Cool ending! I want more! Ben Stiller burn! I've been waiting until the last moment for this moment when he sees a photo of his wife. Why did Lumon need Mark so much that they staged a fake death and pushed him to split up? Well, the fact that the experiment was conducted not only inside, but also outside is understandable. Although, there are still a lot of riddles
@mary_rozental: and they check it all the time - candles from the basement, which Harmony took from Gemma's things and forced them to hold a session with them, then a meeting in a narrow corridor. Moreover, Harmony told Milchik that she was "trying something new with Miss Casey"
@Saen: it's not a fact that the death was fake, I believe that a psychologist with the appearance of his wife may be a clone, or something like that, because: 1) She was always "awakened" for half an hour, as she told Mark herself. And the day where she followed Heli was "the longest day" 2) The scene with her "Dismissal" was shown in too suspiciously detailed detail, and this black corridor through which she passed, and which Irving always draws, well, it looks very much like some kind of cremation chamber, or something like that. The visual and audio accompaniment clearly hinted at its destruction or death. Maybe the clone was destroyed because he failed? 3) Why should Mark's wife participate in this experiment? First to get acquainted, have a relationship, get married, then to imitate death, to introduce yourself a little bit into Mark's activities in Lumen. Check that the separation is working and he doesn't remember her? that's it? There are other, simpler ways to conduct such an experiment, without simulating death. 4) A company with so much money and such technologies can easily conduct genetic experiments and grow clones. Maybe this is exactly what our heroes are doing in processing macro data, looking for numbers based on their emotions, and sorting them, thus creating "souls" for future clones, or, if not clones, then for new divided ones. (but this is a completely fantastic version). Why would they do that? It's all about the company's charter. Aegon wanted to create an ideal society, obedient, utopian, and blindly following his views. In the last episode, Heli's father said that "Soon everyone will be separated." That is, they will implant implants for everyone, and switch to the "ideologically correct version of themselves."
@Castle: It's possible that his wife is in a coma. And somehow the chip allowed her to come out of the coma. Maybe she's in a coma behind that door. As an option.
@Castle: Some of the corporation's employees are not divided or divided, but not like the rest. This is indicated by their status of "not full-time". For example, Casey, Mark's wife, has exactly the same mode of operation. But her robotic and emotionless behavior hints at something. Perhaps there is a clue behind that door. Perhaps their consciousness is not just divided, but there is no part of the "extra". That is, they have nowhere to go after work (Pete told Mark about this in the 2nd episode that there are employees who don't go anywhere). Who knows, maybe there really was an accident, but the consequences for his wife were not fatal, but severe.
@AzW4gfZy: by the way, in one of the episodes we see an admin window with a command line and chip operation modes, there is also one like Glasgow. And The Glasgow Coma Scale or The Glasgow Coma Scale is a well-known scale for assessing the degree of impaired consciousness and coma, if anything. So this theory is quite viable.
@bucket_man: well, you can only guess about that. But perhaps only auti is in a coma while Inni is awake. Perhaps that is why they will not be used full-time. Milchek once said that employees "cannot die on the severed floor" (they cannot die on a divided floor"), that is, the chip can support some kind of human activity - physical or only brain activity, it is not known. Perhaps this was the secret of Helly's recovery after suicide.
Now the whole legacy of Egan is entirely unknown. There was a theory that they were working on a procedure for transferring consciousness.
@DeadDanny: About clones, that was one of Helly's first phrases when she woke up. That is, according to the lore of the world, they may well exist.
In general, in the first episode, they loaded several phrases that were fired only in the last one, such as about Prometheus sacrificing himself for people - in the last one, Dylan sacrificed himself frozen in a pose that chained Prometheus to a mountain. Only Prometheus was doomed to eternal suffering... So I would not dismiss this version.
By the way, this is a very cool moment: there are other words that excite the imagination. Does the "hive" plant the memories of one in many shells? Does "Transferring a branch" transfer one memory to another? "From scratch", "elephant" and "freeze frame" also sound no less interesting..
The whole series was held in suspense! They made me nervous, of course, quite a lot, the whole series was waiting for the moment about Mark's wife! There were guesses about Helen, so there was no strong surprise, but still it turned out cool! But for some reason, Irving's line did not create wild interest.
