s03e01 — Who Are You?

24 Apr 21:32 #

U_lol

04 Jul 16:41 #

After the second season, I read the original source and honestly now, when watching it, I felt no worse than Jules)) I don't remember anything, and I'm completely confused about what's going on. 😂

04 Jul 19:13 #

@U_lol: because the whole plot of the book was redrawn.

hellena_sama

06 Jul 23:40 #

@U_lol: I'm literally reading the second book right now, where the events of this season are supposed to be shown, and I also don't understand anything, of course, they've changed it a lot.

Alexander_36

07 Jul 20:17 #

@hellena_sama: the second book is very tedious. I've mastered half of it so far.…

08 Jul 12:52 #

@buckss: yes, while some nonsense is happening, if we compare the events. It is not clear what they lead to.

08 Jul 12:57 #

@Alexander_36: it's the narrative itself, it's an interesting book, because there's a finale
, I pay a lot of attention to the thoughts of the characters, but there may be few chapters where almost nothing happens, dialogues, and then events suddenly unfold, it becomes interesting, and you're blown away by what's happening. Definitely worth it. It's a bit like separation. It's also terribly boring at first, you fall asleep, the main thing is to wait out a couple of episodes, and then you stick to the screen.

08 Jul 15:39 #

@hellena_sama: The backstory is needed in order to introduce the characters who will eventually be the main ones at the end. The backstory reveals the characters, shows their character and thinking, so that it would be clear why they would eventually make certain decisions later, but it's slow. They show individual moments, the fundamental ones from which the history of bunkers began, and you need to know them in order to understand why they were created and for what purpose. No need to wait for the action in the series, which in fact belongs to psychological fiction. This series of books, and the series itself, are not based on action, but on showing how society has been living in a confined space for centuries, and how a small spark of hope and interest can ignite the flames of rebellion.. These books are about how a bunch of people thought they could retrain people, make them compliant and manageable, but eventually realized it wasn't possible. Because there will always be someone who asks a little more than necessary))) And by the way, in the second part of the book, many answers and characteristics were given to at least one person - psychiatrist Victor))) It was the episodes with the psychiatrist that immediately answered the question of why the bunkers were created, even wrongly, in these episodes they showed the logic of thinking of the person who created the concept of bunkers and the charter. )) The main thing to remember about this moment is where is the thread at the end of the season when everyone will be asking this question)))

dedesessrdsyvfry

04 Jun 12:29 #

God forbid the storyline with amnesia will not be a flop.

07 Jul 15:56 #

@dedesessrdsyvfry: I was a little annoyed by the beginning, abruptly, I jumped over a huge layer, and the feeling that I was stupid and didn't remember anything and missed something. I wanted to look for the previous episode, but there is no such thing.
As it is, I am very happy to see the return of one of my 3 favorite TV series of the 20s.

08 Jul 12:53 #

@AlexSok18: in general, I don't understand why we couldn't continue the line immediately from season 2 of the last episode of the narrative, we stopped at an interesting place there

porco

09 Jul 02:18 #

@AlexSok18: I re-downloaded and revised 2-10, otherwise it's not clear at all)

kinetesa

13 Jun 19:03 #

the episode aired 03.07.2026

Гринч33

03 Jul 08:48 #

If anyone is interested, the original language has already been leaked.

alex_mkrv

03 Jul 10:07 #

The start is pretty good. If only we could stay at this level.

arctictern

03 Jul 11:23 #

This is a powerful start to the season!

Гринч33

03 Jul 12:13 #

The beginning of the season is intriguing. I don't read the original source on purpose, so as not to spoil the impression.

04 Jul 19:17 #

@Гринч33: you're lucky) Now I can't stand to watch :(

05 Jul 00:04 #

@Гринч33: I read everything after the first season) I couldn't stand it, but there was no amnesia or many of the events of the first episode in the book at all, so it's doubly interesting!

Paramelion

03 Jul 13:27 #

People who write about a powerful beginning, are you serious?)))
For most of the series, they remind you who's who.
The line of modernity is really interesting.
Nothing is really clear about the Shelter yet.

Don't you wonder how someone who doesn't remember anything could be appointed MAYOR?!
I'm more than sure, in any society, she would have said something like "you're a heroine, while you recover, and as soon as you remember everything, we'll make you mayor."

Ov3rfl0w

03 Jul 20:42 #

@Paramelion: So she's the most convenient candidate, she doesn't remember anything, she was fed fake memories, and she has the support of the people.

Социофоб

05 Jul 13:41 #

@Ov3rfl0w: there is a puppet (when it is controlled COVERTLY) and here is a variant of the English monarchy where other people actually rule. And the question is are people really idiots? Did they demolish the old government so that the old government (actually the successor of the old mayor) could openly rule them, but gave them the mayor of the "English monarch"?

Ov3rfl0w

05 Jul 14:28 #

@Sociophobe: don't make it so complicated)) People live by the knowledge they are given and by what they manage to learn))

03 Jul 22:00 #

@Paramelion: I didn't see the power. but on the contrary, deja vu happened, that they would again tediously drag out the plot and would not really tell anything in the season.

04 Jul 19:18 #

@kladdenbuch: That's the tradition. Both of the first seasons are a splash at the beginning, then a drag and a cliffhanger at the end

Victor_Flash

07 Jul 13:40 #

@buckss: only here it's like without a splash. Now he will remember half a season.

08 Jul 12:59 #

@kladdenbuch: Yes, and there's a lot more to show and explain (I hope it won't be crumpled up and the characters won't be shallow. Donnie, Juliette, Charlotte, Thurman should be shown well, their motives

05 Jul 00:05 #

@Paramelion: so there, the husband and wife of both gray cardinals did everything cunningly. Please note, they even give her permission to talk to former friends)

id432499826

05 Jul 19:58 #

@Paramelion: you just didn't understand the previous seasons and this episode, but honestly, many of our people don't understand them!

