s02e04 — Ever Been to Ghorman?

@fluffyevil: Imagine, there are people who recognize only the T-canon. 🙄

@kate_archer: I can imagine it perfectly. There are a lot of different types of people in our fandom. Continuing to divide the canon into levels 11 years after the introduction of the mouse, one universe and the new continuity are not even the strangest.

And also try to imagine that there are people who do not catch every bit of information about the universe and do not read every single book that has been published, especially not even translated.

@Nog: Again, I can imagine it perfectly. I understand them. Those that are divided into canons and so there is no broken mouse ent.
Why is there such a jolt from my comment? In Exile, he is crippled and weak because his legs were blown off by an explosion six months before, as described in the novel.

@fluffyevil: okay, I'm not going to divide into canons (everything has been divided for a long time, long before me, I just used a ready-made name for what suits me) and I'll say the same thing much longer:
I recognize what happened within the framework of the universe of sounds only what was shown to me on on the screen of a movie theater or video player. Everything else doesn't exist until someone on the screen at least mentions it. Everything else is legends, rumors, and speculation. And what is written in any book does not exist. It's like being overheard in a bazaar.

@kate_archer: As I said, I'm used to the variety of people who go. Your rejection is your problem. And these events are still canon.

@fluffyevil: Well, for me, those who have gone are those for whom this is a canon.

@kate_archer: Then you fall into the category of headcounters, and the most beaten down ones. From the series * the author was wrong*. But then again, that's solely your problem. Well, and lulz for others.

@fluffyevil: I remember from the foul that arguing with you is banging against the wall, but I'll leave a comment.

Let's assume you're right, and the "legends" casually named by the mouse are canon. Then your "goers" and the "lulz of others" discredit the hardcore fan camp. The camp of those dudes and dudes who don't assert themselves as the smartest guy in a room, but read books based on their fans, build connections, and dig into the world.

Although I would call Kate's position that hardcore fans are crazy just as inadequate. But it's your fault, because obviously her post is emotional, a defensive reaction to yours.

And then what is adequate, from my point of view? The understanding that Lucas is not a god descended from heaven, but a smart man, a businessman who gathered the universe, attracting people of varying degrees of talent - graphomaniacs and cool science fiction writers. People who have given up their ambitions, their worlds, in order to be a piece of the puzzle in a multibillion-dollar empire. Someone because of their great love for the franchise, someone because of the money - it's just like in life.

To put it mildly, whether to consider legends canon or not is not Anakin's choice between the Sith and the Jedi. We don't have to choose at all, we read damn entertaining books and watch movies - our lives don't depend on it.

This is despite the fact that Andor's assumed seriousness seems atonal to me, and I do not share his enthusiasm. But I wouldn't put those who don't like my position in some camp of non-violent fans.

As an analogy, I've read several dozen books on waha, and I'd come to howlong Tube and start self-sacrificing in front of fans of our Oulkats or Sabers that they didn't smell gunpowder and were generally shallow dudes - not that we're sharing a cow, damn it.

The remark about vakha is also relevant because there is a separate layer of guys who literally perceive the glorification of the emperor, as a rule, they coincide with the layer of subscribers of historical channels in VK and soyuzodrochers - an easy target for criticism, that is, easier than conventional fans of "Acolyta", spherical and in a vacuum, or whatever you are there They wrote

@fluffyevil: It reminded me more of Italian, against Mussolini.

@Stolengrad: 22.17

@Pasternag: Thanks)

@u1650424: I thought that the content of the first three episodes could be told in one, well, in two at most. And then you watch it, nothing changes, it's delayed) probably the retelling on YouTube will be easier to watch later and not waste time.

@Justuserservice: вы правы

@Justuserservice: Thanks for that comment! The third episode completed the arc after the boring first two, and then the drudgery began again.

@Stolengrad: I've never met a whining military man. The whole story is based on wars, there were no psychotherapists in Caesar's legions.

@Oliverell22: There is no German Massacre or injury of Guerrera anywhere on the screen. In fact, the date in the GR area is only affected by the last season of the animated series Clone Wars and the Defective batch, if I'm not mistaken. But there's nothing like that in them. And there's only one book about the history of Co.

@Hidji: "The rebels" more.

@Oliverell22: No, no, no, the rebels have been starting for 8 or 6 BBY, I don't remember exactly. In fact, there are events going on there in parallel with Andor. Perhaps some of the plots of the Tales are from that period, but they are too personalized in terms of content and can be ignored.