Ads

s03e05 — First Case, Second Base

The Good Doctor — s03e05 — First Case, Second Base

My rating

Rate
Rate the shows you've watched and get up-to-date recommendations
4.635
MyShows
(2 054)
Duration: 43 min.
Released: 21.10.201922.10.2019 05:00
Watched by: 35 98744.8%
3 season
s03e05
s03e01 - Disaster
s03e02 - Debts
s03e03 - Claire
s03e04 - Take My Hand
s03e05 - First Case, Second Base
s03e06 - 45-Degree Angle
s03e07 - SFAD
s03e08 - Moonshot
s03e09 - Incomplete

Discussion of the 5 episode of the 3 season
Discuss this episode
60

maria-green
maria-green
21 Oct 2019, 16:55 # Show original
Oh, this practice of compromise)))))))))))))))))

Ps: the scenes with my brother are just tearful... 😭❤️
fetisu
fetisu
21 Oct 2019, 18:44 # Show original
@maria-green: That's kind of to tears, but on the other hand, it's kind of creepy...
maria-green
maria-green
22 Oct 2019, 20:07 # Show original
@Agexir: well, he didn't come with an axe in nightmares! :)
Сплюшка
Сплюшка
29 Oct 2019, 17:52 # Show original
It's still weird. I wouldn't want a surgeon like that. I took it in the middle of the operation, threw the scalpel and went to hysteria in the corridor. And if the patient started bleeding or something. Oh, whatever
NinaSweety
NinaSweety
03 Nov 2019, 04:01 # Show original
@Splyushka: Well, as it were, he saved her normal lifestyle and now she won't eat through a straw! I am "for" such a surgeon, but not - cut, cut and throw it away, and let the person be glad that he is alive at all, but the operation is simple...
Razunter
Razunter
07 Nov 2019, 18:04 # Show original
@NinaSweety: she could have bled out during this time and xs what else, all the doctors ran outside somewhere and cackled...
maria-green
maria-green
11 Nov 2019, 20:41 # Show original
@Razunter: outside it's coffee to drink outside)))) And these were a few steps away, and the patient was not ‘lying there alone’, she was under the supervision of staff, in which case they would have been informed or, in general, I think they were standing at the windows through which the operating room was visible) Now I don't remember exactly, but I think they were talking)
Сплюшка
Сплюшка
24 Nov 2019, 10:46 # Show original
So who said that only autistic people can be brilliant surgeons? Choosing a doctor, you somehow sincerely hope that they are all professionals.
ttikhonova99
ttikhonova99
06 Feb 2022, 14:47 # Show original
@Splyushka:As a member of the operations team, I can tell you a lot of things that you won't like.
Surgeons may lose consciousness during surgery, and an operating nurse who does not have any surgical education may be assisted.
If any situation arose that required management approval, then the entire team could wait for hours for the arrival of the chief/responsible surgeon.
Surgeons often hire 1-year residents as assistants. They simply can't wash their hands, but they can be admitted. Due to their inexperience, operations can have complications and a delayed duration.
ttikhonova99
ttikhonova99
06 Feb 2022, 14:48 # Show original
@ttikhonova99:extended time, sorry)
ovcharenko_kate
ovcharenko_kate
21 Oct 2019, 18:19 # Show original
"You don't have any lumps!"©
"Can I check the other breast?"©
😂😂😂
I yelled))
The series is very good!
vlandus
vlandus
21 Oct 2019, 22:07 # Show original
Such a positive female patient. I missed seeing her a little bit after the surgery.
hammerschmiede
hammerschmiede
22 Oct 2019, 03:41 # Show original
Precisely! The reaction to such good news and to the fact that Murphy saved her from not living a full life is interesting.
Annetinka
Annetinka
PRO
22 Oct 2019, 04:41 # Show original
What confuses me a little bit in this series is how easily they carry out operations that no one has carried out before. Maybe I'm wrong, of course, and watching Anatomy for 15 years affects them) but there they had to get permission from the committee or something several times to carry out similar operations that have not been carried out in the country yet. And here.. Well, I've seen how they do it, I'll tell you in words, and let's do it. And the approximate situation has already happened more than once 🤷♀️
siberiandragon
siberiandragon
29 Oct 2019, 23:26 # Show original
@Annetinka: I have read books written by doctors, including surgeons, and experienced surgeons often perform unique, but not too unique operations. People are all different and there are many such unique operations - but the degree of uniqueness is different, they did not choose a new treatment from scratch, but just a slightly less familiar way of performing the operation. Plus, there may be different laws in different states
the episode aired 22.10.2019
Soon1304
Soon1304
22 Oct 2019, 05:05 # Show original
Only the blonde remained without her own operation (although Sean has not yet been credited with this one, but he definitely did half the work and even found a better way).

