@Kookaburra: Compared to Julianne Moore, it's clearly better. Not that I think Moore is a bad actress, but her character in "Hannibal" was different from Starling from "lambs". And here at least you believe that this is a continuation of the story from The Silence of the Lambs.
@daken_k: in Hannibal, everything was different from the Silence of the Lambs, and for the worse. And thanks for the information, if so, then I'll take a chance to look
they started quite vividly, there is a desire to continue watching. the actress playing GG is still causing vague sensations, but the rest of the cast looks very organic.
The first episode is just the perfect introduction to the world of the series. We see Clarice wounded, tired, not recovered young girl, whose wounds are still strong, and she is again faced with human evil. And worst of all, evil is cold, calculating, the most terrible of all possible. But even in this situation, Clarice is great. The references, even in the very vile and cruel deeds of her colleagues, pleased her. Bill, this latest victim, her mother - all this fits seamlessly into the world of the series. The actress who was taken on the role of Clarice is beautiful to the point of outrage. She is organic, vaguely similar to Foster: some manner of speaking, holding her face, some of her movements are clearly inspired by the film. Rarely when the series pleases with the first series, I hope that they will continue the same way. It's a bit slow, but telling us in detail about Clarice and how she takes her place. A place she deserves.
I don't know what I expected, but it's a good start. Very atmospheric. Nightmares, like the fleur of sticky horror experienced by the main character, are felt very clearly. The references to the original are good. They didn't even forget about the letters.
In my opinion, a very good and cheerful beginning for the continuation of the beloved "Silence of the Lambs". A separate plus in the piggy bank to the actress who plays Clarice, for the southern accent that Jodie Foster asked in the film. We will evaluate further, with the release of the next series, how successful the hit and continuation of the original character will be. Everything suits me, at the moment. I will recommend it to fans of original films to watch. It's a pity, of course, that we definitely won't wait for Hannibal's cameo, because of copyright, but I'm sure the writers and directors won't let us down. They are already throwing in references and stills from the film, which is nice.
Run... run while you can. I watched the first season and realized how wrong I was. It is better to review "The Silence of the Lambs" once again. Don't waste your time
I watched the first episode. I will definitely look further. What did you like: - good caste; - dynamic plot; - well shot. But, e, the first case is a contract murder. Somehow the impression was blurred, I thought they would start right away with a hot one: with a new serial killer and an exciting investigation for several episodes. Plus, the scene with the melee of Clarissa and the specialist seems unlikely. Of course, the FBI trains excellent specialists, but once, and Clarissa laid (presumably) an agent of the special services?)
@makakischna: before that, he was dragged 4 times with a piece of mirror into his leg and arm, then he got hit on the back of the head - this equalizes the chances well :)
disappointing, insipid pilot I understand that this is all my inflated expectations, the series is not about Hannibal at all — but I wanted exquisitely confusing mindgames and ambiguous ethical dilemmas. the actress is not bad in the role of a young agent with severe ptsd, but I agree that the dialogues and the script are very weak.
@h2guy: and at first I thought it was Will Graham from the TV series Hannibal kills girls. I haven't completely switched to cannibalism yet, just biting.
The actress tries hard, even in intonation and voice in places are very similar to Jodie Foster. But there is no charisma, unmemorable. There is no episode. This maximally far-fetched story of her appointment over the head of everyone in the Bureau in the first ten minutes of screen time, the classic "I am a talented newcomer among an experienced team who does not believe in me", immediately into the thick of events, conspiracies around ... The shooting did not go far from Criminal Minds. Perhaps the series and the actress will still be revealed, but the pilot is weak for such a primary source.
I didn't expect any "bomb" from the series, but here you are, the pilot flew so that I didn't notice and it's a pity that it's not Netflix and not all the series at once. The actress was picked up perfectly, under the type of Jody, and she plays so far quite according to the character of the character being served. I like the setting, the color scheme too. The fact that the first case would turn out to be like this was already clear, no one would jump off the bat with a new serial number. But here it is just interesting how and where they will lead next, so that the boss finally begins to trust Clarissa's flair. CBS, of course, is always more procedural and the description kind of hints... but you can enter a common line with a new serial number against the background of other cases. We will see, so far, a very good start, very. The main thing is not to fail.
@Sameen: In the Hannibal series, they immediately started with serial numbers and almost every episode was added. The serial number on the serial number and the serial number drives.
On the one hand, there are many references to the original Silence of the lambs, on the other - a plot in the spirit of Thinking like a criminal (what we wanted, this is CBS). The actress seems to be trying to play "that Clarissa", but so far something is missing. In general, it is watchable. I hope the series will develop more interesting further.