Everyhead

05 Jul 20:03 #

@Paramelion: Damn, in the last episode of season 2, the plot gained such momentum and then a fart happened and the speed dropped to zero.

Smartcookie

03 Jul 14:43 #

Did they seriously elect a man with amnesia as mayor???

Гринч33

03 Jul 20:10 #

@Smartcookie: They seriously installed a man as mayor who is being stuffed with pills, no matter what he remembers. That he was a puppet, an appearance of the mayor.

Blew

04 Jul 10:52 #

@Smartcookie: the fact that the mayor was chosen by the most popular person in the community, who is also a part-time folk heroine, is not really surprising)) and even more so, given the fact that there was a popular uprising, it is even a very logical way out - to give the crowd something that will calm it down.

06 Jul 15:30 #

@Smartcookie: they actually had a president with dementia not so long ago, so there's nothing to be surprised about)

Krlstos

03 Jul 14:58 #

It's a good start — there are quite a lot of storylines, it's a pity they will be raked out once a week.

In my opinion, it is quite logical that she, as the ideological leader who saved the shelter after the riot, was appointed mayor. They literally rebelled against the authorities and they needed to believe in something, or in this case, in someone.

The memory is jammed intentionally, which makes it convenient for the top. But its exit to the outside and, in general, resistance to the foundations are located by the lower strata. It's convenient and comfortable for everyone to have her.

He'll remember everything now, and then it'll be really interesting. The main thing is that the resistance does not come out of hiding earlier.

id432499826

05 Jul 20:06 #

@Krlstos: You didn't understand either, there is no power in this bunker, but they showed it in the end!

Krlstos

05 Jul 20:22 #

@id432499826: If a local government has been overthrown, this does not mean that the government has disappeared altogether.

I'm talking about the nominal head of the silo. After the overthrow of the previous government, people needed someone they trusted — Juliet. At the same time, we are directly shown that the silo is part of a much larger system.

id432499826

06 Jul 18:35 #

@Krlstos: you think according to our history books, where overthrows are revolutions, there is no such thing in their popular culture, they have another bogeyman, deep state, who is invisible and controls everything, the head of their vault is a hired manager, he could not cope, they removed him, put a more suitable candidate, but I do not understand with GG, she She found out and is trying to play her game, or are these just another pens of the strong and independent.

Krlstos

06 Jul 18:53 #

@id432499826: There is a feeling that you are not talking to me, because you are refuting theses that I did not express.

Juliet was convenient for everyone, both for those who staged and for those for whom they staged (the people). They'll tell you who else is up there, and what kind of memory phenomenon it is, too. These are the main questions of the season now — there are a lot of episodes ahead, we will watch)

Just for the "their" disrespecting you

08 Jul 13:05 #

@id432499826: they depend on 1, it seems to have been shown before, hinted at

porco

09 Jul 02:20 #

@id432499826: Iishechka has the same power there, it is very clearly shown

dantes_

03 Jul 16:17 #

I don't know why you like it, but the dream called "From the Outside" ended, where nothing happens, and now I'm waiting for another 9 weeks of Jules walking back and forth and restoring my memory for 1 frame, so that in episodes 9-10 she remembers everything and next season we'll find out... something. And even if she remembers earlier, the creators of the series probably thought out how to strangle us before the end of the season.

I hope I'm wrong.

llllllllllex

03 Jul 17:10 #

@dantes_: This season is kind of the final one. Correct me if I'm wrong.

klmvira1

03 Jul 17:34 #

@llllllllllex: The last one will be season 4.

llllllllllex

03 Jul 17:40 #

@klmvira1: Oh, well, I'm glad.

fb1005157

04 Jul 00:26 #

@dantes_: According to the books, there is no bunker at all in this part, only the events of our days, so we added amnesia to the series so that we could look at our favorite characters in parallel with the real plot of the book.

04 Jul 01:54 #

@fb1005157: yes, otherwise we would have watched a different series two years later, maybe we made a good turn, but we still want a book dynamic, although it is very simply written, as for the school level, but still the events there were dynamic.

04 Jul 19:33 #

@fb1005157: there are events in the bunker. You either haven't read it, or you've forgotten.

05 Jul 00:11 #

@JardimFramboesa: Well, in general, yes. The second season was torture, and Jules wasn't shown much at all. And in the third book, 1/3 of the story is assigned to her again. Therefore, it seems to me that they decided to return the vibe of the first season with secrets and not make an abrupt transition to the story of the congressman and Charlotte)

05 Jul 01:18 #

@cinemagoer: I also read the stories in the woods, in the air, in the mountain, now I want to see it all sooner, I wonder if more stories will be added to the series.

05 Jul 01:52 #

@JardimFramboesa: What kind of stories are these?

05 Jul 10:49 #

@cinemagoer: This is Hugh Howie, as well as the official stories, an addition to the books, there are interesting details about what else happened in parallel with the main plot.

08 Jul 13:07 #

@buckss: There were yes, there were few Ju

08 Jul 15:38 #

@JardimFramboesa: Oh, and where can I find it? I really want him to release a book about 40, like he promised

08 Jul 23:45 #

@LouisloveHarry: send me an email, jardimframboesa@gmail.com , I'll send it to you. They are included in collections of short stories.

09 Jul 00:04 #

@LouisloveHarry: Send me an email jardim.framboesa@gmail.com , I'll send it to you. They are included in collections of short stories.

id972349034

04 Jul 11:45 #

@dantes_: Well, if people is doing what they used to say, why don't they continue shooting in the same style and at the same pace?
"From the outside," as far as I'm concerned, it's a social media experiment in general.