Moreover, even Burt Burt is marked on the map. It was as if he was preparing all this for the inside: printouts, a map. Because the inner man didn't even know how to drive a car. He wouldn't have been able to figure out the phone in any way.
@msirish16: You weren't paying attention. Irwin's father suffered from the separation, and he began to dig under the Lumon. I found a list of employees and tried to talk to them. Including Bert. It's just a coincidence
@zadraleks: it's funny that his intro was the most dedicated employee, and the extra, on the contrary, is looking for answers and initially digs under the lumen....I wonder where the extra's memories of the corridor come from, at first I thought that he was drawing the corridor to the recreation room, but it turned out that this is the corridor to another level.
@zadraleks: Why father? there was an article about an employee who was injured at work as an innie, but was it the father? I thought Irving was a journalist.
@oniXtacie: He had a picture of a man in his trunk with the signature father. Although I also didn't understand from watching if it was related to the injured employee.
@Yulta: maybe he just sees it in a dream? How his office part sees black paint as hallucinations, and in real life he paints pictures with it. There is an interlacing. The boss asked Mark's sister if he was seeing his wife, so it could be.
The series is amazing. So many questions. And there were already guesses about Helly, but in the penultimate episode I began to think that she might be related to the Igans. And then it turns out that she is a granddaughter... this is an internal conflict. The personalities of gg in the office are also part of them, so it turns out that deep inside Helena Egan does not agree with what is happening? But in general, when Helena's outie sent her a video message, it was clear that she was not a very nice person.
As for Mark, it also seems to me that deep down he loves and respects Rikken. Oh this situation when Rikken almost showed Gemma's photo to Mark made me nervous) I am very glad that Mark's innie found out that that psychologist is his wife! But unfortunately, it's a pity that hardly anyone will understand his cry (
Irving was clearly doing his own research and it's very interesting where he got the contact sheet of these people? I'm glad Bert is doing well, but I'm sorry for Irving (
For Mark, Irv and Helly, this was the first step towards the destruction of this empire. I think that their actions in this series will not be taken seriously, but at least they now have more information and Mark's sister will begin to help in some way.
I also want to note a comment from the last series, where they said that perhaps separation helps people cope with stress, loss, etc. I think that the main task lies in this and there are a huge number of workers there in different countries. But at what cost?
In general, the actors are super, the script is excellent (although there are some questions about why there is no security in the company, etc.), the idea is fresh and original. I'm going to watch Ben Stiller's other projects)
@Destiny_Ocean: they will take it seriously, Natalie has already figured out that the performance was started by the intro of Helly, and not extra. Yes, and Selvig-the Dog is right there.
@kingforthesirens: it seems to me that the Dog and the Boy would hush it up so both are covered up in their own games. And the reception can be beaten, Helly has switched, but they cannot spoil the reputation of the company, they will somehow be hushed up for the outside world. Well, inside, what will happen to our heroes, I'm scared))
@Destiny_Ocean: what are the plans of the lumen company really there....but the intro work in the offices is meaningless.....macro data, design, goats.....it looks like they are being tested, testing the operation of the chips....for example, in life, a chip was used by a woman for pregnancy and the birth of a child. We don't know what Lumen does at all....I remember in the initial episodes, like friends of Mark's sister and himself, sitting at lunch without lunch, discussed this issue and no one could say what Lumen was doing...it seems to be all in a row.
Wow! While I was watching the episode, I bit my nails with my hand up to the elbow) There was a suspicion that Helly was clearly not so simple. And here it is) I'm glad that Mark managed to find out about his wife. God, it's just the perfect season finale.
Well done, everyone managed to do everything. Mark passed on the information and found out about his wife, Helly annoyed the corporation. And Dylan gets a medal for stretching. And Inrving… It seems that he could have worked at Lumen before the split. He has a lot of information about employees. And it was as if he was waiting for the moment of his inni's awakening, even marking his own house on the map so that Inni could navigate more easily. But why was it initially divided? Is it because of PTSD? The most obvious option, because we were shown that he is a veteran, like his father.
