s01e04 — Исступление

Топи — s01e04 — Исступление

My rating

Rate
Rate the shows you've watched and get up-to-date recommendations
4.275
MyShows
(2 171)
Duration: 43 min.
Released: 04.02.202104.02.2021 03:00
Watched by: 31 95977.71%
1 season
s01e04
s01e01 - Введение
s01e02 - Исчезновение
s01e03 - Воскрешение
s01e04 - Исступление
s01e05 - Преображение
s01e06 - Подношение
s01e07 - Искупление

Discussion of the 4 episode of the 1 season
Discuss this episode
177

wantsmind
wantsmind
04 Feb 2021, 04:14 # Show original
the series, of course, only leads to even more misunderstandings. You're sitting there and you don't know how to live until next Thursday with so many questions. but character dialogues are a separate art.
re_player
re_player
05 Feb 2021, 05:45 # Show original
@wantsmind: By the way, about misunderstandings. I don't know why, but I decided to briefly review the 2nd episode and suddenly noticed that the one-eyed grandfather was being dragged by the hand by the grandmother, who would continue to run with Katya's handkerchief. According to the time, it's at 9:15 somewhere, just during Denis's water treatments. Katya hasn't disappeared yet.

I do not believe that this is an editing error, the series is not of the right level for such joints. And then the assumption does not fit in any way that Katya is the same granny from the subsequent series (and she eventually dropped her favorite handkerchief, and Max took it for himself). Quite an interesting point to think about?)
Lenny_crazy_jo
Lenny_crazy_jo
05 Feb 2021, 20:39 # Show original
@re_player: yes, I also noticed that it was that granny, but I wrote it off for myself that these were Denis's hallucinations, along with a burning bird (which was found not burned yet), a strange tree-wall, people tumbling across the field
vk775121
vk775121
06 Feb 2021, 01:45 # Show original
@re_player: why doesn't it fit? Katya could have been transported to the past and she lived her whole life in the village.
miscellaneous
miscellaneous
09 Feb 2021, 18:05 # Show original
@vk775121: or maybe her soul was released further? After all, nothing really held her back. Sonya wanted to resurrect her sister, Denis wanted to heal, the journalist wanted to dig up dirt on Denis or uncover some other story, Elya wanted to hide from the groom. Katya was driving just to unwind, to change the situation. That's why she passed the tests the fastest, so to speak. Besides, she was polite to everyone, encouraged everyone, helped. She thought it was a dream.
MortVirg
MortVirg
20 Feb 2021, 03:18 # Show original
@re_player: and it seems to me that this is such a scenario move, they give us hints with the help of these inserts. It's not a fact that this is happening right now and it's not a fact that Denis even sees it. This is a metaphorical and not very narrative, justify this small world. On the second viewing, it is quite possible that everything in these inserts will be clear - at least, I hope for such luxury
Hername
Hername
04 Sep 2023, 08:36 # Show original
@re_player: I think it's like foresight. Let me remind you that in the same place in the first episodes Denis saw how the priest hung himself, and this was shown in fact only now.
darisvea
darisvea
04 Feb 2021, 04:15 # Show original
There are more and more questions, fewer and fewer answers
bystritskiy
bystritskiy
04 Feb 2021, 04:30 # Show original
Of course, such series should be released entirely at once)
PlagueSpreader
PlagueSpreader
06 Feb 2021, 01:03 # Show original
@bystritskiy: To make brains boil overnight. :)
id11345303
id11345303
09 Feb 2021, 09:57 # Show original
So I'll wait for the release of all episodes
Russllann
Russllann
31 Jul 2021, 21:33 # Show original
@bystritskiy:in general, you only need to watch TV shows in their entirety
Lava_recommends
Lava_recommends
PRO
02 Oct 2021, 05:43 # Show original
such series are just good to wait for, and immediately watch in one gulp
hard2kilI
hard2kilI
04 Feb 2021, 05:05 # Show original
I'm not the only one who noticed that compared to the very cool three pilot series, the 4th series is twenty-two heads HIGHER?!The
plot is moving, the characters are revealed, it's all good, BUT the actors play better, the dialogues even seem simpler and more pleasant to sound, and still such shots... SUCH that the actors sometimes go into the background altogether. to be honest, the operators said ‘vi ar ze best'. It's a shame to wait another week, but it's worth it.
BoomBox_
BoomBox_
PRO
04 Feb 2021, 06:27 # Show original
It's not fucking clear, but it's very interesting
The convicts only added fuel to the fire with their remarks, now it is clear why the police are driving the car. It feels like the combine is the reason for all this.
So far, everything fits into the concept that the main fears of the characters materialize in this place. Something gives the impression that the one-eyed grandfather, if not the owner, is somehow connected with him
Марго18
Марго18
04 Feb 2021, 18:54 # Show original
@BoomBox_: The owner is probably the driver. The bag with the dog heads was his, he breeds maggots there for fishing (as someone said in this episode). And in his car, he had the same spinner with feathers on the windshield. Probably the shot where the view from the window with flies at someone in a yellow raincoat with an axe was just from his house.
loki_art
loki_art
05 Feb 2021, 02:27 # Show original
Show comment
BoomBox_
BoomBox_
PRO
05 Feb 2021, 05:37 # Show original
@loki_art: The beginning of the series only reminded me of Wayward pines (pines). An accident, then gg gets into a settlement with a bunch of incomprehensible things and tries to figure it out, because the locals obviously don't say something. That's where all the coincidences end.
jonny-jr
jonny-jr
04 Dec 2023, 00:16 # Show original
@BoomBox_: Exactly. I also remembered about this series. And the atmosphere is similar... gloomy, tense. The coincidence was also that it was also impossible to get out of this settlement in the Pines, gg tried to leave, but still returned there, like a vicious circle...Max was told about this by the prisoners that it would not be possible to leave the Swamp.
Darula
Darula
PRO
03 Mar 2021, 00:42 # Show original
@BoomBox_: Hmm, in the Dark/The nuclear power plant was also a key location for the plot, again an analogy :)
darisvea
darisvea
04 Feb 2021, 07:45 # Show original
A few chaotic experiences.