05 Jul 00:09 #

@dantes_: Well, why do you watch TV shows?) I also just emerged from the "Outside", but that's also the thrill of watching and waiting to see what happens next. Come here in the comments, discuss the twists and turns with like-minded people and what you liked or not) And if you want everything at once, you need to watch these films, where everything fits into 90 minutes)

emergenevolve

05 Jul 20:52 #

@cinemagoer: Similarly, watching a TV series is a process that you immerse yourself in and enjoy, and to be honest, I don't even give a shit about the merged endings of the series, because I liked most of what was happening)

07 Jul 16:08 #

@cinemagoer: perfect comment) unfortunately, the shorty series can quickly get forgotten. And walkers, supermen, and others are legends, thanks in part to fillers and the slowness of the plot.
I love it, even though it can be boring sometimes.

Аришка17

07 Jul 23:07 #

@dantes_: I laughed a lot at the mention of "From the Outside", well, yes, it's the best thing to watch before going to bed. But the audience can feel closer to the heroine — I don't remember anything from last season either)

iken

03 Jul 16:20 #

I wonder who the Skype call was with at the end and if Sims knows what his wife is doing.

SoNa_13

03 Jul 20:34 #

@iken: It's hard to say if there's any connection to the books, but we've already been shown who she's chatting with.

Paramelion

03 Jul 22:29 #

@iken: So last season it was that all three of them (with the child) came to the secret room, and the AI said that only his wife could stay.

05 Jul 00:12 #

@Paramelion: It's not very clear if it's the AI or someone from the main bunker giving orders.

Paramelion

05 Jul 00:28 #

@cinemagoer: Well, until proven otherwise, I call AI)

08 Jul 13:09 #

@Paramelion: first

Alexander_36

07 Jul 20:19 #

@iken: With the first shelter

user_

03 Jul 16:33 #

Hooray, we waited))))
Well, how vile they were with Juliet, I wish she would send all these hypocrites and liars out. A cloud of oil? and who is this mysterious voice from the glowing remote control?? I support everyone above, it's all very interesting, if only Jules had enough episodes to uncover all the conspiracies and figure out the speaker from the remote control.

K1ngFi5h

03 Jul 20:18 #

I waited 2 years to watch Jewel regain her memory for half a season. Cool, cho

03 Jul 22:04 #

@K1ngFi5h: Yes, yes, it also broke out into hysterical laughter ahahah

04 Jul 00:34 #

@K1ngFi5h: Well, how can they introduce 1 more shelter and Congress?

06 Jul 15:34 #

@K1ngFi5h: 1,5 года)

08 Jul 13:10 #

@6o4ka: Let's hope so.. I really want Charlotte Truman, Anna and Helen to be revealed
. It's strange that Helen wasn't introduced, will she be at all? TK: When Donnie started doing this project, wasn't he already married? Where's Helen..

oja

13 Jul 10:33 #

@LouisloveHarry: and Helen is a journalist now. That's what I understood. Then, apparently, they will have an affair.

CommanderShally

03 Jul 21:06 #

As I understand it, events from about the first halves of the second and third books will be shown this season, so it's not surprising that in order to slow down the events in Jules' hideout, they staged amnesia.

it's funny that Donny was renamed Danny)

SvoyaVolna

03 Jul 21:38 #

I felt like the main character, I don't fucking remember who all these people were, or what happened last season.

05 Jul 00:13 #

@SvoyaVolna: Yes, we were also recovering our memories bit by bit in the process. 😀

06 Jul 15:35 #

@cinemagoer: Eat more vitamins

Colorian

09 Jul 21:19 #

@SvoyaVolna: ahahaha the best stone!))

rocketolov

03 Jul 21:58 #

2 good moments: on fighter jets and with soup at the end

It's like watching a promo for a season

It's clear that he has amnesia, he doesn't remember anything, but the audience remembers something, it could have been more interesting to start

03 Jul 22:03 #

in short, she's like this: I don't remember anything. that is, 2 seasons before I watched nudnya just so that she would say I don't remember anything on the third season. Well, it's slag, of course. although the idea is interesting and it would be possible to make a very interesting dynamic series exploring a new world out of all this. here are the same mines that cannot be dug beyond 60 m. like try to find out what's there, etc.

05 Jul 00:16 #

@kladdenbuch: in the book, she immediately began to act and try to help Solo, and in fact, she did 1/3 of the book while we were told how it all started and introduced 2 more main characters. Therefore, the move with amnesia, which will slow down her activities a little and allow the story to unfold, seems to me very successful)

03 Jul 22:22 #

There was nothing about memory in the book.

New2018

04 Jul 21:55 #

@LouisloveHarry: it was, apparently you forgot)) just not the main character.

05 Jul 10:40 #

@New2018: Well, Donnie and frozen, yes, I remember that

-VLDMR-

03 Jul 22:22 #

Pills for memory loss - oh, how convenient.

04 Jul 00:33 #

@-VLDMR-: Well, then Donny too)

illymental

05 Jul 10:07 #

@-VLDMR-: revisit the barrel scene

oja

13 Jul 10:36 #

@illymental: By the way, can you explain about the scenes with barrels? Somehow I didn't catch it.

smetana_sg

15 Jul 04:18 #

@oja: general amnesia

03 Jul 22:27 #

Charlotte and Jules didn't lose their memory
So far, the book has only introduced Congress, the Senate, Donnie and Charlotte
Charlotte realized from the trailer that it was her
Just like I imagined - masculine and feminine at the same time
A strong character

05 Jul 01:54 #

@LouisloveHarry: well, they invited a famous actress) I didn't imagine anyone, but the casting was great.

ZarinaPete

03 Jul 22:56 #

I spent half the episode remembering who's who. Then there was deja vu with the first season, these incomprehensible notes. Although the first season is my favorite.
I still haven't read the book, it's boring

04 Jul 00:33 #

@ZarinaPete: The book is cool, the ending is powerful

04 Jul 01:58 #

Comment has been deleted

Transmission

03 Jul 23:43 #

I take it the plane flew into a cloud of some kind of nano-stuff that decomposed everything into mold and fake honey? And then they'll probably destroy the world with this bullshit...
at first I thought Jules had inhaled a lot of shit when she smashed her spacesuit and they were giving her pills. The head of IT could have come up with some plausible story that Jules should do, they know how to do it.

