Ads

s05e04 — Siren Song

Charmed — s05e04 — Siren Song

My rating

Rate
Rate the shows you've watched and get up-to-date recommendations
4.559
MyShows
(780)
Duration: 43 min.
Released: 06.10.200206.10.2002 20:00
Watched by: 90 36476.27%
5 season
s05e04
s04e22 - Witch Way Now?
s05e01 - A Witch's Tail (1)
s05e02 - A Witch's Tail (2)
s05e03 - Happily Ever After
s05e04 - Siren Song
s05e05 - Witches in Tights
s05e06 - The Eyes Have It
s05e07 - Sympathy for the Demon
s05e08 - A Witch in Time

Discussion of the 4 episode of the 5 season
Discuss this episode
26

Anya_Vinogradova
Anya_Vinogradova
04 Mar 2016, 00:58 #
Awesome series!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+28
DrZIG
DrZIG
18 Mar 2016, 06:23 #
Phoebe somehow doesn't reason correctly at the end of the episode. In the same way, she can fall under the influence of another "siren" and cause the murder of Cole or someone else. That's why I don't see any problems in their relationship. At the very least, they would have taken it and together they would have come up with a way to lose their strength.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+93
nevereats
nevereats
23 Sep 2016, 03:13 #
how nice to see an actress in the series, who I loved so much in O.S. - Melinda Clark
still really liked me as a child)) a spectacular woman)
Reply
Show
who liked?
+21
A_S_
A_S_
08 Nov 2016, 01:38 #
I love all the sisters, and especially Phoebe, but how she pisses me off in this episode. I love Cole so much, in particular the Phoebe-Cole couple. Phoebe can be understood too, but what about her love for him? He's trying, isn't that the main thing? I don't care that he's evil, if he's trying for his beloved. Love will save the world (c) isn't that what they say?
Reply
Show
who liked?
+72
julia_tachynska
julia_tachynska
18 Mar 2017, 23:04 #
Ohhh, Mother Donnavan, sirens...

I'm just nostalgic for DV))
Reply
Show
who liked?
+41
by_banan
by_banan
21 Dec 2023, 13:19 #
And I thought what a familiar face
Reply
Show
who liked?
+2
cabaret_boy
cabaret_boy
07 Jul 2017, 15:02 #
Melinda Clark is the beautiful Amanda from Nikita)))
Reply
Show
who liked?
+11
daanko_bro
daanko_bro
13 Jul 2017, 20:51 #
allons-y!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+24
lis_pushistyj
lis_pushistyj
18 Oct 2017, 15:08 #
4x12 Arsonist: So I'm bad if I have to use my power to serve evil? Piper: No, that's not how our forces work. by themselves, they are not bad, not evil, it all depends on how we apply them.
5x4 Cole: I've done a lot of good things, killed demons, organized a charity. Phoebe: It doesn't matter who you're helping, if you're using demonic powers, nothing else matters.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+121
angledy
angledy
14 Nov 2017, 23:53 #
@Stollenwurm: L - logic.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+52
angledy
angledy
14 Nov 2017, 23:54 #
- Did you get my flowers?
- yes. "I'm sorry I tried to strangle you" - it's not often that a florist has to write such postcards)
Reply
Show
who liked?
+67
Starry_Night
Starry_Night
11 Feb 2018, 02:38 #
That's why I REALLY dislike the fifth season—so it's for the terrible injustice towards Cole in each episode. Of course, before, Phoebe and the others were often wrong about his actions, but after killing the Owner, it became completely unbearable. Therefore, each episode, especially the finale, is accompanied by wild sadness for me. As for Phoebe herself, she was terribly disgusted with her illogical behavior and words. She's been contradicting herself for the last three seasons. (in situations with Cole)
Reply
Show
who liked?
+80
chch93
chch93
18 Feb 2018, 20:29 #
Melinda Clark is a gorgeous lady, always plays spectacular women. What's in the O.S., what's in The Vampire Diaries. Every time I'm happy to see her in one of the episodes of my favorite TV series.
My favorite Paige is invariably reckless and, of course, as categorical as possible. Since I'm a witch, that's it, I put on an Amazonian costume and ride with a spear, poking at demons, forgetting how much compassion I have for others. It was good that the sisters and Leo were able to bring her back to the path of helping the world in time, not only with a bottle of potion in their hands, but also with an ordinary friendly conversation.
The child has a special sense of humor, bubbles instead of burping, flowers instead of tearing flesh, what a sweetheart! Very vividly, well, succinctly transferred the typical problems of a couple during pregnancy to the magical theme of the series. Leo has become less sensitive than usual, although on the other hand, he really can't give up his duty, his job, but at the same time he could have spent a little more time on her, and not shrug it off, considering all this nonsense And Piper has a typical female trouble, especially in the acute period of the explosion hormones: I don't have enough attention, you don't need our family at all, and other emotional outbursts sometimes out of the blue. They really forgot how to listen to each other. The baby solved the situation amazingly by swapping their places and letting them visit the other's skin, giving them a real sense of what each of them feels, learning to understand each other more and thereby solve their problem. And it's also a great opportunity to once again appreciate Krause's comedic talent.: Leo under hormones is something with something XD
Reply
Show
who liked?
+17
chch93
chch93
18 Feb 2018, 20:31 #
@chch93: Like a thousand million times before, it's incredibly difficult for me to look at Foal like this, and at the same time, how beautifully they place these accents. How much there is between them unfinished, unspoken, left to burn out in the minds of both. I can understand Phoebe with how afraid she is to believe him again, to get burned again, how stubbornly she does not see how much he is trying to become a better person for her and for her. And she's trying to make a weak attempt to admit that he's improved, but everything around her, her sisters, their past failure with him, all screams that this should not be done. In these attempts to deny her love for him, she only digs deeper and declares absolutely illogical things. Power is just a tool, the color of a plus or minus is given to him by the person himself, and she should know this like no one else. What difference does it make where he got this gift if he uses it for good? My heart breaks when I look at Cole, so drooping, so crushed, who no longer knows what to do if only she would believe and come back to him. How hard and stupid it is, even though there are so many disappointments and mistakes between them, but love will heal everything, only she. It's terrible to look at their broken souls and realize that maybe they won't stick together again.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+14
tvseriesnerd
tvseriesnerd
PRO
25 Jul 2018, 22:05 #
Kiss this, bitch!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+10
Jptichka
Jptichka
PRO
24 May 2019, 18:24 #
Everyone is annoyed by Phoebe, someone writes that you can understand, but they don't understand. Lol.
Guys, Cole tried to kill her a million and one times, then turned her into evil, deliberately fueled it. He's a demon. Phoebe is sure that he won't change, and as we all know, that's the way it is. At any moment, his powers can get the better of him, as a master, and nothing will save them. She can't trust him anymore. And, on the contrary, she is very strong, she is well done, this is not throwing just like that out of the blue, it is not easy to stop loving a person, but if she does not see herself with him, then it is necessary.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+20
fb1077970
fb1077970
28 Apr 2021, 15:50 #
Thank God I saw at least one such opinion. I understand Phoebe very well. This relationship is toxic from start to finish. And she tries her best to get rid of them, but they don't let her do it. Cole looks like a typical aggressor in a couple, who, if transferred to ordinary life, but if he gets drunk, he beats his wife, and in the morning he kneels, begging for forgiveness, presents flowers and gifts, and also swears that this will never happen again. But a month goes by, and everything goes in a circle. So here, Cole is all regretful, but under the influence of something, everything starts all over again. And Phoebe, who has been in the role of victim/savior for so long, saying that I'm going to change him, finally wants to get out of this solid circle.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+13
fb1077970
fb1077970
28 Apr 2021, 15:57 #
Of course, I understand those people who say that this is how it is possible to destroy such a couple. And what about their great love. Love generally wins over everything and everyone. I also admired their couple as a child, it seemed to me that they had a great love story. But only now I grew up and at a conscious age, after reviewing the series, I realized how destructive and toxic these relationships were. In life, you need to stay away from such people as much as possible
Reply
Show
who liked?
+11
id169356578
id169356578
07 May 2021, 20:41 #
You're right, as a child, I also thought that their love was such a strong feeling. And how she resented in season 5 that Phoebe was pushing Cole away, even though she loved him.