1. The characters and lines of blonde and Ali do not like the word at all. I also don't like the blonde's sister. It's interesting to watch the lines of the guys and Katya.

2. And the policeman. Maybe he's not so rotten after all? Why did he want to take those who were still there to the train? So it's possible? Has he been walking around there for so many years, aware of everything, scared, but nevertheless ready to try?

3. How are the "technogenic" line of the plant and this "divine" heresy of theirs connected?

4. A creepy moment with Alina, even the photos on the tombstones were not so impressed.
AlbertValeev
AlbertValeev
05 Feb 2021, 02:14 # Show original
@dasha_dks: How are the "technogenic" line of the plant and this "divine" heresy of theirs connected? - Hell's forge. Desires are not fulfilled by God, but by the devil - there is also an inscription on the wall where the priest hangs himself - in short, the underworld is - souls are being prepared for hell
id317342497
id317342497
05 Feb 2021, 03:21 # Show original
Yeah, and it seems to have become clear who the owner is) but I think that he checks them with the realization of fears of the forge. Something like that. "Get out", against the background of a hanging priest, just brr
Dori_Grey
Dori_Grey
PRO
09 Feb 2023, 00:28 # Show original
@AlbertValeev: in general, it says "utopia" on the screensaver, it turns out it should be an ideal world (a dream, a non-existent world, an ideal society), hell and utopia are things that can't be read like that.. or the screenwriters got something mixed up.
AnyaRokenroll
AnyaRokenroll
04 Feb 2021, 08:37 # Show original
The sister is still a bitch, they only begged her back in vain
Unicom
Unicom
04 Feb 2021, 14:37 # Show original
Butterfly Effect?)
antnantn
antnantn
04 Feb 2021, 14:56 # Show original
Oh my God, and psychedelics of course. although it's really interesting. In any case, we don't have many such series. extraordinary, so to speak) let's see what happens next. as long as they don't leak everything at the end
x0m1ak
x0m1ak
PRO
04 Feb 2021, 15:44 # Show original
Why does the policeman have a black-and-white photo of his son? Why hasn't Arina's age changed? Why is there no connection? I will keep silent about the rest of the questions.. I wonder if the accident at the chemical plant also happened in 1999?
Марго18
Марго18
04 Feb 2021, 17:24 # Show original
@x0m1ak: the same questions) plus, who pays Arina's mom a triple pension and how if they can't leave the village?
darisvea
darisvea
04 Feb 2021, 19:28 # Show original
B/w photo, because the policeman has been living there for decades.
Yulkafomkina
Yulkafomkina
05 Feb 2021, 02:15 # Show original
So everyone stays at the age they died at, I think
Jesse
Jesse
PRO
05 Feb 2021, 18:52 # Show original
@Yulkafomkina: But what about Katya, who is with a yellow scarf? She's an old woman now and she goes around telling the guys that she's been in the village for 100 years and they don't remember her?
x0m1ak
x0m1ak
PRO
05 Feb 2021, 18:59 # Show original
@Jesse: apparently Katya was pumped out by doctors after the accident, and she disappeared from the village. And then she sinned again and found herself after death in this afterlife to serve)
PlagueSpreader
PlagueSpreader
06 Feb 2021, 01:08 # Show original
@x0m1ak: Does this date mean that Boris Nikolaevich Yeltsin is involved in everything?
Yeltsin Death Brigades, that's it.
x0m1ak
x0m1ak
PRO
06 Feb 2021, 01:22 # Show original
@PlagueSpreader: Yeltsin was a skin and worked in a hell forge)
Leonbrawl
Leonbrawl
07 Feb 2021, 02:58 #
@x0m1ak: лол
ushakovatory
ushakovatory
13 Jan 01:25 # Show original
@x0m1ak: why do their phones still hold charging?
zula22
zula22
04 Feb 2021, 17:49 # Show original
they are pumping and pumping....Will the answers be in the last episode? but obviously not all of them
MaLyutka
MaLyutka
04 Feb 2021, 17:54 # Show original
I decided to wait until all the remaining episodes are released, otherwise you're just annoying yourself, the series is awesome! Ahaha
vk775121
vk775121
06 Feb 2021, 01:50 # Show original
@Lyutaya: so that's the point, you get positive emotions from the series and food for thought every week. So the brain works better and there are more emotions)
MaLyutka
MaLyutka
06 Feb 2021, 02:48 # Show original
@vk775121: my brain is already working hard, just when I have time - I watch movies, I love TV series, and of course when they throw up a series, you get distracted, the general feeling is lost, because while watching you somehow get into it, worry, get involved, catch every moment, and when the series are scattered, sometimes I want to watch it all over again, for example, I watched Ozark, then I waited for another season, the last one, and, of course, I already somehow forgot what was there and how, well, if he was the only one, and I was a series fan...ahaha, then I watched it after the release of all the seasons from the very beginning. Oh, I wrote everything so messily, sorry..ahaha
x0m1ak
x0m1ak
PRO
06 Feb 2021, 03:09 # Show original
@Lyutaya: for example, I like old TV shows in which I try to postpone 3 or more seasons for later in order to watch all the seasons in one gulp. It takes a long time, but you completely immerse yourself in the series)
But you have to watch new TV series, then a year later remember or review the last episode)
MaLyutka
MaLyutka
06 Feb 2021, 03:15 # Show original
@x0m1ak: yes, yes, that's right, I've already lost count of the series, I'm reviewing my stocks now and I realize that many have already released a sequel, but I completely forgot what was there and what was all about....ahaha, I still have a fad, I'm hooked on Czechs here, then I switch to ours, well, rather because they are one or two seasons and completely out, but with Vikings I acted ugly, they used to come out irregularly, and over time they stopped bothering me and I him I stopped watching, although I really like historical ones, yes, I love everything, but now I'm sitting and thinking maybe I should reconsider Vikings from the very beginning.......ahaha
x0m1ak
x0m1ak
PRO
06 Feb 2021, 03:44 # Show original
@Lyutaya: I've been waiting for a month and I start watching Vikings for the first time from the first episode to the end) and I dilute the American ones with ours and Scandinavian ones, there are also few seasons usually)
MaLyutka
MaLyutka
06 Feb 2021, 03:53 #
Comment has been deleted
re_player
re_player
04 Feb 2021, 18:21 # Show original
Given the plot, this should be watched as they watched the Darkness from Netflix: all episodes in one gulp. And just the first 3 episodes just went great in this format. In vain they decided to change the pitch (or at least did it like with Dyatlov Pass, where several episodes were rolled out at once).