Maybe the chip was originally created for the army? You recruit soldiers, they carry out the most cruel orders without question, only they have no memories, and they do not suffer from PTSD after the tour ends. And everyone is happy. After all, there are so many protocols in the functions of the chip, they can't all be for office work. And Helen's father confirmed that their company has been messing with chips for a long time, if the prototype was created in her childhood. Most likely, they started for health, but it turned out as always.
The series is great. I wish there were more of them.
@Rage: it seems that the chip for controlling human consciousness was originally created not for the benefit (to survive loss, ptsd, etc.), but for managing people and total control.
In one of the first episodes, Mark was asked, "what if you're killing people there?" This is a very working theory about why Lumon actually created this technology.
@annchous: it seems to me that this is just the sect as it is, and with chips you can control the adherents as you like. And their job is just to test themselves for the operation of the chips. They are full-time subjects.
adore They were able to keep the pace and gave out such a series. It turns out to be the season finale. Let's close now and become the greatest sadists in the world.
The finale is just unrealistic, how can we wait for the next season now?
The only point that I didn't fully understand is the technical detail of the separation: I kept thinking that "separation" (despite the term) is closer to "isolation", i.e. this piece of you, memories, etc. it is isolated, not separated, and when Dylan started overtime, the whole trio It was supposed to merge and recover into a single person who remembers both work and himself outside of work, then Mark did not reveal himself to the boss.
But while I was writing, I remembered that Dylan, despite not "turning on", did not remember either the child's name or the fact that there are three of them.
@xyll: Dylan activated the protocol only for Helly, Mark and Irving. There was no point in turning it on for himself, he was "at work". In addition, furSy correctly noticed that the protocol does not connect your two personalities, but only wakes up the working one (disabling the main one) when you are at home.
@Rage: About Dylan, I was talking about the episode in the closet when it was turned on a few episodes ago. @furSy: Yes, I understood that, it's just that the whole series thought that when they were turned on, they would become like Petey - they would remember both lives.
Turning on the mode is like riding in an elevator: one person falls asleep, another wakes up. So this elevator was conditionally "turned on" remotely.
Dylan woke up from work in the closet of his extra personality and, if not for the child who caught his eye, he would have continued to know nothing about "his" marital status. This is not a merger, but a switching of extras to intras in opposite conditions. Therefore, when intra-Dylan turned on at work again, he remembered what happened to him, intra, in the skin of the "original".
According to this logic, Irv, Helly and Mark, once back in the office, will remember their "extra" experience: a trip to Bert, a speech at the Lumon gathering and recognizing the psychologist's wife. For the main personalities, this will be a memory lapse, because the extras did not participate in this reality at all.
@p-elena: you explained it correctly, but it's difficult, in my opinion))
But definitely, the inclusion of intras in any conditions does not provoke a fusion of personalities, either one or another personality acts in a regular situation. And merging them, like Pitti's, is an emergency situation caused by outside (non-Lumen) interference.
Thanks It sounded simpler in my head) Synonyms were summed up. I used them so that I would not "drive intra through intra, see intra, in extra intra..." 😅
@p-elena: tell me, maybe someone else knows....That's when Dylan was turned on....Milcheg went to his house, and as he said later, the boss did not know about it.....then the head of the guard was already kind of dead, but even if he was still alive......who was holding two switches for Dylan's Overtime work?
@Tiny: Maybe there's another way to turn them on? It's kind of remote. In general, a mode with two toggle switches far apart from each other is usually designed so that it cannot be done by one person. In other words, this is protection against an intruder: there must be at least two people. Like, for example, multiple keys that should be inserted at the same time
@xyll: Merges are not possible. Everyone in Lumen believes this, except for the doctor's aunt, who originally put the two Piti together, and Selvig. But Petey merged unorganically, with consequences. So in the current reality of the series, the separation is irreversible. But switch - please.
@TQueen: it seems to me that the company knows about the reversibility of separation but is deliberately silent, otherwise people will want to do it. It seems to me that the boss and Milchek are also separated in fact, they just exist constantly in one version of themselves. They are kapets adherents, maniacs. This is strange. The real manual is probably not like that. The top of any totalitarian sect or system aims at power and bonuses for their loved ones, no matter what they preach to the adherents. And these two are believers themselves, so to speak.
