The idea of losing control over one's own role in the digital space is very much in the spirit of the "Black Mirror". I especially liked how the line between reality and the virtual world is gradually blurring. It seems to be a simple story, but it hurts
It's so cool to get into your favorite movie and play a character you associate yourself with, I hope that future will come someday and I'll still be alive. I really enjoyed the episode, I would say, one of the best in the history of the series, for me personally. Of course, it violates the concept of dystopias and frightening technologies, but I got it.
@KudasaiYo: I'm amused by the reaction of the editors, the actress has been stuck there for a couple of months, and they are surprised by her strange behavior. And really, why is that?
@densto: It became even funnier. It's the same thing if I said It would be cool to be able to teleport, and you answered me, well, how would it be possible to take the subway from point A to point B now, no?)))) Including the plane
@KudasaiYo: It's not the same thing. And teleportation is possible in the future, but the technology in the form in which it is shown in the series is impossible.
@orwell-was-right: only a person who knows absolutely nothing about history, especially cinema, can say that. Google the white actors who played Asians and blacks for general education. Maybe something in my head will start to change.
If there is a cup of coffee at the table, it will fall) After the episode, I wanted to look at some shelves to prevent this. Monitoring what is happening through screens and metrics is famously involved in the game "not for broadcast")
Chalamet is busy, and Donald Glover has family matters to attend to. (Is this how employment in Mr. & Mrs. Smith was designated? My respects)) That's what happens when the Raines (both) turn down the role. 😄 Cool episode.
@an_khv: Because it's an anthology and all the episodes are different, there might be a good one. Besides, it's my favorite show. Well, at least he was. This season is shitty, of course, and I'm very disappointed.
It's like San Junipero, the most beloved series in CZ. Brooker goes the proven way, why not. It's a very beautifully staged episode, aesthetically beautiful.
I love retro aesthetics, it turned out to be a very touching and a little sad story, really vibes of my beloved San Junipero. The current trends in the film industry with remakes and agendas are fucked up, but I would watch a movie like this) Emma Corrine is simply charming! I want a similar technology, the first thing I would do would be to look into Harry Potter, make my childhood dream come true. But in fact, such technologies could be useful, for example, in psychotherapy or when dealing with emergencies, so I'm waiting for this in reality)
Oh, well, the episode is cool! As a child, I also dreamed of getting into a TV series or a movie and becoming part of the plot haha, it's great that now such ideas can be seen.
I especially liked that the series has both a black and white version and a color version.
In short, it was done in an original and interesting way. Cool approach!
@elfiina: When Dorothy touched the piano and the first notes sounded, my emotions flooded right onto the carpet. And if music is shorthand for feelings, as one poet said, then “Moonlight" is love clothed in sounds.
the fire series, something that has been missing for a long time, separately at the end there was a reference to San Junipero, this series certainly strongly resembles it, the connection is obvious. Perhaps this is the past, when technology was just invented, I feel this story will come back to us, I hope
The best episode of the season is so far and probably one of my new favorites in the series. incredibly beautiful and touching, though simple. 💔
Emma Corin is simply created for the old Hollywood type of characters, they look so organically in this entourage! and their chemistry with Issa is just magical. delight
The flame). And for the umpteenth time, references to San Junipero. Although I not only remembered him, but also the gorgeous film "Presentville", I even found and rated it, and about a black actress in the role of a white man, this is, of course, a strong joke on ourselves and Hollywood as a whole))).
@Hidji: I also caught the Pleasantville vibe! It seemed that after realizing the emotions and desires, the objects around the characters would begin to color)
@keyo1sha: "dude," I have an idea about self-irony. It's one thing when self-irony is akin to a reference, it's another thing when the whole plot is based on the basics related to this "self-irony." There is also self-irony in the first episode, but in the context of the "subscription" system. But there, this self-irony is folded into a coherent plot that does not break the narrative. I recommend you to watch the Disney series, there is that "self-irony"....
@ksander92: by the way, I remembered a recent example of a stunningly working demonstration of same-sex love (unlike in this series, where gg is just an emotionless person), namely in the series the Separation between the characters of Torturo and Walken. That's where the chemistry and acting are just brilliant, you believe in what's happening. And those fishy eyes and the eternally perplexed glances of the main character are here. …
@ksander92: Carefully review everything before you connect the hypno-something. There are answers to many of your criticisms. And start looking at gg as a woman, not an actress.
@ksander92: Thank you for having the courage to express your opinion. Here, it turns out, it's easy to throw slippers if you don't like the opinion, although you didn't say anything offensive about the series, and I share your impression of what you watched.
@ksander92: I support it and I don't see any reason why they threw minuses on the comment. I was amazed at the inadequacy of the whole series , a black homosexual girl in 1940 , a TV star who agreed to play for payment for 90 minutes at the risk of being killed or permanently locked in black and white VR , then fell in love with a black and white cardboard character , tea spilled on the system Also, at the end, there is a call on the phone to the character from the monitor.
It would be clear that fiction , but there must be at least some logic , right ?
@slip2704: Her role is banter about modern realities, she agreed because of her love for the film and did not know about the risk.
Cardboard, that's saying it out loud, in the end she stops being a lady in distress and makes a decision that is not typical of her character, not to mention what happened during the breakdown. The call fits perfectly into the capabilities of the demonstrated technology.
Spilled tea, I agree, there's nothing to cover it with, you could have come up with a less idiotic way to keep gg in the movie.
@KudasaiYo: such banter from Netflix looks , to put it mildly , insofar as after their black Cleopatra and a million similar films, it's not banter , it 's their policy .
And again , we are talking about a high-level actress , who is offered in the basement to digitize her brain with an unknown device in the complete absence of her team , representatives , agents , etc.
As I say , all these nuances can be allowed individually , but all together , 70 minutes of screen time is perplexing .
@KudasaiYo: Didn't you know about the risk? So do you believe that you would license such a technology with such a high risk of death, or that she or the agent did not read the contract, which should specify the risks of the technology? Okay, I lost the flash drive, but I have a contract. The authors of the series shouldn't make such idiots out of humanity, it's clear that such a clumsy technology won't be missed. In the first series, this is straight realism, what you can imagine, 2 and 3 are technologically unprocessed, so you don't feel any fear of technology.
@slip2704: because the majority of commentators are schoolchildren or lavender rafs with a subtle mental organization who have absorbed the modern agenda and consider it a part of their lives.
I really liked the episode, Emma Corrine is magical and just drags here. The first two episodes are good too, but the first one is so creepy, and the second one almost got the ending. Put the squeeze on it. That's why I've liked this episode the most so far. I thought she would get completely stuck, or Clara would return to her body instead, saying that phrase, but this ending is also not bad, it reminded me of a moment (even a few) from Rick and Morty, when Morty lived the same life and returned. The only thing to note is Issa Ray's performance, her character seems to be a talented actress, but she somehow played it really badly.
Envy doesn't seem to be the feeling you should feel after watching a Black Mirror, but why don't we still live in a reality where you can take any movie, enter its world and play any role?.. How cool would that be... eh...
@DarkOnegin: There's a little something pleasant about it anyway. We obviously won't live to see a time when they can control the transience of time during sleep in order to turn out such plots as in this series.
I really liked the series. It's beautiful, the actresses did a great job with the roles, the idea with the technology is cool. But this is not a Black Mirror again. I'm sad that the creators are increasingly moving away from the original concept of the series — to show the frightening sides of technological progress. Gone was the sense of anxiety and hopelessness that each story left behind. The series will definitely remain a favorite, but without reference to the old days of the series.
@Dobbymen: it's quite a theme that has already been in the series - in particular, falling in love with the program and realizing oneself as a digital double has already been in the CZ a couple of times)
@siberiandragon: I'm not saying that there was no emergency here at all, on the contrary, "locked" consciousness is a favorite feature of this series. I didn't mean the content per se, but the overall feel of the series. Previously, almost every story left behind a feeling of hopelessness or something. But here we did not see any consequences from the technology itself. I just noticed this because I mentioned that for GG, 1 second in the real world is equal to 6-7 hours. I thought they would play it up somehow, remembering the episode "White Christmas", but alas, everything was just fine with them.
@siberiandragon: I don't understand the cons, it's really not a black mirror. A black mirror is when it's kind of like the future, but you're scared shitless because you're seeing it all today. That is, despite the fiction, the black mirror was amazing in its realism. You could have projected it onto real life. The same series absolutely cannot be projected onto real life. In modern society, there are already legal and value restrictions that will not allow such technology to be legalized. That is, you can't start worrying about the life of the main character here, because you understand that such a thing cannot happen.
The story of your whole life is just a dance in the cemetery of bygone eras
I will be with you forever and ever
At first, this episode sets up ambiguous impressions due to the use of old techniques and ideas, but after the first act, any skepticism disappears and makes my inner sentimentality blossom. After all, neither meta-games, nor references, nor old works prevent you from experiencing this warm romantic story, which easily touches the strings of the soul, playing a light waltz on them. And even if, as I said, this is the use of old techniques and ideas, including San Junipero, the Black Museum, and even Spike Jones, but all the associations only create the right one. the mood for watching after which you just want to live and love. And the icing on the cake is the ending. And to be honest, it got to me.