After a few years, I finally understood. Their relationship is really toxic.
The last straw for Phoebe was when he turned her into the queen of evil. Although under the strong will of the owner.

Conversely, Phoebe is very strong in spirit for me now, because you must agree, it's not so easy to take and blunt your so strong feelings.

For me, she has grown by another 1 step as a character. And no matter how hard it is, she's doing the right thing.

I hope people will look at their relationship from a different angle. And they will actually understand them.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+9
bustrsss
bustrsss
15 Aug 2019, 02:24 #
Phoebe used to say "there is good in you" "you can change" "it doesn't matter who you were and what actions you did, the main thing is who you are now" now " evil is inside you. This is your essence and good deeds will not change that." Yeah. It's clear Phoebe went through a lot, was on the side of evil and all that. But Cole was going to give up his master's powers for her, and she stopped him. And now that's it.:((it is sad that such a strong couple, who have survived many trials, is being destroyed.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+31
keyfro
keyfro
19 Jul 2020, 18:22 #
I'm the only one who doesn't understand how Cole, such a super strong demon, couldn't resist the Siren's charms?
Reply
Show
who liked?
+23
Hotchocolate
Hotchocolate
25 Oct 2020, 05:06 #
Leo is so funny in this episode 😂😂
Reply
Show
who liked?
+28
SantaJul
SantaJul
PRO
07 Apr 2022, 22:37 #
Лео говорит, что если бы Коул не спас Мелиссу, она бы не смогла получить крылья и стать Хранителем. Что-то я не вижу логики, ведь:

«Хранителями становятся лишь наиболее достойные люди; после смерти это им предлагается высшими магами добра, старейшинами. Человек может отказаться, и тогда он вновь станет смертным»

Не в первый раз мы уже слышим, что у Лео подопечные будущие Хранители, но зачем это надо все, если Хранителями они становятся только после смерти?
Reply
Show
who liked?
+7
ChandlerLi
ChandlerLi
01 Sep 2023, 23:13 #
Она должна в будущем, что-то совершить, что поможет ей стать хранителем. Мб спасет кучу людей, будет помогать проблемным людям или сиротам и тп
Reply
Show
who liked?
+4
hellyafckinright
hellyafckinright
30 May 2023, 16:04 #
многие жалеют Коула и осуждают Фиби, но разве так сложно её понять? она миллион раз давала ему шанс, доверяя своим чувствам и к чему это привело? ей пришлось собственными руками убить свою любовь. а теперь он возвращается и весьма навязчиво пытается доказать , что он хороший.. неужели она сразу должна броситься ему на шею, подвергать себя и сестер опасности?… ей как минимум нужно дать время, и тогда возможно она сама придет к выводу, что Коул изменился (хотя где гарантия , что какие то силы янова не склонят его ко злу). Фиби изменилась, повзрослела, поняла , что отношения это не только любовь, но и рациональность.
Reply
Show
who liked?
+5
bazilesaya3
bazilesaya3
PRO
05 Mar 19:35 #
Пайпер очень красивая и свежая в этой серии! Понравилась идея обменяться с мужчиной проблемами и делами, жаль в жизни так нельзя!
Reply
Show
who liked?
+4
Add a comment:
Ads