A weak beginning. Where does this rating of the series come from? Only inexperienced viewers, fans of the TV series "Think like a criminal" can like it - they solve a crime there in 1-2 days. Shoals, shoals: "The car has no numbers," although cars in the USA can only have one number, usually in the back, the dude got there. Specialists and snipers do not leave any traces at all, and here lies a greasy filter from a cigarette with DNA. The funniest and most improbable is the "fight" scene: the specialist has a bunch of knives at hand, probably, and has his own (he could just take it off quietly, and not fight with him). It's the same with Clarissa - instead of strangling her, I could just stab her, the Scriptwriters really don't have knives at hand. If it goes like this, it will be closed after the first season.
@Chizhikpyzhik: Blacklist and Clarissa are different studios. CBS in the middle of the first season closed good series, for example, Thieves of extra class or Chips, money, lawyers.
A great start, I didn't even know that the series was being prepared, I stumbled upon it by accident, I didn't expect anything. But the atmosphere, the shooting, the actress - hooked right away. It is very interesting what will happen next
The attitude is ambiguous - sometimes the dialogues and behavior of some characters cause confusion. I liked Clarissa's young partner - in my opinion, he looks the most organic in the series. I'm waiting for the second episode to form a final opinion on whether it's worth watching further or not.
Somehow it seemed strange to me that, before they had even really examined the corpses, they had already so categorically declared that the killer was a serial killer. Isn't it usually the opposite, the cops try to hide it to the last, so as not to sow panic among people?
the first impression is positive. I'm glad that the actress got, the references and flashbacks are pleasing (because they exist), and the fact that the case is not related to a serial killer is sudden and unexpected, it certainly attracted attention with this, too - they did not go on the same rails. most often, gg in such series are brilliant, sharp-tongued, self-confident singles. and here a touching, as they wrote above, wounded, sweet girl, immediately got herself well, if not a friend, then an ally for sure.
In principle, not bad. I liked the main character, the plot is interesting. No plots for perverts. And it would have been a great series if it had been filmed 15 years ago. And so, the boss is naturally sexist. Everyone is overly sensitive. I remember the behavior of the surviving girl, I will never believe that she would have turned into this. And Clarissa is suddenly running around with her inarticulate sufferings. But you can watch
@ramzy: it is also not clear such a change in the behavior of the surviving victim. It seems that Bill didn't mock her much, only kept her in a pit, and not for so long that they would go crazy. Maybe she wasn't quite herself before.
I will definitely look further. However, the actress does not reach Jodie Foster. Stylistics is directly opposite to the aesthetics of "Hannibal". But it keeps you on your toes
I liked the pilot, they guessed right with the actress. Of course, willy-nilly you compare with Jodie Foster, but this one is also good. At least it does not cause "rejection" like Moore The atmosphere is oppressive, the idea is catchy. I hope it will stay that way until the end of the season and they won't merge it) Definitely I will look further
It is very difficult to take seriously a TV series with such relations within the FBI, it is practically a military organization with strict subordination, no one there is a fuck-up when communicating with the press, and even more so does not violate direct orders from superiors. The prosecutor cannot appoint any person to detectives/FBI employees, it's a damn different organization, it's a supervisory authority, so it doesn't work anywhere.
@mononooke: Do you think the FBI is a very serious organization? They smear the handles of the drawers with cream, and then they cackle like teenagers. There is no seriousness there.
The actress came in whole and at once. She fits the role well, and she has charisma. As for the series itself, it is still difficult to say anything definite about the first series. The beginning is quite good, let's see how it goes further. I hope the series will not sink to the bottom, as it happens with many TV shows now – they start for health, and finish for the repose
Dialogues are kick-ass, as if they were written by an excellent tenth grader without imagination. It sounds absolutely cardboard, both in English and in voice acting. The way the group's dislike of Clarissa was shown is just a deuce, as if this is not a sequel to the cult psychological thriller at the time, but an amateur production, where everything is clumsy and head-on, so that the casual viewer understands exactly what it's about.
the overall picture and atmosphere are quite in the spirit of Silence ... and the motivation of the heroes is what no, but how annoying are small mistakes and shoals, pronouncing actions and just stupid actions of people in the frame... a little weak for the first episode ((
Just in case, I clarify that I have not watched the film "The Silence of the Lambs" and the same "Hannibal". In general, it was not boring to watch. The investigation is fascinating, but to confidently say that it is serial is somehow strange. I liked Clarissa, I'm sorry for her. She is under such pressure, and the FBI is mocked, which causes sadness and anger. Maybe it seemed to me alone that the moments with photographers for some reason reminded me of the beginning of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, where there was also a moment with photographers. The comparison may be strange. I hope it will be even more interesting in the future.