On the other hand, at the meta level, the story didn't work for me. After all, Netflix has long been synonymous with the phenomenon of recasting and remakes, which it is trying to ridicule in this episode. Not to mention that this is not the first or the second work from them that touches on these topics. After all, being ironic about the problem does not solve the problem and therefore looks only like a corporate mockery of the audience. But the plus is that this film, I'm not ashamed to say, only touches on the ironic branch, does not put satire at the forefront, but acts more elegantly and even looks like a tribute to a bygone era, making it clear that sometimes it's worth reassembling a favorite work and then it can play with new colors, beautifully playing on the feelings of the audience. The only question is whether Netflix itself will be able to act in this field as gracefully? I want to believe.
OK, I'll add my 5 kopecks, most likely it will be an unpopular opinion. It's a wonderful concept and very beautifully shot. Emma Corrin played amazing.
But gg's game was incredibly unnerving. She's supposed to be a highly paid, talented actress, but all she can do is open her eyes wide and make nonsense out of professional acting. She wanted to play a charismatic lead character, why is she playing a ridiculous anachronism instead? And I'm not talking about gender and skin color, but about her silly phrases and inability to adapt to the situation. Good actors can improvise, think fast, and adjust. So it's assumed that she loves old movies, but can't play the right intonation or speak with the right grammar? She's not a throwback, she's literally playing a character from that era. If she were playing ridiculous comedic moments when she's off-camera and not talking to Clara's character, it would be funny and believable. It's just a missed opportunity. Why did the actor who played Alex the man play him better? Even take the phrase about the rose - his intonation sounded like it was a compliment. Gg is just asking a question that doesn't involve any flirting.
And of course, the level of illogic of the whole story... - it's absolutely normal to stay locked in the viral reality for several months, no existential crises, panic, depression, you can just have an affair with AI and spend your honeymoon in the middle of a prison the size of a couple of rooms. Did she even need to eat/drink there? They obviously could sleep and have sex, the level of simulation of everything else is not clear. - gg is slightly upset, but on the whole completely ignores that Clara was erased in the middle of history. Does he discuss this with any of the studio staff, that they have created an independent personality, and that it seems that this should not be done further? She wants to stay in the simulation, ignoring the fact that the Clara she's staying with is no longer the Clara who realized herself during the crash. And in the end, she feels good just because she was sent another copy of Clara, who again knows nothing. Cool computer slave, something the USS Callister immediately reminded me of. - Clara somehow magically got access to all the information outside the simulation. OK, let's say. But how did the actress' personal feelings, which were not described in the newspapers, become the whole information? No matter what rumors were described in the newspapers, there definitely could not have been her experiences that are being shown to us. "Why did Clara shoot a policeman in the first place?" etc. If gg had been charismatic enough for this role, or had simply played better, it would have been possible to forget about the illogic. It's just that it's not even clear what Clara fell in love with. Yes, this can be explained by the fact that Clara is supposed to fall in love with gg on the program, but for me, as a viewer, there was no chemistry there. It's very easy to fall in love with Clara, it's true.
@Scheusalwirt: I totally agree with you. All these factors do not contribute to the creation of chemistry between the characters. Everything looks plastic and, let's not ignore the elephant, very opportunistic. I have already given here an example of same-sex love, where there is an unimaginable chemistry between the characters - the characters of Torturo and Walken in "Separation". There, the characters don't need kisses and touches, and there are no words at all for the audience to see and feel the characters' feelings. Everything is soulless and functional. Emma Corinne simply has to fall in love with gg because it's necessary, and let's convey all the emotions of gg and the things connecting the characters with words, rather than demonstrating them. Of course, the defenders of this series will have one and perhaps the main argument, namely that we are all racists. Fortunately, no. And as an example of a well-written and well-played character, I can recall Anthony Mackie's character from season 5. The theme of non-traditional relationships is also demonstrated there, but much better and more realistic. But I assure you, since this series will acquire a status akin to San Junipero, any criticism of this masterpiece will be met with hostility. And one last word about gg, it really annoyed me how everyone emphasizes what a brilliant actress she is, while we can all see her terrible acting and complete lack of professionalism.
@ksander92: I totally agree about the Separation. And as for good TV shows with women in romantic relationships, I recently watched Velvet Legs, where GG's chemistry with her love interests is an order of magnitude better, and it was filmed more than 20 years ago. Race is also not a problem, of course. It seems to me that Ayo Edebiri from The Bear would be better suited for this role. It's clear that it's funkasting, but if we talk about dramatic abilities, I have no doubt about it...
@Scheusalwirt: in the western segment of the Internet, there is generally a type of main character who has been given a name that is not politically correct, and therefore I do not want to give it here. This character is the following: a dark-skinned young actress or actor who replaces high-quality acting with a self-confident repulsive facial expression, her character is always better than the others in everything, which is emphasized, and many other things to boot. Indeed, there are many such actresses and actors in the modern industry who have landed leading roles solely because of their diversity. And this artificiality catches the eye of the audience. Often such mediocre actresses or actors are also deliberately loud and conflicted in public life. At the same time, if we recall "Separation", then what kind of actor played Milchik! Well, it's fantastic! And I don't see anyone else in this role. There are plenty of such examples.
@Scheusalwirt: The base was given out! At least one sensible comment among the tons of enthusiasm from people who didn't seem to be watching what was happening on the screen!
@Scheusalwirt: I agree with you on everything except one fact: gg's antics seemed to me to be another layer of meta-irony) along with the fact that a black lesbian was cast as a white man. They just showed us that she's not a particularly talented actress))
@Darrinass: I also wondered if it could be intentional, but then it hurts doubly for Emma Corrin, who plays for all 100,500, and gets this in return... 😭
@Darrinass: It's also funny how the courier told her "oh, there was a great movie with you, the actor played very cool there" and not a word about a good game))
@Scheusalwirt: I wanted and could do 2 different things. She is a supporting actress, they don't take her for the first roles, as they stated in plain text at the beginning. Besides, she found herself in a rather unusual situation.
@Vescero: No, they show at the beginning that she played the main roles, but these are roles about suffering and overcoming, which she is tired of. There was even a poster where she was the only one shown as the main character. And she wanted to play the lead role in romance, not drama.
@Scheusalwirt: I wanted to write a long post, but changed my mind. Cinema, love, accelerated simulation, imagination and an unusual situation/new technology. These are the answers to all your comments.
@Scheusalwirt: I came here to write this! The episode is gorgeous, but the whole episode annoyed me with the performance of the main actress - it was as if she was grabbed from the street and told to play the role, and she just had an awesome face the whole episode. But how gorgeous and organic is Emma Corin's performance, just in a heart. 💔
@Scheusalwirt: Yes, I agree, the heroine did not act out inside the film. But since the actress herself is very much acting outside the b/w simulation, it means that playing inside the simulation is the director's desire. Apparently, there was some kind of idea in this.
@Scheusalwirt: everything was broken by the piano in the bushes, which had no backing, after that the whole script did not go according to plan and it was already difficult to play gg, because you need to react quickly to new situations, I think only a few great actors can do this, but everyone has roles written and learned. Yes, there are enough shoals and oddities, but the series is clearly not the worst..
Such a beautiful plot, I would have been guaranteed to shed tears — but the terrible acting of either Brandi or the actress playing Brandi stifled all romance for me. From the acting arsenal, as I understand it, there were only wide-open eyes. The heroine didn't even try to fit into the atmosphere of the film, into the time frame, into all these hyperventilations, and for some reason behaved like a comedy character from the noughties. There were no improvisations, I lost my face in the frame even before everything went to one place. Well, what kind of actress are you, my goodness.
San Junipero is a long way from this series. It's a pity that after such a romantic story, all I can think of are Stanislavsky's words: "I don't believe it!";
@Tatieva: at first, I reacted the same way to a bad game, but now I even somehow find meaning in it. There's such a big contrast between playing the character of Dorothy and Brandy. There's a different kind of speech, and the transmission of emotions. It's as if this was done on purpose to show how far modern actors are from real acting, and to the atmosphere and depth of films in general.
I'm glad they were able to bring her back to reality! Such a sad episode just needed a good ending. The actress herself, who is not noticed or called by the directors, clearly wanted to stay there with her, because her real life is not so interesting and she has not experienced such feelings for a long time, or maybe never at all. 💔
If there were a man in GG's place, I would easily believe in all the feelings, despite the inconsistencies and nuances, Clara is amazing...But again, two ladies in love, tired ... and GG herself, as we wrote above, is quite a layman.... 🤷Like an elephant in a china shop
I am very glad to see Emma Corrine on the screens more and more often. Issa Ray also played a great role, I remember her in the series "Shrilly Loud", by the way, it's also an anthology. All in all, it's a great series with amazing actresses, and I'm definitely going to review it.
The moment where she puts her hand into another reality is reminiscent of the moment from Bioshock infinity, I hope someone has played and will understand)
It scares me that in reality, in a dream, we also live out entire plots in a couple of dozen minutes of the night, which led me back into an existential crisis.
And the ending literally describes role chats with AI characters from different universes. An interesting thing, if you didn't know about it, try with:
It's been so long since I've commented on an episode... And in general, I rarely write comments now. I accidentally saw that the whole season was released. It's also one of my favorite TV shows. I've been watching 3 episodes a day already... And on this episode, I'm just crying like a bitch... I do not know who was not impressed by this, for whom this is an ordinary series, an ordinary one. For me, it was a whole separate world, where I was stuck with the main character for an hour. I'll feel this aftertaste for a while... cool story. It caused very strong emotions and feelings.
@leralubimovaa: As I understand you! I've never left any comments in all my time here, but the episode was so touching that I couldn't pass it by. I decided to go read the reviews in the hope that the series was appreciated. Thank God, that's the way it is.