And so it is good, although nothing is really clear, except the fact of being in the afterlife.
vk775121
vk775121
06 Feb 2021, 01:51 # Show original
@re_player: the darkness was difficult, but I think once a week he would have had more hype)
AhmetzyanovR
AhmetzyanovR
04 Feb 2021, 18:50 # Show original
I increasingly doubt that this is really an Afterlife (purgatory). The cop's behavior and remarks are very distracting from this. He's a local. Alina's photo, the grave in the last episode, the priest constantly hanging himself - all this is still confusing, and this makes it even more interesting. After each episode, I want to sit and discuss.
I believe that all the lines will be properly justified. Because I already doubt all the theories.
PlagueSpreader
PlagueSpreader
06 Feb 2021, 01:12 # Show original
@AhmetzyanovR: They deliberately mixed a bunch of things so that no one would come to an unambiguous conclusion. And at the end, one hundred percent there will be an open final. So that everyone gets fucked up.
p-elena
p-elena
09 Feb 2021, 00:32 # Show original
I have a stupid theory that hanging is used as a transition somewhere else. For example, a priest may not belong to the Afterlife world and come here to help souls, and then hang himself and "come back", or something.
And that the Burnt Ale also decided to send it somewhere in this way, and not kill it.
(I am writing it myself and I do not believe that this is possible in a scenario.)
vk860469
vk860469
04 Feb 2021, 19:27 # Show original
Apparently, time stopped at this place because of this plant with fumes, some experiments were probably carried out. This explains the police instead of the police, ageless Lolita and other mysticism
Марго18
Марго18
04 Feb 2021, 19:35 # Show original
@vk860469: interestingly, Benjamin, the old woman's husband, died in 2017. That is, for each character, time seems to have stopped at different points
Meloman_Nastena
Meloman_Nastena
21 Oct 2021, 01:28 # Show original
And he shouldn't be there, she "begged" him. But then she herself must be much younger if she died in 1999…
Foxtober
Foxtober
04 Feb 2021, 21:15 # Show original
I wonder why Lisa didn't immediately try to leave the monastery? Or a monastery like a buffer zone between the world of the afterlife, and Lisa's soul is not yet strong enough to get into purgatory. And the priest probably hangs himself on purpose to resurrect. And there are also very creep inscriptions on the walls in his room.
kinosha
kinosha
06 Feb 2021, 04:30 # Show original
She tried, but on the stairs she caught shortness of breath, as well as then having an attack coming out of the walls. Grandma said that "we need to gain strength"
tatrati
tatrati
PRO
07 Feb 2021, 23:05 # Show original
@Kirafox: It's stupid that they didn't think of dragging her back to the monastery, one hundred percent will come to life
Stalker96kor
Stalker96kor
04 Feb 2021, 21:35 # Show original
It's getting more and more interesting. My opinion from the watched series is as follows:
1. "Hell's Forge" i.e. the factory is Hell. Or a certain place that negatively affects the Anomalous Zone of the "Swamp" (you can't call it anything else).
2. A blind grandfather can be anyone. From God, to a certain observer (he looked out the window, he walks in the fields, crawls on the ground, etc.).
3. All our characters are dead. I wrote in the last episode that the first girl "survived", but my theory failed when we saw this girl as a grandmother.
4. "Swamps" - Purgatory / Hell - where everyone does not die and does not age (I think a non-Russian will not die on the gallows, as a priest does not die).
5. The priest could have been corrupt during his lifetime, for this he remained in the Swamps (bundles of money on his desk, maybe even he burns them every day over and over again).
6. As mentioned above, the village can give the embodiment of the desires and fears of the heroes in Reality. Arina is the embodiment of a journalist's desire and, judging by her graduation date (1999), has also been dead for a long time.
Don't judge my observations strictly, I'm just a spectator, not a critic.

