for them to escape from the demon world compared to escaping from the orphanage. The first season raised a very high bar, which the second, IMHO, did not reach.
It's a pity that users themselves cannot hide spoilers in their messages!
I do not agree that this is pointless, they wanted to know specifically about the promise, I threw off specific pages and chapters with a promise, no more and no less.) You yourself note that a person does not want to read the entire manga.
Believe not?
Then the second season does not meet expectations at all due to its impetuosity and very scant information about the world of demons, the capture of the main center in one episode fit and then a lot of meaningless speeches and goodbyes, the conclusion if the next season comes out I will watch after the release of all episodes
тоже не понял
It's not about nutrition, he's with the blood of Musicals himself.
Or is this a seed for the third season?
But the rest... Mother of God, what was that?? I kept thinking, they can't just leave all the kids on the other farms. They didn't leave, of course, but ...
Hypothetically, it was not a bad idea, we take and ferry children from all farms to the human world, then no new promise is needed, no sacrifices are needed (as we have already found out, the dangers of our heroes do not take, so let's omit that it is more dangerous). But we are shown in this ~magnificent~ slideshow that Emma has made a promise after all. And here I join the comment above: which one? What the fuck kind of leg is that? On what terms, what was sacrificed? Why, if you can just transport the children? And if in the end they decided not to transfer it mechanically, but with a promise, then the question arises: why did they change the plot if they came to the same thing?
The treatment of children from industrial farms killed them in general: sorry, but there is nothing to treat, there is only euthanasia. Again, when talking about Lambda, they said that it is very difficult, expensive and dangerous to raise children on farms with the illusion of freedom, care and tests, so it is unlikely that industrial cultivation in anime is very different from the same in manga, there is not much else to come up with. How do you cure children from a completely vegetative state to what has been shown? He's playing chess!
And one last thing: a slideshow, really? Even without voice acting? I already had time to think: wow, will there really be a season, how they change the system, how they save children, they will show us the search for a demon with an unpronounceable name (for me he is forever brlbrpp), perhaps something from the carved arches, they will tell about the aristocracy, finally they will say at least something about ent (hello, ignorance how to kill demons)?? No, HAVE A SLIDESHOW!
I have some questions about the moment where Norman is hugging someone surrounded by a bunch of people (some of whom are quite grown-up). Is this the same Norman settlement, unknown to us and with unknown people, from Norman's unknown activities before his group met with Emma and Ray? What is the underground city shown below, which is probably not the same settlement? Maybe it's something from the manga that I don't remember, but I'm sorry, if you're such an independent work, spitting on manga, then at least, well, explain ~...
Perhaps my eyes, clouded with disappointment, did not see something obvious, but to be honest, I am very upset, this is a failure...
Even the voiceover was saved 😁
I thought that in a couple of minutes before the end, the grown-up Emma, looking into the distance at the children playing, would tell in the form of a slide show how people accepted children and sisters from farms, what a new agreement was concluded between the two races, and what kind of people Norman hugged.
It turns out, either give it up or events will go as expected, but the anime will be closed and you will not learn anything, so now read the original source.
Starting watching the second season here yesterday, I was already mentally preparing for the waiting mode of the 3rd. Naively, I thought that such a popular anime would last for 5 seasons.
I would even agree to wait two years for a full-length film, so as not to lose the thread of a smooth narrative telling about children in the world of people and about the creation of new orders in the world of demons.
Of course, everything has already been written by the users above before me, there are a lot of questions left to which there is only one answer -to read manga. (for example, I am interested in the reason for the abrupt (at the right moment for the main characters) switch to the side of Isabella's children, and in the comments they were intrigued by the character from the bunker, etc.)
Peter Ratri seemed to know that we were going to watch a somewhat incomprehensible ending next, so he merged, not wanting to take part in it.
Phil remained a cute kitten even after he grew up. ☺️
Slideshow...just your mom's slideshow, oh, it's clear, that's how you did with a great project/work, you just inserted yourself into the ending of the slideshow EVENT FOR THE WHOLE SEASON
You even put a moment with moms in the toilet, you could at least show an excerpt where Isabella talks about her mom's plans, otherwise the guitar in the corner turned out to be funny, which worked on command.
I read the manga and after the bunker I realized that everything, everything, would not just be fucked up by the best charismatic characters, and after Norman's show, then the idea was instilled that "new" characters would not be prescribed, oh
Just oh, at least they'd do a comeo...
It's the funniest joke you can think of.
Scriptwriters: let's make a slideshow of pictures in the last 2 minutes instead of a full-fledged season 3
Audience: What? No
Screenwriters: And no one asked you)
They threw a loaf of bread on the ground and told them to grab it. I didn't get it.
P,S, even after a huge timescale, Norman looks the same, unlike Ray and Emma, what a😃
season 1 and season 2 - Heaven and earth
Imagine that season 2 did not exist
And the first one just has such an open ending. Much better than such a vanilla-sugar slideshow
I thought the second season was galloping across Europe, but no, the last episode proved that it was still a fairly measured development of events.
