It was BRILLIANT. I really missed the episodes where every 3 seconds you ask yourself the question "what's going on?". The fake Doctor and Donna were so creepy and interesting at the same time. And this empty ship, strange sounds, constant tension.... You're wondering every second if they're real. And how cool the relationship between the Doctor and Donna showed. It seems to me that no one understands him as well as she does, real soulmates! AND OF COURSE THE ENDING!!! Wilf, we missed you.😭 And explosions at the end!!! Something grandiose is planned, we are really waiting for the toymaker! In general, 10/10. Very much in the spirit of the old doctor
To be left without a TARDIS and without a screwdriver, that's a risky venture xxx
- What was that? - Some kind of noise. - Thank you, you helped me a lot :D
The Doctor and Donna are in the same episode together without other characters - oh, yes! What was needed! The graphics of some moments, of course, really returned to the tenth) The detective component is also straight from there, and it was the atmosphere of this series that I liked more than the previous one. I rested my soul and returned at the same time) The aliens with their long arms, jaws and all that brought back memories of the first seasons (but in the best sense).
The insanely sad story of the ship's captain. What a sacrifice for the sake of all living things :with And a very cool interaction between the Doctor and Donna. Being literally in the "void" is a strong move, I love that. Of course, it was funny that he left her at the end, in the end she was saved by the fact that the TARDIS calculated the difference in wrist length :D
Uiiilf! How glad I am to meet you!
However...The Doctor scattered salt at the edge of the universe and the Earth went crazy...Something strange, but still very interesting :)
What have we got? A remix of Midnight with an admixture of a two-part series about Flesh and the Day of the Doctor (a line about zygons).
Did I like the series? Yes. Was I worried about Donna, who was left behind? Yes. Everything is great.
A couple of things I didn't like: 1) the tempo was compressed at the end, I'd rather throw out the scene with Isaac Newton to hell. Out of place at all. And I added these couple of moments to the ending, where the Doctor somehow drives away the non-Donna in a more interesting way. There would be more drama to put the squeeze on here! 2) This series could have gotten 5 points from me, if not for the long tongue of RTD (for which no one pulled it) and the director, who gasped and groaned that it was hard. What's hard? Should I keep a greenscreen for David and Catherine? Or maybe make stretchable body parts? Oh, yes, there was no such thing (season 6 - wink wink). Or maybe a copy-shifter? Oh, yes, the first one was gone at Midnight, and the second one was gone on Doctor's Day. In short, fewer words and more business is needed, and it's better to keep the ENT of the series in mind. 3) Strange passages through the Doctor himself. "We are at the edge of the universe -this has never happened before." BRO, JUST A COUPLE OF EPISODES AGO WITH TEKTEYUN! And then he tells about the Fluxus himself. Is that what it is? What for?
In short, damn, fuck RTD with his comments. I won't read anything by episode 3.
@NebSehemvi: Well, as I understand it, the edge of the universe and THE VOID that lies between the universes (and where the Doctor was in Flax) these are different concepts. Although, according to the Tardis wiki, the Doctor at the edge of the universe has already visited the classics and the expanded universe more than once (https://tardis .fandom.com/wiki/Edge_of_the_universe)
@Rompotte: As far as I remember, in Flax, they crossed from one end of the universe to the other end of the universe through the void. Plus, the creatures themselves came from the void.
It seems that there is still some slight illogicality.
Plus, it's very strange that in the Flax it was really shown as from edge to edge - they had the old universe behind them. And then they said that there was no light, because the stars were very far away. It turns out that in the Distance they were in the void then? Is the Bottle still on the edge?
@NebSehemvi: I agree that this is not very logical, and the frame with two universes from Flax does not make any sense at all (for example, in "Army of Ghosts" the Doctor says that in the Void there is "no light, no darkness, no top, no bottom, no life, no time"). We'll have to wait for Cambulian flat mathematics to figure it all out)
@NebSehemvi: As I understand it, it depends on which dimensions to look at. He has never been on the edge of our physical universe, for example. And Flax is generally in another dimension.
@Haraborsh: yes, the whole promotion was about the fact that we won't tell you anything, there hasn't been such a thing in DC yet, you fall off the chairs.
Then they posted this in the DC magazine itself: In the magazine’s episode preview, the “Starring” section lists “David Tennant, Catherine Tate, [REDACTED], [REDACTED], [REDACTED]”
The names ended up being that woman with Newton, Newton and Wilf at the end. Everyone (especially in the Anglophandom) imagined who would be there. My MAXIMUM bets were modest, some kind of eyeliner in the spirit will save someone from the ship, maybe some character from DC, who will be needed in the 3rd cycle. Or maybe Jokey will light up at the end of episode 2 (and Wilf lit up - although it's a pity that this was the only scene for all three episodes, he won't be in the third)
That's why I have complaints about the marketing of this series. In general, RTD is on his mind and likes to praise himself in public, so it would be right to ignore what he says and look at the fact. Unfortunately, I didn't know about this, because for seasons 1-4, DC wasn't particularly interesting to me from a production point of view and I didn't listen to what he was broadcasting there.
Specifically about the director - he either jokingly or seriously whined a little and said "the one who will shoot it will not be lucky," and then it turned out that they wanted to give him this script and he groaned that it was hard and no one had ever shot this before. And I still didn't understand what I wasn't filming? There were stretching body parts in DC, there were scenes with "clones" (the same flesh, the same Day of the Doctor in the black archive). And they also dared to say in a documentary about the shooting that there was no such thing in DC or in any other TV project, and that made me laugh.
@NebSehemvi: I get what you're talking about, although I don't agree with everything. I agree about what REDACTED resulted in in the magazine. I do not agree that we have already seen everything that happened in the series.
@Haraborsh: why don't you agree that we've already seen everything that happened in the series? What did we see that was fundamentally new?
Again, I'm not saying that the elements don't work or are harmful to the series - on the contrary, everything works fine. I'm just saying that the promotion is too loud and bold, with all the elements that have already been there. But with expectations, there is just a smaller problem, of course, that RTD apparently does not know how to work with the expectations of the audience, but it is also the fault of the audience if they wrote something down there in [REDACTED].
@NebSehemvi: we can discuss VK later, if you want, I'm afraid it won't be very convenient here. For example, I can't attach pictures here without a PRO
@NebSehemvi: I think "redacted" is a joke about the fact that Tennant and Tate are essentially two characters each playing. Well, plus Newton, MB, is an actor from the TV series "It's a sin" by the same Davis, fans should be pleased Well, the director clarified on Twitter before the show that the secrecy was not due to the return of someone, but to watch and not have any clues about what would happen next, so that it would be more interesting (for me it turned out that way)
Well, he's the good old Doctor Who! The second hurdle is much better than the first one definitely. I really liked the plot of this series and the kind of thriller atmosphere, and the whole episode with only the Doctor and Donna is the best that could be, Tennant and Tate are the best duo ever!
@driveshaft: Damn, I was swearing out loud too. What the fuck did they do that for?! It is Newton, who we know exactly what he looked like. Just fuck it? I can't believe in my life that there wasn't another actor for this role. Specific sabotage.