@xyll: in fact, this is the creation of a second personality coming out. Yes, there is one person, one essence, some inner qualities are also most likely the same....but still, without past memories, experience, knowledge - this is a different person turned out, he has a new branch of development of destiny. I feel sorry for them...if I were Lumen, I would never activate them again after such a failure. It's easier to take out the chips and that's it. Although they said that it seemed impossible to go back, but maybe they meant something else.
@Yulta: I think it's no longer the creation of a new personality, but the murder of a real formed personality. The goal is this. Haley, as I understood it, had the best result in the survey. She really didn't remember anything about herself, but she knows and remembers the general things. That's probably why she wanted to test the latest version of the chip on herself. To advertise the legacy and make big deals, these chips can be used for good.
so only Irving didn't manage to do anything? (it's sad for him, and for us–to wait-out now. before the news went out that they had renewed for a second season, I was hoping that it would be a tight mini-movie, but okay, now let's continue. beautiful
@santa_marinella: He didn't have time to do anything because, frankly, he acted like a fool. and I'm not saying this for homophobic reasons-I'd say the same thing if he went after some granny.
his character had good potential - he's been sniffing around there for years, trying to get into the subconscious. it would seem, hooray, you can help yourself and tell everything you know - no, he itched and he went to his love. I felt so sorry for Dylan at that moment: he was standing there, poor, in a very unfortunate position, and not for a couple of minutes, but for dozens of minutes! literally torture. and all for the sake of those three doing something useful. and this idiot again spat on his team for personal purposes. absolutely incompetently leaked Irv, it's even a pity.
@HowYouDoing: Well, their idea was to tell someone they could trust. Irv doesn't have anyone, he wanted to tell Bert, especially since Bert is marked with an address at the docks, and there is already something on the map. I could have written a note, of course, but it's more sincere here. moreover, they wanted to tell what they didn't like there - and his friend clearly suspects this himself, and digs under the lumen
@nilson: I understand your point of view, but for the average viewer, it seems to me that this is not obvious) in terms of, if you find that your friend is digging for a company and your task is to make the company look bad, then this is vin-vin, the simplest and most understandable way is to write a detailed note to yourself, tell everything, what do you know - and you did even more for the end of the company than the other two) maybe that's the point: too much contribution to the plot from a minor character. but then why was he initially given such a strong backing? The question is, of course, rhetorical
@HowYouDoing: And it seemed to me that of all the three, Helly's performance on stage would have the least effect. (that aunt is a fanatical Dog, at the end of the series she will just fall on her and turn everything into a joke when Helly gets up and becomes the 1st person. And the people in the audience giggle as if nothing had happened and this is part of the performance. ) The only thing that is not clear is how Helly's father, who is the founder, did not think twice when his daughter tried to hang herself. Either he is such a cruel fanatic of his business, or he himself firmly believes that the doppelgangers live a happy life there. Rather the first, because he doesn't look stupid.
@Nastyalarionova: The thing is, they don't know if they trust themselves. Helly R saw for herself how her external personality was blackmailing her to stay there. Apparently others don't know whether to tell themselves either.
@santa_marinella: he managed to knock on the door, it will be opened, and the external version will have to communicate)) in general, he learned a lot from the recordings, he will tell his friends, depending on what happens there.
O *uet a flurry of emotions caused the finale, even the words are difficult to find. I almost prayed that Mark would have time to tell his sister that his wife was alive, burst into tears when he did. I hope the second season will be released sooner, because this one will not go away from memory now at all. It was nice to note in the course of the series that many assumptions turned out to be correct, especially the unexpected twist eventually came out with the exhibition. Of course, I understood that there is a conflict of personalities, but to turn myself out, just to prove to my father and the world that everything is fine - it's terrible. The brain explodes.
@kingforthesirens: by the way, yes, it turns out not only Selving hid Helly's suicide, but also extra Helly herself, since the council and her father found out about it just before the exhibition.