Why shoot the second season at all. We could just make a bonus episode in the form of a slideshow for the first season...
– Emma...
- I'm back, my family🧡
and these ARE NOT TEARS OF JOY
time skip for three seconds?0?0??0???Are you serious??0?0?
my God, it's scary to imagine how manga fans feel, if they did this to my favorite Attack, for example, I would have been dazed a long time ago🤟🏻
In general, I agree with those who say that the season is crumpled and generally not impressive anymore. It is possible that if you had saved it as in the manga, it would have been longer and more interesting.
But in general, it's just normal.
At least there was a feeling that in one of the versions of Stay night there was an identical frame.
I've been waiting for this moment all season to see what was changed that the author didn't like so much. And what is my surprise: they did not change the N-I-H-E-G-O. It ended, roughly speaking, as in the source, but with huge disadvantages: cutting out the lion's share of chapters, characters, changing and adding some plots (which, by the way, did not change the weather at all), as well as, which was especially annoying, simplifying the plot and meaning. It was as if I was deceived: instead of the expected cool season, we were given this crude parody. I endured for a very long time and tried to come to terms with it, so that many would say that this is a new interpretation. But, gentlemen, the slideshow at the end just finished me off, huh. It's just a spit in the face. Not only did they cut out everything that was possible, but also very important events that ignorant people need to explain, they showed in pictures. Like, "figure it out for yourself, we'll show the last frame that they're already all together. And this means that they have succeeded - that's enough for you." Thanks, but I didn't have enough. For the first time, I was so disappointed with the work, because there were so many expectations :(
Guys, I wholeheartedly recommend to everyone who has not done this yet - read the manga! You have to find out what this story really is. That's where the plot really penetrates to the bone, where you really worry about the characters, where they really fight for their lives and for the change of worlds... If that nonsense about the fact that the author himself wanted to change is true, then the author is a fool. To spoil your own work so much, eh.. As it is, I am very glad that I decided to read the manga at the time, as I could not wait for the release of the episodes of the second season for a long time. And after all that I saw, I didn't regret it. So read the manga, gentlemen. There you will learn this true story.
He's finally going to let me go. Peace to all!
I haven't seen such a stupid and crumpled ending for a long time. Stupid because "peace, friendship, chewing gum" defeated everything, in particular, the moment with Peter Ratri strained me very much, and crumpled because it felt like they were galloping across Europe.
In general, I'm not happy with the second season. Sadly.
The last series somehow looked indifferent, you don't worry about the characters at all, since no one even risked death or something like that.
So, this handsome guy - https://i.imgur.com/fuWEhe7.png - the guarantor of the treaty concluded between demons and humans 1k years ago – Julius Ratri and his brave warriors got a little tired of fighting, and Ratri found a way to stop the war – to make peace through Him. Ratri betrayed his own and went out to the demons to make a Promise - so that the worlds of demons and humans would become delimited.
but He turned out to have a peculiar sense of humor: He helped end the war, yes, He delimited the worlds, but not for nothing. as a result of the agreement, the participants agreed that demons would not enter the human world, but they could grow people on their territory (the first sources of human flesh were just Julius Ratri's associates). On the part of the humans, He demanded that the Ratri clan monitor the fulfillment of the Promise until the end of time, while Julius himself remained in the territory of the demons. on the part of the demons, to establish a holiday in honor of Him – Tiferi – at which the best meat of grown people will be given to Him as a tribute. in the first case, He punished Ratri badly, in the second, He walked with a tank over the pride of the demon queen, who, alas and ah, had to eat mediocrity, not the best meat.
Judging by the manga, the human didn't stick anywhere, because when Emma got to Him for the sake of making a second Promise, He just threw, they say, well, okay. the motives, why does He need a holiday and that's all, are not clear, but it looks like He just gets bored and creates game because He can.
But children cured from factories are powerful. Vincent Megamind squared. The consequences of the experimental farm have resolved themselves %)
But drinking Ratri is fine. What is the logic of such an action? It is not clear.
The first season is 10/10, the second... Well, with great love for the project - 6 at best.
Sorry. Very sorry
Perhaps it's really better to read the manga right away, there are a lot of questions left for the plot...
And in general, the finale of season 1 kept me in suspense, like the whole season, but this one was...well, normal, it will go ... eh, I hope that if they continue to shoot the new season, they will approach it more responsibly
If I got into the first season to the point of trembling and palpitations, then the second touched me only a couple of times tangentially.
The ending, though beautiful, is absolutely fused. They could have stretched it even for a series and shown what was going on with the new contract, the future of the children, how the demons now live in their world and on, on, on.
Nevertheless, it is a good starting point for reading manga.
I'm glad that everything ended well with them, but there wasn't enough truthfulness in the whole story.
Disappointment (
Ps:But it would be a little crazy about Emma's memory loss. I understand why she makes a promise and renews the agreement with Mujica, because she should be crowned in the future, but why weave a creature with an unpronounceable name into the plot and eventually lose Emma's memory, that's out of the logic of the world and that's it.