The distance, of course, is very similar to Midnight. In some ways, Midnight is even scarier, because we will never know where this thing came from. But the distance is still amazing..... I love the reference to Marvin from the Hitchhiker's Guide! I love the fact that, like in a good detective story, all the evidence is collected by you! I figured it all out a little bit before the Doctor-and that's great.
It is a pity that the Doctor, despite all his newfound openness, still cannot share something with Donna. But on the other hand, at least now he could really admit that he was not okay. It seems like it's bigger than ever.
Is it scary for the thread with gravity — will it become the thing that broke the universe or just a constant joke? 👀
This is a very cool series, I was pleased with the atmosphere, it has not been like this for a long time, an interesting atmosphere, I also liked that they remembered the Stream (I hope they will talk about the timeless child later), Wilf is back. It's just great!
An interesting series. It's a pity that many conversations took place with their fake versions, although the Doctor and Donna can understand each other without words, and this cannot be taken away from them.
Wilf! ❤️
It's just like the Doctor to sprinkle salt on the edge of the universe and-oh...
Mavity is alarming, I hope this is not just a joke, but also has to do with the overall plot, and in the end everything will return as it was.
@Darkes: I haven't watched the reconstructions or read the novelization of the story of "Celestial Toymaker" with the First Doctor, so I have no idea what happened there, but considering that the Toymaker will appear in the third special episode, then here's my completely ill-conceived fan theory in three seconds - superstition in the form of salt and a change in the past awakened at the edge of the universe from gravity to gravity, the Toymaker was somehow released/summoned. Well, accordingly, correcting the situation with the Toyboy will somehow lead to the restoration of the name "gravity" and to the regeneration of the Fourteenth Doctor into the Fifteenth.
@Darkes: It turns out that the Doctor did not recognize the real Donna twice. It's a shame for her (I opened up with a copy, but I didn't tell the real Donna anything.
At first, I kept thinking that the Doctor and Donna were just making fun of Newton, who said mavity. But in fact, they had already flown away from him by that moment. Something is clearly wrong here... 🤔
I understood it in such a way that since he said "gravity", gravity no longer existed in history and this particular option remained. Therefore, even the Doctor corrected himself later, when Donna asked again, they say, "what kind of "gravity"?".
@pinta_vodki: This is a joke about the butterfly effect. it is not clear yet whether there will be any more serious consequences (I think not, but you never know).
@April: I think the Doctor understands this (he called it right), and will fix it somehow in between. But it's cool if they keep calling her that for a while. If there is a hurry in the third, then there should be exactly gravity, it turns out
The second episode, I'm just squealing with delight. The "midnight" creep vibe, and the moment when it suddenly turned out that there were doppelgangers – I had SUCH goosebumps.
At the very end, when the Doctor left Donna, I believed for a few seconds that this was all that RTD really arranged for her to end like this. How glad I am that the Tardis figured out the liar, although I am sad that the Doctor did not recognize her himself.
And how unexpected and delightful it was to see Wilf 🥹
I just can't believe that the next episode is already the last with David and Catherine, so I want a whole season with them! Although Joking is also very much looking forward to new stories)
@Olululala: I think in the end he didn't even think, he just acted. Although it was possible not to involve the Tardis, just to see how she looks at the Tardis))
I really liked the episode, 10 out of 10, I'm still in a wonderful state of nostalgia and I'm really enjoying the return of Russell T. Davis, Murray Gold, David Tennant and Catherine Tate. and then there was the most wonderful and sincere Wilf pleased with his appearance, I was sure that it was worth waiting for him only in the "Chuckle" (the third anniversary special)
I will not hide that due to the increased secrecy surrounding this particular episode, all the "jubilee" hopes were pinned on him for the return of some previously unknown familiar characters - River Song, the Eleventh Doctor, Dr. "Ruth" the Fugitive, Karvanista, Captain Jack Harkness, Gwen Cooper, the Thirteenth Doctor, Yaz, the Master, Missy, Martha Jones, Amy Pond, Clara Oswald, Vashta Nerada, the main five from the "Class"... Of course, not the whole crowd, but at least someone. The expectations from this mysterious episode were for all 15 out of 10, and unfortunately it did not meet such high expectations.
The anticipation before the "Chuckle" is still beyond the limit, and my poor heart feels that I will cry at the repeated farewell to Donna and on the stage of Tennant's third regeneration.
But if the anniversary returns are really limited to David Tennant and Donna Noble and her family, then it turns out that three special editions in honor of the 60th anniversary of Doctor Who are epic, ONE last episode of the Chris Chibnell era "The Power of the Doctor" in which there were a Master, Daleks, Cybermen, regeneration of the Thirteenth (technically two regeneration of the Thirteenth), Tegan Giovanca, Ace, The First Doctor, The Fifth Doctor, the Sixth Doctor, the Seventh Doctor, The Eighth Doctor, Dr. "Ruth" The Fugitive, Kate Sewart, Ian Chesterton, Melanie Bush, Joe Grant... And yes, it was an anniversary episode in honor of the 100th anniversary of the BBC channel, but still!
Of course, I liked the episode, but I completely did not understand why the Tardis flew away (because of these "doppelgangers", or because of the impending explosion), and most importantly, why did it return, because none of the threats were eliminated?
@Demonakor: The threat was that these creatures would leave the ship and start a war all over the universe. The easiest way for them is to capture the Tardis, which is why she flew away immediately, and returned only when the bomb was accelerated and it was already clear that the creatures would be destroyed.
@almaz_nasurdinov: I agree. The Tardis has returned for the Doctor, and who the owner drags into the house: an old girlfriend, a new girlfriend, a robo-dog, a talking cabbage or a reasonable slime is no longer the business of the Tardis.
@nandi: or the Tardis has a non-linear consciousness, perhaps in some sense she foresaw when she needed to leave and when to return. Although even this understanding of time seems too human to me.
An amazing episode, just amazing! The moment when you realize that there is a fake Doctor and Donna is just creepy Well, the ending of the episode broke my heart 💔
Well, I will write separately that these two episodes for me were like I met an old friend again, whom we had not seen for a very long time and at the same time immediately realized that we were all the same and how much we missed each other! I was very afraid that this reunion would be like 99% of all reunions - it seems to be the same actors, but it is clear that the same chemistry is not even close. How wonderful that this is not the case here at all!
@Leonius: It's good for a regular series, but not for an anniversary issue. RTD said that he had planned a season of 12 episodes with Tate and Tennant in general, but due to the schedules of the actors, only 3 episodes.
@Mozzy: Only 3 episodes? I was hoping there would be a Christmas party with Tennant, too. It's a shame, but I hope before leaving this time he will still say that he is ready now...
A very good episode! This whole empty ship, with a creepy rusty robot making strange noises, immediately made me think of something not good. The creatures were wildly creepy, of course. Especially when they were stretched. The moment that Donna saw all these 15 years of Doc's life (and I think she did), it's so sad... And I really feel sorry for Doc.
Well, the ending is something! Wilfred!🥺🤩 Give me the next episode. How much time had passed on Earth while Doc and Donna were flying?