@kingforthesirens: I hope that Mark's sister will not take his cry of "she's alive" as if in relation to his lost daughter, like he was so worried that he screamed with joy, ahhh..... It seems like he's holding a photo in his hand, maybe at least it won't be for nothing
Well, what the hell is back in the most interesting place, it's not human, they would have given me at least 20 minutes to watch, or 5 minutes, why break it off like that Now it's a year to wait for season 2
@Felix_Play: they were in overtime mode for exactly 40 minutes, as well as the duration of the series, I would like to say so, but I revised the series and paid attention to all the hours, and then 20:45, then 2:10, then 1:10 in general, my spgs failed (
I was already in tears at the end!!!! How can you end up like this???? I've been sitting in suspense all series! It's a great series! I started watching it and thought about a completely different development of the plot, but here.... Bravo to Ben Stiller!
@EmilD: it is a pity that in the society of TV series viewers it is impossible to express negative emotions from watching. They will immediately trample you into the "mud". Do I agree with you about the opinion of the story itself
@Mario_rossario: I understand people who don't like negativity, I'm like that myself, I liked the series as a whole, without enthusiasm, like some, but the final episode disappointed more than pleased, but if people like it, then it's cool.
@Mario_rossario: the series is good, and by the way, there really haven't been many of them lately, so it doesn't seem to show anything like that and it's so intriguing. I was personally disappointed that the most interesting place....and what to expect next. I hope that the writers and producers will not spoil the next season and generally answer all the questions in the end....There are enough TV shows without answers and decent endings. The final episode was the most intense, so I wanted everyone to have time....I hope that Mark's sister will understand everything from his cry that his wife is alive, the photo is in his hand with his wife.
Cool series. Lately I don't remember anything that would touch me so much. Yes, there are a lot of controversial points. There are a lot of stupid things killing this series as science fiction. He's more of a fantasy.
The series will definitely be in my top 10 favorites of the year. It's been a long time since I've had so much fun watching, despite the fact that there are still many questions left. Anyway, the actors are just top notch. Adam Scott is a wonderful dramatic actor, a real discovery for me.
It was just extraordinary, an amazing finale. I really hope that the next season will start from about the same place where this one ended, and the creators will do without unnecessary timescips. I would like to consider all the details of the consequences of what happened here.
One of the best TV series of this year right now! I see this opening scene of the second season, where Irving stands in front of Bert's open door, and they look at each other uncomprehendingly; Helly is on stage, the hall is covered with deathly silence and a lot of questions begin to pour in; Mark is asked what he is talking about, who he means. It's a very tricky switching system, of course, you can't just switch it off and leave it in the same condition. We are looking forward to the second season!
@SilverТIger_7: Helly is not on stage, but is lying under it with Natalie. Which is good, because after such a performance, no one should have any doubt that it was NOT a joke)
@AEE: This fanatic boss will just turn everything into a joke, and the audience will clap and that's it. Moreover, it was clearly made clear to us that Helen (the daughter of the main inventor) clearly believes in her father's idea and wants to help him in every way. So, as soon as he wakes up, he will immediately begin his prepared false speech.
Oh, and a tense episode, everyone is on the verge, they'll make it/they won't make it, that's it. The season ended well. But, I must admit, the series started out hard for me, in some places it was tedious, in some places it was very interesting, but with each episode the degree and my attention increased. And at the end, boom! Disappointed in Harmony, as soon as she got on the right path, she was happy (kind of sincerely) for Mark that he decided to leave and then, hoping to restore his position in the company, ran to ruin their plans. In general, Apple TV+ series delight with their gorgeous visual images, filming, actors, and attention to detail.
@DROoOVER: >Disappointed in Harmony, but she got on the right path, was happy (kind of sincerely) for Mark that he decided to leave I think she was glad that after Mark's dismissal, his inner self would die and stop interfering.
Throughout the season, the thought has not left me that the old woman is clearly attracted to Mark. What if she killed his wife, tricked him into going to Lumen?
@mixer1701: You shouldn't have messed with him: I also thought Harmony liked Mark. At the beginning of the season, watching him through the window, she said so sadly: "poor Mark." And with her "guest house" she hinted VERY STRONGLY that it was possible to hook up with her. I don't know if it has anything to do with the incident with his wife, but the theory is clearly good, worthy of a living.
