Here's a new episode that confirmed Becky's orientation, even though it was already obvious. I hope she escapes Gilead successfully. There is a feeling that Hulda may have cheated on the fact that she started menstruating, or the second one will do it, but these are just sensations…
Garth was promoted to Commander. At that moment, the news took my breath away from me, I can't even imagine what kind of emotions Hannah had at that moment. Well... Hannah, girl, good luck with your husband! 🤞🏻
In general, it's interesting how they determine that it's time to do prom, why they don't wait until all the girls have their periods. Like, have you started, is everything enough already? And then they wait for the next group to arrive?
@MOPE_AHAHACOB: and where did the wives of this pension fund go? usually, on the contrary, men die, women stay)) So many commanders don't have wives, and by the way, it's strange that Gilead doesn't take care of children's health and doesn't drown boys + girls for normal marriages.
@torture: if Gilead had done everything right, it would have been a utopia, not a dystopia) I think the very fact of fertility is important to them, men can produce offspring for a long time. Of course, the fact that their health is not checked and they can drink alcohol in general, but God forbid a drop falls into the mouth of the girls, says a lot about this "state", and their wives, by the way, could have been hanged/exiled for "arousing the guard" or something like that, remove it because I haven't been pregnant for a long time, in short, there are many options…
@torture: In the original series, the girls were chosen and they became mothers with existing wives. Here, too, the families of pensioners were not shown, and the problem of their world is the general infertility, which is why there are no wives, but they are looking for young, docile, healthy girls.
What an abomination to marry girls to old men ! And where are the young boys, and what is the way of the boys in Gilead?
It seems to me that Agnes's mate will be found sooner than it becomes possible with Garth, especially since she came across a figurine in the last episode, they will probably try to give it away as quickly as possible.
Was there a hint that Aunt Lydia should be cleaned up?!
@lady_kana: In the series itself, this was explained - these girls are from the most prestigious houses, so they are wooed by high-ranking commanders (who are mostly elderly). Young commanders of low ranks are apparently given less prestigious girls.
@MOPE_AHAHACOB: well, the actress aunt Lydia is already 70, it's probably hard to act ((So, probably, there would have been a central character further, she would not have burned like a child)
I can't get tired of saying how much I like Garth and Agnes! how convenient that he will change his position soon)) 0)
I wonder if he has any feelings for her? still, outwardly they fit well, but internally they are on different sides of the barricades.
Perhaps he will be able to guide her towards understanding what is really going on and eventually reveal who her mother is and that her parents are alive.
once again, the understanding is that the children of the maids are not privileged at all, the same hostages of the position are just starting their monthly periods, they should be married to the elderly 2-3 times older so that the "wives" are obedient and give birth to children
@MargoRose: I don't really understand, how long has it been in the movies that there are love lines between an adult guy and a 13-14-year-old girl? At the same time, I understand what the series is about. But against the background of "adult commanders-girls," the romanticization of "younger men-girls" looks like
@bvvvvvvvvvvv: Well, it's a pretty common story about girl commanders. Remember the painting "Unequal Marriage" by Pukirev, hanging in the Tretyakov Gallery. Considering that Gilead is shifting such plots into modern times, it is more than enough. Farts want young blood) it's clear
As for an adult guy + 13-14, he is most likely 20 years old, and by Gilead standards this is just normal, and in reality this often happens. Only girls are closer to 15-16, and the latter usually hang themselves and actively seek out non-peers.
@torture: in life, it was different, it happens and it will be. my comment is about the fact that I am very confused that the 13-20 relationship is presented as a good alternative to the 13-50 relationship, and also confused that some viewers openly ship and seem to support such a relationship.
I'm encouraged by Garth's attitude towards Daisy. She says you have to earn more so that we can mess with you and get you out of there. On the one hand, war and rebellion are dirty business, you have to use any means, and Daisy is a good spy, it's a pity to lose her, especially since she is so close to important people. But it still pisses me off, I could at least try to explain it like that, otherwise she'll decide that no one cares about her there, and she'll mess up more
Some kind of totalitarian Bridgerton on minimals. It would seem that the first ball, beautiful young ladies, dancing, and such a feeling of disgust and hopelessness after contemplating all this
Damn, I know the girls are young and they don't teach anatomy and biology, but where are the adults going? the desire to get young meat overshadows everything, apparently, including the fact that it is impossible for such young girls to give birth, they are still growing and developing, they have just started menstruating, what kind of husbands and childbirth they have! it's just some kind of idiocy to declare "everything for the sake of children" and in fact force yesterday's children to give birth, raping them in every sense and getting weakened offspring and a broken body that could have given birth to much more without such a rush.
