@superime: and it doesn't bother you a bit that Aramis is white and Isaac is Indian in the Characters?????You should at least Google the cast before writing such nonsense...
An excellent adaptation of Dumas's novel for original British television! so convincing that every time I mentioned a French name or a city, I wondered what France had to do with it if the series was about English medieval special forces?) but it doesn't matter that the Musketeers turned out to be a little more English than they should, right?! the main thing is that the characters are conveyed very accurately.The actors are talented and charismatic, the adventures are exciting. what else is needed for the happiness of a TV series fan))
This is such a free interpretation of a famous work that they have only names in common with Dumas. Historically, almost no hits, such utter crap is shown in places that I watched episode 1 with great difficulty. The Musketeers never fought with their hands, much less with their feet, they were all nobles, and kicking is plebeian. My lady with the demand for a bath- well, this is absolutely out of the question!!! Yes, no one ever washed there in those centuries, it's a well-known fact! And mestizos and obvious Black roots, it just killed me. Honestly, I don't understand at all why spend a lot of money on expensive costumes and make such an absurd series.
@oakhmedova: Do you seriously think that the nobles in any situation cared only about not looking "plebeian"? ))) Read the real memoirs, be surprised! Here is one example of a "duel" from Tallemand de Reo: "A certain nobleman, a Huguenot, named Perponchet, who served as a captain in Villa Cotre under Marshal d'estreux, once commanding the gendarmes of this Marshal in the detachment that Monsieur d'Arpajon led to Lorraine, in some kind of scuffle that broke out due to accommodation, received from a relative of Monsieur d'Arpajon received several blows with a cane, which the offender did not really want to admit. Arpajon decided to bring about a reconciliation between them; but on the day when it was to take place, Perponchet gathered all his gendarmes at headquarters, told them to hide their pistols under their cloaks; and when they gave him a stick in his hand, he struck with it half a dozen hard blows to the one who apologized to him, and he did nothing I couldn't help it, because the force was on the side of Perponshe. They stood up for him, and the matter ended in a draw. " If hitting with a stick is better than with a foot - well, I do not know ...)))
Yes, it turned out to be a very loose interpretation on the theme of the original book, but compared to the 2011 film, it's almost canon) If you don't expect the series to match the original or the story, it's very, very good.
@BATCOH: In the third season, the echoes of the story are audible to the naked ear. Only Aramis is like Mazarin (but this is more logical than Anna's relationship with d'Artagnan, as in the "Iron Mask"! ))) Priests have always been in her line. XD Some cardinals were courted by four pieces!)
I want to scream like a girl. THE MUSKETEERS! whatever the facts and realities, it's just nice to see your favorite characters on the screen in such a decent performance.
-Он знает девиз мушкетёров "каждый сам за себя!" - прекрасно)) Это одно из любимых произведений Дюма, но это не значит, что все экранизации должны идти чётко по книге) Мне нравится эта адаптация, продолжаю смотреть)
Разрешите обратиться со странным (может быть) вопросом!)) Гастон Орлеанский (брат короля Людовика XIII) играет сколько-нибудь значительную роль в сюжете сериала?
Сериал интересен, зацепил. Только вопросы к звуку. Либо он так пострадал при переводе, либо изначально был не на высоте. Часто запаздывает. Да и немного странен, на самом деле
Когда включала сериал была настроена ну очень скептически, люблю книгу и советскую экранизацию. Но пилот очень зашел, вообще не воспринимается как роман Дюма, но, как ни странно, это мне вообще не показалась минусом, даже, скорее, наоборот.
Кстати, Портос здесь мулат не случайно, по некоторым данным, Дюма писал Портоса со своего отца - Тома-Александра Дюма https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%94%D1%8E%D0%BC%D0%B0,_%D0%A2%D0%BE%D0%BC%D0%B0-%D0%90%D0%BB%D0%B5%D0%BA%D1%81%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B4%D1%80
"Родился в колонии Сан-Доминго, на плантации Геноде близ Жереми. Его родителями были владелец плантации — француз Антуан Делиль Дави де ля Пайетри и чернокожая гаитянская рабыня Мария-Сессета Дюма."
@DoctorHolmes: спасибо. Приятно, когда в исторических фильмах-сериалах, особенно экранизациях, небелый персонаж имеет исторические основы, а не diversity for the sake of diversity.
сериал понравился, на самих героев приятно смотреть. Ну да, не совсем те мушкетеры, что в советском сериале, но вполне харизматичные. Смотреть лучше не сравнивая ни с чем, как отдельное самостоятельное произведение. Отличный приключенческий сериал
Начал смотреть ничего не зная. Начало заинтриговало - впрямь поверил, что мушкетёры в этом варианте разбойники, и думал - д'Артаньян с ними подружится или нет. И был "рад", что их просто подставили =D P. S. Хорошо, что не стали строить интригу сезона на том, кто таинственная дама из прошлого Атоса. Интересно, как тут расскажут их историю - в советской версии кажись лишь в общих чертах рассказали что да как было.
При просмотре не нужно сильно думать о книге и реальной истории. Просто наслаждаться красивой картинкой, актерами и саундом со знакомыми персонажами. Приключенческий сериал, где есть храбрость, любовь, интриги и главное дружба. Я получила огромное удовольствие; рада что наконец посмотрела его)
I've been watching the series for three years, but I just found out that Isaac is Aramis.
The Musketeers never fought with their hands, much less with their feet, they were all nobles, and kicking is plebeian.
My lady with the demand for a bath- well, this is absolutely out of the question!!! Yes, no one ever washed there in those centuries, it's a well-known fact!
And mestizos and obvious Black roots, it just killed me.
Honestly, I don't understand at all why spend a lot of money on expensive costumes and make such an absurd series.
Here is one example of a "duel" from Tallemand de Reo:
"A certain nobleman, a Huguenot, named Perponchet, who served as a captain in Villa Cotre under Marshal d'estreux, once commanding the gendarmes of this Marshal in the detachment that Monsieur d'Arpajon led to Lorraine, in some kind of scuffle that broke out due to accommodation, received from a relative of Monsieur d'Arpajon received several blows with a cane, which the offender did not really want to admit. Arpajon decided to bring about a reconciliation between them; but on the day when it was to take place, Perponchet gathered all his gendarmes at headquarters, told them to hide their pistols under their cloaks; and when they gave him a stick in his hand, he struck with it half a dozen hard blows to the one who apologized to him, and he did nothing I couldn't help it, because the force was on the side of Perponshe. They stood up for him, and the matter ended in a draw. "
If hitting with a stick is better than with a foot - well, I do not know ...)))
If you don't expect the series to match the original or the story, it's very, very good.
whatever the facts and realities, it's just nice to see your favorite characters on the screen in such a decent performance.
Это одно из любимых произведений Дюма, но это не значит, что все экранизации должны идти чётко по книге)
Мне нравится эта адаптация, продолжаю смотреть)
"Родился в колонии Сан-Доминго, на плантации Геноде близ Жереми. Его родителями были владелец плантации — француз Антуан Делиль Дави де ля Пайетри и чернокожая гаитянская рабыня Мария-Сессета Дюма."
P. S. Хорошо, что не стали строить интригу сезона на том, кто таинственная дама из прошлого Атоса. Интересно, как тут расскажут их историю - в советской версии кажись лишь в общих чертах рассказали что да как было.