(The only thing I didn't understand was why my sister died again as soon as she went outside. She was defrosted. Or they beg to talk and they immediately die outside the temple, as the grandmother's husband died again. "I begged him off" means I also revived him).
m1stakе
m1stakе
05 Feb 2021, 01:56 # Show original
@Stalker96kor: and what's wrong with the girl who turned grandmother? She survived, then died in old age, perhaps.
loki_art
loki_art
05 Feb 2021, 02:33 # Show original
@Stalker96kor: perhaps the sister will rise again, but she will not be able to go outside the temple, so to speak, magic works only inside. Again, the same criminals have a fenced area where others are not allowed - it would be nice if such moments were explained (beaten), but I don't think they will do so)
BoomBox_
BoomBox_
PRO
05 Feb 2021, 05:32 # Show original
@loki_art: convicts can go beyond the fences, on the contrary, no one can enter their circle
strelkovskaya
strelkovskaya
08 Feb 2021, 17:58 # Show original
@Stalker96kor: Sonya's sister needs to gain strength, apparently, because the first time she couldn't go further than the stairs, and the second time she already reached the exit.
alexrovkina
alexrovkina
08 Feb 2021, 22:51 # Show original
it seems to me that if Sonya's sister is dragged back inside, she will immediately resurrect) as we wrote earlier, a la magic works only within the monastery
lasforry
lasforry
04 Feb 2021, 22:08 # Show original
but the question does not let me go, what in the first or second series was the policeman doing in the house of this 14-year-old girl? it's also as if they've known each other for a long time (well, obviously they have, but as if there's a connection between them, maybe even she's the mother of his son)
Марго18
Марго18
05 Feb 2021, 02:19 # Show original
@lasforry: their conversation was not heard there at first, but she replied to him something like "Maybe his master took him away." He probably asked her about his missing comrade.
Grmelik
Grmelik
05 Feb 2021, 02:27 # Show original
@lasforry: and I actually thought that they were one family, that the cop was Arina's father)) Now it is clear that this is not the case, that he just came to visit Arina
id120151174
id120151174
05 Feb 2021, 00:46 # Show original
I like Max as a character
blackroq
blackroq
06 Feb 2021, 00:36 # Show original
Similarly, at least someone is doing something.
Gordey
Gordey
05 Feb 2021, 02:48 # Show original
Has Elya fallen into another reality? Why didn't the journalist find her? And my sister is a bitch.. But she needs to be dragged back to the church, you'll see and she'll recover.
tatrati
tatrati
PRO
07 Feb 2021, 23:07 # Show original
@Gordey: maybe he dragged her away from there, it didn't seem clear if they were still in the same building or not, or maybe they were further away, the journalist braked in the first class. In general, it was strange how they cut him off, did they really forget everything after finding the photo that he was following the old woman.
iken
iken
05 Feb 2021, 03:23 # Show original
ex-cons seem to be the most adequate here and really aware of what the fuck is going on here. in general, this series reminded me of the SEC objects, specifically about this http://scpfoundation.net/scp-1266-ru
Melhiorat
Melhiorat
08 Feb 2021, 08:10 # Show original
@iken: I don't know why they stopped, but it really looks like UPC. Even the church is mentioned there. As if Glukhovsky took half of the script from here)
MortVirg
MortVirg
20 Feb 2021, 03:31 # Show original
@Melhiorat: so it seems like it was originally a story, but Glukhovsky just adapted it, well, since his name is loud, they write everywhere, and I saw about the author and the story somewhere casually once
Arrivera
Arrivera
15 Feb 2021, 19:14 # Show original
@iken: it is very similar, especially about the fact that the inhabitants settle visitors at home and try to feed them.
Марго18
Марго18
16 Feb 2021, 14:32 # Show original
@iken: or could it be that Glukhovsky himself invented this object? A lot of coincidences
vladdyblog
vladdyblog
PRO
05 Feb 2021, 03:32 # Show original
It was not easy to show this in the 1st episode of the guys who crashed in a car. Perhaps in this Afterlife they undergo tests in which it will be found out whether someone will survive or die without being awarded life. According to the words that were said in one of the interviews from the creators of the series, the ending will be open and lead to reflection. This means that the answers to most or a minority of questions will need to be thought out by yourself.
AK-09
AK-09
05 Feb 2021, 05:09 # Show original
Oh, well, they twisted it, but still I'm waiting for some unexpected twist, and not one of those that come to mind :) and so you immediately remember fantasies about twin peaks and darkness :) great show so far
00rainbow00
00rainbow00
PRO
05 Feb 2021, 05:38 # Show original
I had a picture of my dead sister in a funeral frame on the screensaver for the series all the time, and lilies are lying next to it. But this was not the case in the series. Is this a glitch, do I see the future 🤔😁 or did I miss a frame?
nika_cumber
nika_cumber
08 Feb 2021, 03:55 # Show original
Such a shot was in the first episode, when they were at the house of Sonya's family.
00rainbow00
00rainbow00
PRO
05 Feb 2021, 05:40 # Show original
Why did the guy hang up the Ale, I wonder?What was his goal?
Candramelekh
Candramelekh
PRO
05 Feb 2021, 10:08 #
Comment has been deleted
Heisen_berg
Heisen_berg
05 Feb 2021, 10:35 # Show original
Everyone: discussing theories, sharing their assumptions, trying to figure out what and how ...
I: Lisa eats cucumber so appetising)0))
no4nou
no4nou
05 Feb 2021, 14:44 # Show original
Yes, the series is good, it feels like something fresh, I've been waiting for this for a long time.
Mutant_Zero
Mutant_Zero
05 Feb 2021, 16:39 # Show original
If you think the soundtracks are terrible, then you just don't have the taste :)
Estelle69
Estelle69
05 Feb 2021, 17:55 # Show original
@Mutant_Zero: the usual taste, it always has been and always will be
xlbuff
xlbuff
05 Feb 2021, 20:24 # Show original
@Mutant_Zero: yes, the devil knows, in my opinion the songs don't really fit into the atmosphere of the place and for me personally they rather break the immersion. A controversial decision, not even in the like/dislike plan.
p-elena
p-elena
09 Feb 2021, 00:39 # Show original
Unexpectedly perceive previously heard AIGEL tracks, to which this series adds other meanings)
halfling
halfling
01 Jan 2022, 19:24 # Show original
@Mutant_Zero: not just the soundtrack, but also the clip inserts.
Hannah_Abbot
Hannah_Abbot
PRO
05 Feb 2021, 18:42 # Show original
I thought Arina camgirl was moonlighting.
I like to watch the dynamics of Denis and Sonya's relationship.
For the second week, I have been tormented by the question of who made the site for them and accepts calls.
Malefika
Malefika
13 Feb 2021, 03:37 # Show original
I'm thinking about it too. Maybe the site and the monastery are real, they don't seem to have been killed on purpose, it's just a parallel world.
Florance
Florance
21 Sep 2021, 12:33 # Show original
This is the most important question - this place has a connection with our ordinary world. A website, calls, word of mouth about miracles; missing piles of people in those places who were clearly going to the monastery; a driver who knows about this place and evades answering about the missing with the phrase "you won't believe it anyway" (about what is happening here). And I'm afraid to confuse who said, it seems, too, the driver, that Denis exceeded the plan by bringing 5x with him instead of 4x. And the truck driver who "collects old ladies" and carries coffins is also interesting - where is he from? Our world or the "afterlife"? It still seems to me that it is impossible to die in the afterlife and no one needs coffins there. The priest returns after the meeting, Elya is not dead either.
Rielsey
Rielsey
05 Feb 2021, 18:55 # Show original
It's great, it's getting more and more addictive with each episode and I want to understand more and more what the hell is going on in the Swamps.
Visually, the series is generally just a delight.
xlbuff
xlbuff
05 Feb 2021, 20:16 # Show original
After watching it, there is interest, but the weekly episode release format does not suit the series at all, in my opinion. And the details are lost and the right attitude is lost. It is better to wait for the release of all the remaining episodes.
destiel2003
destiel2003
06 Feb 2021, 03:51 # Show original
I really liked Elya, I would like to know more about her, it's a pity that her character was leaked. And I also really like the soundtracks - the Aigel group perfectly fit into the gloomy atmosphere
kinosha
kinosha
06 Feb 2021, 04:34 # Show original
Weirder and weirder, as Alice would say.
Everything is fine, but it would be better to release it as a netflix, in a piece.
The first episodes blew people's brains out, but now it's strained, my emotions have already calmed down in a week.
v1v24
v1v24
06 Feb 2021, 04:38 #
Попробую спрогнозировать концовку: явного ответа на вопрос, являются Топи аномальной зоной или чистилищем, мы не получим, выберется оттуда в нормальный мир живых только Денис, так как он единственный, кто хотел уехать, т.е. цеплялся за жизнь. Он очнётся в машине среди мертвых товарищей, потом спустя время поймёт, что его рак ушёл, а платой за исцеление стали души не ценящих свою жизнь людей, которых он туда привёз.
v1v24
v1v24
06 Feb 2021, 04:52 #
Хотя может выберутся в реальный мир как раз те, кого хозяин/одноглазый изгоняет через повешение. Или их души просто упокаиваются? Понятно только одно - священник пытается выбраться из Топей именно этим способом, но безуспешно
AnyaRokenroll
AnyaRokenroll
06 Feb 2021, 07:24 #
Ой, а это интересная теория.