@violetq_: According to the book, Agnes (Hannah) is over 20 years old (like 22-23), and Daisy (Nicole) is just 15 years old. They have a difference of 8 years, Agnes (Hannah) was already about 3-4 years old when she was taken away from her parents (June and Luke) And Daisy (Nicole) was born in Gilead to June and Nick about 8 years later.
And, as I understand it, they don't have their periods like everyone else in the ordinary world at 11-12, but they all have different ones, up to the age of more than 20 years. Because infertility and all the usual laws of the female body don't work all over the world.
According to the series, of course, they all look the same age + I found an article that Daisy is not Nicole in the series ("Franchise creator Bruce Miller confirmed that Daisy from the series is not Nicole."), although in the book Daisy = Nicole. And in the series Daisy and June are very similar + the words from June herself that Daisy's dead parents are not her relatives. Strange, of course
I wonder how they'll do it in the series, based on the book or not.
@violetq_: many people already have no spermatozoa left, or as it is correctly called, that is, in fact, it is one continuous violence and no children in the end, sick freaks
@Ittanni: that's it! What's the point of marrying girls to old men if they're already infertile. The maids won't help either. Therefore, the red line here is not "everything for the sake of children," but "everything for the pleasure of men."
@Aggie: well, by the way, yes, considering that Gilead allegedly drowns for children, it was necessary to initially include an annual medical checkup with men, right at the Legislative level) right from the 1st day. Lawrence wasn't about pleasure, he seemed like a normal guy. But probably in reality, the top of Galada would have taken a bite and wrapped up this bill.
@Znata: and it seems that Serena also said that Fred is infertile, but in Gilead, no one would think that a man is to blame, they are well done by default.
@torture: so it's across the batka: according to the official interpretation of the regime, "infertile men do not exist, there are only infertile women." This is enshrined in Gilead law.
@miralisssa: In fact, they organized a coup d'etat in order to have girls in slavery on the basis of state ideology, to rape them, to get high from the fact that they are their masters, and they cannot contradict them. Wet fantasies of many men in reality. God willing, they will remain fantasies.
These girls are the first wave of children born in the last world, taken from the same as June and given to childless families of commanders. The children of the maidservants born in Gilead are already the next tingle, who will be passed off as an aged conditional Nickname. That's how I see it.
No wonder there are problems with childbirth, young girls are wooed for old men, and all their sperm cells have already died. 🥴
The men on the balcony at this prom are filled with arrogance. Does each of them really want to marry a submissive doll brought up by the cruel rules of society🙈
Well, how Agnes recoiled from her father when she only glanced at the dentist. Grandpa got Becca drunk, it's disgusting. And her confession in the ladies' room is very sad. Sulamith is a kitten who rushes into a cruel world - I want triplets, because for this they will buy a merce and a necklace) And where are you going with this merce, I want to ask? You can't even see the fucking Jaws. Ugh, three times. This series awakens the darkest part of me.🙈
@karinabuzia: They all want a woman to match the image in her head, and not be a real person. And when girls are raised instilling that they are not supposed to have a personality, all that remains is to conform to the image dictated by the hubby.
On the one hand, it's a beautiful world with dancing and cakes, and on the other, it's disgusting because they sell girls like puppies. Whoever is cuter will be taken into the house. I'm not talking about the age difference at all! But the scariest thing is that they are brought up in such a way that they themselves want to be the wives of these people and even "fight" with each other for a place...
And Shumanit turned out to be not a rat, but a normal girl, like she punched a snitch in the face) I'm just afraid to imagine what kind of folk tincture with mushrooms it is, which provoked menstruation on the same day, no matter how it turned out to be just bleeding 🙈
I don't understand the rules of this world a bit. So there are no more maids? Or are they just not shown to us here because the story is not about them? And what will happen to purple girls who don't have periods? Before that, wives were infertile, will they be able to become wives too, or will they become aunts? And where are the wives of all these old commanders? Why did they come to woo, are they all widowers or what, or how does it work?