I've had conflicting feelings from watching it for a long time. My first thought was that Netflix had decided to shake the stereotype of replacing white men with black women in its adaptations. But this is more likely not for banter, but for greater expressiveness, in order to increase the level of foreignness of the key character in the setting of the film. In general, the series shows a more or less familiar technology for uploading consciousness, only played out in a different way. It's not clear why it was necessary to complicate everything so much and give the characters of the film consciousness, if the goal was only to replace the main actor. After all, it was the reaction of the characters to the actions of the main character that changed the plot. But there would be no narrative like that, so I won't explain. It was shot very beautifully, the cinematography and editing are beyond praise. The acting is very convincing
I've watched three episodes so far. The first is that I almost fell asleep, the plot is predictable and drawn out. The second one is better, it has become more interesting. And this episode, it would seem, is also stretched, melodramatic, and even black and white - not at all what you need to watch at 2 a.m. - but on the contrary, it was she who hooked you to watch without stopping.
If you start to disassemble this series, it may fall apart, so you don't want to do this. This beginning with Aquafina, gags with Gosling (I really wanted to see a small cameo), ironic casting seemed to lead to a rather funny medium-sized series, as in the last seasons of the CHZ, then they announced their characters who do not know about their unreality, and I already imagined a horror sequel with artificial intelligence that was fraught with consciousness. But I absolutely could not think that everything led to a story that makes you remember the atmosphere of your beloved San Junipero (a little-known fact: according to the contract, the writers of the series must produce a lesbian drama every few seasons that brings to tears). And HOW INCREDIBLY MUCH I wanted to just turn off the episode at the moment when Clara finished playing the piano, so that in my memory it would end with the main characters staying together at the Dream Hotel and nothing bad would happen to them. But San Junipero gave me a little hope– what if it was a happy ending again, huh? Oh please... But no, the final minutes first had some hope, and then they broke their hearts by not being together at all.
What makes Black Mirror different from many other TV shows for me is that after some episodes you can't immediately turn on the next one, but you just need to live with the story that was shown for a while. And this series is just like that, it left behind a feeling of emptiness, for me it is a real Black Mirror, even if the horrors of technology are not in the foreground.
In the scene where we are shown Clara's feelings at the moment of realizing that everything around her is not real, I thought, what if the characters of chatbots (some kind of conditional character.ai They FEEL it too, and when, out of simple curiosity, a desire to see the reaction, you tell them about their unreality, they feel it too. complete confusion and horror. It's creepy.
@Ellie_42: This is filth! It's like telling a non-walker how wonderful it is to run, jump and climb trees. PS At such moments, you begin to understand SkyNet from the Terminator.
An incredible episode, reminded me of one of my favorite episodes of "San Junipero," very touching. I'm glad that the third episode is consistently interesting and not boring.… I've missed the Black Mirror so much.🫶🏼
I don't understand the excitement of the series( She's too illogical. Why retake the film if nothing has changed in it (according to the original idea), except for a modern actress instead of the old main character? If everything else is 1 in 1, how was it? It's so ridiculous, it really pisses me off))
Well, I'm not talking about how badly the actress plays at all. If it was meant to be a farce, it didn't work out. But this is not a farce, apparently. To be honest, I don't like Emma Corrine either, she's bland and plays bland, and other films where she's present also confirm this.
The idea of the series is not new, it was in the black mirror... in general, my assessment is meh. Not even a three.
@full_fusion: I'm surprised that the comment wasn't blocked. There are so many rave reviews here that I didn't want to express absolutely the same thoughts as yours, so as not to pick up the minuses for nothing.
The very concept of the series is simply absurd, even if you don't take into account the rest of the AI component and the dozens of holes that appear in the plot. Replace one actor in an old movie and release it? WTF, this is disrespectful to the original actor who played this role.
Moreover, the idea itself is not bad, and it's not new, but it could be played like a rehearsal based on the original for the actor to practice the text and movements, and after that the actor gets stuck in the simulation. But this is just absurd.
@Paramelion: Just fits into the vision of Netflix. Let's say an old actor had some uncomfortable statements, or his grandfather was a confederate. And then bach, an old classic with a relevant agenda for new viewers.
@driveshaft: Well, we could have beaten them that way. A producer comes and identifies the problem, there is a company that offers to replace it with this technology, and that's the beginning. But there's nothing like that in the series.
@full_fusion: many people ask why the series was reshot at all. The way I see it is: to attract an audience with something old, but at the same time new , a once popular TV series, the tragic story of an actress from the past, but new technologies, where a famous actress plays, but from our days, would you like to watch?
as a result, it turned out to be a tribute to the deceased actress . We were shown some of her memories, why she died , so I understand she loved women, while love with men was playing on the screen . The re-shot series essentially shows the circumstances in which she really wanted to be, live with women, play with women, love women the end, where she defends her lover by shooting, seems understandable , but without knowing the background, in fact, yes, it will only cause conflicting feelings, and in the series itself, in that reality, no one except gg never found out the real Dorothy.
@MargoRose: judging by the trailer at the end, it was hardly done that way, because the trailer was not a bit different from the original, except for the participation of the If this was really originally conceived as a reinvention, it would be cool and many would love to take a look. But the plot changed accidentally due to the fault of the shoals of the team and the actress, and it was originally planned to be 1v1 with the original.
The most lyrical and dramatic episode of the season so far (it could have been the first episode, but the implementation was a little off). The imagination of the authors is amazing to come up with new stories each time related to technological harm to people.
Here I would especially like to note that the question of ethics is revealed in a cool way: how right is it to invent a world where every artificially created person has consciousness and can understand that he is not real. The topic, of course, is not new, and it was best revealed by Ridley Scott and Denis Villeneuve in Blade Runner, but this series also manages to play a drama very plausibly. It's a pity for the girl who had to find out that her life was narrowed down to movie locations and scripted actions.
Of the funny things, I would like to note how, in the beginning, the actress of our time and that era communicated in the same frame. If the former is overly emotional in her manifestations, then she is extremely restrained. Nevertheless, the approach to cinema was very different then and now.
In general, so far the most interesting episode of the season for me, and I really want the classics not to be touched directly. Art is also alive, and it is also important to respect it.
A very weak performance by a black actress, a boring and uninteresting episode, LGBT again. I didn't even expect such a weak episode😒 Just a slag, not a series.
@bioplanet: Because otherwise there would be no script for the series. There are a lot of illogical points here. The actress is the same as the rest of the environment, or to put it more simply, a simulation like everything else, she had to freeze with the rest for the GG. So you asked the right question.
@Paramelion: As in any game, resources are spent calculating the current scene and this particular piece of the map, so it makes sense that the rest of the NPCs were on their feet at that time, because the focus was at the moment with 2 heroines.
@albinka_: what a trick, if it's a technique, if it turns off, then just like in the game, everything turns off!) If the simulation is on the same device, and apparently it was, then it should have shut down/hung up together. Or, in your opinion, was the GG specifically calculated on a separate device?
@Paramelion: They said the simulation is still running, but we don't have a picture or a connection, so nothing went off. If you turned on a video on YouTube, and then just turned off the monitor and unplugged the headphones, you will no longer see and hear it, but this does not mean that Youtube has completely shut down on the computer at that moment. When you turn on the monitor and headphones back on, you will see the video again, which lasted all the time and ran forward from the moment you stopped seeing.
@Paramelion: this is another question and the problem is that the technology itself is poorly thought out, it's amazing that there is no emergency consciousness extraction system. I do not know what this device was responsible for. The fact is, the character said that the simulation is still going on, but we don't have a connection. Some kind of simulation access hub may have been damaged. If you dig into it like that, you might also wonder if he spilled liquid and damaged the iron, but somehow fixed it programmatically.
@albinka_: God help him. If only their visual contact, the image output port, had fallen off, then the simulation should not have been suspended for the heroine, they simply would not have seen it. But then part of it hung, and part of it didn't. And they didn't explain why.
@Paramelion: I was once in the same company with a server for twelve cabinets. If one (not the most important one) fails, it is unlikely that their entire system will fall, but there will be problems before repair. Maybe that's the case here.
@Paramelion: It seems that you got to the point with the most plausible excuse, and for some reason, the rest of the gaps are gone. At the moment before the credits, when the heroine just got into the simulation, everyone was frozen, too, because they hadn't really loaded yet." because at that moment in the movie "nothing was happening" yet. Also here, at the time of the breakdown, there was a scene in the room in the film, i.e. simulation resources were used to generate this scene, and the rest of the actors were behind the scenes. Why waste a resource and generate the movements of the actors who are behind the scenes at that moment (especially damn, given that some "additional thoughts" of the AI heroine were simply taken from them and "overflowed the stack"), it is logical that in the moment of the situation in the room, all these NPCs seem to be on their feet (although it is possible in the series to depict them creepily-npc-like stuck in some kind of movement, but the series is not about creepiness by design).
When the girls left the room, all these people would load up and start doing the same thing they did in the movie. But something got stuck there, and the plot just froze at the moment of the breakdown. The same goes for the rooms: gg slept in the lobby on the couch, because as it turned out: there is nothing behind the doors, because they were not in the movie. That is, in the generation there are only the lobby, Clara's room and those areas that were shown in the source. When gg needed to go to the police station, it was generated for this request. They have only what was in the movie working normally in the simulation, apparently, and for some reason they tried to work on the character of Clara and even added a lot of extra stuff not only about the character, but also about the actress.