@schqual: in fact, the ship was supposed to become a full-fledged trap - a huge locked box so that nothing would escape from there. But since the creatures would have understood why he was doing this if the ship was being redesigned quickly, it was simply slowed down, just like the robot. So yes, the ship was preparing to explode, sealing itself and confusing the enemies more and more
@Leonius: what other vague hints about orientation? It's the Doctor, I mean, what's the problem? well, except that it seems to me that he would ignore any person in this regard and would not notice
@Leonius: the fact that the word agenda is used is already clear with the continuation of the conversation, but I will still say that the Doctor can be anyone, evaluate and even love anyone, regardless of who he is now, because, as he himself once said, they have no framework in gender stereotypes and in general he is an alien, all these terms may not even concern him :D
@Leonius: I agree that it is not necessary, but not for the reason that you specify, in principle, many similar scenes can be said that they are not needed, but for some reason quibbles only occur when it comes to characters of the same sex and I can agree that part of it is somehow clumsily inscribed in the plot and in places it hurts the eye-a rumor, but in principle you can ignore against the background of other advantages and good things , but this is not yet a dude who will probably be in the next season, if not in the season, for a combo, so to speak, so whether it will still be :D
@Geist-Luft: that's exactly what I wrote for the last episode, so the message about female power and you're a man, you won't understand, looked extremely inappropriate
@blackmore: but the Doctor did not determine it by anatomy (where the Tardis determined the difference between 100 and 99.9), but by a test question that he asked himself. And the Doctor liked the clone's answer better. That's the fiasco Leonius is talking about.
@id5098067: well, the fact that he immediately began to check says that he didn't really believe it, he just made a decision in the face of a catastrophic shortage of vermin.
@Krasnogvardeets: if anything, some people can love both girls and boys at the same time, respectively, there are zero contradictions with those events with Rosa
@Geist-Luft: If the Doctor was asexual in the classics, in the restart of the hetero (although considering the 13th this is not entirely true; probably, you can say ginefil_coy), in the new restart of the bi, then what next??? A really alarming trend. Soon no one will be able to protect themselves from the Doctor's love)
@Rompotte: well, I wouldn't say that about restarting, have you seen the Doctor with the Master? that's about it xD yes, it's a pity all the Doctor's entourage, no one can escape, a new fluh is coming :D
@Ianthinus: Well, yes, probably. I rather meant that on the screen we were mostly shown his relationships with women (with a few exceptions like flirting with Captain Jack, crashing on the Master and the android boyfriend)
@Krasnogvardeets: for me, it was not at all about gayness, but in principle about openness in saying that someone is hot there, just as it is now easier for him to say about feelings, so sexuality began to be expressed more clearly, and not necessarily homosexuality. this subtext didn't even surprise me, there could have been a beautiful woman in Newton's place, and the scene would have been perceived exactly the same way. it seemed to me that it had long been clear about the Doctor that he leans in both directions, or in principle does not divide people by gender.
The series... uh. Maybe not super straight, but good. The atmosphere holds until the end. Even the graphics seem to have kinks, but at the same time you can feel the atmosphere of old movies and TV series. Doppelgangers are just a miracle. This series is definitely several times stronger and better than any with 13 doctors. Personally, the series came to me. I think if I read the comments above, I will immediately see the disadvantages, but it will be later. And at the time of writing this comment, everything is sound.
@akifa: There was the end of the universe, not the edge. Trillions of years into the future and trillions of light-years from Earth are not the same thing. Time and distance are different concepts. Moreover, "Utopia" with Professor Jan, which the Tenth Doctor, Martha and Captain Jack got into, is not even the only place at the end of the universe, there was also Orson Pink's ship in the episode "Listen" and the place where the Twelfth Doctor and Clara met Ashilda in "Hell Bent". Chronologically, the point is the same - the end of the universe, geographically - the points are different, three different stones in different places, presumably very far from the place where the Fourteenth and Donna ended up in this episode.
If you really wanted to get to the bottom of it, then you could remember that a couple of episodes ago in "Flux" the Thirteenth Doctor was with Tekteyun BEYOND the edge of the universe, on the edge of ANOTHER, new universe.
And the Eleventh Doctor was outside the universe in "The Doctor's Wife", he was in the pocket universe in "Hide", and the Tenth was in a parallel universe in "Rise of the Cybermen / Age of Steel". And that's if you don't touch the classics.
Вот это уже гораздо больше похоже на ДК, которого я когда-то любила! Крепкая серия с параноидальной атмосферой)) И как приятно было увидеть Уилфреда! Он и взаимодействие Доктора с Донной прям вернули в старые-добрые)) Из минусов выделю слабый графон, но в целом пофиг на него, серия удалась!
У меня не то чтобы были ожидания к серии, но она их превзошла! Большое спасибо за возвращение старого доброго ДК, и мне абсолютно всё равно, что серия в какой-то мере похожа на другие, так как это было уже очень давно, а сериалу 60 лет:D Всё новое - это хорошо забытое старое!
Обожаю ДК! Не моргай, не дыши, не улыбайся, не думай и т.п. Серия хороша. Я в очередной раз убедилась, что дуэт Доктора и Донны — один из любимейших мной в ньюскуле. Актерская игра Дэвида и Кэтрин, как всегда, на высоте. Стабильно: если переживает/плачет Донна, переживаю/плачу и я. А Уилф в конце, что называется, «добил». Как хорошо, что нам довелось ещё раз увидеть Бернарда Криббинса в этой чудеснейшей роли. Светлая память ему❤️ Промо следующей серии интригует. Жду с нетерпением погрузиться в очередной хаос.
Серии просто чудесные, так скучала по 10) Будет очень грустно, когда он будет уходить опять( Я не хочу что бы они уходили. Хочу 3-4 сезона что бы вот именно на уровне вышедших 2х серий. Я безумно рада когда ждала их, но теперь понимаю, что последняя серия скоро и это означет уход... очень грустно...
Я, конечно, кайфанула от серии, но... момент, где Доктору в конце понравился ответ фальшивой Донны... и когда он по началу не узнавал разницу между настоящей и фальшивой (про то, откуда она) ... это так разбивает сердечко... особенно, потому что она сама разгадала фальшивого Доктора...
И даа это было офигенно!!! Без шуток. Нам обещали хоррор эпизод, мы получили хоррор эпизод. Двойник Доктора уж слишком долго бежал к роботу, как удобно, когда у главных героев есть сюжетная броня)) Это точно не тот десятый доктор-В этой серии это было особенно видно. Он эмоционален, открыт, местами осторожен. Полная противоположность безбашенному Десятому и это Фантастика, серьезно! Его истерика, когда он сболтнул недоДонне лишнего бесценна!!!! Теннант шикарный!!Боже,я его обожаю!!! Донна - прекрасная!!Оказавшись с Доктором в новой среде, все, о чем она думает, что ей эти приключения уже не нужны. Что у нее есть любящий муж и замечательная дочь. Вот это я называю развитие и взросление персонажа...
Серия крутая, сначала не понимаешь что происходит, а потом жуть полная под конец. Напомнило серию "Полночь" из 4 сезона, где доктора тоже нечто копировало его.
С Ньютона упал: "- Что это за слово, потяжение, поежение, ПАЖИЖЕНИЕ"
Через некоторое время Доктор: - Донна, это сила притяжения. - Чего? - То есть пажижение!
Я тот человек, которому вообще пофиг на количество черных на квадратный метр серии. Но хоть убейте, никогда не пойму одного - зачем пихать чернокожих на исторически белых людей? В чем прикол? 😂 Это всё равно, что поставить Киану Ривза на роль Барака Обамы 🤣 Уверен, будет весело.