If you look at it like another detective series, then I don't see anything terrible. But if you look at it as a continuation of the Lambs, then I'm sorry-I'm sorry, don't make me laugh. Those who praise it exactly like that movie, I think you can sell a stone if the famous brand is printed on it. You're talking bullshit, comrades😂
@alyonapetrova88: And who says that the series is a continuation of the Lambs? This series is specifically about Clarissa, about her mental state and her attempts to gain weight among those who actually don't put her in anything and believe that "the new girl was lucky." And among those who try to dictate to her what to do. Her overcoming of the fact that in the first case she had to face two maniacs, she had to shoot, that she would continue to live with this.
@Szayel: I'm terribly sorry, but we are talking about Clarissa Starling, it is from the lambs and it was after the events of this film, and even the footage was reshot - this is called a sequel. And above, some commentators write that this is the level of that movie and Judy Foster. Which is just ridiculous :) This is a separate ordinary detective series that stole the character's name and a few events from the hit to attract an audience. And your comment would be appropriate if the series were called, say, Natasha Govnareva, a newcomer to the FBI, who needs to prove her place and has a traumatic experience with a maniac. And I would say, so this is not the "silence of the lambs". :)
@alyonapetrova88: do you see for yourself what you are writing? The series is ABOUT CLARISSA, it doesn't have to be the same as the movie. It shows exactly Clarissa herself and her life, her experiences. Nobody stole anything. And the actress in the pilot series shows herself well. And yes, if you love the beautiful Jodie Foster so much, you would write her name correctly, otherwise it looks like she has merged with Julianne Moore.
@alyonapetrova88: you're completely right, it's not Clarissa, but some kind of Clara. well, there is no Hannibal, otherwise the fannibals did not survive such shit. and so we just laugh and wait until they close
@alyonapetrova88: I recently reviewed "The Silence of the Lambs", and somehow now the film doesn't seem to be such a super-masterpiece. About on a par with this series, well, maybe a little better.
я ждала большего от пилота, надеюсь в дальнейшем не разочарует сериал. я ждала чего-то в стиле сериала Ганнибал(потому что Кларису представили как по типу Уила Гремма, что она по-особенному видит портрет убийств и убийц), но чет далеко не похожее, да и не лучше его. и ничего такого вау-захватывающего в делах или в представлениях, раскрытиях и т.д.
мдаааааааа...я ожидала что-то в духе сериала Ганнибал...ну или Охотников за разумом.а тут .......... столько трепа, ужасных коллег и почти расследования то нет и блин..наемник имитирует серийника, чтоб точно всех жертв связали и докопались, почему их убили...нельзя было сжечь, закопать, утопить, изуродовать...хреееень только спецагенты так курят....чееееесь субординацию не соблюдать - ну не знаю... и божечки...та самая собачка - это вот понравилось. как и флешбеки
@zula22: Верное замечание. Действительно, имитировать одного серийника в трех убийствах, чтоб наверняка эти убийства связали между собой. А так подстроили бы как ограбление или несчастный случай - никто бы не связал их в одно дело.
@zula22: Хотя мы немного поторопились с замечанием. В 11-ой серии объясняется, почему именно выбрали подделать под серийного убийцу, а не под рядовые, незаметные убийства.
Серия унылая. Персонажи пресные. За рассуждениями Клариссы наблюдать абсолютно не интересно. Тем более что, они заключаются в пересказе нами уже увиденного. Например: Мы видим труп женщины с маникюром. Кларисса: "Маникюр и педикюр...Она следила за собой". Зачем говорить банальные вещи? С киношной Клариссой она ни в какое сравнение не идёт. Это кто угодно, но только не Кларисса. Если сравнивать с другим сериалом "Ганнибал", то этот сериал ему не то что уступает, он и рядом не стоит. Хороший сериал должен "брать тебя в заложники" с 1 серии (бывают и исключения), чего не случилось в данном случае. Удовольствия от увиденного я не получил, но ещё пару-тройку серий (возможно даже весь сезон) просмотрю, чтобы составить окончательное мнение.
I hope they will keep the bar further and not slide into endless psychotherapy sessions.
the actress playing GG is still causing vague sensations, but the rest of the cast looks very organic.
The references, even in the very vile and cruel deeds of her colleagues, pleased her. Bill, this latest victim, her mother - all this fits seamlessly into the world of the series.