04 Jul 00:09 #

@Transmission: [id145555742:bp-172009266_1417|Anna], it seems to me that the pills were injected in order to connect them with Donny later, as he would also get confused later to regain his memory and do what he had to do..

04 Jul 00:10 #

Show comment

Norax

04 Jul 01:37 #

@LouisloveHarry: but why spoiler everything? I've read it too, but a lot of people haven't...catch a spoiler complaint

g1586639

04 Jul 08:11 #

@LouisloveHarry: Thank you, short and clear! I didn't want to read the books, because there are probably already a lot of inconsistencies with the series. But it's been interesting to find out the ending for a long time.

04 Jul 08:52 #

@g1586639: You're welcome :)

04 Jul 08:52 #

@g1586639: yes, there are more and more inconsistencies, it is not clear which way they are going, the line with Lucas has been removed altogether, although it is very important for the development of Juliet's personality

04 Jul 09:39 #

@LouisloveHarry: zbs I like spoilers.

04 Jul 09:40 #

@LouisloveHarry: 50 bunkers with different stories (cool), it would be possible to mix up something like hundreds, where they end up starting a war with each other.

g1586639

04 Jul 11:19 #

@LouisloveHarry: What happened to Lucas in the original?

04 Jul 11:30 #

@g1586639: It is Lucas who begins to understand how the shelter system really works and who controls them. His knowledge helps Juliet understand the structure of bunkers and how to save people.
After the events with Bernard, Lucas actually becomes a person who can control the information and technologies of Shelter-18, which means he influences the future of all residents.
For Juliet, he gradually becomes not just an acquaintance, but the closest person and partner she trusts. In the books, their relationship develops into true love.
In the finale of the trilogy, they act together and make decisions on which the fate of the survivors depends.

04 Jul 11:33 #

@g1586639: It was Lucas who "negotiated" with the first hiding place, Donnie (Troy).
When Anna changed Thurman to Donnie after freezing, on the computer. Donny was pushing Lucas, revealing secrets to him. But Juliette didn't trust him. I thought they were being controlled again. There were decent bed scenes with Lucas, she had scenes with scars. In the series, she also seems to hide her scars. But then they will miraculously disappear) And only Lucas will notice it)

04 Jul 11:34 #

@g1586639: by the way, her father is also alive, he went straight to Semen in the final with everyone and Jules, and almost one of the first took off his helmet. Why it was removed is not clear. And they seem to have a warmer relationship in the book.

04 Jul 11:53 #

@g1586639: Lucas will die, in their hiding place, when Thurman returns, Donnie will be captured, and Ju's hiding place will be poisoned, but they dug a tunnel to Solo's hiding place in advance, as she wanted, who will have time to pass through it and they will be there for a while. Charlotte, meanwhile, is going to lose Donny, which unites her.
Lucas will die in the server room from smoke / gas - the passage will not leave.

04 Jul 12:03 #

@g1586639: The remaining ones who go into hiding Solo, Charlotte will contact Jules by chance and tell the whole truth, because she and Donnie are also hiding. They'll be able to talk once. Charlotte will tell you about this seed. And they don't have much food there. And the desire to go outside will still overpower you to find out the truth. Well, they have nothing left to lose... In the end, they'll just trust Charlotte, believe her, come out, and it seems true. Later, while Donny is undermining 1 shelter, he will let her go outside in a suit (force her to leave). Since he's seriously ill there, he only has a couple of days left. He would sacrifice himself so that she would survive. She's going to go by seven, too. That's where he and Jultui will meet. What a happy ending)

g1586639

04 Jul 13:29 #

@LouisloveHarry: Thanks for the detailed reply!

05 Jul 00:19 #

@LouisloveHarry: Well, yes, it's already interesting to watch after reading it, because a lot of new things have been added.

ArtchibalD

03 Jul 23:51 #

As usual, it's very interesting, but it's too long...I hope the plot will spin faster this time!
PS: is this trolling of the audience from the scriptwriters - the heroine doesn't remember and we don't remember?

04 Jul 00:09 #

I wonder how they're going to replace Thurman with Donnie now that Thurman is a woman in the series. …
Like the gender will be changed or what))?

04 Jul 00:17 #

And where was Lucas sent? He's in touch with 1 now... why is that woman suddenly talking to them?
Bernard
I put him in his place.
In the room where everything is
Books

Лаваш

04 Jul 04:36 #

Okay, at least they didn't pull the twist that they were stuffing her with pills, remembering the pace of season 2, I could have waited for this episode in the fifth as a PLOT TWIST. The only thing I don't understand yet is the dynamics of Sims and his wife, which one of them is in charge of this whole situation, on the one hand, he's always trying to be the shadow boss everywhere, on the other, she's still talking with a megamind.

I love the series, but I still remember the cons... So far, to be honest, the line of modernity is much more interesting than the line of shelter. Both from the point of view of lore and the picture (still, these corridors and stairs are a bit tiring).
In the shelter itself, it's as if there will be an endless tinkering with Juliette's memory, which she will return at a critical moment in the finale and something from the congressman will play a role in the shelter...
Honestly, as if the line with protest and "lies on the screen" was supposed to end after the end of last season, but it's here again, xs how much it will be interesting.
It seems like there are only three books and the first one was stretched over two seasons, and the rest one at a time, so I really hope that this season will be a little faster (at least the quick disclosure of the twist with pills hints), but I'm afraid to hope much. Well, I hope we'll hear something more about the characters of the second season from another hiding place.

04 Jul 10:28 #

@Lavash: Where's Lucas..

pinta_vodki

04 Jul 06:00 #

Shh, it was much better than you could tell from the trailer — it felt like she wouldn't remember anything at all for half a season, and it would be the same from episode to episode, like in the second season. And look, I've already started to remember something, and I realized that everything is not so simple! So, we hope for something cheerful!