And the main idea is that so far these operations have been successful, so I think that Morgan may come up with a less rosy ending to the operation (either it will screw up, or everything done even correctly will not save the patient at the end).

And I'm happy for Sean - especially in a romantic situation))) He 's a naughty boy 😂
Funny_Scarf
Funny_Scarf
22 Oct 2019, 19:02 # Show original
@Soon1304:
I accidentally mentally dubbed Sean "Titchup" and now I can't get it out of my head 😂
Dana_ptr
Dana_ptr
07 Apr 2020, 23:28 # Show original
The park is still..
veganforjustice
veganforjustice
PRO
19 Apr 2020, 16:16 # Show original
@Dana_ptr: Review the end of the episode, Park was sent to another operating room and he also performed surgery.
LincolnMM
LincolnMM
22 Oct 2019, 10:27 # Show original
My boy touched a boob. God, I'm glad for Sean as a little brother. Now a little bit about the disadvantages of the series for 5 episodes of season 3. Sometimes it feels like everyone is autistic, and Sean is normal. Why is he the only one who shows real emotions, and everyone is like dumb machines with a built-in legal and medical encyclopedia, no one talks like that in real life. For comparison, in the same House or Clinic (another genre, yes) there was more lively communication. It's all sad((
Gourry_aka_pm
Gourry_aka_pm
22 Oct 2019, 18:06 # Show original
@LincolnMM: I remember House somehow and catch the system. Shore is great at characters with various character deviations, and it sucks just as much with normal adequate people, he succeeds... Translucent inventors. From the same House, without looking into the cast, only House and the Thirteenth are immediately remembered as characters (well, yes, Taub plus or minus the slipper was not flat), but only Sean, Glassy and Morgan are well painted here (I don't know if Carly and Lea should be counted in this standings).
Funny_Scarf
Funny_Scarf
22 Oct 2019, 19:00 # Show original
I love Glassey's reactions to Sean's "kind of off topic at first, but then paradoxically accurate" words - he has such a hilariously puzzled face! And that moment with the bandana is just like a grandfather telling a fairy tale to his beloved grandson :)

Park did a good job, skillfully extracted information from Sean, calming him down. I'm glad he got the operation, even if he did it behind the scenes. Everything is going smoothly so far: I'm afraid that Morgan will get a hopeless tin again, as she once did in quarantine.
By the way, Melendez somehow became too little: he came, fished out a tumor-distillery and went back into the closet - just like the hospital administration)
ElaMalakashi
ElaMalakashi
22 Oct 2019, 19:48 # Show original
The "inner brewery" almost killed the guy.
A cool association with candles:
"What do we do when we go crazy?
- Blowing out the candles
- how many candles do you need
- 3
- slow exhalation..."
bloodstone31
bloodstone31
22 Oct 2019, 23:01 # Show original
A very sensual series...Sean opens up and socializes more and more every season...The series reveals the characters more and more and you can even see their transformation...
ВладимирЕршов
ВладимирЕршов
23 Oct 2019, 01:21 # Show original
It's strange why no one told Sean that he shouldn't talk about his personal life in such detail. That is, when he was given advice, his girlfriend then stuck a girl out of the Garbage, and then apparently she did not dare to tell Sean and it was far from Leia.
Funny_Scarf
Funny_Scarf
23 Oct 2019, 18:30 # Show original
@Vladimirershov: It seems to me that Carly Lee will stick it in again when she really turns up somewhere nearby. Well, or when she comes to Sean's doorstep, just like he did to her at the end of the series)
And about "She didn't dare tell Sean": in my opinion, she understands that if she tells Sean, he will tell Lia everything, and hz that she will tell him and advise him; therefore, in my opinion, it is more logical to first stick Lia, they say, curiosity is curiosity, but if Sean, due to autism, does not understand where To draw the line, do you have to understand what is ethical and what is not? — and then Leah will stop Sean, saying there's no need to go into details like that (which will only work if she reacts calmly like Claire and admits Carly's arguments, which I'm not sure about).
ramill
ramill
24 Oct 2019, 03:01 # Show original
Lim noticed very clearly how well they work as a team. Sean did a great job, he didn't do the operation for the sake of the operation, but really thought about the patient. I hope in the future he will learn to control his emotions at least during operations!

Carly is the perfect first girlfriend for Sean. He has experience communicating with people with autism and with such an easy and kind attitude helps him to learn "new things".
His arrival at the end is just a ruckus. A boy came to touch the second breast!😂
Сплюшка
Сплюшка
29 Oct 2019, 17:56 # Show original
I just don't understand, does she really like him or is this some kind of social experiment for her?
ramill
ramill
30 Oct 2019, 05:32 # Show original
@Splyushka: It would be too harsh of her to use Sean as an experiment. And why would she do that? She grew up with such a child, she knows what it is.