And, by the way, if she really faked the accident, then it would fit perfectly into her not-so-kind character.
hz, it seems to me that she just has a fierce schizophrenia. Then why is she yelling at him all the time in the office, throwing mugs at him? She's an incredibly disgusting boss, but such a nice neighbor... also this altar in her room... she's just crazy about this whole topic and that's it :)
My God, this is just a fucking amazing episode! 1000/10! It's just perfect. So many twists, so much tension and such a finale! Definitely the best TV series of the year!
P.S. Don't worry about Mark, he didn't just shout, he was holding a photo in his hand, so the sister should understand everything. P.P.S. Did you pay attention to the woman who said that she had a wound on her head from a bird? This is not for nothing. Apparently, she had a separation operation. And the man who started screaming that he had found the child? Strange behavior. There are muddy people around my sister's husband.
@DeadDanny: Hmm, but with the wound from the bird, excellent observation, thank you. Perhaps the character will shoot in the second season. I watched it in the first episode, when it came to the separation of Mark - she did not say a word during this discussion, only at the end, after Rickon's speech, she said that she "also supports his decision."
Yes, they probably mentioned the strange smell from her and the wound for a reason. Maybe the smell, because he works in a department like that with goats
This is the best season ending that has ever happened in all the series. It's just super-orgasmic. They managed to do everything, usually they break us off and the heroes do not have time for something, here the heroes finally managed to do it. I'm done!
the acting is simply incomparable. Britt Lauer for the toilet scene should be given all possible statuettes of all the awards that are available for the series. Adam Scott actually plays two different people throughout the series. the end of the season is excellent, despite the fact that they did not give answers to the questions. the series is one of the best in recent years.
By the way, yes, now everyone is delighted with how Oscar Isaac played several characters in the Lunar Knight, and then it's just different action-comedy characters, but here Adam Scott is no worse and pulls out two dramatic personalities
IMHO - the best TV series of the year, while we are waiting for the 2nd season, I recommend to see who missed it - Bikes from the loop, I think I should also go in if I liked this series...https://old.myshows.me/view/65742/
Everything is fine, there is only one question - does this guard have such a blunt knife or was this rag made of Kevlar? He sawed at her for ten minutes :D
It's amazing! I liked the series right away, but I really hooked it from the middle... And so every last episode was so gorgeous and breathtaking to such an extent that it was scary that the finale would be solved. Oh, it was scary, but at the same time I was mentally prepared for the fact that if there was bullshit, then I would not regret the time spent, because the work is really gorgeous. In short! This is a 100% cool ending. That's just awesome. And of course, a TV series with the most brutal cliffhangers =) Every time I say "fuck you ..." on the credits =) Thank you! That's what I want to say. Awesome.
According to the plot... It is simply impossible to imagine what bleating goats will be thrown at us next season. And how nice it is to understand that you can't really predict anything =)
I continued to write a review and realized that I would just get everyone with my delight. I'll limit myself to this. It's just that such series are so rare... This is very valuable.
It's been a long time since I've been so worried! A series of fire, just 40 minutes under tension, in the last seconds I screamed with joy, Mark managed! Yuhuuu *dance*
Well, that's the end! I haven't seen such high-quality work for a very long time. And the actors and the plot and how they shot it. Bravo! They kept us in suspense right up to the last second!
@Yulta: there are just enough answers given to make up the big picture. this is the essence of this genre. the same Leftovers in that spirit. but there are many reviews, for example, on YouTube, the LOST EXPLAINED channel, there are answers to all questions about the series in general
Once again, I made sure that Ben Stiller doesn't do shit. The best science fiction series of the year at the moment and most likely will remain so. Everything is perfect, the script, the acting, the scenery, the cinematography, the music, and even the opening credits. Everyone who loves science fiction and (or) thrillers must watch it.
To say that this is a cool series is not to say anything at all)))delight and admiration, and pain that it took so long to continue!really in the most interesting place!!!
After the first measured episodes in the style of "nothing is clear, but very interesting", the audience was forced to sit with bated breath and worry about every minute of screen time for the characters. Bravo to the creators of the series. Very cool!