@kronenberg: Где вы чернокожих в серии увидели? Актер сыгравший Ньютона наполовину белый, наполовину индиец. И мне кажется, РТД просто любит брать привлекательных мужчин на роли исторических гениев(см. Шекспир, актер которого, как мне кажется, еще менее похож на настоящего Шекспира)
@mmyau: есть кстати, надгробный посмертный бюст в цвете, который является подтвержденным экспертами, но там вообще другой человек, чем мы привыкли воспринимать, но там ему 51 год, и он немного с не живого леплен.
@kronenberg: а давайте инопланетян будут настоящие инопланетяне играть? Для достоверности, а то как-то совсем не то. А Ньютона обязательно кареглазый чувак, потому что зачем же брать зеленоглазого, если мы знаем про карие глаза. И подобный фактчекинг можно довести до бессмысленности. И я уверена, что из Киану вышел бы отличный Обама, хотя пример не совсем правомерен, учитывая, что это первый президент-афроамериканец, то есть это большая часть сюжета и мотивации персонажа, на это нужен акцент. Ну камон, это все театр, в тех случаях, где это реально непринципиально, то какая разница, как он выглядит. Сериал все равно исторически недостоверен, мы смотрим на Ньютона глазами человека из современного мира, приписываем ему осовремененные слова, реакции, язык тела, грим, "причесываем" мир прошлого - от авгиевых конюшен на улицах и каких-нить туалетов в парадных залах. Ну так и пусть тот условный мир будет расово более разнообразен чем был на самом деле. А для достоверного изображения истории есть другие фильмы.
После 13-го доктора таксиста, которого в хуй не ставили пассажиры, очень прикольно наблюдать как 10-му говорят "Тыж Доктор, давай решай\делай\вытаскивай нас из этого дерьма".
Wow, this is the kind of Doctor I've missed! I just realized how much I've missed him in recent years.
It's funny, because in fact we have a two-actor theater here, but there is plenty of action. Graphon, of course, is eyesore. But perhaps such unnaturalness is even for the best. The sinister valley effect, that's it. Some scenes, like the long arms or the huge Doctor and Donna running on all fours, will definitely give me nightmares. Well, I generally like to mess up when you need to determine where the copy is and where the real one is. It's always fun and interesting.
Tennant is an actor. I was really hooked by the moment when the false Madonna pressed him with memories. He snapped, saying, of course I'm running, because how can I stop, look back and see all that I left behind. Tennant had so much pain on his face. And then when he realized that Donna wasn't real... Goosebumps. At such moments, you remember that the Doctor is not a guy from the next street, but a millennial time traveler. Who saw more than he needed to. It's a pity Tennant only dropped by for three episodes. I demand a full season of 10-12 episodes for the Fourteenth. You are welcome.
@Allons_y: a full season would be very cool, like RTD even wanted to do that, but the actors' schedules are too loaded, they managed to dock only for three episodes, alas🥲
@Allons_y: "graphon is eyeless" xs, in my opinion, in terms of overall quality, this is the best among all that was in the Doctor, and in general the picture. Well, I think the unnaturalness was done quite intentionally.
I'm a simple person, I love "Midnight", and this episode came to me. The false Donna instantly burned down, in fact, but in general it is logical that, at first, the copy of the Doctor was better than the copy of Donna (she is brilliant, but without a metacrisis, the Doctor's thinking speed cannot keep up). However, the false doctor was also slowing down at this time, incongruously to the moment. I liked the insert with Newton, "I'm going to think under the apple tree" – and everything is already clear, and even the trick with "gravity" was brought. Honestly, even if it remains just a joke, I won't be upset.
Honestly, I'm not crying, I'm just really glad to see Wilfred.🥲
This series is much more consistently enjoyable and in the spirit of the old RTD seasons It is very similar to the episode "Midnight" from the distant season 4 By the way, there is a suspicion that Donna made a reference to her with a remark about "they won't sit in a corner and do it calmly"😁
It still doesn't seem to be the level of haste for such a big date, I hope that there will be something so big in the final series that we will remember for a long time And of course, we will be sad and crying for a long time because of another farewell to Tennant and Tate
I am one of those who have never reviewed "Midnight", but I consider it literally the scariest of all that was in new school (due to the fact that I simply did not watch old school). I liked "Dahl" too.
I think it's impossible to constantly come up with something completely new. And I'm not sure what I need at all. Cinema has grown a hell of a lot over the years, and "The Doctor" is still trying to keep the comfort of penny graphics (in places) and huge artistic assumptions (and we are smart, we see all the plot holes and pianos). Well, let it be. It's a fairy tale. Sometimes scary, dramatic, but a fairy tale. Geek culture does not have to grow old with its fans when the younger generation has already grown up to replace it. They haven't seen enough of us yet, let them enjoy it.
@iasra: Seriously? Poor Tennant? Then it turns out that RTD is obliged to include representation under the yoke of Disney. Now Tennant the poor guy is playing LGBT people for the first time. Which, well, does not fit in with his life position in any way. What else do we learn? And where was he restricted? You're putting him in a frame.
Хорошая серия в духе Полночи, при просмотре совсем не скучал. Но серия неплохо смотрелась бы внутри полноценного сезона, а у нас же тут типа праздник, юбилей.
@merlott: я так поняла, что находясь на краю вселенной, он используя суеверие как-бы дал ему жизнь, и теперь суеверия уже не просто суеверия. Немного не логично, почему то что произошло в этом месте может влиять на вселенную? Но Доктор и логика, не всегда вместе)))
Очень атмосферная серия получилась. И такое обилие прекрасных совместных сцен Доктора и Донны❤️ Но у меня, честно говоря, по итогу просмотра осталось какое-то непонятное послевкусие: как будто мне, как зрителю, что-то хотели сказать через символизм, а я не поняла 🤔 Жду теперь с нетерпением финальный спешл этого шикарного дуэта. Должно быть что-то эпичное
@small_mystic: где вы увидели, что из Доктора сделали гея? Фраза "а он горяч" не делает персонажа геем. Тем более, что Доктору все эти ваши ориентации не важны (и это говорилось давно)
@small_mystic: Натаниэль Кёртис, который играл Ньютона, вполне себе британец (с индийскими корнями), между прочим. Он играл у РТД в "Это грех". Я думаю, что РТД просто позвал актёра, с которым уже сработался, на камео. Не особо думая, что "о, ну как он может играть Ньютона" (я, в принципе, тоже против не была; Нат очень красивый и хороший актёр). Ну и Доктор не гей (а пансексуал хд). В оригинале, во всяком случае, он после "да, Ньютон горяч" сказал, что "ого, я и так теперь говорю" (дословно не помню). Это скорее про то, что он теперь достаточно откровенен, чтобы такое сказать. Как с "я очень люблю её" про Донну в первом спецвыпуске. Без упора на то, что он теперь и парнями так откровенно интересуется.