The actress who was taken on the role of Clarice is beautiful to the point of outrage. She is organic, vaguely similar to Foster: some manner of speaking, holding her face, some of her movements are clearly inspired by the film.
Rarely when the series pleases with the first series, I hope that they will continue the same way. It's a bit slow, but telling us in detail about Clarice and how she takes her place. A place she deserves.
The references to the original are good. They didn't even forget about the letters.
A separate plus in the piggy bank to the actress who plays Clarice, for the southern accent that Jodie Foster asked in the film. We will evaluate further, with the release of the next series, how successful the hit and continuation of the original character will be.
Everything suits me, at the moment. I will recommend it to fans of original films to watch. It's a pity, of course, that we definitely won't wait for Hannibal's cameo, because of copyright, but I'm sure the writers and directors won't let us down. They are already throwing in references and stills from the film, which is nice.
What did you like:
- good caste;
- dynamic plot;
- well shot.
But, e, the first case is a contract murder. Somehow the impression was blurred, I thought they would start right away with a hot one: with a new serial killer and an exciting investigation for several episodes.
Plus, the scene with the melee of Clarissa and the specialist seems unlikely. Of course, the FBI trains excellent specialists, but once, and Clarissa laid (presumably) an agent of the special services?)
I understand that this is all my inflated expectations, the series is not about Hannibal at all — but I wanted exquisitely confusing mindgames and ambiguous ethical dilemmas.
the actress is not bad in the role of a young agent with severe ptsd, but I agree that the dialogues and the script are very weak.
There is no episode. This maximally far-fetched story of her appointment over the head of everyone in the Bureau in the first ten minutes of screen time, the classic "I am a talented newcomer among an experienced team who does not believe in me", immediately into the thick of events, conspiracies around ... The shooting did not go far from Criminal Minds. Perhaps the series and the actress will still be revealed, but the pilot is weak for such a primary source.
The funniest and most improbable is the "fight" scene: the specialist has a bunch of knives at hand, probably, and has his own (he could just take it off quietly, and not fight with him). It's the same with Clarissa - instead of strangling her, I could just stab her, the Scriptwriters really don't have knives at hand. If it goes like this, it will be closed after the first season.
— she has a ring on her finger ...
- her husband loved her...
Somehow nothing, to be honest.
most often, gg in such series are brilliant, sharp-tongued, self-confident singles. and here a touching, as they wrote above, wounded, sweet girl, immediately got herself well, if not a friend, then an ally for sure.
The atmosphere is oppressive, the idea is catchy. I hope it will stay that way until the end of the season and they won't merge it)
Definitely I will look further
In general, it was not boring to watch. The investigation is fascinating, but to confidently say that it is serial is somehow strange. I liked Clarissa, I'm sorry for her. She is under such pressure, and the FBI is mocked, which causes sadness and anger. Maybe it seemed to me alone that the moments with photographers for some reason reminded me of the beginning of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, where there was also a moment with photographers. The comparison may be strange.
I hope it will be even more interesting in the future.
But if you look at it as a continuation of the Lambs, then I'm sorry-I'm sorry, don't make me laugh. Those who praise it exactly like that movie, I think you can sell a stone if the famous brand is printed on it. You're talking bullshit, comrades😂
This is a separate ordinary detective series that stole the character's name and a few events from the hit to attract an audience.
And your comment would be appropriate if the series were called, say, Natasha Govnareva, a newcomer to the FBI, who needs to prove her place and has a traumatic experience with a maniac. And I would say, so this is not the "silence of the lambs". :)
And yes, if you love the beautiful Jodie Foster so much, you would write her name correctly, otherwise it looks like she has merged with Julianne Moore.
столько трепа, ужасных коллег и почти расследования то нет
и блин..наемник имитирует серийника, чтоб точно всех жертв связали и докопались, почему их убили...нельзя было сжечь, закопать, утопить, изуродовать...хреееень
только спецагенты так курят....чееееесь
субординацию не соблюдать - ну не знаю...
и божечки...та самая собачка - это вот понравилось. как и флешбеки
The music was nice btw.
Clarice's therapist is played by the actor that played a very unstable gut in Frontier (2016). *deep sigh* I miss that guy.
С киношной Клариссой она ни в какое сравнение не идёт. Это кто угодно, но только не Кларисса.
Если сравнивать с другим сериалом "Ганнибал", то этот сериал ему не то что уступает, он и рядом не стоит.
Хороший сериал должен "брать тебя в заложники" с 1 серии (бывают и исключения), чего не случилось в данном случае. Удовольствия от увиденного я не получил, но ещё пару-тройку серий (возможно даже весь сезон) просмотрю, чтобы составить окончательное мнение.