Если вспомнить, что обязательно надо было привезти друзей, что бы посетить монастырь. Возможно, это плата за исцеление. Или же в конце он станет перед выбором — его здоровье или же жизнь друзей.
КрошкаЕнот
КрошкаЕнот
07 Feb 2021, 03:29 # Show original
@v1v24: great theory, especially considering that the driver (I think he is the Owner) said something like - about 4 brought, well done, the plan was exceeded"
tatrati
tatrati
PRO
07 Feb 2021, 23:19 #
@v1v24: по-моему из них всех только Соня не ценит жизнь, ей нужна была лишь сестра. А вот, например, Макс не хочет уезжать просто потому что хочет найти девочек, Эля тоже искала Катю до того как попала в плен, а по ее мольбе видно, что умирать не хочет.
glado044
glado044
06 Feb 2021, 10:01 #
Я один флешбеки из «Dark” ловлю? Надеюсь Глуховской не скопирует идею
Aliceinfear
Aliceinfear
06 Feb 2021, 15:21 #
Мне одному Максим напоминает блогера Варламова?:D
m1stakе
m1stakе
08 Feb 2021, 12:26 #
@fraver: ходит там выеживается на малые архитектурные формы в виде ям с кольями.
Siropchik
Siropchik
01 Mar 2021, 01:50 #
@fraver: блин, да!)) Я ещё в первой серии об этом подумала) Ещё и журналист тоже😁
smilanich
smilanich
PRO
27 Mar 2021, 03:38 #
@fraver: а мне больше Женю Синельникова - ведущего и режиссера Орла и решки)))
AlbertValeev
AlbertValeev
06 Feb 2021, 23:38 #
Хотелось бы побольше пересечений - вот этого аналогового патриархального Предсмертия в борьбе с Цифровым Левиофаном (с телефонами героев). Чтобы как-то программа главного героя участвовала. Только лишь девочка с больной матерью отказалась фоткаться почему-то (видимо поистрепалась с 99-го) Был момент с телефоном на кладбище. Короче если смотреть через объектив камеры телефона-он покажет реальные ТОПИ и отличит мертвых от еще не определившихся живых - надо смотреть через телефон!!! True or False . И адский айфон превратиться в спасительный крест в этих Дантовских кругах ада. Ну как идейка?
mavlytovfagiz
mavlytovfagiz
PRO
07 Feb 2021, 05:19 #
@AlbertValeev: мне кажется девка за которой бегает журналист всем видится по разному. Потому что когда журналист сказал "помнишь девку у милиционера?" Макс ответил "Какую девку?"
Мне кажется они видели ее в разных обличиях)
valdislava
valdislava
27 Feb 2021, 21:38 #
@mavlytovfagiz: в сериях до этой Денис шутил про Лолиту и Гумберта, так что мне кажется одинаково видят. Хотя хз
mavlytovfagiz
mavlytovfagiz
PRO
28 Feb 2021, 01:55 #
@valdislava: вы рискуете получить спойлер)))
valkiriya88
valkiriya88
07 Feb 2021, 03:00 #
@id317342497: а кто хозяин?
mavlytovfagiz
mavlytovfagiz
PRO
07 Feb 2021, 05:20 #
@valkiriya88: Глуховский)))
bellamy
bellamy
07 Feb 2021, 05:29 #
то есть никого не смутило, что у Арины на макбуке музыка играла, когда она танцевала у зеркала)))))