@Ianthinus: уверена он прекрасный актер, но Ньютон не был индусом. Ориентация Доктора тоже была бы понятна, если бы не прежний опыт с этим лицом, когда мы знали его как гетеросексуала и не ощущение, что эта тема добавлена в угоду современной повестке, как и эпизод внезапной women power в прошлой серии
@small_mystic: Ньютан в нашей жизни не был Индусом, а в сериале ДК он может быть кем угодно, хоть Марсианином) Вообще-то прежнее лицо не означает прежние привычки и вкусы, и с каждой регенерацией у Доктора могут они меняться, в том числе ориентация, но вообще-то Доктор должен быть пансексуалом, он инопланетянин, все-таки, а не человек)
@small_mystic: индийцем (к тому же он британец с индийскими корнями, а не индиец). Индус - это тот, кто проповедует индуизм. Житель Индии - это индиец. И я продолжу настаивать, что "я и так теперь говорю" не про ориентацию, а про откровенность (хотя даже если да - не вижу в этом никаких проблем).
@small_mystic: да кто же запрещает выражать своё мнение. Я так же просто выражаю своё. Считаю, что в таком сериале, как "Доктор Кто" Ньютон в исполнении Натаниэля Кёртиса выглядит уместно (а про отличия индийцев и индусов это скорее от того, что уже задолбало, что индийцев называют индусами, а это неправильно филологически; ну и Нат, опять же, и не индиец, а вполне себе британец хд).
as a person who really liked the thirteenth and its plot, I really liked that rtd does not give up everything that happened in seasons 11-13. A great episode
@natefprice: I liked not even the fact that he did not give up on it, but the fact that he develops it with understanding. And Tennant is a great fit here.
I completely forgot that the new episodes have already been released, but when I remembered, I watched both at once. I haven't read or watched any interviews about them, only one trailer, so there were no expectations. I even somehow missed that these are some kind of anniversary episodes, it just looks like a new season. As a result, the impressions are very positive - as if I returned back to my favorite 4th season🥰
I couldn't watch this episode at night, it was scary, it was calmer in the light of day. But how damn cool! My Doctor is back!💕 Meditation!😂
I really liked the series. The Doctor and Donna are wonderful. How the doctor hugged her, pressed his hand to her chest, kissed the top of her head - wonderful good relations of friends who mean a lot to each other. This was not enough. Alien creatures are frightening and unusual. The phrase my arms are too long is added to other famous ones: don't blink, you're my mom, hey who turned off the light.. For a moment I felt like a child watching a doctor for the first time, no boring shooting. You're waiting to see what happens next. Even the rusty robot added atmosphere. The breaking Doctor, this also outlined the features of a new character. I never thought that my beloved doctor would return and this is an amazing feeling. Back to the future, forward to the past)
PS. I also like the new screensaver and logo. And the Tardis. And a screwdriver. I'm holding my fingers so that the new dock doesn't let me down.
The first episode didn't bring old school together, but the second one is one of the best episodes in DC in the last few years! A very cool horror in the spirit of Midnight.
As in the good old doctor, the horror is induced by one simple phrase - Are you my mom? - Don't blink. - Who turned off the light? - My arms are too long.
I love the chamber series and the atmosphere of intense light horror in the Doctor. Here I keep remembering the episode 'Midnight', and this time-stretched bomb reminded me of 'Hide', with the 'ghost' stuck in one minute, stretched over years. When I saw these slow movements of the robot, I immediately remembered her and thought that it could be something like that.
The series is definitely very good and decent, but really high expectations from the haste leave a slight feeling of incomplete satisfaction (now I'm trying not to hope too much for the splendor of the final haste.
I liked this episode more than the last one Just an adventure without family and gender issues It is clear that Disney has brought some money It's a pity that there are only three episodes with this doctor and this companion😕 But I hope it's just different and there will be a strong interesting story with Jokey
Let's make do with a short comment: This series will definitely be included in the list of favorites, it is very reminiscent of the good old days in the atmosphere, as if it met with friends🩵
At the moment with coffee, I screamed like a seagull. Donna, only she could have made the moment so fiercely. But the story of the ship's captain is very sad. But giant hands and a responsive jaw... Rough. And I thought for a second that Donna would stay on board.
@kriptopsix: yes, this is for fans of the real doctor and not these bidegartions. In general, this is how the doctor series should look like. Moffat is also missing. It's been a long time since I've been down in the comments)
I almost cry with delight and relief. The Doctor is back! Our dear Russell T is a classic, when out of the blue there is terrible shit, nothing is clear, but it feels so good.
– what did she see? – so, different things. – for example? tell. Where have you been since our last meeting? what happened? – it's nothing special. robots, chases, waterfalls. – Oh, really. But what really happened? – a lot of things. – Are you okay? – I will. – When? – in a million years.
Oh, well played! I love stories with doppelgangers. and they were creepy. It's great that the doctor remembers his past life. rtd just happily used all this to make Tennant suffer beautifully on camera again. and as always, it suits him very well. It was a wonderful conversation with the fake Donna. it turned out to be a strong horror in space, and the plot did not fall apart and was solid. in general, gravity rules. :)
@Mast_natan: Micro spoiler: Gravity appears in the following episodes as well.
While it is difficult to say exactly why this was done, perhaps in the third season the Doctor will meet Newton again and gravity will play some kind of plot role. But so far the most working theory is that Russell T. Davis wanted to add some kind of running gag to the series, and came up with such an unobtrusive joke with "gravity" that he can repeat for years and no one will get tired of it because it does not take up much screen time and space in the script. In general, it is not so important what this phenomenon is called, Newton did not invent it and did not launch it, he just opened it and named it, the essence of universal gravitation and attraction does not change from the difference in a pair of sounds.
@KonstantinRomeow: it's hardly just a joke, otherwise Chekhov will cry, and human logic doesn't always work in the Doctor's universe, I wouldn't be surprised if changing the name changes the physical phenomenon itself.
God! What a breath of fresh air! After the thirteenth Doctor, you can completely forget that the Doctor Who series can be interesting. Although it's probably all Tennant's fault and his new suit!😅
@Darken_Rahl: well, it's noticeable that tennant has aged, but it didn't stop him from watching with his mouth open and a half-eaten sandwich. It was strong. The last time I was impressed by the series about the perfect disguise. I still fell in love with her before I met the series, I accidentally stumbled upon TV at night. I said that I was even sick😅
@Mast_natan: yes, yes, she is the one, now I looked at what it's called. When they were hiding under the bed, and something sat on top, right up to the goosebumps every time
@Darken_Rahl: I mean, the thirteenth doctor was a complete disappointment to me. And here is an interesting series, Tennant in a stunning costume and the spirit of his favorite episodes, for example: "The Girl in the Fireplace" or "The Journey of the Damned". I really liked the series!
Oh gods, it's such a strain that at some point I forgot how to blink. A strong, powerful series that demolishes everything in its path. +1 to the piggy bank of selected episodes (Planet Midnight, Silence in the library, Sent down from heaven, and now the Wild Blue Distance).
It seems to me that I have figured out the idea of RTD (actually not, but you can dream) — very often, to get acquainted with Doctor Who, they advise "Start with Tennant" meaning the Tenth. But now it has gained a new meaning, from this episode it is really possible to enter the universe. Fly in with a run. I missed you so much!