@ElllaDee: On the second episode, I was wondering the same thing about maids, I went to read, there are maids, although they are smaller, but they function and exist in exactly the same way
@abullycanreally: I also have a problem. Where do they get new souzhanok? Those who were forcibly driven to Gilead have already reached childbearing age, and the children who were given to Commander families are given to commanders as wives, regardless of whether they are fertile or not.
@Znata: The maid caste was originally created as a temporary measure - many new children would be born, new girls were planned to be raised according to new laws (actually, as in the "testaments"), and there would be no need for maids. therefore, if they remained at the beginning of this series, then very few.
@Znata: Not everyone came out: Gilead is only 10 years old, the youngest maids are now 28-30. Do you also remember the episode where June hid a black houseman? His wife also told June off so arrogantly, saying how can you give up your child. It's like she did it voluntarily. So, the man was hanged, the boy was given up for adoption, and the wife was made a servant. And also that young wife of the elderly commander on the farm, she was also made a servant as punishment. Therefore, under any far-fetched pretext, a woman can be made a servant, and her child can be taken away. And if at first women who gave birth were offered a choice: to become a maid or go to labor camps, now they hardly give a choice, as it seems to me.
@_Mia_Wallace_: Tell us (those who have read) and the books explain why the same women who can give birth, on the contrary, were not exalted? After all, as if it were possible to make the same Gilead, only instead of handmaidens, there are privileged holy women from whom dust motes are blown away. In addition, it is more convenient when all the children born remain in the same family and at least no accidental incest occurs further for the benefit of the same healthy demographic.
@bvvvvvvvvvvv: as far as I remember, there is no such explanation. But it is not customary to exalt women in Gilead, they are illiterate servants or accessories.
@Znata: Come on, the pearls are coming to them. Maids are probably also obtained from visitors. Maybe there are some illegal supplies from other countries. It's just not on the same scale now as before, but now there are probably more fertile wives. Well, I'm not insisting, I'm just thinking out loud)
@llllllllllex: those who, in their opinion, are sinners, were made servants. I've been married for the second time, for example, had an abortion in the past, or something like that. Plus, there were already families of commanders who were infertile, and apparently they wanted their own children. So we found this loophole from the Bible.
At one point, I even respected Aunt Lydia when she scolded the commander and asked him to keep an eye on his freaks so that they wouldn't get the girls drunk. In general, you look at all this, at all these dances, glances, you understand where everything is going and what can await them, becoming the wives of commanders, and such horror runs up. It's scary to look at all this every time. Can you remind me how they become aunts? In general, it seems to me that they have the most relaxed position, not counting the commanders. The rest are under constant surveillance. The wrong look, the wrong word, and you're fucked. Shu is a beauty. It's high time to punch this chocolate bar
@kot_nastya: What if she's already frail, walks with a stick, or can't get up at all? They'd rather find a young one in her place. It says so on the fandom website
@galerians: The aunts who were at the beginning of Gilead are unmarried former lawyers, teachers, judges, etc. And for those girls who already want to become an aunt during Gilead, you need to:
go through an interview with all four founding aunts and convince them that your vocation is really to be an aunt.
complete a probation period of half a year, show your worth (clean, wash dishes, etc.). You are already allowed to start writing and reading
Access to the library opens. You need to complete the training, which lasts 9 years.
As a pearl maiden, you need to go outside Gilead, recruit other girls there, and then return with your "pearls" back. That's all, the way is over. You're an aunt now :)
@Znata: Yeah, right off the bat, "how do you plan to fulfill your marital duty," not "how do you plan to love your husband and how do you see your family")) such a question is of course stupid)) what should she say? I wonder)
I have a question here. Where do so many old bachelors come from? They can't all be widowers. Initially, the commanders in Gilead were family men, as far as I understand. Either they have harems of young concubines there, or they banish their wives of the same age somewhere far away.
A handsome security guard driver who is being promoted to commander - we've already seen this somewhere) Agnes repeats June's story, except for her status, of course.
It is very interesting how the boys who are born in Gilead grow up. It's clear about the girls both here and in the "maid", but not a word about the boys...(
myshows.me is an informational TV & movie catalog and watch-tracking service. We do not host, store, stream, or distribute any video content, and we do not provide download links. All information is reference material only.
Discussion: Season 1, Episode 5 Join the Discussion
88There is a feeling that Hulda may have cheated on the fact that she started menstruating, or the second one will do it, but these are just sensations…
Garth was promoted to Commander. At that moment, the news took my breath away from me, I can't even imagine what kind of emotions Hannah had at that moment. Well... Hannah, girl, good luck with your husband! 🤞🏻
I shuddered from the moment in the hall, where first the men danced, and then the pension fund went out to the girls.