и кто этот мужик, который Элю нашёл?
Lika7587
Lika7587
09 Feb 2021, 05:22 #
@bellamy: это пропавший коллега мента
valdislava
valdislava
27 Feb 2021, 21:39 #
@bellamy: так а что не так с музыкой?
tesslazy
tesslazy
28 Feb 2021, 02:27 #
Проблема в маке,такие вещи в 99 году отсутствовали
Но с другой стороны она могла подобрать это у таких как эти москвичи, «проезжавших мимо»
bellamy
bellamy
02 Mar 2021, 02:10 #
@valdislava: не так то, что в такой залупе откуда-то взялся макбук у человека, просто забавно было
ChrisRedfield
ChrisRedfield
07 Feb 2021, 09:57 #
Сериал просто охрененный. Давно не видел такой качественной мистики. Выглядит как сборник всех основных мистических шаблонов - тут вроде и заигрывания со временем есть, и намек на галлюцинации, и прямым текстом про посмертие, и злой лесной дух, и пузырь без выхода, и проживание петли... Но при этом сериал вообще ни разу не вторичен, смотрится очень захватывающе, а никакая теория так и не выглядит окончательной.

А может именно все теории и верны? Что, если тут сразу несколько аномалий замешано?
Melhiorat
Melhiorat
08 Feb 2021, 08:15 #
@ChrisRedfield: в перевале дятлова похоже было. В том плане, что перебирали все теории и идеи о смерти группы весь сериал, а в итоге (спойлер).
ChrisRedfield
ChrisRedfield
07 Feb 2021, 16:12 #
Кстати, мне все больше и больше кажется, что никакое это не посмертие. Не мог же сериал, который пытается быть загадочным и играет на полунамеках взять и вывалить интригу всего сюжета да еще и буквально прямым текстом.
Irson
Irson
07 Feb 2021, 16:38 #
Такую жесть на экране не часто увидишь. Хорошо, что не ночью смотрела её, страшно было ппц.
Meloman_Nastena
Meloman_Nastena
21 Oct 2021, 01:36 #
Ночью как раз смотрю… ошибка моя
AiaBerezko
AiaBerezko
07 Feb 2021, 23:25 #
Есть идея, что мент отправился в монастырь, чтобы отмолить своего сына и сам за него «остался», возможно, он ехал с напарником, но напарник выжил и из Топей спасся, таким образом пропал. Короче, столько всего в голову приходит.
И им нужно очень сильно обосраться в финале, чтобы я поставила 4 звезды. Просто обалденно неожиданно от наших! Молодцы! Просто красавчики.
Kopylovayulia
Kopylovayulia
07 Feb 2021, 23:42 #
Пока, конечно, кажется, что они мертвы. Катя исчезла потому что выжила. Обратила внимание, в первых сериях, когда она остановила того мужика на грузовике с гробом, он ещё про неё сказал, что она единственная живая из них. Тогда бабулька это и есть Катя, которая умерла уже в старости. Водителя тоже почему не было, потому что он выжил. Единственное, пока не понятно, что за хозяин и как и зачем появилась Сонина сестра.
id227797
id227797
14 Sep 2022, 17:33 #
Хорошо если Катя выжила. А то как-то её прям слили
BCubbins
BCubbins
07 Feb 2021, 23:46 #
Просто хочу отметить отменную и чертовски правдоподобную игру всего актёрского состава
Очень приятный момент!
Melhiorat
Melhiorat
08 Feb 2021, 07:28 #
У нас медицина только для здорового человека бесплатная ©
Полотенце
Полотенце
08 Feb 2021, 09:24 #
Show comment
m1stakе
m1stakе
08 Feb 2021, 12:29 #
@Полотенце: не забудь взять с собой полотенце, когда будешь смотреть следующую серию
maybe12345
maybe12345
08 Feb 2021, 10:32 #
серия понравилсь меньше, чем предыдущие. мало динамики. общение Макса с Ариной повтор из предыдущей серии не раскрывает их персонажей, не двигает сюжет

из динамичного: Лиза, живая и вредная, как противоположность Сони, эпизод, где Макс находит фото Арины в школе, беседа Макса с зеками.

Испытание для Эли отстой, можно хоть в мистическом сериале не смаковать будни маньяка.