@JuliaCheckmareva: Silence in the library is like a knife to the heart!!!I will endlessly remember and remember, at the same time a wonderful, but such a sad series!!By the way, for some reason, not everyone likes this particular anniversary episode, but I think on the contrary it's amazing!!!These dialogues between the Doctor and Donna are so touching!!!That's seriously on a par with Midnight and an Empty child)))I 'm seeing you off
@Geronimoooo: This is generally the perfect inclusion in my favorite Doctor-companion pair. For those who missed Tennant and sorely missed Donna, here are Tennant and Donna, TWO Tennants and TWO Donnas. Such a concentrated almost mono performance, which is bigger inside than outside. Gods, I'm so glad that this particular couple got these three extra episodes. Donna deserved it.
Wild blue distance - the translation is so-so, of course, there must be something more sublimely literary, like Untouched/Undisturbed blue, Pristine blue heights, Unexplored blue distance, and my favorite, but well-known concept is Beautiful far away) What are your options?
This is the best series since Peter Kobaldi. It was so boring to watch doctores, no plot, no intrigue, in the end everything was elevated to such an absurdity that the demand for horror is how you can continue the series with such divine enemies. This episode brought back what the viewer expects from the Doctor Who series, it's a pity, or I'm waiting. It's a pity it's not enough, then it's nonsense again. Bioregeneration, like a point from previous seasons. I didn't like it. I like the fact that you can do anything in Doctor Who, but I'd rather watch Doctor Who and the girl who waited than this sequel. It hurts a lot after watching the last season and the specials.
Oh! My! God! What did I just watch?! (in the best sense of the phrase) Yes, initially I wrote a comment after 2 minutes of watching in order to get rid of multiculturalism (for many, this phenomenon causes a storm of indignation; I just get punched on the op in cases that are not particularly appropriate), please do not judge strictly🙂 The whole series was in awe of what was happening. I regularly had the feeling that I had already seen something similar, but I was not completely hoovian, I could not remember what exactly)
With these series, the bar has been returned, I hope they will not lower the bar further, because this series is the little thing that returns to childhood)
@MoldonDS: исключение из чего? Сценарист этой серии написал также серии для нового сезона, который выйдет в мае и скорее всего там тоже будут серии подобного плана.
This is an amazing episode. So many years of some outright rubbish from chibnell and here he is just a good episode of the doctor. He's obviously not the best, not brilliant, but good, and I missed that terribly.
Previous seasons were so disappointing(although, I really liked the Thirteenth one), that I postponed watching this series for a long time and watched it only now. And how I liked her! There doesn't seem to be anything super new and almost the entire series is based on the game of Tennant and Catherine Tate, but it was just a breath of fresh air after all the previous episodes, where a lot of things happened, but almost nothing was remembered in the end.
And, of course, I can't help but remember the 12th💔
AND OF COURSE THE ENDING!!! Wilf, we missed you.😭 And explosions at the end!!! Something grandiose is planned, we are really waiting for the toymaker!
In general, 10/10. Very much in the spirit of the old doctor
To be left without a TARDIS and without a screwdriver, that's a risky venture xxx
- What was that?
- Some kind of noise.
- Thank you, you helped me a lot :D
The Doctor and Donna are in the same episode together without other characters - oh, yes! What was needed!
The graphics of some moments, of course, really returned to the tenth) The detective component is also straight from there, and it was the atmosphere of this series that I liked more than the previous one. I rested my soul and returned at the same time) The aliens with their long arms, jaws and all that brought back memories of the first seasons (but in the best sense).
The insanely sad story of the ship's captain. What a sacrifice for the sake of all living things :with And a very cool interaction between the Doctor and Donna. Being literally in the "void" is a strong move, I love that. Of course, it was funny that he left her at the end, in the end she was saved by the fact that the TARDIS calculated the difference in wrist length :D
Uiiilf! How glad I am to meet you!
However...The Doctor scattered salt at the edge of the universe and the Earth went crazy...Something strange, but still very interesting :)
And, of course, the long-awaited Allons-y!
A remix of Midnight with an admixture of a two-part series about Flesh and the Day of the Doctor (a line about zygons).
Did I like the series? Yes. Was I worried about Donna, who was left behind? Yes.
Everything is great.
A couple of things I didn't like:
1) the tempo was compressed at the end, I'd rather throw out the scene with Isaac Newton to hell. Out of place at all. And I added these couple of moments to the ending, where the Doctor somehow drives away the non-Donna in a more interesting way. There would be more drama to put the squeeze on here!
2) This series could have gotten 5 points from me, if not for the long tongue of RTD (for which no one pulled it) and the director, who gasped and groaned that it was hard. What's hard? Should I keep a greenscreen for David and Catherine? Or maybe make stretchable body parts? Oh, yes, there was no such thing (season 6 - wink wink). Or maybe a copy-shifter? Oh, yes, the first one was gone at Midnight, and the second one was gone on Doctor's Day. In short, fewer words and more business is needed, and it's better to keep the ENT of the series in mind.
3) Strange passages through the Doctor himself. "We are at the edge of the universe -this has never happened before." BRO, JUST A COUPLE OF EPISODES AGO WITH TEKTEYUN! And then he tells about the Fluxus himself. Is that what it is? What for?
In short, damn, fuck RTD with his comments. I won't read anything by episode 3.
It seems that there is still some slight illogicality.
Plus, it's very strange that in the Flax it was really shown as from edge to edge - they had the old universe behind them. And then they said that there was no light, because the stars were very far away. It turns out that in the Distance they were in the void then? Is the Bottle still on the edge?
As I understand it, it depends on which dimensions to look at. He has never been on the edge of our physical universe, for example.
And Flax is generally in another dimension.
Then they posted this in the DC magazine itself:
In the magazine’s episode preview, the “Starring” section lists “David Tennant, Catherine Tate, [REDACTED], [REDACTED], [REDACTED]”
The names ended up being that woman with Newton, Newton and Wilf at the end. Everyone (especially in the Anglophandom) imagined who would be there. My MAXIMUM bets were modest, some kind of eyeliner in the spirit will save someone from the ship, maybe some character from DC, who will be needed in the 3rd cycle. Or maybe Jokey will light up at the end of episode 2 (and Wilf lit up - although it's a pity that this was the only scene for all three episodes, he won't be in the third)
That's why I have complaints about the marketing of this series. In general, RTD is on his mind and likes to praise himself in public, so it would be right to ignore what he says and look at the fact. Unfortunately, I didn't know about this, because for seasons 1-4, DC wasn't particularly interesting to me from a production point of view and I didn't listen to what he was broadcasting there.
Specifically about the director - he either jokingly or seriously whined a little and said "the one who will shoot it will not be lucky," and then it turned out that they wanted to give him this script and he groaned that it was hard and no one had ever shot this before.
And I still didn't understand what I wasn't filming? There were stretching body parts in DC, there were scenes with "clones" (the same flesh, the same Day of the Doctor in the black archive). And they also dared to say in a documentary about the shooting that there was no such thing in DC or in any other TV project, and that made me laugh.
What did we see that was fundamentally new?
Again, I'm not saying that the elements don't work or are harmful to the series - on the contrary, everything works fine. I'm just saying that the promotion is too loud and bold, with all the elements that have already been there. But with expectations, there is just a smaller problem, of course, that RTD apparently does not know how to work with the expectations of the audience, but it is also the fault of the audience if they wrote something down there in [REDACTED].