P.S. And yes, people who have read books, can you please not spoil everything all the time? Well, or at least put a warning that there is a spoiler below. I'm like Jules — after two years of amnesia, I remembered why, unlike other series on this site, I stupidly stopped going into the comments on Silo. =(

04 Jul 08:54 #

@pinta_vodki: They're already moving away from the book. ent itself seems to be changing after Thurman's portrayal of a woman..

Sich666

04 Jul 17:14 #

@LouisloveHarry: It was also confusing at first, but then I remember one detail related to women, so they can beat that too. As I could without spoilers)

pinta_vodki

05 Jul 03:05 #

@LouisloveHarry: it's a little soothing, but some common points are still likely to persist. But I want both theory and surprise not to spoil)

05 Jul 10:33 #

@Sich666: Eh, Charlotte?

04 Jul 08:55 #

If you've read the books, tell me, Sims wasn't there much, I don't remember his wife or him at all. I wonder why they were added here? And a bunch more new characters (the girl from the supply chain). Weren't there any at all? Score time?

LoveToBones

04 Jul 16:33 #

@LouisloveHarry: stop comparing two separate works already. Your verbal diarrhea above reads like "I read books and know everything in advance, but everything is not like in books!11!!!1!".
I've also read books, but I can discuss the SERIES outside of the context of the books, because they're two different works. Forget about the fact that there are books in principle, the series is BASED on them, and does not accurately convey every line and plot twist.
You've already watched two whole seasons without wondering why, because the first two seasons also have a lot of differences from the books. Take it easy and enjoy, without spoiling those who haven't read it. Treat the audience with respect. Here you can only spoilerize the content of a specific series that you are writing about in the discussions.

04 Jul 17:07 #

Comment has been deleted

04 Jul 17:07 #

Comment has been deleted

05 Jul 11:20 #

@LoveToBones: If you don't like something, you don't have to read it, right?

05 Jul 11:51 #

@LouisloveHarry: If you want to discuss a book, you can discuss it on a book forum. I've read it too, but I don't understand why spoil the intrigue for those who haven't read it. Your messages look like you want to tell everyone that you can read. Wow, I read the book, I can read. There are many who don't want to know the plot in advance, why are you writing spoilers? Get together with like-minded people and discuss the book where books are discussed, and here they are discussing the series.

05 Jul 11:59 #

@JardimFramboesa: In any case, when you enter the discussions, you should already understand that there will be spoilers. It's like going to the comments in the Lost and they're already writing about the finale in season 1. They asked me how it would end, and I replied)

05 Jul 12:33 #

@LouisloveHarry: No, there shouldn't be any spoilers about how it ends. Why compare a TV series from 20 years ago and a new series that has just been released, under the discussion of which you lay out how everything will end. But now everyone knows that you can read.

05 Jul 12:48 #

@JardimFramboesa: Game of Thrones and the outside have been freely available for weeks before the finale...

05 Jul 12:49 #

@JardimFramboesa: and why did they throw spoilers at the finale in the discussion from the outside, when the finale has not yet been released? I flipped through it, because I needed it, someone was reading it.

05 Jul 13:22 #

@LouisloveHarry: How would I know why someone was out there somewhere throwing spoilers? Apparently your like-minded people want to spoil people's high. Now we are talking specifically about you and how you are being carried here by the discussion of this series.

Blew

04 Jul 09:53 #

It seems like the series is normal, nothing out of the ordinary, but it was a bit boring to watch. Last season ended on a high note, with a fierce movement and it seemed that this one should continue those events, but here everything is kind of sluggish, everyday, plus new characters and events in the bunker that don't catch on yet. Surely, of course, the pace will accelerate later, but judging by the experience of previous seasons, you will have to wait a lot for this. It's especially funny to read the rave reviews from critics against this background .

lexastaw

04 Jul 11:52 #

Hopefully, this process of remembering won't last the entire season.
I would not like it to turn into a retelling of the first two.

Sich666

04 Jul 17:10 #

And they came up with a pretty good idea, everyone was wondering how they would show the events in the bunker when the 2nd book of the Shift, this is a prequel. Yes, they will talk boring and slow again, but that's how it should be in the series, there's still a mountain of events. Smena, the best book of the entire trilogy, I'm looking forward to this season.

tyrell

04 Jul 18:46 #

The squirrel!

Victor_Flash

07 Jul 13:57 #

@tyrell: Yeah, I noticed it right away too! The best character of the third season so far.

arinka_Lo

04 Jul 19:07 #

The fact that a parallel line was finally introduced in the past is a plus. But I keep thinking that it would have been better if they had started this last season, instead of this endless boring mess in the Shelter.

pinta_vodki

05 Jul 03:07 #

@arinka_Lo: by the way, yes, it would be nice to diversify the gloom of the second season.

EmilD

05 Jul 00:34 #

A normal start, just a flashback will dilute the slowness of what is happening in the bunker and the series will not stall as much as in the middle of the second season.

Максим_Кравченко

05 Jul 00:44 #

Favorite TV series. I hope the issue of amnesia will be resolved by episode 2-3. And there will be a movement. My wife and I were also sitting at the beginning, we didn't understand. The same part has already been forgotten. The comments recalled that Sims, his wife and child went into the "golden room" together, but only his wife was allowed to stay. The first episode didn't come out bad for me, it's sad that the next episode will have to wait a week. On the contrary, I want more of the bunker itself than what was "before".

da__da__ya

06 Jul 15:32 #

@Maksim_kravchenko: it's going to be like this - she's been recovering from amnesia all season, in the last episode she says * I remembered something!* and the season is ending

E770

05 Jul 01:17 #

I didn't like the idea of amnesia even when watching the trailer, but it doesn't seem to be that bad. The line with the past is also interesting, it will dilute the gray picture of the shelter.

Nice to see Jessica Brown Findlay.

illymental

05 Jul 10:26 #

I'm waiting for Solo's backstory, and especially for his little friend. But it's probably next season.

05 Jul 11:17 #

@illymental: Yeah, and I wonder about his childhood, how he survived there, I always felt sorry for him.