Священник по ходу вешается каждый день, наказание у него такое. Вешать еще и и Элю фантазии не хватило у сценаристов.
Mordecai
Mordecai
22 Oct 2021, 13:25 #
@maybe12345: почему фантазии не хватило? может, это какой-то оче
редной способ выбраться из "Топи" в этой вселенной.
ushakoffa
ushakoffa
08 Feb 2021, 17:27 #
Какое макабрическое зрелище - этот танец Арины (Лолиты/Маргариты) перед зеркалом!
zSarkasm
zSarkasm
21 Feb 2021, 08:12 #
Класс ! Поддерживаю вообще мнение , мне тоже Арина напомнила о Маргарите !
id227797
id227797
14 Sep 2022, 17:44 #
Я тоже вспомнила о Маргарите, когда она перед зеркалом танцевала
Chertanovskiy
Chertanovskiy
08 Feb 2021, 17:58 #
Заметили, что тут постоянно делают акцент на воду? Они пьют воду постоянно, обливаются ею и т д. И ещё такое впечатление, что кроме огурцов (опять же состоят почти из одной воды), у них другой еды не существует.
Fadelena
Fadelena
09 Feb 2021, 02:06 #
Помидорки были
barbarian88
barbarian88
09 Feb 2021, 02:17 #
@Chertanovskiy: картошка ж ещё, они на ней и держатся)
Demya_
Demya_
09 Feb 2021, 18:11 #
@Chertanovskiy: да-да... еще название тОпи, топИ могут обыграть
Полотенце
Полотенце
08 Feb 2021, 23:52 #
Пай девочка Соня прям полная противоположность шлюшки Ленки из Трудных подростков
MaLyutka
MaLyutka
09 Feb 2021, 00:20 #
Comment has been deleted
hermionajjj
hermionajjj
09 Feb 2021, 01:10 #
Comment has been deleted
x0m1ak
x0m1ak
PRO
09 Feb 2021, 01:49 #
Comment has been deleted
annlove7
annlove7
09 Feb 2021, 11:46 #
Опять деревня, опять чудеса чудесные какие то, зеки в лесу
mativ
mativ
09 Feb 2021, 13:55 #
В сериале много пасхалок, намеков, аллегорий. Свежий пример: когда Денис пытается молится, по левую сторону стоит сестра Лиза в черном и убеждает, что бога нет, по правую Соня, в светлом и просит верить - как по классике дьявол над левым плечом, ангел над правым.
purcess_leia
purcess_leia
10 Feb 2021, 21:35 #
@mativ: Я бы назвала это не пасхалками, а средствами выразительности 🙃 Но здорово, что вы обратили внимание
valdislava
valdislava
27 Feb 2021, 21:41 #
@mativ: а ещё?
vikalebidko
vikalebidko
09 Feb 2021, 19:16 #
На самом деле все запутанно! Все больше придерживаюсь версии,что они на самом деле все разбились ещё в начале! Но Катя выжила, потому что когда она привела водителя,чтобы он вытащил их машину он сказал: Берегите ее! Она из вас всех больше всего на живую похожа! Катя выжила,но забыла где она живёт(об этом нам и говорит старушка с жёлтым платком). С девушкой у которой мама пострадала от аварии на заводе тоже по всей видимости мертва( ей уже должно быть больше 30 лет).
vk217280
vk217280
11 Feb 2021, 12:59 #
@Chertanovskiy: и драка в воде, и женская рыжая голова из воды выглялывала, и Денис пьёт все время воду в деревне и в монастыре тоже...
zSarkasm
zSarkasm
21 Feb 2021, 08:14 #
Во во ! Женская рыжая голова тоже очень заинтересовала !
Mordecai
Mordecai
22 Oct 2021, 13:28 #
@vk217280: кто это?? что это??
id227797
id227797
14 Sep 2022, 17:34 #
Да рыжая голова это интересно
veer
veer
13 Feb 2021, 04:30 #
Жаль что сериал не вышел целиком сразу, такое хочется смотреть залпом!
vikusya_love
vikusya_love
14 Feb 2021, 02:34 #
Comment has been deleted
Севереса
Севереса
17 Feb 2021, 23:44 #
А что если возвращает и делает чудеса не Бог, а Хозяин?
Из-за чего все те, кто у него попросили будут в долгах или не смогут уйти тоже?
Darula
Darula
PRO
03 Mar 2021, 00:52 #
@Севереса: отличное предположение! Значит, Соня и Денис уже обречены
Redopera
Redopera
18 Feb 2021, 01:20 #
Очень хорошо.
Пока воздержусь от разбирательств.
Чувствуется Глуховский.
raven_earl
raven_earl
18 Feb 2021, 06:00 #
Аигел - существует.
Создатели Топей - пихают её треки везде где можно.
qds
qds
20 Feb 2021, 01:50 #
Кучерявый идет искать в дом, сначала во всеоружии с какой-то палкой, а потом просто читает книгу спиной ко входу, после чего просто уходит. Я уж не говорю о том чтобы предупредить кого-то перед тем как идти туда, взять кого-то с собой, рассказать хотя бы что он видел, когда возвращается домой. Очень умные и мотивированные герои (нет). Бредятина.
_прокрастинатор_
_прокрастинатор_
PRO
22 Feb 2021, 02:22 #
как же мне абсолютно неинтресна линия Сони. да и вообще эту героиню искренне считаю очень пресной что ли. девчуля красивая (и в каждом кадре мне напоминает Вику Синицину с такими же бездонно голубыми глазами), но на этом все.

хадрящий Денис в компании Сони наполняют на меня какую-то тоску и печаль. и это срочно нужно исправлять. когда-нибудь я дождусь тандем Дениса и Макса как это было в первых 2-х сериях забавно, бодро и с харизмой и химией героев, а пока имеем, что имеем.

очень понравился Макс в этой серии. увидел "платок" побежал спасать, узнал что-то побежал докапываться до правды (хотя я бы сначала к Арине сходила). и какой же Тихон классный, вот без шуток (очень боялась за Грома, но, видимо, зря такого "своего" парня подобрали).

милиционер вызывает только положительные эмоции. говорит все как есть и ещё и пытается оградить ребят от всей этой фигни, что творится.

