When this sheriff first bent over the body, I thought I imagined he looked like Jack. And then yes! I was right. Everyone was tricked with Lucas, but initially it was clear that he was not Jack.
However, the dynamics between the real and fake Jack is not entirely clear. Was this Lucas just a fan of Jack and did nothing but want to take his fame for himself? It's not entirely clear.
Discussion: Season 3, Episode 21 Join the Discussion
2Everyone was tricked with Lucas, but initially it was clear that he was not Jack.