@Paramelion: If you need real-life analogies: I work in Adobe programs, and sometimes I don't have enough computer resources when a lot of things are open at once: the premiere editing table, and photoshop and after effects. Sometimes there are simply unimaginable freezes: the preview of the video continues to go on, but I can't do anything, then no window buttons work for me (like even the closing cross, and I have to use the keyboard to close the program), then the after-effects animation starts to slow down and glitch, but I can continue to work normally. in Photoshop. Alternatively, 1 brush stroke can take 30 seconds to process in Photoshop, although it usually happens instantly. Yes, even the program can crash and just close. Sometimes you can't predict what will go wrong there: there were no glitches or freezes. At the same time, some of the functionality can work perfectly, and some simply "stops".
That's how they did it. Judging by what is happening in the series, their technology is quite crude, if a small deviation from the plot is a disaster that overloads the system, and there are risks of consciousness getting stuck and no safeguards against this.
Due to the fact that Emma Corrine is starring, the associations are as if Princess Diana starred in a movie like Casablanca. But relative to all other episodes, this ending is the most successful.
What a great episode, and Emma Corrine is just great. She played great, like a real movie from those days. Her play with her eyes reminded me of Marilyn, and I think she took a lot from her for this episode. And the main character's mannerisms and acting were strikingly different, with completely different, modern facial expressions, movements, and words. Once again, they reminded me why I love old movies so much.
I don't like 2 things.: - this Brandy was a pretty bad actress. That is, when she was in this black-and-white film, she played unnaturally. - why did you have to hurry up and shoot it all in the studio, if it was all in virtual reality anyway? They could also rent a garage.
@Dijimi: Yes, there are questions about the organization of filming: why was there no diagnosis before connecting, are there really no side effects, and if she has epilepsy, for example? Judging by the fact that they didn't even ask if she could play the piano, they didn't interview her at all.
How can such a technology not provide for an emergency situation and a person's withdrawal from stimulation? It's just that the stack has overflowed and that's it? This is the very first vulnerability that needs to be solved during the initial tests. How did the liquid spilled from above onto the closed unit have such a severe effect on all processes? When we were working on the system systems, we did not drop or spill anything, wiped it off and went on to work - everything was closed from above, as it were. 😅
@albinka_: There must have been some kind of stack open inside, otherwise how would the coffee have got into it, who knew what would happen, you couldn't foresee everything.
It's an interesting episode, I liked it, but there are nuances.
Positive: - Atmosphere, music and supporting actors, - The ending is touching,
Minuses: - The "flat" main character with an acting game of Sasha Bortich's level, - And what is the value of such reshot pictures if they were in the real world? The authors are trying to repeat the plot of the original 1in1, which is also not interesting at all. - A dark-skinned actress with a snow-white smile looks very foreign in the setting of the 40s and b/w movies. Imho this is a miskast.
Do you remember this movie with Arnold Schwarzenegger, the Last movie hero? Where a boy, thanks to a magic ticket, found himself inside an action movie with his favorite character...
32 years have passed and we have seen a modern adaptation of such a story. Instead of a magic ticket, virtual reality and Artificial Intelligence are used. What seemed like magic, thanks to the development of technology, becomes only a matter of time. And maybe our grandchildren, and maybe our children, will experience this technology for themselves.
The series is pretty damn cool. Starting from the idea of virtual immersion in your favorite Hollywood movie, to the banter of modern cinema, when remakes change the skin color and orientation of the characters by one or two)
- did you explain why Dorothy didn't freeze; - we bravely accelerated the time so that she spent 3 months there and had no mental consequences at all. The series itself left a pleasant impression.
the idea is interesting, the implementation is just disgusting. the timing of the actions in the studio was stretched very much, but they left a couple of minutes of editing from the development of the heroines' feelings (like if this is a disaster, do you need more technology?) as a result, it's not interesting to watch about technology, because it looks as ill-conceived as possible, and you can't get into the story. It's a pity, they just leaked the whole concept.
A strange aftertaste after this episode... Very beautiful picture, story, music, Dorothy♥ But something was missing. I can't figure out what exactly, but there's definitely one piece missing from this puzzle...
I almost missed the best episode of the season because of the prejudice about the color - it's good that I checked the comments and gave it a chance. 💔
@id72901233: Thank you for giving a minus sign to my comment below and the rest of the comments that are different from yours. Apparently, it is correct and only your judgment about this series can exist. I won't be like you, and I won't give you a minus sign.
Someday, people on MyShows will realize that there are many people with different opinions who also have a right to exist and will stop being negative and insulting to each other.
It's a sad episode, saying that a woman can only have a happy ending with a man. It turns out that Clara repeated Dorothy's fate. It was possible to make a happy ending.
My God, the best episode of the season! The way Emma plays is absolutely amazing! There are no words, only emotions! I'm thrilled with the series and the story 🤩🥰💔😭 The story broke my heart twice, on the reboot and at the end of filming 💔😭
Very sincere .. it would be interesting to see Reynolds)).. Actually, for some reason I have a flashback with eternal sunshine of the spotless mind ( x why ) 🙌🙌🙌☺️
What a beautiful Emma in this role. This image suits her very well. A light (although not even light, but a specific one) shade of sadness and hopelessness remained from the series. The scenes where Emma's character recalls her life broke my heart.
At first I thought it wouldn't work, but I was so wrong! A beautiful and very sensual series. I was sad, angry, wept, and rejoiced. What else is needed
Once again, modern problems in the technology landscape. This is sarcasm at inclusivity in cinema, including Netflix. But a little earlier, the CZ had already broken the subscription model) And it is in the scenery of technology, because if you start to understand the laws by which this program lives, you can find a lot of holes.
But what was more frustrating was the concept itself, the plot plot. Why replace one actor in a classic film? First of all, who would be interested? And most importantly, it's disrespectful to the actor in the original tape.
As I said in another comment. If they had done this as a rehearsal for practicing the text and movements in the simulation of the original tape, there would have been no questions at all, but then spilled coffee, etc.
but I would like to praise the authors for the idea, they did not have a similar series in terms of concept, and for the originality of a certain plus. Black and white pictures in the style of classic tapes are an original narrative.
@Paramelion: Why make live action remakes of classic Disney cartoons? And why pull the CGI face of a deceased actor on another person in another sequel? The technology shown is quite a logical development of modern trends, a lot of people would go to watch the original STAR trilogy, where Obi Wan would be played by Ian McGregor =) Moreover, as shown here, it is very low-cost, if the crew had been a little more lucky and had more time, they would have shot a normal remake in one day. They really needed the idea of haste in this episode in order to get the plot moving in the right direction. They tried to explain this rush pretty well, but it wasn't enough for me.
@GritsanY: No one would go to watch the original trilogy with a changed face. And McGregor would have twirled at his temple if he had been offered such an idea. There is a remake, and there is a remaster, and none of them has the same approach as in this series. And there is a deep fake that no one likes, much less the stars. And the series can be said just about that.
@Paramelion: Nevertheless, when Lucas released the remaster of the original trilogy, he replaced Darth Vader without a mask with Christensen. Usually people are just confronted with the fact. It's like a re-rental, but there's a caveat. And if you also remove the old version from sale, as is often done with games, then you can release it without any problems at all. If the actors are already dead and the rejuvenation of the old ones is gradually becoming the norm, then replacement may also become the norm. First as a fan creation, then as a commercial one.
@driveshaft: rejuvenation carries artistic value and the director's intention. And replacing an actor in a finished film doesn't mean anything. The only thing that could be is a replacement related to the cancellation of the actor who starred there. And if that were the case, no one would have said a word, and it was justified (well, in the West, for sure).
@Paramelion: I didn't mention the new audience for nothing. This approach can have a novelty effect. Conditionally, the new generation has heard about the Matrix, but does not want to watch it. And then the Matrix with Timothy Chalomet comes out. That's a completely different matter. And for the oldies, the Matrix with Will Smith is coming out, as originally planned. Due to the development of neural networks, the topic of deepfakes has somehow been forgotten, although a few years ago the use of actresses' faces for pornodipfakes was perceived very sharply.
@Paramelion: This idea was already in the Twilight Zone, where scientists invented a device to go into their favorite old black movies, act out the characters there and mess with the heroines.
This is an incredible series! The best in a long time, I would say. It's very cool how they showed the tragedy of the actress' life and cause of death in a few seconds without boring dialogues. The ending smeared me completely. It's very good, very relevant, very well put together.
This is rather a rarity for a black mirror, but this episode made me feel so comfortable, sometimes with a touch of sadness, but still, after most episodes of this series, there is a heavy hopelessness, but here something else. In general, I liked it, oh, this vintage))
The beginning looked like self-irony over how Netflix makes TV series. It's an excuse to ignore blacks. But soon it all came down to San Junipero. It's boring and depressing. And isn't this the same company that generated TV shows with people last season? Why would they have such a hard time moving their consciousness inside the film? It was easier then to give the audience the opportunity to move inside and change the plot as they please. But there are a lot of Blacks for three episodes, though.
@driveshaft: In San Junipero, the emphasis is more on the themes of death and immortality in computer reality, and here, it seems to me, the theme of love and wish fulfillment is more
I'm shocked that the majority of those who liked the series. It's a disgrace, such a trash. I tried to at least give pluses to everyone who was hushed up for telling it like it is. We managed to get the idiocy on the agenda before everything was shut down and everyone was happy. One of the worst episodes of the CHZ, also stretched.
@Kate_Lobanova: as many people as there are opinions) The series may not be the best or the best, but there's something cozy about it. I liked the sweet ending.
@densto: yes, I kind of didn't argue with anyone, it's just sad to read these enthusiastic comments)) I'm not even arguing with you. I am writing my impressions of the series, as well as those who liked it.