SlepoiZadrot

05 Jul 13:06 #

First of all, I would like to say that for a long time I thought about where this music in the screensaver came from, and it only came to me now. It's similar to the music from the TV series "The world of the wild West"
It's fun, of course)

And secondly, I'm already waiting and waiting for the moment when Juliet wakes up from her dream, and solve everything and everyone....)

07 Jul 16:14 #

@SlepoiZadrot: and it reminded me of Daredevil, but yes, MDZ is just better suited here.
I love these intros.

Nikolaha

05 Jul 21:22 #

I don't even know, some kind of double feelings. The first episodes of the first two seasons were spinning into a whirlwind. The same episode just passed.
It's strange to see Juliette so... lost. So driven and driven. It's not about her!! Apparently it has been going on for 2 months, and she has taken minor resistance actions.
I'm surprised by my friends and their reactions. Weren't they supposed to come to the rescue? To support or assist in memory recovery?
Okay, let's look further.

tanу

05 Jul 21:31 #

Nothing is clear, but it is very interesting.

Liza

05 Jul 21:52 #

It seemed that the new head of the supply department is the same actress as Muriel from Good Omens, but there is no information about this on the film search (but they are often late)

The move with memory loss was frustrating, of course, but it also added to my worries about gg

imRebel

05 Jul 21:58 #

@Liza: This is her, telling insta how nice it is to be a part of the third season. quelinsepulveda

ByTalya

05 Jul 23:39 #

Thanks to the retelling of the seasons on YouTube, otherwise you won't even remember what happened in the second one.
I hope my memory starts coming back quickly, I want more action.

kreaciatus

06 Jul 09:09 #

It's cool, of course, that many people have read the books, but here's a discussion of the series for a second. The book can be discussed on other resources.

yanna_l

06 Jul 12:27 #

I am very glad to see the return of the series, I have been waiting for more than a year, it seems! But damn, losing five minutes is such a setback.... I hope they won't delay this for a long time! I wonder how the guys are doing in the other bunker. I wonder if they will be shown again?

BinkaDeath

06 Jul 13:50 #

Memory loss in two timelines ...
I specifically watched the retellings on YouTube, but apparently we will remember with the main character together.🫠

06 Jul 15:28 #

The beginning is powerful! However, there are traditionally high expectations from this series)
It's great that Juliette was made mayor, but it's bad that she was brainwashed, and now it's like in one famous movie - "I remember here, I don't remember here." And where did the second bunker at number 18 go, or what was it? Solo or whoever else was there, what's wrong with them?

The secret message in the soup is just 5 points 👏 Bravo, and the spy vibes have arrived.
Oh, who put up a banner about lying on the screen, but they are clearly fighting for the right cause, well done. Not like some people on airplanes, although I don't like to get into geopolitics, but this agenda has been shoved into TV shows for years.
The fact that Bernard survived in the airlock, and then he was killed, in general, is not so important. He was still that weirdo with the letter M and pretty infuriated the past 2 seasons.

It's interesting, of course, what kind of substance was sprayed in the air, which even disabled the fighters. Antimatter, damn it))
Maybe they poisoned the planet with this crap?
Although who knows, I hope they'll tell you more. Fortunately, now there are enough flashbacks from the time before the disaster, so it will definitely be interesting.

P.S. That feeling when both Paradise and Shelter/Bunker come out in one year)

LoveToBones

06 Jul 23:31 #

@6o4ka: what kind of right cause are those who write about lies on the screen fighting for? That poster is literally a riot that killed a nearby bunker. Everyone believed that it was a lie on the screen, and rushed out of the bunker, where in the end everyone dried up to dust, and then Jules walked through their bones when she was escaping from the cleanup. This is not a just cause, but ruin.

Mouse_Sonya

06 Jul 16:44 #

Logically, Juliet should have been slammed next to Bernard and told everyone that they were both burned, which would have been easier than stuffing her with pills and shaking because she was remembering something.

MetaModernBoy

11 Jul 05:24 #

@Mouse_Sonya: Then it would have been more difficult for Sims and his wife to legitimize their power after the uprising.

06 Jul 23:18 #

How did clever Camilla fall for a butcher like Sims in the first place? He looks like a leather jacket salesman from Sadovoda, doesn't shine with brains, likes to kill and torture old women, and when a more or less strong rival appears, he immediately hides in diapers or behind his wife. Why would Camille, with her brain, need this miracle?

randolphcarter

08 Jul 12:16 #

@mixer1701: I have a code name for him, Jigan.

06 Jul 23:52 #

In general, it's funny how the girl who controls everything is so reminiscent of season 4 of The World of the Wild West. When The World of the Wild West was released, it all seemed like some kind of technophobic future, but now it seems more or less inevitable.

caitlyn_kiramman

07 Jul 20:09 #

@mixer1701: by the way, what happened to the world of the wild west after the first season, why did the series slide so much?

07 Jul 21:41 #

@caitlyn_kiramman: I think it would be inappropriate to discuss this series here, but despite the fact that seasons 1 and 4 seem to be different series altogether, I believe that if season 4 had been released in 2024-2025, it would have been discussed much more with this superintelligent (or not) the AI that controls everything.

caitlyn_kiramman

08 Jul 20:29 #

@mixer1701: appropriate. AI is now being actively introduced into the defense industry, billionaires are building bunkers, so there's a lot of fun ahead of us.

funnypennywise

15 Jul 13:31 #

@caitlyn_kiramman: the second season of Westward can still be watched, but then somehow the Terminator turned out.

ArtchibalD

07 Jul 11:45 #

Like this...The second episode hasn't been released yet, but it's already available to watch...well hackers, well AI))
I am waiting for the world's first AI-generated series, where the plot will be determined by the audience through their theories - everything will be logical and harmonious!

mavlytovfagiz

07 Jul 14:49 #

It seems that another exciting season awaits us...