What an abomination to marry girls to old men ! And where are the young boys, and what is the way of the boys in Gilead?
It seems to me that Agnes's mate will be found sooner than it becomes possible with Garth, especially since she came across a figurine in the last episode, they will probably try to give it away as quickly as possible.
Was there a hint that Aunt Lydia should be cleaned up?!
Young commanders of low ranks are apparently given less prestigious girls.
how convenient that he will change his position soon)) 0)
I wonder if he has any feelings for her? still, outwardly they fit well, but internally they are on different sides of the barricades.
Perhaps he will be able to guide her towards understanding what is really going on
and eventually reveal who her mother is and that her parents are alive.
once again, the understanding is that the children of the maids are not privileged at all, the same hostages of the position
are just starting their monthly periods, they should be married to the elderly 2-3 times older so that the "wives" are obedient and give birth to children
As for an adult guy + 13-14, he is most likely 20 years old, and by Gilead standards this is just normal, and in reality this often happens. Only girls are closer to 15-16, and the latter usually hang themselves and actively seek out non-peers.
sometimes seems like it's hyperbole about our society and women in it being perceived as a commodity:(
They have a difference of 8 years, Agnes (Hannah) was already about 3-4 years old when she was taken away from her parents (June and Luke)
And Daisy (Nicole) was born in Gilead to June and Nick about 8 years later.
And, as I understand it, they don't have their periods like everyone else in the ordinary world at 11-12, but they all have different ones, up to the age of more than 20 years.
Because infertility and all the usual laws of the female body don't work all over the world.
According to the series, of course, they all look the same age + I found an article that Daisy is not Nicole in the series ("Franchise creator Bruce Miller confirmed that Daisy from the series is not Nicole."), although in the book Daisy = Nicole.
And in the series Daisy and June are very similar + the words from June herself that Daisy's dead parents are not her relatives.
Strange, of course
I wonder how they'll do it in the series, based on the book or not.
Blaspheme women for their inability to give birth to infertile children? YES
The men on the balcony at this prom are filled with arrogance.
Does each of them really want to marry a submissive doll brought up by the cruel rules of society🙈
Well, how Agnes recoiled from her father when she only glanced at the dentist.
Grandpa got Becca drunk, it's disgusting.
And her confession in the ladies' room is very sad.
Sulamith is a kitten who rushes into a cruel world - I want triplets, because for this they will buy a merce and a necklace)
And where are you going with this merce, I want to ask?
You can't even see the fucking Jaws.
Ugh, three times. This series awakens the darkest part of me.🙈
So there are no more maids? Or are they just not shown to us here because the story is not about them?
And what will happen to purple girls who don't have periods? Before that, wives were infertile, will they be able to become wives too, or will they become aunts?
And where are the wives of all these old commanders? Why did they come to woo, are they all widowers or what, or how does it work?
Do you also remember the episode where June hid a black houseman? His wife also told June off so arrogantly, saying how can you give up your child. It's like she did it voluntarily. So, the man was hanged, the boy was given up for adoption, and the wife was made a servant.
And also that young wife of the elderly commander on the farm, she was also made a servant as punishment.
Therefore, under any far-fetched pretext, a woman can be made a servant, and her child can be taken away. And if at first women who gave birth were offered a choice: to become a maid or go to labor camps, now they hardly give a choice, as it seems to me.
Well, I'm not insisting, I'm just thinking out loud)
In general, you look at all this, at all these dances, glances, you understand where everything is going and what can await them, becoming the wives of commanders, and such horror runs up. It's scary to look at all this every time.
Can you remind me how they become aunts? In general, it seems to me that they have the most relaxed position, not counting the commanders. The rest are under constant surveillance. The wrong look, the wrong word, and you're fucked.
Shu is a beauty. It's high time to punch this chocolate bar
It says so on the fandom website
@galerians: The aunts who were at the beginning of Gilead are unmarried former lawyers, teachers, judges, etc.
And for those girls who already want to become an aunt during Gilead, you need to:
That's all, the way is over. You're an aunt now :)
Agnes repeats June's story, except for her status, of course.
It's clear about the girls both here and in the "maid", but not a word about the boys...(