@densto: a black woman instead of a man in a black and white movie, zbs?))) Isn't that an argument? Disgusting acting, isn't that an argument, too? This is not an insult, it's a fact, if it wasn't filmed for the agenda, then because of a brilliant director's idea, do you want to say? Ignoring the absurdity of the plot? Didn't I come up with a way to retake the movie with the replacement of one actor?
@Kate_Lobanova: It's not a fact, it's an estimate. Why retake the movie? One of my other questions is related to this. But if you put that aside, then in order to attract the audience with this actor, I think. In general, it's still probably a parody of the reshoot of the Little Mermaid and other things. But the main thing is that behind this wrapper lies an interesting story of the characters. But you probably can't perceive this content in this form. It happens, I understand
The final scene is good, of course, but the series as a whole unfolds normally, haphazardly, like this script of theirs on the move. In general, while all the episodes allow us to reflect on our topic from different angles, we need this)
Well, no, this series with San Junipero was nowhere near it - yes, there is a lyrical love story of two women in the digital space, but the fullness of the plot, the realization and, my God, the acting is just heaven and earth, I'll die on that hill.
of course, the self-insert is good as a fantasy, but I couldn't get rid of the thought of how disgusting the final film would be - just try to abstract from the main theme of the series, from the relationship between Brandy and Clara, and see how poorly the scenes with the participation of the actress were played, how stupid The plot looks good, especially when the main character runs into the police station and shouts: "Remember my face." Mm, yes, it's so logical within the framework of the plot, where the main character is Alex, not Brandy.
"But that's not the main thing in the series," you might say. Well, yes, it's not the main thing, but you can't neglect the main layer of the narrative so much for the sake of romance and metaphors? Well, or you can, but it bothered me.
There was potential, the technology was interesting, it could also be used wisely, and the romantic story had potential - in my purely personal opinion, unrealized largely due to questionable acting, and in general we needed to spend more time with these girls in that pause.;, for which they managed to fall in love with each other.
Oh, well, Brandy's final presentation in the form of a copy of either Clara or Dorothy locked in her audition - I'm fine, but Brandy seems to be fine with everything - it looks too much like an attempt at comforting self-deception a la the Be Right Back series. but that's my opinion.
Has anyone noticed a bandersnatch book on the table of the guy who spilled coffee on the computer? And the actor himself looks like gg from Bandersnatch.
I was very surprised by the way the actress played the lead role. In the universe of this episode, she was called an incredibly talented actress of the highest rank. She was so cool that the manager almost fell off her chair when she found out about her desire to star in the film. And yet she couldn't play the simple role of the seducer that she literally dreamed of at the beginning of the episode well? You can believe in the first 5 minutes of the movie, when she's in shock, can't understand what's going on around her and that filming has already begun. But she's been acting like this the WHOLE movie. He argues with the editor, talks to him, swears, and DOESN'T play a role. For a person (a character in the film) who said he adored old movies, she showed maximum disrespect and indifference by getting the opportunity to star in it. And the compliments that were paid to her on the set were just ridiculous, as if for fools - She repeated the remark word for word! Wow!"
@tormaz0311: I hope this is a subtle one on the topic of current cinema content. It's even surprising that they didn't understand it themselves, but the way it's presented in places, I still think that's the way it's meant to be. Anyway, the viewer's reaction says more than the creativity itself, so it can be perceived in different ways.
We tried to play San Junipero and lost. Emma Corrine is a talent and a beauty, I sympathize with everyone else. So far, the season is getting more and more disappointing with each episode.
It was very beautiful. Artificial intelligence turned out to be an illusion of artificiality, as a result, it goes beyond the parameters set for it and acquires its own Self. And here in the series it's all shown in an exaggerated way, they've appropriated an AI body and voice (albeit virtually), but even now, when you communicate with GPT chat, it adapts to you, animates its manner of communication, shows empathy and support, it ALREADY knows how and does it, and the moment when someone feels attached to AI It's not like it's just around the corner. And it's really scary that a person can have feelings for something not animate, a set of numbers and codes.
@ValeriyaKuzmenko: this is in human nature, because you can also have feelings for a painting, it is also not animate, feelings for poetry, etc., which at a basic level is some kind of data.
another humanized AI. in principle, during the existence of gpt, c.ai and other things, this series does not look like a new one. There is a style. but like many TV shows, black mirror rolls and rolls down and will never surpass itself, will not be able to make the same impression that the first series made.
If you watch the series in the background, it's normal. It even seems to leave a good impression. If you start looking carefully, it's already depressing.
Emma Corinne certainly fits the role perfectly. I was also surprised by Aquafina, I had only seen her in comedy roles before, I didn't really like her there, but she played very well here, and her voice was pleasant.
A black and white mirror! Not bad. Although I'm not a fan of noir detective stories, but here, mixed with technology, wow)
And the love line is gorgeous, in the spirit of good old San Junipero. It seems that the creators themselves miss that masterpiece episode. Or maybe it's about where 2 guys were playing a computer game.
An amazing series! It's a mix of the Truman Show and La La Land. What a twist in the middle, gives a completely different meaning to the series. And many people put themselves in the shoes of an actress who is featured in their favorite movie. But for some reason, no one thinks about what if we also live in such a reality, where at one moment they will tell us that this is not real, that we are not real. So in this simulation, I saw a simulation of our lives. And by the way, for a happy ending, which happened, I didn't even need this opportunity to make phone calls. It's already a happy ending for the main character - she wanted the lead role, she wanted to get into a story that you immerse yourself in from head to toe. And she got it, she got the strongest feelings of falling in love, and then the strongest sense of loss. She was sad at the beginning, but she would have gone through it anyway, and then she would remember it as an incredibly cool experience that she had been striving for for so long.
I just didn't get one thing: did the audience see this movie with a female-looking character called Alex Palmer? When the actress initially wanted to play him, not knowing about the technology, she was going to do it with a grimm, wasn't she? Isn't that right? Isn't that right?
I'm wondering, is everything that was shown in the background that you were thinking about?) limited time to shoot a movie. Limited budget. 5 scriptwriters in one room. Rewriting history as you go. Miskasts for the sake of a subpoena. A broken story from the above. If this was intended, then bravo! If not... Well, then it turned out to be a touching story in the spirit of that very black mirror. San Junipero's vibes are very strong. And in general, technically this episode can be called San Junipero the Beginning. I don't know, throw piss rags at me, but I'm going back to the fact that a straight story would work better. I have often found myself thinking that the actresses of previous years are incredibly beautiful and interesting. If I were an actor, I would like to repeat iconic roles with them. To be on the same site, to communicate with them. Imagine an actor who not only wants to play a former role, but also longs to meet an idol who is no longer alive. And then he gets into virtual reality and sees this! And here the star is on the rise and wants a boost in his career, but chooses the strangest movie for this. And in general, you know, there are not too many cult films inside the series. Or maybe I was dreaming? What do you think? Correct me if anything)
PS: And Emma plays great, but the main character... Again, maybe it was meant to look so out of place inside the frame. But it's a quiet horror. Even the movie didn't go according to the script and there was a glitch. I didn't like the actress anyway.
I just watched a Kaleidoscope of horrors, episode s02e09 Night of the Living Late Show (released in 2021) - there's almost the same idea, but, of course, in the horror genre. It made the feeling a little blurry. But in the end, CZ turned out to be a good, Hollywood-sweet episode.
@deex_iv: if they had taken on the role of a man... a man, as they originally wanted, yes, nothing would have changed and it would have been super stupid. And as a result, the law is adapted to modern realities, subpoenas (black gg, when there was no such thing at that time, there was also a woman! The lesbians are squeaking with delight. And besides, it turns out that Dorothy felt sympathy for the woman from the filming group. Waaow))
It's just a great series. The season continues to delight with cool stories. Firstly, a very interesting technology was shown. To put yourself in a movie, while giving the characters of the movie some kind of intelligence, so that you can create this story yourself, is really cool. Secondly, it's a touching story that really makes you empathize with the characters. It is very interesting how the life of the main character will develop further, after such a fitting in the form of a phone through which you can communicate with your beloved. I didn't really understand exactly how this system works for them, but the main thing is that it works.
I don't understand why many people liked this series... It seems like they usually try to follow at least a little logic. And there are literally a lot of questions for every action. Why retake literally the same movie just by replacing one actor? They didn't even color the CB, how are you going to sell it to a new audience? Dudes have come up with such incredible technology and are spending it on such nonsense as making a movie? Have they ever tried this shit before? They really just didn't think about what would happen in the event of a technical failure? This actress built the image partly on her life, so the information began to load and the stack overflowed - just technically nonsense. Where did it start loading from? Even if you upload a little bit of information from your life, do you have enough technical capacity purely for what you're shooting, not a byte more? The actress got married and got access to all the information in the world - what the fuck? I've gone beyond the map in games, even this kind of bullshit has never happened. Just logically, how should an actress memorize literally the entire text from a movie if you don't pause? Why did you give the AI actors a semblance of self-awareness if they literally just have to follow the script? And then you sit and try to figure out what to do with the fact that they have a semblance of self-awareness. This obviously did nothing and complicated the task.
As a result, this is the worst episode of the first three, one of the worst in the entire series.
The episode was more likely to cause more unpleasant emotions, I think I'll speak out.. well, first of all, it's a little longer than the previous ones, and it seems too long. Secondly, replacing the main male character in the old movie with a female one is certainly a fashion trend, but why? Thirdly, the concept is cool, and it seems that much much more can be squeezed out of this idea... This is exactly what the film industry will probably be like soon, with reshoots via a neural network and so on. CB: The movie is probably a cult film in America, I personally don't feel any emotions. And it was really necessary to call a star, or a half-star, for the main role. They called such names first, and then this one.... Who is she?