Well, the director clarified on Twitter before the show that the secrecy was not due to the return of someone, but to watch and not have any clues about what would happen next, so that it would be more interesting (for me it turned out that way)
The distance, of course, is very similar to Midnight. In some ways, Midnight is even scarier, because we will never know where this thing came from. But the distance is still amazing..... I love the reference to Marvin from the Hitchhiker's Guide! I love the fact that, like in a good detective story, all the evidence is collected by you! I figured it all out a little bit before the Doctor-and that's great.
It is a pity that the Doctor, despite all his newfound openness, still cannot share something with Donna. But on the other hand, at least now he could really admit that he was not okay. It seems like it's bigger than ever.
Is it scary for the thread with gravity — will it become the thing that broke the universe or just a constant joke? 👀
Overnight I krypova i smishna
I was also honored, it was not for nothing that the RTD turned.
Wilf! ❤️
It's just like the Doctor to sprinkle salt on the edge of the universe and-oh...
Mavity is alarming, I hope this is not just a joke, but also has to do with the overall plot, and in the end everything will return as it was.
The "midnight" creep vibe, and the moment when it suddenly turned out that there were doppelgangers – I had SUCH goosebumps.
At the very end, when the Doctor left Donna, I believed for a few seconds that this was all that RTD really arranged for her to end like this. How glad I am that the Tardis figured out the liar, although I am sad that the Doctor did not recognize her himself.
And how unexpected and delightful it was to see Wilf 🥹
I just can't believe that the next episode is already the last with David and Catherine, so I want a whole season with them! Although Joking is also very much looking forward to new stories)
I will not hide that due to the increased secrecy surrounding this particular episode, all the "jubilee" hopes were pinned on him for the return of some previously unknown familiar characters - River Song, the Eleventh Doctor, Dr. "Ruth" the Fugitive, Karvanista, Captain Jack Harkness, Gwen Cooper, the Thirteenth Doctor, Yaz, the Master, Missy, Martha Jones, Amy Pond, Clara Oswald, Vashta Nerada, the main five from the "Class"... Of course, not the whole crowd, but at least someone. The expectations from this mysterious episode were for all 15 out of 10, and unfortunately it did not meet such high expectations.
The anticipation before the "Chuckle" is still beyond the limit, and my poor heart feels that I will cry at the repeated farewell to Donna and on the stage of Tennant's third regeneration.
But if the anniversary returns are really limited to David Tennant and Donna Noble and her family, then it turns out that three special editions in honor of the 60th anniversary of Doctor Who are epic, ONE last episode of the Chris Chibnell era "The Power of the Doctor" in which there were a Master, Daleks, Cybermen, regeneration of the Thirteenth (technically two regeneration of the Thirteenth), Tegan Giovanca, Ace, The First Doctor, The Fifth Doctor, the Sixth Doctor, the Seventh Doctor, The Eighth Doctor, Dr. "Ruth" The Fugitive, Kate Sewart, Ian Chesterton, Melanie Bush, Joe Grant... And yes, it was an anniversary episode in honor of the 100th anniversary of the BBC channel, but still!
Well, the ending of the episode broke my heart 💔
I was very afraid that this reunion would be like 99% of all reunions - it seems to be the same actors, but it is clear that the same chemistry is not even close. How wonderful that this is not the case here at all!
It's a shame, but I hope before leaving this time he will still say that he is ready now...
The creatures were wildly creepy, of course. Especially when they were stretched.
The moment that Donna saw all these 15 years of Doc's life (and I think she did), it's so sad... And I really feel sorry for Doc.
Well, the ending is something! Wilfred!🥺🤩
Give me the next episode. How much time had passed on Earth while Doc and Donna were flying?
and I can agree that part of it is somehow clumsily inscribed in the plot and in places it hurts the eye-a rumor, but in principle you can ignore against the background of other advantages and good things
, but this is not yet a dude who will probably be in the next season, if not in the season, for a combo, so to speak, so whether it will still be :D
The doctor who didn't recognize Donna and almost fried her is a fiasco, bro..
yes, it's a pity all the Doctor's entourage, no one can escape, a new fluh is coming :D
Personally, the series came to me.
I think if I read the comments above, I will immediately see the disadvantages, but it will be later. And at the time of writing this comment, everything is sound.
If you really wanted to get to the bottom of it, then you could remember that a couple of episodes ago in "Flux" the Thirteenth Doctor was with Tekteyun BEYOND the edge of the universe, on the edge of ANOTHER, new universe.
And the Eleventh Doctor was outside the universe in "The Doctor's Wife", he was in the pocket universe in "Hide", and the Tenth was in a parallel universe in "Rise of the Cybermen / Age of Steel". And that's if you don't touch the classics.
Из минусов выделю слабый графон, но в целом пофиг на него, серия удалась!
Серия хороша. Я в очередной раз убедилась, что дуэт Доктора и Донны — один из любимейших мной в ньюскуле. Актерская игра Дэвида и Кэтрин, как всегда, на высоте. Стабильно: если переживает/плачет Донна, переживаю/плачу и я.
А Уилф в конце, что называется, «добил». Как хорошо, что нам довелось ещё раз увидеть Бернарда Криббинса в этой чудеснейшей роли. Светлая память ему❤️
Промо следующей серии интригует. Жду с нетерпением погрузиться в очередной хаос.
Будет очень грустно, когда он будет уходить опять(
Я не хочу что бы они уходили. Хочу 3-4 сезона что бы вот именно на уровне вышедших 2х серий. Я безумно рада когда ждала их, но теперь понимаю, что последняя серия скоро и это означет уход... очень грустно...
момент, где Доктору в конце понравился ответ фальшивой Донны... и когда он по началу не узнавал разницу между настоящей и фальшивой (про то, откуда она) ... это так разбивает сердечко... особенно, потому что она сама разгадала фальшивого Доктора...
Без шуток. Нам обещали хоррор эпизод, мы получили хоррор эпизод. Двойник Доктора уж слишком долго бежал к роботу, как удобно, когда у главных героев есть сюжетная броня))
Это точно не тот десятый доктор-В этой серии это было особенно видно. Он эмоционален, открыт, местами осторожен. Полная противоположность безбашенному Десятому и это Фантастика, серьезно! Его истерика, когда он сболтнул недоДонне лишнего бесценна!!!! Теннант шикарный!!Боже,я его обожаю!!!
Донна - прекрасная!!Оказавшись с Доктором в новой среде, все, о чем она думает, что ей эти приключения уже не нужны. Что у нее есть любящий муж и замечательная дочь. Вот это я называю развитие и взросление персонажа...
С Ньютона упал: "- Что это за слово, потяжение, поежение, ПАЖИЖЕНИЕ"
Через некоторое время Доктор:
- Донна, это сила притяжения.
- Чего?
- То есть пажижение!
Но хоть убейте, никогда не пойму одного - зачем пихать чернокожих на исторически белых людей? В чем прикол? 😂 Это всё равно, что поставить Киану Ривза на роль Барака Обамы 🤣 Уверен, будет весело.
И я уверена, что из Киану вышел бы отличный Обама, хотя пример не совсем правомерен, учитывая, что это первый президент-афроамериканец, то есть это большая часть сюжета и мотивации персонажа, на это нужен акцент.