I really liked the anime, I will miss them
but seriously, of course, everything has already been written above, but it really seems that this is such a draft
when the authors write the events briefly at first - they make the frame of the story, and then add details, prescribe the motivation of the characters, the logic of events, add side branches of the plot and all that would stretch the anime for several more seasons
but the screenwriters are deprived of the budget, and they cram everything they have into this season, and in the last episode they don't even have time to at least voice this unfortunate slideshow
and it seems that the season does not look quite terrible, but how much missed potential is sad
I haven't read the manga, so every episode I felt some kind of understatement. Everything is very fast and crumpled. A couple of episodes ago, they just ran away from the farm, and now it's over.
Why adapt the manga at all if you don't do it properly?
I gave 4 stars for the first season, I immediately want to slap two. As a result, 3/5.
- Emma, this is impossible.
- Well, what is it?
- and let's not kill demons, why are we like jerks
- Emma, this is impossible.
- Well, what is it?
- and let us, 13-year-old (?) PEOPLE destroy the centuries-old way of the DEMON world, what are we like jerks
...
In general, Emma is not a jerk and she really did it, though, with a lot of pianos. And how she turned the last point, they decided not to show us at all, although it's such an amazing story - a little man against a huge world of demons. Slideshow a separate song - who are these demons, where did the old queen go, what promise did Emma make, where is the price for this promise, why did Phil grow up and the little girls from their own farm remained the same, Seongju abandoned his idea of eating "wild people", why, because Emma is not a jerk? It turned out to be a great manga advertisement, you can't say anything, there are more questions than answers, I'm going to read.
well at least my mother is alive
(it would be better not to watch)
Won't it be boring to watch and read the same thing? So at least the aching ones have something to discuss, because you're looking at a different interpretation.
Why do you need a voiceover that will tell you what happened? Everything is clear enough. As many people wrote here, go to the manga for details. For example, I don't want to watch different anime on cd for 100500 seasons. A concise conclusion is enough.
I liked the anime.
even if you don't take into account the manga, I remember how excited I was watching season 1. how creepy, scary, intriguing and wildly interesting it was.
it was possible to do it just WELL And EFFICIENTLY, even if you decided to rethink and change the manga, but alas and ah.
I'm just really sorry for what one of my favorite stories has turned into.
As for the second season, it's all hellishly controversial. Plot twists fly by instantly, the pace has become disgusting, many scenario moves have remained undisclosed. For example, where did this evil-blooded one come from, why did Mom become a Grandmother, where did the previous one go, and Seongju's cruel phrase "Eating wild children" turned out to be a blank shot in general.
You probably can't blame the authors. Perhaps they were told that the series is limited to so many episodes, period. Naturally, choosing to make a good season, but not finishing anything, or crumple up the plot, but finish the series, they preferred the latter. And that's right. But the lost opportunities of the series are incredibly sad. He needed as many episodes as in the Attack of the Titans, then everyone would play with perfect colors.
I remember watching the first season in one breath, waiting for all the plot twists.
And now... It's just that I've been reaching for my face all season, plus the last five minutes of episode 11, are you serious??? it is better to assume that this season has never existed in principle :)
The most important thing was just left out
That's why I even liked the idea. By the way, I knew about the plot even before watching the anime. And I was afraid that I would not be interested, but it turns out that the plot is not tied to what the children should learn, but tied to the fact that the children should escape and that's cool.
I don't know why, but I liked the first season much more than the second. Perhaps because there were more adventures in the second season. I've never cried, and maybe it's because I knew that none of the main characters would die. Well, either my psyche is already broken and I'm crying just because of all sorts of stuff.
"We want to smile! We want to be free." 💔
But some kind of blurry ending
It could have been better(((
This meme phrase perfectly describes everything that is happening. No responsibility, no karma, everyone is alive and well. Zero tragic deaths. Even Norman is cured! What the hell did he do, that he didn't have much left?
Emma was a little short of the burr in her voice and the armored car. And so - the spitting image of a revolutionary. The truth is with dreams of a pink world where everyone is friends with each other. It's a shame that the good and depressing setting of the first season was turned into a hash at the end.
Oh yes, and thanks to the creators of the anime, that in the end they made a reference to the Soviet magazine "Funny Pictures". Respect for that.
Of all of them, Phil liked it the most. Despite the fact that he is still small but smart and agreed to stay and wait for the elders to return for them :)
The series itself is ambiguous. It looks crumpled in places. But it looked very easy. It is unambiguous for viewing. But over time, it will simply dissolve among the masses.
I'm not really into manga, but this is the case when I want to know what we animeonly were deprived of by this frenzied speedrun of the plot
were needed. Season 1 was of course much stronger than the 2nd, but it still came to me (probably because I hadn't read the manga), in principle I was glad to watch this anime
The ending was good, it's good that it wasn't stretched for another season