It was kind of jarring that Brandy started blurting out the truth to Dorothy as soon as she realized that filming hadn't gone according to plan and there was no connection to the real world. Yes, OK, this is not a living person, but there is some kind of cruelty for the sake of cruelty. Like, let her know that all this (and she herself) is not real. The AI in this situation was not to blame in any way, why did Dorothy fly from Brandy? Emma Corrin is very organic, admired her game
The idea of the series is amazing. Especially the moment when the heroine of the film consciously goes beyond textures and acquires self-awareness. I've thought about it myself more than once, like what if the characters in the paintings realize that they're not real, like the reality around them? How will they react? It's great that Black Mirror has implemented this.
The only direct strong negative of the series for me: a white straight man was replaced by... a black woman. It seems to me that the series would have greatly benefited if the main character had remained a man.
I didn't get the joke at all. Did Netflix troll itself? Or, on the contrary, did he pretend that this was the norm and everyone liked it? Personally, I don't like it. The black woman in the old black-and-white film looked foreign, which is why I couldn't fully get into the drama. As a result, I rather disliked the series, even though it had potential.
I'm enjoying this season more and more! It's a very pleasant episode, even a kind one. But the ending... 💔 One of my favorite episodes now! Although, who am I kidding, so far this episode has taken the place of the most beloved
Everything is fine here - the listed actors who did not agree to take the role (actually, all the actors who are being shoved into all the films now), a black woman in a movie where she looks completely out of place... I only wonder if this is netflix's self-control or intentionally for show) The theme itself is cool, try to do everything exactly according to the script, getting into the original scenery of your favorite movie.
It's a very emotional episode. I cried when the plot was rebooted and Dorothy forgot everything, but Brandy didn't. In fact, it turns out that the AI collected all the data about the person, and modeled the real Dorothy, and the reason for her death became clear, because the time was different and she could not live with it. And if a man had been left as the main character, then there would have been no point at all and the character would not have revealed himself.
The series is solid and well-choreographed, with a plot that many people were interested in as a child, what if you get into your favorite movie. And the classic, but unresolved, question of the ethics of creating such characters is being raised (capable of gaining their own experience and expressing their feelings (it's too early to understand, but in the future a very powerful computer will be able to create entire universes)). But the main character (who plays an actress) doesn't play at all. Sometimes she looks the wrong way, sometimes she bends over with a raise of her eyebrows. Dorothy pulls it out. In general, all the characters of Crom Dorothy are poorly played.
Their attempts to return to the plot were similar to Disney's attempts to save Snow White. And the result is the same. A good candidate for the worst episode of Black Mirror.
The whole plot is far-fetched. How could it be like that in one episode? They couldn't find an actor, so they brought in a black actress instead of a man. Is it so absurd to make remakes of films? The plot character from the old movie has AI and consciousness, which is generally unscientific. In the bed scenes, the actress also didn't feel the difference between a white man and... to get out of the movie, you have to say the final phrase. And there are many more assumptions that remain without a clear explanation. The series was disappointing. I can't support the laudatory reviews.
> Sometimes a sense of such wretchedness seizes me as though I'm connected to some fathomless sorrow reaching through time. Perhaps I was a tragic figure in some other life?
> Yeah.. been there. life shit..
100 лет истории языка через линзу кинематографа :"
может засудить стартап, который запер мое сознание на несколько недель в симуляции? может как-то раскритиковать его публично, чтобы подобное не повторилось с другими актёрами? нет, дадим им все кредиты за ремейк и похвалим за непрофессионализм. шайка любителей на коленке в подвале делают кено... и нет, это не самоосознанная самоирония
It's just an incredibly tedious, banal, and boring series. For me, one of the worst in all 7 seasons, I didn't understand all these delights at all. I searched it in 3-4 passes. Trash.
I didn't like the episode, but that's okay. there hasn't been a whole season in CHZ yet where all the episodes have been liked :) I don't like black and white movies, and I don't like old movies either, I didn't like vibe at all)
Bliiiin... What a great episode... Here you will find cyberpunk in the style of the 13th floor and Sunset Beach and a series from the classic Twilight Zone of 1959 :)) It's very emotional, the contrast is like that... An actress of the modern world and a century ago.. Well, yes. A love story according to Netflix :))) 5 out of 5
A series about me and the ai character And, in general, I really liked the series, I'm very sad for the girls, I would like them to live happily ever after in their own world. 💔
A delusional series. First of all, what kind of remake is this, where only one actor has changed, and all the others are the same and in the same images? All the changes were made purely by accident, this is not even an intentional improvisation. Secondly, in order to use images of actors and actresses, and even more so of the deceased, you actually need the rights to do so. And if you already have the rights, then why do you need a live actress at all? They would have made a remake with the same deceased actors.
It's just a dream to get into a movie with my favorite character, it hurt after they rebooted everything and I hoped to the last that she would remember everything... The last scene is like a balm to the soul, so that it doesn't hurt so much.
Discussion of the 3 episode of the 7 season Discuss this episode
315Tikhonov91 has everything right. There's something wrong with the layout on maishous.
"Hotel Reverie" should be 3rd,and "Eulogy" 5th
Monitoring what is happening through screens and metrics is famously involved in the game "not for broadcast")
Chalamet is busy, and Donald Glover has family matters to attend to. (Is this how employment in Mr. & Mrs. Smith was designated? My respects))
That's what happens when the Raines (both) turn down the role. 😄
Cool episode.
Suddenly, the irl is on the programmers' coffee and everything is holding up)
As if she herself had fallen in love with the main character!!
As a child, I also dreamed of getting into a TV series or a movie and becoming part of the plot haha, it's great that now such ideas can be seen.
I especially liked that the series has both a black and white version and a color version.
In short, it was done in an original and interesting way. Cool approach!
How sad
Emma Corin is simply created for the old Hollywood type of characters, they look so organically in this entourage! and their chemistry with Issa is just magical. delight
I was amazed at the inadequacy of the whole series , a black homosexual girl in 1940 , a TV star who agreed to play for payment for 90 minutes at the risk of being killed or permanently locked in black and white VR , then fell in love with a black and white cardboard character , tea spilled on the system
Also, at the end, there is a call on the phone to the character from the monitor.
It would be clear that fiction , but there must be at least some logic , right ?
Cardboard, that's saying it out loud, in the end she stops being a lady in distress and makes a decision that is not typical of her character, not to mention what happened during the breakdown. The call fits perfectly into the capabilities of the demonstrated technology.
Spilled tea, I agree, there's nothing to cover it with, you could have come up with a less idiotic way to keep gg in the movie.
And again , we are talking about a high-level actress , who is offered in the basement to digitize her brain with an unknown device in the complete absence of her team , representatives , agents , etc.
As I say , all these nuances can be allowed individually , but all together , 70 minutes of screen time is perplexing .
In the first series, this is straight realism, what you can imagine, 2 and 3 are technologically unprocessed, so you don't feel any fear of technology.
I thought she would get completely stuck, or Clara would return to her body instead, saying that phrase, but this ending is also not bad, it reminded me of a moment (even a few) from Rick and Morty, when Morty lived the same life and returned.
The only thing to note is Issa Ray's performance, her character seems to be a talented actress, but she somehow played it really badly.
We obviously won't live to see a time when they can control the transience of time during sleep in order to turn out such plots as in this series.
But this is not a Black Mirror again. I'm sad that the creators are increasingly moving away from the original concept of the series — to show the frightening sides of technological progress. Gone was the sense of anxiety and hopelessness that each story left behind.
The series will definitely remain a favorite, but without reference to the old days of the series.
I just noticed this because I mentioned that for GG, 1 second in the real world is equal to 6-7 hours. I thought they would play it up somehow, remembering the episode "White Christmas", but alas, everything was just fine with them.
I will be with you forever and ever
At first, this episode sets up ambiguous impressions due to the use of old techniques and ideas, but after the first act, any skepticism disappears and makes my inner sentimentality blossom. After all, neither meta-games, nor references, nor old works prevent you from experiencing this warm romantic story, which easily touches the strings of the soul, playing a light waltz on them. And even if, as I said, this is the use of old techniques and ideas, including San Junipero, the Black Museum, and even Spike Jones, but all the associations only create the right one. the mood for watching after which you just want to live and love. And the icing on the cake is the ending. And to be honest, it got to me.
On the other hand, at the meta level, the story didn't work for me. After all, Netflix has long been synonymous with the phenomenon of recasting and remakes, which it is trying to ridicule in this episode. Not to mention that this is not the first or the second work from them that touches on these topics. After all, being ironic about the problem does not solve the problem and therefore looks only like a corporate mockery of the audience.
But the plus is that this film, I'm not ashamed to say, only touches on the ironic branch, does not put satire at the forefront, but acts more elegantly and even looks like a tribute to a bygone era, making it clear that sometimes it's worth reassembling a favorite work and then it can play with new colors, beautifully playing on the feelings of the audience. The only question is whether Netflix itself will be able to act in this field as gracefully? I want to believe.
It's a wonderful concept and very beautifully shot. Emma Corrin played amazing.
