What? Are you serious? Is this what Grigory Melekhov should look like? Seriously?? But in terms of rum, he is higher than his brother Peter, and as shown here, he is lower. And Gregory certainly doesn't have blue eyes!!! After all, according to the novel, it clearly goes that he has slanting, black eyes in the slits, because as it was in the novel, he had Turks in his ancestors. Yes, they may have guessed by age here, but they definitely failed with Grigory's appearance. >< And Stepan, which is better? Yes, his radiant smile does not come off, and as if everything is just fine and he is just happy. After all, but according to the novel, he often beat Aksinya, and here it is shown that everything is fine with them; And has anyone been confused yet by the fact that Peter and Daria have a child? As if this was definitely not in the novel. And also, is it normal that the whole village wears the same pants? Seriously. Employees and civilians alike, all wearing the same pants.
Yes, there are many things that confused me in the first series, because I immediately compare it with the novel that I recently read.
The only thing I really didn't like was the skin.)) As if since spring, the guys there have been plowing in the fields with their asses up, fishing and everything else, spending most of the day outside, they should be tanned. The tan appears in some places closer to the middle of the second series, if memory serves, in the first they are all white, as if they live in our time and work from morning to evening in offices, and do not live on the street. I liked everything else, it's cool that it's close to the text, and the images are conveyed mentally. I watch the series and realize that really only Russians can film their classics like that. No foreign Anna Karenina or Wars and Worlds can compare with ours, because only ours can convey emotions in this way. And in our eyes - the whole of Russia. It's nice.)
This is the worst film adaptation. What are you doing? Where are your eyes? Everything is dead here. First of all, it's a complete mess. A lot of lines are not from the book, but simply inserted by the screenwriters, and they are out of place. They completely kill the whole idea of the book. The whole book is aimed at showing the status of the patriarchal family in the Don Cossacks and how all this is collapsing with the advent of Soviet power. Sholokhov started doing this in his early stories! And what's here? It all came down to a love story, as always. Well, where has it been seen, huh? Acting is no good at all. There is nothing of the Cossacks in the remarks, all the ethnography has been killed at the root. Besides, the ost of this series is disgusting. In moments when everything is broken for the characters and life goes on with a tear, such a light cheerful melody sounds. Just for what? This is an unbearable series that killed the whole true plan of Sholokhov.
Are you serious? Is this what Grigory Melekhov should look like? Seriously??
But in terms of rum, he is higher than his brother Peter, and as shown here, he is lower. And Gregory certainly doesn't have blue eyes!!! After all, according to the novel, it clearly goes that he has slanting, black eyes in the slits, because as it was in the novel, he had Turks in his ancestors. Yes, they may have guessed by age here, but they definitely failed with Grigory's appearance. ><
And Stepan, which is better? Yes, his radiant smile does not come off, and as if everything is just fine and he is just happy. After all, but according to the novel, he often beat Aksinya, and here it is shown that everything is fine with them;
And has anyone been confused yet by the fact that Peter and Daria have a child? As if this was definitely not in the novel.
And also, is it normal that the whole village wears the same pants? Seriously. Employees and civilians alike, all wearing the same pants.
Yes, there are many things that confused me in the first series, because I immediately compare it with the novel that I recently read.
The tan appears in some places closer to the middle of the second series, if memory serves, in the first they are all white, as if they live in our time and work from morning to evening in offices, and do not live on the street.
I liked everything else, it's cool that it's close to the text, and the images are conveyed mentally. I watch the series and realize that really only Russians can film their classics like that. No foreign Anna Karenina or Wars and Worlds can compare with ours, because only ours can convey emotions in this way. And in our eyes - the whole of Russia. It's nice.)
First of all, it's a complete mess. A lot of lines are not from the book, but simply inserted by the screenwriters, and they are out of place. They completely kill the whole idea of the book. The whole book is aimed at showing the status of the patriarchal family in the Don Cossacks and how all this is collapsing with the advent of Soviet power. Sholokhov started doing this in his early stories! And what's here? It all came down to a love story, as always. Well, where has it been seen, huh?
Acting is no good at all. There is nothing of the Cossacks in the remarks, all the ethnography has been killed at the root.
Besides, the ost of this series is disgusting. In moments when everything is broken for the characters and life goes on with a tear, such a light cheerful melody sounds. Just for what?
This is an unbearable series that killed the whole true plan of Sholokhov.