I'm rather surprised how quickly Sean switched to her. Does he really like her? Or is she an experiment for him? (Well, there, I can't touch Titi, oh, I can't 😂)
Lykke
Lykke
24 Oct 2019, 10:14 # Show original
I admire Freddie. He plays great. <3
denisch
denisch
25 Oct 2019, 02:07 # Show original
Recently, on the Internet, somewhere it was about a man who produced alcohol in his stomach))) I knew right away what was the matter.)) And in terms of weapons, well, adults, without children. They went a little too far))
siberiandragon
siberiandragon
29 Oct 2019, 23:29 # Show original
@denisch: Glassman is a doctor who regularly sees harm from guns and has probably performed more than one operation on a teenager with a gunshot injury + given his situation, this can especially trigger him
Olga_cat
Olga_cat
27 Nov 2019, 01:32 # Show original
@denisch: I thought that Glassey's fear of guns was either somehow connected with the death of his daughter (I don't remember if any details about what happened were told at all), or Glassman may well sometimes have suicidal thoughts, he's still a pretty depressed guy, and in that case, the gun next to the bed well It's not worth storing at all.
poohthewinnie
poohthewinnie
26 Oct 2019, 00:53 # Show original
the title of the series is a bomb))
and the series itself is fire
deer-p
deer-p
26 Oct 2019, 19:59 # Show original
It seems to me that there has already been a similar episode somewhere with a drunk without alcohol 🤔
klaria
klaria
08 Aug 2023, 14:41 # Show original
@deer-p: Literally in every medical series. Literally 😅
KonstantinRomeow
KonstantinRomeow
27 Oct 2019, 06:53 # Show original
I'm not sure, but I kind of heard out of the corner of my ear or read out of the corner of my eye that the ratings of the "Good Doctor" are falling. Not to such an extent as to close the series, but the budgets have clearly been reduced - if I'm not mistaken, there hasn't been a single "visualization" of Sean's thought process for the third season so far. And even now, instead of 3D holograms, there were videos of some Japanese operations. And in general, there has been more talk about the personal lives of doctors - a quarter of the series of Claire with her dead mother, a quarter of the series of Glassman with his wife and their conflict over the gun, another quarter of the episode of Carly thrusting her tongue and tits into Sean... in short, there is very little time left for medicine.
I'm not whining, of course, but it would be great to get an episode a la the first season, focused on an interesting medical problem and a complex operation.

I'm also worried that Resnik's first independent surgery may be unsuccessful. I would not like to, considering how she grew up before our eyes and revealed herself from the positive sides.

And I'm even more worried that cutie Lia will get a "couple of affectionate ones" from rude Carly for useful and relevant advice. I already dislike Carly wildly after her attacks on Claire, who helps everyone (gt;_<)

Andrews reminded himself a little of the first-season

It was nice to see Sean's brother again, he had been gone for a long time.
ramill
ramill
27 Oct 2019, 15:19 #
@Kostyurik: не думаю что отсутствие визуализации Шона связанно с рейтингом или бюджетом. Здесь это было неуместно, потому что была интрига, почему он остановился и начал кричать.
Да и изначально визуализация была показана для того, чтобы понять, как работает его мозг. Так вот лучше пусть будет редко, но очень качественно и в тему, чем каждый раз просто какие-то всплывающие кадры.
arifmetica
arifmetica
28 Oct 2019, 00:57 #
@Kostyurik: визуализация была в первой и второй серии, когда оперировали невесту и Шон искал способ удалить рак, а потом когда он дома думал как собрать пареньку челюсть. Да и сама дыра в челюсти стоит отдельной благодарности - сделали её просто шикарно. В третьей Шона почти не было, а в четвертой был мужик-параноик, там визуализировать было как бы нечего.
Сплюшка
Сплюшка
29 Oct 2019, 17:59 #
Я вот воспринимала отсутствие брата как знак того, что Шон эмоционально и психологически стабилен. Не могу разделить вашу радость по поводу его появления. А Лия не такая уж беззащитная няша, мне кажется если бы она вдруг решила побороться за внимание Шона, то она бы этой Карли фору десять раз дала.
otterstern
otterstern
28 Oct 2019, 23:48 #
Рада была снова увидеть Лию))
Шон был так взволнован новостью, что сбежал из квартиры, не убрав за собой.
otterstern
otterstern
29 Oct 2019, 00:51 #
Возникает ощущение, что Карли удивляет сложности Шона в отношении прикосновений? Она же должна понимать это исходя из его диагноза и истории с соприкосновением руками.
Почему Лиа поняла неудобство Шона с полуслова, а Карли нет?
Сплюшка
Сплюшка
29 Oct 2019, 18:02 #
Я думаю, что Карли понимает, но пока не нашла способ эту проблему обойти. Плюс чем больше она узнает Шона, тем больше его новых заморочек всплывает. Есть замечательный сериал Monk про детектива с кучей фобий. Там тоже очень классно показан этот период адаптации ассистента ко всем заморочкам босса.
siberiandragon
siberiandragon
29 Oct 2019, 23:30 #
@otterstern: не то что бы удивляет, просто Карли не делает к нему особого отношения и пытается выстроить честные, открытые взаимоотношения, что только хорошо. Лиа так-то тоже не особо церемонилась с его личными границами, на чем они и подружились
Blahh
Blahh
22 Nov 2019, 16:55 #
" - Дебби разрешает Вам трогать грудь?
- ... Да...
- Тогда Вам вообще не о чем беспокоиться. "