07 Jul 16:21 #

I like the backstory so far, although it's very much in conflict with what's in the bunker, as if I'm watching 2 different TV series.

It's so funny, the actress who plays the pilot's sister is forever Lena Crown from Brave New World for me).

07 Jul 21:43 #

@AlexSok18: Damn, I kept trying to remember where I saw this actress! The congresswoman's assistant from the past also looks very familiar.

08 Jul 05:30 #

@mixer1701: and when I looked at the review for previous seasons, I saw that Karen from the office played the Sheriff's wife. It's funny, because I had my first acquaintance with the actress right here, then the CHZ, and then the office, and that's it, I got a foothold like Karen)

Аришка17

07 Jul 23:10 #

Not only the tropes with memory loss were dragged from "Good Omens", but also some actors (Hastur and Muriel, hello) haha

sunshine_lika

08 Jul 00:16 #

Damn, because of the flashbacks, I kept catching myself thinking: I'm watching a Fallout or a one-vibe Hideout.

mavlytovfagiz

09 Jul 21:06 #

@sunshine_lika: ahaha) I also got everything mixed up and I have to remember was it in the Fallout or in the Shelter?)))

a1392150

08 Jul 00:21 #

An interesting start. One thing I didn 't understand 🤨 Shirley and Knox
In a romantic relationship or
Friendly?

08 Jul 01:56 #

A few(!) It's a jarring moment that Jules with amnesia (which, as we learn, is not amnesia at all) was made mayor, but this fragment is missing. And Sims is her puppet master, which is obvious to others.…
So far, the line of the past or the present (the war in Iran) looks more interesting.

Kentavr

08 Jul 02:40 #

The authors of the series clearly have their own very special vision of the development of all this, because there are practically no parallels with the book anymore, and they are deliberately complicating their lives so that they cannot even try to follow the book rails. And even though the plot is stalling somehow, even now I am very, very interested in how the plot will be resolved in the end :D
Hooray, intrigue!

Tartugec

08 Jul 03:31 #

@Kentavr: the authors do everything right for the current realities. Science fiction writers at the time, when they were writing books, could not even think that this was the reality of the future. But here, instead of books, through movies and TV series, they serve pieces of the truth about what awaits us and how control works.

Kentavr

08 Jul 05:07 #

@Tartugec: No, it's not, it's a 2011+ book, everything is completely fresh. The authors of the series don't change anything "real-life", they just change the plot. For example, changing the gender of a character that is important to the plot without replacing or introducing another character is not a reality of the future.
That is, everything that is conventionally "technological" shown in the series is also in the book, one way or another, they do not change this, or they do not change it somehow radically, preserving if not the letter, then at least the spirit and essence of the idea.

08 Jul 13:18 #

@Kentavr: The author of the book is involved in the filming and he is IN favor of changing the plot of the book, but they want to reduce the ending to 1. Let's see what happens. The main thing is not to spoil it + politics does not interfere . The USA can 't show it in a bad way , of course ..

Tartugec

08 Jul 03:30 #

I watched two episodes. It's like my memory has been erased and they're trying to remind me who's who and what the series is about. I thought it would be action packed and she would tell everyone the truth. In fact, we're just looking at amnesia and the history of pill creation and control methods in parallel. AI rules everything clearly.

08 Jul 09:44 #

@Tartugec: Where did the second episode come from? 🤔

Tartugec

08 Jul 19:08 #

@id_oleg1488: on different free services. Translated by dragonmani))

08 Jul 13:20 #

@Tartugec: And what about 2 already?

08 Jul 15:26 #

@Tartugec: The backstory is needed in order to introduce the characters who will eventually be the main ones at the end. The backstory reveals the characters, shows their character and thinking, so that it would be clear why they would eventually make certain decisions later, but it's slow. They show individual moments, the fundamental ones from which the history of bunkers began, and you need to know them in order to understand why they were created and for what purpose. No need to wait for the action in the series, which in fact belongs to psychological fiction. This series of books, and the series itself, are not based on action, but on showing how society has been living in a confined space for centuries, and how a small spark of hope and interest can ignite the flames of rebellion.. These books are about how a bunch of people thought they could retrain people, make them compliant and manageable, but eventually realized that this was not possible. Because there will always be someone who asks a little more than necessary))) And by the way, in the second part of the book, many answers and characteristics were given to at least one person - psychiatrist Victor))) It was the episodes with the psychiatrist that immediately answered the question of why the bunkers were created, even wrongly, in these episodes they showed the logic of thinking of the person who created the concept of bunkers and the charter. )) The main thing to remember about this moment is where is the thread at the end of the season when everyone will be asking this question)))

randolphcarter

08 Jul 12:14 #

Why do I feel like I've watched a completely different series with new characters?

mavlytovfagiz

09 Jul 21:07 #

@randolphcarter: I thought I was the only one with this feeling)

08 Jul 13:25 #

It is interesting to observe the dynamics of Donald and Charlotte's relationship as brother and sister. The actors are just exactly matched. It's funny how they tease each other like kids)

ИнтeрecныйФиллep

08 Jul 15:19 #

I won't repeat the mistake with the second season — I watched the episodes by release date, it seemed that the series was delayed. But the people in the comments advised to watch in one gulp.

I'll try this with the third season, let me wait 2 months for it to be fully released, but I'll get high from binge watching.

08 Jul 15:40 #

Comment has been deleted

08 Jul 16:35 #

@LouisloveHarry: Riley, you can find… But in terrible quality and only in a clumsy dubbing with advertising inserts in the text!

ИнтeрecныйФиллep

08 Jul 16:37 #

@id_oleg1488: This is a spammer, there are no 2 series

08 Jul 16:44 #

@ИнтeрecныйФиллep: I found it on another resource through a search. Lordfilm-baza.info

08 Jul 17:43 #

@id_oleg1488: It was opening for me

08 Jul 17:44 #

@id_oleg1488: I was surprised myself.

08 Jul 17:46 #

@id_oleg1488: Was the episode leaked earlier?