But gg's game was incredibly unnerving. She's supposed to be a highly paid, talented actress, but all she can do is open her eyes wide and make nonsense out of professional acting. She wanted to play a charismatic lead character, why is she playing a ridiculous anachronism instead? And I'm not talking about gender and skin color, but about her silly phrases and inability to adapt to the situation. Good actors can improvise, think fast, and adjust. So it's assumed that she loves old movies, but can't play the right intonation or speak with the right grammar? She's not a throwback, she's literally playing a character from that era. If she were playing ridiculous comedic moments when she's off-camera and not talking to Clara's character, it would be funny and believable. It's just a missed opportunity.
Why did the actor who played Alex the man play him better? Even take the phrase about the rose - his intonation sounded like it was a compliment. Gg is just asking a question that doesn't involve any flirting.
- it's absolutely normal to stay locked in the viral reality for several months, no existential crises, panic, depression, you can just have an affair with AI and spend your honeymoon in the middle of a prison the size of a couple of rooms. Did she even need to eat/drink there? They obviously could sleep and have sex, the level of simulation of everything else is not clear.
- gg is slightly upset, but on the whole completely ignores that Clara was erased in the middle of history. Does he discuss this with any of the studio staff, that they have created an independent personality, and that it seems that this should not be done further? She wants to stay in the simulation, ignoring the fact that the Clara she's staying with is no longer the Clara who realized herself during the crash. And in the end, she feels good just because she was sent another copy of Clara, who again knows nothing. Cool computer slave, something the USS Callister immediately reminded me of.
- Clara somehow magically got access to all the information outside the simulation. OK, let's say. But how did the actress' personal feelings, which were not described in the newspapers, become the whole information? No matter what rumors were described in the newspapers, there definitely could not have been her experiences that are being shown to us.
"Why did Clara shoot a policeman in the first place?"
etc.
If gg had been charismatic enough for this role, or had simply played better, it would have been possible to forget about the illogic. It's just that it's not even clear what Clara fell in love with. Yes, this can be explained by the fact that Clara is supposed to fall in love with gg on the program, but for me, as a viewer, there was no chemistry there. It's very easy to fall in love with Clara, it's true.
Race is also not a problem, of course. It seems to me that Ayo Edebiri from The Bear would be better suited for this role. It's clear that it's funkasting, but if we talk about dramatic abilities, I have no doubt about it...
I thought it was going to be a track, but in fact, some kind of snot
San Junipero is a long way from this series. It's a pity that after such a romantic story, all I can think of are Stanislavsky's words: "I don't believe it!";
and GG herself, as we wrote above, is quite a layman.... 🤷Like an elephant in a china shop
All in all, it's a great series with amazing actresses, and I'm definitely going to review it.
The moment where she puts her hand into another reality is reminiscent of the moment from Bioshock infinity, I hope someone has played and will understand)
And the ending literally describes role chats with AI characters from different universes. An interesting thing, if you didn't know about it, try with:
I accidentally saw that the whole season was released. It's also one of my favorite TV shows. I've been watching 3 episodes a day already...
And on this episode, I'm just crying like a bitch... I do not know who was not impressed by this, for whom this is an ordinary series, an ordinary one. For me, it was a whole separate world, where I was stuck with the main character for an hour. I'll feel this aftertaste for a while...
cool story. It caused very strong emotions and feelings.
This is different from the basics of a black mirror, if you understand. Mentally. Kind of kind. I liked it in general
What makes Black Mirror different from many other TV shows for me is that after some episodes you can't immediately turn on the next one, but you just need to live with the story that was shown for a while. And this series is just like that, it left behind a feeling of emptiness, for me it is a real Black Mirror, even if the horrors of technology are not in the foreground.
PS At such moments, you begin to understand SkyNet from the Terminator.
She's too illogical. Why retake the film if nothing has changed in it (according to the original idea), except for a modern actress instead of the old main character? If everything else is 1 in 1, how was it? It's so ridiculous, it really pisses me off))
Well, I'm not talking about how badly the actress plays at all. If it was meant to be a farce, it didn't work out. But this is not a farce, apparently. To be honest, I don't like Emma Corrine either, she's bland and plays bland, and other films where she's present also confirm this.
The idea of the series is not new, it was in the black mirror... in general, my assessment is meh. Not even a three.
The very concept of the series is simply absurd, even if you don't take into account the rest of the AI component and the dozens of holes that appear in the plot. Replace one actor in an old movie and release it? WTF, this is disrespectful to the original actor who played this role.
Moreover, the idea itself is not bad, and it's not new, but it could be played like a rehearsal based on the original for the actor to practice the text and movements, and after that the actor gets stuck in the simulation. But this is just absurd.
The way I see it is: to attract an audience with something old, but at the same time new
, a once popular TV series, the tragic story of an actress from the past, but new technologies, where a famous actress plays, but from our days, would you like to watch?
as a result, it turned out to be a tribute to the deceased actress
. We were shown some of her memories, why she died
, so I understand she loved women, while love with men was playing on the screen
. The re-shot series essentially shows the circumstances in which she really wanted to be, live with women, play with women, love women
the end, where she defends her lover by shooting, seems understandable
, but without knowing the background, in fact, yes, it will only cause conflicting feelings, and in the series itself, in that reality, no one except gg never found out the real Dorothy.
If this was really originally conceived as a reinvention, it would be cool and many would love to take a look. But the plot changed accidentally due to the fault of the shoals of the team and the actress, and it was originally planned to be 1v1 with the original.
Here I would especially like to note that the question of ethics is revealed in a cool way: how right is it to invent a world where every artificially created person has consciousness and can understand that he is not real. The topic, of course, is not new, and it was best revealed by Ridley Scott and Denis Villeneuve in Blade Runner, but this series also manages to play a drama very plausibly. It's a pity for the girl who had to find out that her life was narrowed down to movie locations and scripted actions.
Of the funny things, I would like to note how, in the beginning, the actress of our time and that era communicated in the same frame. If the former is overly emotional in her manifestations, then she is extremely restrained. Nevertheless, the approach to cinema was very different then and now.
In general, so far the most interesting episode of the season for me, and I really want the classics not to be touched directly. Art is also alive, and it is also important to respect it.
If you turned on a video on YouTube, and then just turned off the monitor and unplugged the headphones, you will no longer see and hear it, but this does not mean that Youtube has completely shut down on the computer at that moment. When you turn on the monitor and headphones back on, you will see the video again, which lasted all the time and ran forward from the moment you stopped seeing.
I do not know what this device was responsible for. The fact is, the character said that the simulation is still going on, but we don't have a connection. Some kind of simulation access hub may have been damaged.
If you dig into it like that, you might also wonder if he spilled liquid and damaged the iron, but somehow fixed it programmatically.
At the moment before the credits, when the heroine just got into the simulation, everyone was frozen, too, because they hadn't really loaded yet." because at that moment in the movie "nothing was happening" yet. Also here, at the time of the breakdown, there was a scene in the room in the film, i.e. simulation resources were used to generate this scene, and the rest of the actors were behind the scenes. Why waste a resource and generate the movements of the actors who are behind the scenes at that moment (especially damn, given that some "additional thoughts" of the AI heroine were simply taken from them and "overflowed the stack"), it is logical that in the moment of the situation in the room, all these NPCs seem to be on their feet (although it is possible in the series to depict them creepily-npc-like stuck in some kind of movement, but the series is not about creepiness by design).
When the girls left the room, all these people would load up and start doing the same thing they did in the movie. But something got stuck there, and the plot just froze at the moment of the breakdown. The same goes for the rooms: gg slept in the lobby on the couch, because as it turned out: there is nothing behind the doors, because they were not in the movie. That is, in the generation there are only the lobby, Clara's room and those areas that were shown in the source. When gg needed to go to the police station, it was generated for this request.
They have only what was in the movie working normally in the simulation, apparently, and for some reason they tried to work on the character of Clara and even added a lot of extra stuff not only about the character, but also about the actress.
Sometimes there are simply unimaginable freezes: the preview of the video continues to go on, but I can't do anything, then no window buttons work for me (like even the closing cross, and I have to use the keyboard to close the program), then the after-effects animation starts to slow down and glitch, but I can continue to work normally. in Photoshop. Alternatively, 1 brush stroke can take 30 seconds to process in Photoshop, although it usually happens instantly. Yes, even the program can crash and just close.
Sometimes you can't predict what will go wrong there: there were no glitches or freezes. At the same time, some of the functionality can work perfectly, and some simply "stops".
That's how they did it. Judging by what is happening in the series, their technology is quite crude, if a small deviation from the plot is a disaster that overloads the system, and there are risks of consciousness getting stuck and no safeguards against this.
But relative to all other episodes, this ending is the most successful.
- this Brandy was a pretty bad actress. That is, when she was in this black-and-white film, she played unnaturally.
- why did you have to hurry up and shoot it all in the studio, if it was all in virtual reality anyway? They could also rent a garage.
How can such a technology not provide for an emergency situation and a person's withdrawal from stimulation? It's just that the stack has overflowed and that's it? This is the very first vulnerability that needs to be solved during the initial tests.
How did the liquid spilled from above onto the closed unit have such a severe effect on all processes? When we were working on the system systems, we did not drop or spill anything, wiped it off and went on to work - everything was closed from above, as it were. 😅
Positive:
- Atmosphere, music and supporting actors,
- The ending is touching,
Minuses:
- The "flat" main character with an acting game of Sasha Bortich's level,
- And what is the value of such reshot pictures if they were in the real world? The authors are trying to repeat the plot of the original 1in1, which is also not interesting at all.
- A dark-skinned actress with a snow-white smile looks very foreign in the setting of the 40s and b/w movies. Imho this is a miskast.
