as much as possible Mamenkin's ending, according to the book Zuleikha stays with Ignatov, why does the film adaptation again separate them so cruelly?
I liked the series overall, but the epilogue sucks.
you_know_nothing
23 Apr 2020, 06:23 # Show original
although I misunderstood the MB and Ignatov, who remained to hand over the cases, will still join her...Anyway, why chew it like that? (((((
Sammy_chita
PRO
23 Apr 2020, 06:52 # Show original
Agree. They chewed it up for fools. I didn't like the series, but the actors are generally good, there are no complaints.
poohlaya
29 Apr 2020, 21:46 # Show original
@you_know_nothing: I didn't really understand the message of the film: on the one hand, the ending says, move and develop, and in general, the first part of the film is a kind of roadmovie. On the other hand, Zuleikha opens her eyes, which in fact does not particularly open them in the film, harnessing frankly unhealthy and codependent relationships with men, including her son. The film really shows Ivan's development more, but somehow after he finally desecrated in the middle of the series, it is unclear how their relationship with Zuleikha developed, because he bullied her for most of the film, and then bang, and they are a happy couple. It feels like the creators were trying to stuff it to the maximum and make a stripped-down clone of the Eternal Call. "Zuleikha disappears at noon"
Мася
23 Apr 2020, 09:32 # Show original
Ignatov opens his eyes. I haven't read the book, but judging by what a colleague who read it told me, this is another soap from the Russia 1 TV channel. And in fact it turned out that way. You don't have a single character height, Zuleikha just took and learned everything that she hadn't been able to do before. Ignatov, he just took and started loving Zuleikha from scratch and everything is explained simply by voice-over, apparently there was not enough money for a more or less detailed disclosure. Chulpan, as always, is beautiful, otherwise so-so.
the episode aired 23.04.2020
vk580524
23 Apr 2020, 18:54 # Show original
This is "Ignatov stayed to transfer cases" it's somehow not in the style of Russia 1. Both had to get off the platform. We didn't get enough.
poohlaya
29 Apr 2020, 21:47 # Show original
@vk580524: the actor was busy filming another soap, probably
Заяц
24 Apr 2020, 21:40 # Show original
The whole series is a guide on how to blow a very good story. Hurtful. I once read the book with pleasure.
doleskina
25 Apr 2020, 12:28 # Show original
It's a pity that I didn't read the book first. Now I'm reading with pleasure, but the series turned out to be average. The last episode turned out to be completely empty, a lot of water.
wasted_views
26 Apr 2020, 01:27 # Show original
It is very stupid that the grown-up son acquired a European appearance, and I don't care that there was an Asian eye cut.Well, they could have aged Zuleikha, well, at least give her hair gray.
Ever
27 Apr 2020, 16:54 # Show original
I was surprised that all the houses were finished with a board, when they supplied only logs. And where did the electricity come from in those years?
Hatjkva
29 Apr 2020, 17:37 # Show original
I was glad that Ikonnikov did not return to this squalor, but stayed in Paris.
JF87
04 May 2020, 04:47 # Show original
Zuleikha never opened her eyes, except for the moment when she understood her mother-in-law and her motives. It's a pity, the book is great, deep and meaningful. And the series...
aliolita
04 May 2020, 13:29 # Show original
It was necessary to spoil the book like that, God forgive me 😬
Demiant
11 May 2020, 04:38 # Show original
Almost disgusting soap, but, as always, great Chulpan
Inga_Neuro
PRO
17 May 2020, 03:42 #
Ну как можно было на роль повзрослевшего Иосифа-Юзуфа взять мужчину откровенно славянской внешности! Пипл схавает? Ну нельзя, нельзя так внаглую лошить зрителей! Совершенно отсутствует восприятие героя, ибо это подмена, а точнее - подстава на ровном месте. Зато всю семью татарами сделали.
vlandus
10 Jun 2020, 22:54 #
Книжка прикольная. Экранизация - на троечку.
play_me
23 Jul 2020, 17:35 #
Мда, давно я не видел что-то настолько же глупое. В каждой сцене персонажи выглядят как идиоты. Как можно было такое снять!? Столько нелогичных действий могут совершать только умственно-отсталые люди, написали такой сценарий просто конченные дауны
I liked the series overall, but the epilogue sucks.
(((((
The film really shows Ivan's development more, but somehow after he finally desecrated in the middle of the series, it is unclear how their relationship with Zuleikha developed, because he bullied her for most of the film, and then bang, and they are a happy couple. It feels like the creators were trying to stuff it to the maximum and make a stripped-down clone of the Eternal Call. "Zuleikha disappears at noon"
I haven't read the book, but judging by what a colleague who read it told me, this is another soap from the Russia 1 TV channel. And in fact it turned out that way. You don't have a single character height, Zuleikha just took and learned everything that she hadn't been able to do before. Ignatov, he just took and started loving Zuleikha from scratch and everything is explained simply by voice-over, apparently there was not enough money for a more or less detailed disclosure.
Chulpan, as always, is beautiful, otherwise so-so.