08 Jul 17:51 #

@ИнтeрecныйФиллep: there is some kind of dragon money voice acting... I think I'll wait for the lost film.

Doctor_13

08 Jul 23:34 #

@LouisloveHarry: Dragon money is a terrible voice acting, don't be fooled. Cutting and TVshows are usually cool, Lost takes longer to make, and without matyukov

Doctor_13

08 Jul 23:33 #

The mayor is from the working class, giving all power to the Soviets. Except it's all a puppet show, but it's much better. I immediately thought that Jules had been pumped up with something, so that this topic with amnesia would not be forgotten until the end of the season.

Monogatari

08 Jul 23:38 #

I don't really like that "airtime" is spent on prehistory.

It would be nice to talk about how the bunkers were built, why such rules/pacts were introduced, or something that would reveal life in the bunker.
But the story about Iran seems so far from the main plot, and so predictable (everything will end in big BANG), that I don't even really want to delve into it.

However, if they somehow elegantly steer towards the main plot (there are already parallels with amnesia), then it will be cool.

Lan

08 Jul 23:40 #

I really liked the beginning, I really wish we hadn't stretched Santa Barbara's memory for half a season. As it is, everything is going great so far.
By the way, I'm interested in whether there were dogs in the original, too, because this moment surprised me a little))

g1585438

09 Jul 22:16 #

@Lan: there were dogs, but few. They were considered useless creatures that only eat and shit. Few people had it for themselves just like that. Miners and workers drowned them as puppies, and who didn't drown them... They were... food for people from the lower floors. Tents were set up in the market and they were fried and sold. After all, they bought it... It was all described in book 3. And this is not some kind of spoiler, they definitely won't show it.

shubkin

09 Jul 12:55 #

The worst plot moves from the TV series of the noughties with fake amnesia went into action😴
Why is everyone calmly watching the Sims mess with go and not really doing anything for three months?
Is it radiation sickness on the neck or vitamin side effects? 😁

UlknAries

09 Jul 19:49 #

I'm like Jules, I don't remember anything either 🫠

IMMORTALKING

10 Jul 17:28 #

@UlknAries: I'm with you! I'm straining, and I still can't remember what happened to the young IT guy Jules once loved. 😁

oldbk

09 Jul 21:53 #

As I understand it, nanorobots destroy/affect a person's memory if they happen to be alive. This happened to both Jules and the congressman's sister (when she took a certain viscous mass in her hand).
Jules continues to be pumped with nanorobots, giving her pills with them. What happens next in the story with the congressman's sister is already getting interesting.

bulidze

10 Jul 00:20 #

What a dreary episode, they're dragging their feet again and not moving the plot at all 😵💫

skagerrak

10 Jul 10:58 #

It's funny how the roles of actors are growing, here the congressman is played by a guy who was an assistant to the senator in his Heirs.

HighCrunch

10 Jul 15:12 #

What kind of joke is this? I turned on the first episode, a woman is sitting on a bench and a man is sitting on a bench and a woman is insulting a man, calling him a pig, talking there sucked a lot today, who wrote the script?

HighCrunch

10 Jul 17:23 #

Well, what can I say, the worst scenario decisions and the worst TV shows are those who introduce the past, the future, amnesia, some flashbacks and so on, and such a series is hiding. An outright bad series that kills the pace every season.

That is, we are waiting for the first season for something to happen, we are waiting for the second season, and we will also wait for the third season. Every season kind of starts over, there is no development. Everything goes in a circle.

The beginning - > despondency -> cliffhanger

It's already starting to get annoying, it's just dragging out time, as well as the same thing from the outside.

The series has one plus, literally one - Rebecca Ferguson is one of the most beautiful women in the world.

skagerrak

10 Jul 17:53 #

@HighCrunch: I protest, the worst thing is time jumping)

11 Jul 09:06 #

@HighCrunch: I'm only watching because of Rebecca Ferguson, when I saw her fixing that engine of theirs in an alcoholic T-shirt, uhh🔥💦

Kiko_o

10 Jul 20:06 #

از manipulation بدم میاد.
و سایلو با همین شروع شده :'(

Hectic

11 Jul 18:51 #

@Kiko_o: Hello, I'm going to the bar.

Igoryamba

11 Jul 22:17 #

norm

Социофоб

13 Jul 15:02 #

Were there any books about the war between Iran and the United States?

Or is the series tailored to modernity?

bulidze

14 Jul 09:52 #

@Sociophobe: I was, yes.

-Эдуард-

14 Jul 18:26 #

The whole point of watching the series is gone🤦♂️😁😁normal people would immediately ask how are you, how did you get back, where were you, is it possible to live there😂😂but the stupid bitch Amers just clap it's not clear why🤦♂️😁

Ytzin

15 Jul 08:17 #

I barely finished half of it, it's going hard. Amnesia? Seriously? Is that santabarbara? And then, at what point did it become a series about a congressman, a bunch of women around him (no, seriously, did he even talk to a man in the series?) And the bombing of Iran? Why is that even necessary? Why in such a volume?
It seems that the authors have completely written themselves out

funnypennywise

15 Jul 13:33 #

I agree that amnesia is the most disgusting decision, the series has already been stretched, and the beginning is not impressive at all.

kiprian_zhurov

15 Jul 15:40 #

@funnypennywise: amnesia, separation of personality and time travel for me are twists that already make you want to spit, unless the plot is based on them first.

funnypennywise

15 Jul 16:05 #

@kiprian_zhurov: amnesia is too cliched a movie, stretching an already stretched plot. Time travel was well beaten in the Dark, to the separation of personality in the opposite direction

kiprian_zhurov

15 Jul 16:06 #

@funnypennywise: well, in the darkness, it was originally that the story began with time travel in essence, and not suddenly introduced in the third season)

kiprian_zhurov

15 Jul 15:39 #

I watched the moment when the United States really started bombing Iran again, it was a bit funny

dolcenoia