Улыбнул этот момент и выражение лица Глассмана )
nezabudka
nezabudka
03 Dec 2019, 19:54 #
@Blahh: да, я так смеялась!)))
Blahh
Blahh
04 Dec 2019, 00:58 #
@nezabudka: Аналогично )

очень забавная сцена. и разыграли замечательно.
sherbakova_vs
sherbakova_vs
23 Nov 2019, 22:57 #
Хорошая серия )♥️
LaaNa133
LaaNa133
PRO
24 Dec 2019, 01:54 #
Отличная серия!
Nikolaha
Nikolaha
11 Jan 2020, 23:19 #
Show comment
Dana_ptr
Dana_ptr
07 Apr 2020, 23:25 #
НЕЕЕТ КВИГМАЙЕР(Стив) ВЫРОС И УЖЕ НЕ ТАКОЙ МИЛАШКА ;(((((((((((((
Dana_ptr
Dana_ptr
07 Apr 2020, 23:26 #
Название серии просто пушка
Dana_ptr
Dana_ptr
07 Apr 2020, 23:27 #
-Однажды один хирург.. *история*
-Почему у вас шапочка того хирурга?

О Шон ❤️
Геворг
Геворг
PRO
13 Sep 2020, 22:34 #
Хоть и признаю, что оружие может быть более опасным, чем полезным, но вряд ли стоит пытаться заставить человека передумать за один день и без всяких обсуждений. Можно хотя бы убедиться, что человек знает правила пользования, чтобы никому случайно не навредить.
Scribhneoir
Scribhneoir
13 Dec 2020, 21:07 #
Пациентка Шона - просто прелесть! Вот у кого надо поучиться позитивного смотрения на мир! =) Жаль, что за кадром остались хорошие новости.
little_danica
little_danica
27 Dec 2020, 02:35 #
Почему никто не сказал, как перегриммировали Шона?😅 лицо бело-желтое, а шея розовая. Колоссальные отличия..
SiaSs
SiaSs
15 Jun 2021, 14:55 #
меня немного бесит девушка Шона, но так радостно было в момент, когда он потрогал ее за грудь

и появление в оранжевой шапочке до мурашек, ещё и брат рядом я не могу просто💔
а самое покрасите было, когда он придумал способ спасти своего пациента
это было великолепно
Mpha
Mpha
25 Oct 2021, 13:53 #
Ох как я устал наблюдать как с Мерфи постоянно нянчутся, так же не бывает в реальной жизни, ситуация вообще не показывает, как могло б быть в реальности, только вот вам иллюзия, что у вас и подружка сексапильная будет и девушка будет сама к вам инициативу проявлять и друзья в больнице будут все за вас, и просто так, потому что вы обаятельные. Да, я понимаю, что сериал и тут должно быть все более красивее чем в жизни, но не так же ванильно. Согласен с тем, что Шон умеет диагностировать и он гениален, но хирургия не его. Видимо должны так тянуть резину чтобы было интересно смотреть. Цепляют только интересные случаи и забавные моменты по типу «а вам дают трогать грудь?».
id231113678
id231113678
08 Jan 2022, 13:19 #
Мне так нравится как развивают персонажа Морган . Сначала возненавидела её, а сейчас стала одним из любимых персонажей
klaria
klaria
08 Aug 2023, 14:35 #
Can I check your other breast? 😅

Глассман немножко поднадоел уже. Сначала уговорами уговаривал Дебби, что им всенепременно нужно пожениться, а сейчас каждую серию всё ему не так.
Кстати он довольно ловко управляется с оружием. Будет какая-то предыстория?
Add a comment:
Ads