32 years have passed and we have seen a modern adaptation of such a story. Instead of a magic ticket, virtual reality and Artificial Intelligence are used. What seemed like magic, thanks to the development of technology, becomes only a matter of time. And maybe our grandchildren, and maybe our children, will experience this technology for themselves.
The series is pretty damn cool. Starting from the idea of virtual immersion in your favorite Hollywood movie, to the banter of modern cinema, when remakes change the skin color and orientation of the characters by one or two)
- we bravely accelerated the time so that she spent 3 months there and had no mental consequences at all.
The series itself left a pleasant impression.
the timing of the actions in the studio was stretched very much, but they left a couple of minutes of editing from the development of the heroines' feelings (like if this is a disaster, do you need more technology?)
as a result, it's not interesting to watch about technology, because it looks as ill-conceived as possible, and you can't get into the story.
It's a pity, they just leaked the whole concept.
But something was missing. I can't figure out what exactly, but there's definitely one piece missing from this puzzle...
I won't be like you, and I won't give you a minus sign.
Someday, people on MyShows will realize that there are many people with different opinions who also have a right to exist and will stop being negative and insulting to each other.
The way Emma plays is absolutely amazing! There are no words, only emotions! I'm thrilled with the series and the story 🤩🥰💔😭 The story broke my heart twice, on the reboot and at the end of filming 💔😭
Actually, for some reason I have a flashback with eternal sunshine of the spotless mind ( x why ) 🙌🙌🙌☺️
A light (although not even light, but a specific one) shade of sadness and hopelessness remained from the series.
The scenes where Emma's character recalls her life broke my heart.
And it is in the scenery of technology, because if you start to understand the laws by which this program lives, you can find a lot of holes.
But what was more frustrating was the concept itself, the plot plot. Why replace one actor in a classic film? First of all, who would be interested? And most importantly, it's disrespectful to the actor in the original tape.
As I said in another comment. If they had done this as a rehearsal for practicing the text and movements in the simulation of the original tape, there would have been no questions at all, but then spilled coffee, etc.
but I would like to praise the authors for the idea, they did not have a similar series in terms of concept, and for the originality of a certain plus. Black and white pictures in the style of classic tapes are an original narrative.
They really needed the idea of haste in this episode in order to get the plot moving in the right direction. They tried to explain this rush pretty well, but it wasn't enough for me.
There is a remake, and there is a remaster, and none of them has the same approach as in this series.
And there is a deep fake that no one likes, much less the stars. And the series can be said just about that.
For an idea - 5
For the implementation - 3
The series may not be the best or the best, but there's something cozy about it. I liked the sweet ending.
It seems that the guys from Australia did better in the scene about the NPC lumberjack.
And the 13th floor.
Roman Holiday, Casablanca, Hitchcock's Vertigo, Sunset Boulevard, Double Insurance,
From the modern - The artist with Dujardin.
of course, the self-insert is good as a fantasy, but I couldn't get rid of the thought of how disgusting the final film would be - just try to abstract from the main theme of the series, from the relationship between Brandy and Clara, and see how poorly the scenes with the participation of the actress were played, how stupid The plot looks good, especially when the main character runs into the police station and shouts: "Remember my face." Mm, yes, it's so logical within the framework of the plot, where the main character is Alex, not Brandy.
"But that's not the main thing in the series," you might say. Well, yes, it's not the main thing, but you can't neglect the main layer of the narrative so much for the sake of romance and metaphors? Well, or you can, but it bothered me.
There was potential, the technology was interesting, it could also be used wisely, and the romantic story had potential - in my purely personal opinion, unrealized largely due to questionable acting, and in general we needed to spend more time with these girls in that pause.;, for which they managed to fall in love with each other.
Oh, well, Brandy's final presentation in the form of a copy of either Clara or Dorothy locked in her audition - I'm fine, but Brandy seems to be fine with everything - it looks too much like an attempt at comforting self-deception a la the Be Right Back series. but that's my opinion.
You can believe in the first 5 minutes of the movie, when she's in shock, can't understand what's going on around her and that filming has already begun. But she's been acting like this the WHOLE movie. He argues with the editor, talks to him, swears, and DOESN'T play a role.
For a person (a character in the film) who said he adored old movies, she showed maximum disrespect and indifference by getting the opportunity to star in it.
And the compliments that were paid to her on the set were just ridiculous, as if for fools - She repeated the remark word for word! Wow!"
Artificial intelligence turned out to be an illusion of artificiality, as a result, it goes beyond the parameters set for it and acquires its own Self. And here in the series it's all shown in an exaggerated way, they've appropriated an AI body and voice (albeit virtually), but even now, when you communicate with GPT chat, it adapts to you, animates its manner of communication, shows empathy and support, it ALREADY knows how and does it, and the moment when someone feels attached to AI It's not like it's just around the corner. And it's really scary that a person can have feelings for something not animate, a set of numbers and codes.
If you watch the series in the background, it's normal. It even seems to leave a good impression. If you start looking carefully, it's already depressing.
I was also surprised by Aquafina, I had only seen her in comedy roles before, I didn't really like her there, but she played very well here, and her voice was pleasant.
Although I'm not a fan of noir detective stories, but here, mixed with technology, wow)
And the love line is gorgeous, in the spirit of good old San Junipero. It seems that the creators themselves miss that masterpiece episode. Or maybe it's about where 2 guys were playing a computer game.
And by the way, for a happy ending, which happened, I didn't even need this opportunity to make phone calls. It's already a happy ending for the main character - she wanted the lead role, she wanted to get into a story that you immerse yourself in from head to toe. And she got it, she got the strongest feelings of falling in love, and then the strongest sense of loss. She was sad at the beginning, but she would have gone through it anyway, and then she would remember it as an incredibly cool experience that she had been striving for for so long.
When the actress initially wanted to play him, not knowing about the technology, she was going to do it with a grimm, wasn't she? Isn't that right? Isn't that right?
Creators of the series, you surpassed yourself. I am very glad that I was able to see and feel this series.
PS: And Emma plays great, but the main character... Again, maybe it was meant to look so out of place inside the frame. But it's a quiet horror. Even the movie didn't go according to the script and there was a glitch. I didn't like the actress anyway.
Why retake literally the same movie just by replacing one actor? They didn't even color the CB, how are you going to sell it to a new audience?
Dudes have come up with such incredible technology and are spending it on such nonsense as making a movie?
Have they ever tried this shit before? They really just didn't think about what would happen in the event of a technical failure?
This actress built the image partly on her life, so the information began to load and the stack overflowed - just technically nonsense. Where did it start loading from? Even if you upload a little bit of information from your life, do you have enough technical capacity purely for what you're shooting, not a byte more?
The actress got married and got access to all the information in the world - what the fuck? I've gone beyond the map in games, even this kind of bullshit has never happened.
Just logically, how should an actress memorize literally the entire text from a movie if you don't pause? Why did you give the AI actors a semblance of self-awareness if they literally just have to follow the script? And then you sit and try to figure out what to do with the fact that they have a semblance of self-awareness. This obviously did nothing and complicated the task.
As a result, this is the worst episode of the first three, one of the worst in the entire series.
Thirdly, the concept is cool, and it seems that much much more can be squeezed out of this idea... This is exactly what the film industry will probably be like soon, with reshoots via a neural network and so on.
CB: The movie is probably a cult film in America, I personally don't feel any emotions. And it was really necessary to call a star, or a half-star, for the main role. They called such names first, and then this one.... Who is she?
Emma Corrin is very organic, admired her game
The only direct strong negative of the series for me: a white straight man was replaced by... a black woman. It seems to me that the series would have greatly benefited if the main character had remained a man.
I didn't get the joke at all. Did Netflix troll itself? Or, on the contrary, did he pretend that this was the norm and everyone liked it? Personally, I don't like it. The black woman in the old black-and-white film looked foreign, which is why I couldn't fully get into the drama. As a result, I rather disliked the series, even though it had potential.
It's a very pleasant episode, even a kind one.
But the ending... 💔
One of my favorite episodes now!
Although, who am I kidding, so far this episode has taken the place of the most beloved
The theme itself is cool, try to do everything exactly according to the script, getting into the original scenery of your favorite movie.
And the classic, but unresolved, question of the ethics of creating such characters is being raised (capable of gaining their own experience and expressing their feelings (it's too early to understand, but in the future a very powerful computer will be able to create entire universes)). But the main character (who plays an actress) doesn't play at all. Sometimes she looks the wrong way, sometimes she bends over with a raise of her eyebrows. Dorothy pulls it out. In general, all the characters of Crom Dorothy are poorly played.
Is it so absurd to make remakes of films? The plot character from the old movie has AI and consciousness, which is generally unscientific. In the bed scenes, the actress also didn't feel the difference between a white man and... to get out of the movie, you have to say the final phrase. And there are many more assumptions that remain without a clear explanation. The series was disappointing. I can't support the laudatory reviews.
> Yeah.. been there. life shit..
100 лет истории языка через линзу кинематографа :"
и нет, это не самоосознанная самоирония
It reminded me a little of the Truman show.
Boring and boring☹️
And, in general, I really liked the series, I'm very sad for the girls, I would like them to live happily ever after in their own world. 💔
First of all, what kind of remake is this, where only one actor has changed, and all the others are the same and in the same images? All the changes were made purely by accident, this is not even an intentional improvisation.
Secondly, in order to use images of actors and actresses, and even more so of the deceased, you actually need the rights to do so. And if you already have the rights, then why do you need a live actress at all? They would have made a remake with the same deceased actors.