п.сы вот смотришь сериал все так мрачно, депрессивно, жутко, а потом открываешь инсту Тихона или Вани, а там "'солнечная" фоточка, как они рассматривают жучка🤭
valdislava
valdislava
27 Feb 2021, 21:43 #
@_прокрастинатор_: мне про Соню тоже так. Очень многообещающая внешность, а по факту ничего
valdislava
valdislava
27 Feb 2021, 21:44 # Show original
So this is an afterlife/purgatory for whom? For a specific area or city (funny)?
АннаДякина
АннаДякина
01 Mar 2021, 17:40 # Show original
It's good that there is this application - check all your guesses with others, and it's easier to look further) it's twisted, of course, as much as possible, and I love this atmosphere of devastation of the past, semi-abandoned old cities..
Annie10792
Annie10792
02 Mar 2021, 19:40 # Show original
As I understand it, Lisa can now only live within the confines of this monastery? Like the price of resurrection?
macaron
macaron
25 Apr 2021, 18:15 # Show original
"Where is Angarsk anyway? That's some kind of ass, too, isn't it? Inside the afterlife.."

The very moment when he came from Angarsk hd
Sherumidan
Sherumidan
25 Apr 2021, 20:37 # Show original
That awkward moment when you don't get into the game of some of the main characters. It is possible to trace the character of Katya, Sophia, and even Eli well. In the sense that their background is clear, as well as their actions based on this very background.

What is going on with the characters of Maxim and Danchik's characters is sometimes not entirely clear to me. It's like there's an even wagering going on, and then, out of the blue, BANG and you see some kind of game. As it was, for example, during the skirmish on the lake. Why was this scene necessary? To show that Maxim aka ebyr the terrorist is not empty in itself, but represents something? That he supposedly really cares about the lost girls and at the same time in some strange way protects their honor, trying to punch a sick Denis in the face? Denis's main motives are also a bit difficult to understand. Something can be attributed to a disease, something to very strange pills, but sometimes you sit and look at everything with a straight face. Is there some kind of game going on around and the best thing to do is to fold your paws and wait until the pain covers your head? If it was an attempt to get depressed from the hopelessness of the situation, then it was more like a game of a moody child. "I won't, because go on."

I certainly really liked the painting. The work of the film crew, the acting, and yes, the script from Glukhovsky is just on top. But these strange throw-ins (you can't call them anything else) are a little unsettling. The characters of the female characters are well sustained, you understand the causal relationship. But men's... It seems that some moments were filmed either to increase the timing, or to sluggishly prop up the plot in the right direction, or so that we simply do not forget that some characters still really exist in the narrative.
Florance
Florance
21 Sep 2021, 12:47 # Show original
You might think that in everyday life, people's actions are always understandable to others.
id264460076
id264460076
26 Apr 2021, 15:34 # Show original
I feel God is not returning their dead relatives...
I feel sorry for Sonya, Denis too.
aries_moon
aries_moon
08 May 2021, 16:52 # Show original
Where is Angarsk anyway? Is it also some kind of posthumous ass?
I, who live in Irkutsk: 🗿😂 well, in principle it is true
DarkNightSky
DarkNightSky
13 Jun 2021, 03:56 # Show original
Why does Arina have such a fresh manicure😅
scotinka1337
scotinka1337
26 Jun 2021, 15:16 # Show original
Here, under the previous episodes, everyone compared the series with Darkness, and for me, by episode 4, an analogy with American Horror Story suggests itself. They also like to show some fuckers where the dead live.
Mordecai
Mordecai
22 Oct 2021, 14:21 # Show original
@scotinka1337: What is the season of ahi? or with all the seasons combined?
PrincessZuko
PrincessZuko
12 Aug 2021, 01:59 # Show original
Damn reminiscent of the German "Dark"
attlst
attlst
15 May 2022, 12:12 # Show original
@PrincessZuko: they stole the screensaver already (in the first episode), so I think the inspiration was one hundred percent
Domenika
Domenika
01 Sep 2021, 22:24 # Show original
I don't like red smoke, that's right, it doesn't look natural at all... The game is happening and there are more and more questions, nothing is clear with the sister, how she was returned and taken away again, it seems they have all been stuck in some place between for a long time.
Meloman_Nastena
Meloman_Nastena
21 Oct 2021, 01:39 # Show original
Why am I watching this at night?
attlst
attlst
15 May 2022, 12:12 # Show original
I thought Sonya would at least try to drag her sister back when she was already lying down, but no
Maria2816
Maria2816
11 Jul 2022, 17:21 # Show original
"Fight" in the water 🙄😂😂😂😂👍
id227797
id227797
14 Sep 2022, 17:38 # Show original
Why does Denis constantly touch his face in front of the mirror
id227797
id227797
14 Sep 2022, 17:47 # Show original
It's not clear to me. If Arina is all sexy: naked in the garden, dancing in front of the mirror. What is it that turns a journalist off? Or maybe she's this mysterious master's favorite?
ОльгаВоробей
ОльгаВоробей
07 Mar 2023, 21:41 # Show original
The red-haired girl surfaced in the lake?I wonder what that means..There are more and more questions ..
Enjoy230
Enjoy230
19 Aug 2023, 15:59 # Show original
It is even more unclear
Lia15
Lia15
PRO
10 Jan 00:23 # Show original
They are either all under something, or they still died in episode 1.
Do I understand correctly? Or even some kind of nonsense and just a favorite bed trip hahah
posredstveno
posredstveno
06 May 18:46 # Show original
I don't know why everyone compares with darkness, for me it's so much closer to the swamps from the outside than darkness.
lenacherrypanova
lenacherrypanova
23 May 20:21 # Show original
My first thought is to drag my sister back to the monastery.
lenacherrypanova
lenacherrypanova
23 May 20:22 # Show original
I don't believe that Ale will die. Maybe someone will break in and save you? Can Max do it?
Add a comment:
Ads