Ну камон, это все театр, в тех случаях, где это реально непринципиально, то какая разница, как он выглядит. Сериал все равно исторически недостоверен, мы смотрим на Ньютона глазами человека из современного мира, приписываем ему осовремененные слова, реакции, язык тела, грим, "причесываем" мир прошлого - от авгиевых конюшен на улицах и каких-нить туалетов в парадных залах. Ну так и пусть тот условный мир будет расово более разнообразен чем был на самом деле. А для достоверного изображения истории есть другие фильмы.
It's funny, because in fact we have a two-actor theater here, but there is plenty of action. Graphon, of course, is eyesore. But perhaps such unnaturalness is even for the best. The sinister valley effect, that's it. Some scenes, like the long arms or the huge Doctor and Donna running on all fours, will definitely give me nightmares.
Well, I generally like to mess up when you need to determine where the copy is and where the real one is. It's always fun and interesting.
Tennant is an actor. I was really hooked by the moment when the false Madonna pressed him with memories. He snapped, saying, of course I'm running, because how can I stop, look back and see all that I left behind. Tennant had so much pain on his face. And then when he realized that Donna wasn't real... Goosebumps.
At such moments, you remember that the Doctor is not a guy from the next street, but a millennial time traveler. Who saw more than he needed to.
It's a pity Tennant only dropped by for three episodes. I demand a full season of 10-12 episodes for the Fourteenth. You are welcome.
I liked the insert with Newton, "I'm going to think under the apple tree" – and everything is already clear, and even the trick with "gravity" was brought. Honestly, even if it remains just a joke, I won't be upset.
This series is much more consistently enjoyable and in the spirit of the old RTD seasons
It is very similar to the episode "Midnight" from the distant season 4
By the way, there is a suspicion that Donna made a reference to her with a remark about "they won't sit in a corner and do it calmly"😁
It still doesn't seem to be the level of haste for such a big date, I hope that there will be something so big in the final series that we will remember for a long time
And of course, we will be sad and crying for a long time because of another farewell to Tennant and Tate
And let's fix it:
Wilfred🫡
I think it's impossible to constantly come up with something completely new. And I'm not sure what I need at all. Cinema has grown a hell of a lot over the years, and "The Doctor" is still trying to keep the comfort of penny graphics (in places) and huge artistic assumptions (and we are smart, we see all the plot holes and pianos). Well, let it be. It's a fairy tale. Sometimes scary, dramatic, but a fairy tale. Geek culture does not have to grow old with its fans when the younger generation has already grown up to replace it. They haven't seen enough of us yet, let them enjoy it.
And where was he restricted? You're putting him in a frame.
https://www.thepinknews.com/2023/12/02/david-tennant-lgbtq-ally-5-times/
Ну и Доктор не гей (а пансексуал хд). В оригинале, во всяком случае, он после "да, Ньютон горяч" сказал, что "ого, я и так теперь говорю" (дословно не помню). Это скорее про то, что он теперь достаточно откровенен, чтобы такое сказать. Как с "я очень люблю её" про Донну в первом спецвыпуске. Без упора на то, что он теперь и парнями так откровенно интересуется.
Ньютан в нашей жизни не был Индусом, а в сериале ДК он может быть кем угодно, хоть Марсианином)
Вообще-то прежнее лицо не означает прежние привычки и вкусы, и с каждой регенерацией у Доктора могут они меняться, в том числе ориентация, но вообще-то Доктор должен быть пансексуалом, он инопланетянин, все-таки, а не человек)
И я продолжу настаивать, что "я и так теперь говорю" не про ориентацию, а про откровенность (хотя даже если да - не вижу в этом никаких проблем).
I couldn't watch this episode at night, it was scary, it was calmer in the light of day. But how damn cool! My Doctor is back!💕 Meditation!😂
Alien creatures are frightening and unusual. The phrase my arms are too long is added to other famous ones: don't blink, you're my mom, hey who turned off the light.. For a moment I felt like a child watching a doctor for the first time, no boring shooting. You're waiting to see what happens next. Even the rusty robot added atmosphere.
The breaking Doctor, this also outlined the features of a new character. I never thought that my beloved doctor would return and this is an amazing feeling. Back to the future, forward to the past)
PS. I also like the new screensaver and logo. And the Tardis. And a screwdriver. I'm holding my fingers so that the new dock doesn't let me down.
- Are you my mom?
- Don't blink.
- Who turned off the light?
- My arms are too long.
The series is definitely very good and decent, but really high expectations from the haste leave a slight feeling of incomplete satisfaction (now I'm trying not to hope too much for the splendor of the final haste.
Just an adventure without family and gender issues
It is clear that Disney has brought some money
It's a pity that there are only three episodes with this doctor and this companion😕
But I hope it's just different and there will be a strong interesting story with Jokey
This series will definitely be included in the list of favorites, it is very reminiscent of the good old days in the atmosphere, as if it met with friends🩵
But the story of the ship's captain is very sad. But giant hands and a responsive jaw... Rough.
And I thought for a second that Donna would stay on board.
– so, different things.
– for example? tell. Where have you been since our last meeting? what happened?
– it's nothing special. robots, chases, waterfalls.
– Oh, really. But what really happened?
– a lot of things.
– Are you okay?
– I will.
– When?
– in a million years.
I just can't, it's too much. 💔😭
, it's so creepy, it almost fell back in the end
I love stories with doppelgangers. and they were creepy.
It's great that the doctor remembers his past life. rtd just happily used all this to make Tennant suffer beautifully on camera again. and as always, it suits him very well. It was a wonderful conversation with the fake Donna.
it turned out to be a strong horror in space, and the plot did not fall apart and was solid.
in general, gravity rules. :)
Two Davids 😁
While it is difficult to say exactly why this was done, perhaps in the third season the Doctor will meet Newton again and gravity will play some kind of plot role. But so far the most working theory is that Russell T. Davis wanted to add some kind of running gag to the series, and came up with such an unobtrusive joke with "gravity" that he can repeat for years and no one will get tired of it because it does not take up much screen time and space in the script. In general, it is not so important what this phenomenon is called, Newton did not invent it and did not launch it, he just opened it and named it, the essence of universal gravitation and attraction does not change from the difference in a pair of sounds.
+1 to the piggy bank of selected episodes (Planet Midnight, Silence in the library, Sent down from heaven, and now the Wild Blue Distance).
It seems to me that I have figured out the idea of RTD (actually not, but you can dream) — very often, to get acquainted with Doctor Who, they advise "Start with Tennant" meaning the Tenth. But now it has gained a new meaning, from this episode it is really possible to enter the universe. Fly in with a run.
I missed you so much!
Gods, I'm so glad that this particular couple got these three extra episodes. Donna deserved it.
Yes, initially I wrote a comment after 2 minutes of watching in order to get rid of multiculturalism (for many, this phenomenon causes a storm of indignation; I just get punched on the op in cases that are not particularly appropriate), please do not judge strictly🙂
The whole series was in awe of what was happening. I regularly had the feeling that I had already seen something similar, but I was not completely hoovian, I could not remember what exactly)
There doesn't seem to be anything super new and almost the entire series is based on the game of Tennant and Catherine Tate, but it was just a breath of fresh air after all the previous episodes, where a lot of things happened, but almost nothing was remembered in the end.