If I had this device with a bright flash from the movie "Men in Black" , I would unscrew the relay to the maximum and generally erase everything completely 😭
Wow!! And now how to live another week before the next episode?! ... In the sense of "this is the season finale"? What's the ending?! So that there will be an episode in a week, as usual! :<
And if you put aside the joke, then there are simply no words, the series is a TOWER. This is how you need to build a story, this is how you need to make characters fall in love and write plot twists - do not take them from the ceiling, but serve them quite logically. I believe that Helena is an important person, because throughout the season we were shown that she would not bend under the "worker", even under threat of death, she would not engage in dialogue. And I really like how everyone has their own story arc- Halle has a conflict with herself, Mark has a trauma about the "death" of his wife, and Irving has feelings for Bert. And, of course, my respect for Dylan in this episode. I wouldn't have lasted 10 minutes in this position, but he's just a mountain man! It took as much as a whole Mr. Milcheck HDD to get the switches to release I started watching, not expecting anything at all, in the end I just liked it to the point of insanity. Let's have a second season, my body is ready.
The best series of recent years in the style of mindfuckery. The good legacy of Lost, Darkness, Mr. Robot... If you want something similar, I also highly recommend "Messages from Other Worlds" by Jason Siegel.
Guys! I haven't yelled like that since the Black Mirror! Thank God someone thought of stirring up something like this, as we are shown in the Separation! But to end on such a note is really sadistic. How can we wait for a whole year to continue?
P.S. I went to "split up"! While my first half is waiting for the continuation, the second half will live and not suspect anything! Wake up by the beginning of season 2...
@grizzly48: I'm looking at the original, but thanks to your comment, I went to check what's in the baibako translation - respect for this studio has only grown. I wonder since when videos calling for stopping the war (!) have become "anti-Russian". It is not allowed to discuss politics on myshous, which means that both comments will be deleted, I suppose. And yet: Glory to Ukraine.
@id70201890: It still doesn't seem right for me to continue the conversation here, but I would be happy to convey my position if you have a desire to argue. As a person who has been interrogated by both the KGB in Belarus and the Armed Forces of Ukraine, I have something to share. Personal messages on VK and Twitter are open, their accounts are linked to myshous - feel free to write.
It is a pity that your idea of Ukraine boils down to Nazism and sadism. The country is wonderful, as are its people.
@id70201890: they write "Live Belarus", "We are the people" and everything in that spirit, this is such a national phrase that almost every country has. and you should watch less TV or where did you get that cotton ball from there-but it flew into your head
By the way, there is a rare place where there are no kremlebots, and by likes you can perfectly see who is actually the majority and who is the minority.
God, that scream from Mark in the last minute of the episode just tore everything apart from the inside. You experience both the abyss of despair (because, perhaps, they will never see Miss Casey again, it is still unclear) and the highest bliss (because SHE is ALIVE!).
I wonder how events will develop, because something like this appears between Mark and Helly at the end of the season, and this farewell kiss...
Episode 8: Mark: What if we don't wake up? Or are our extras scoundrels? Helly: Well, it's all clear with me... Mark: You know, I... hope there's at least something I care about. Something important. Helly: You've been taking great care of me, Mark. Mark: It's just... I want to take care of you. HELLY: Thank you. It's mutual. Mark: Thank you.
And such a touching scene at Miss Casey's session, I so wanted them to remember everything, looking at each other:
Miss Casey: I've only lived 107 hours. I only know these half-hour sessions. The most beloved part of my life is the 8 hours I spent with you...I've never lived so long at a time... Mark: We have to do something to help. Miss Casey: Why are you worried about me? Mark: Because we are people, not someone's appendage. These are our lives, this is all we have. No one has the right to take it away from us. Miss Casey: Thank you, Mark. ... Miss Casey: Your extra loves to do... honey: It's great. They don't remember each other.
That's what the series turned out to be, that's what he managed to awaken such a range of emotions! The immersion into the atmosphere of the series was maximum. Pausing, I wanted to come back and come back again. The eyes are streaming aquamarine, the heart is tearing into millions of particles (it needs to be patched up for the next season), curiosity and the desire to get to the bottom of the deep and secret meanings of this series cannot be tamed. I really want to see the sequel! Hold on, guys!
The series is amazing, but the whole first season seems to bring us to a much bigger picture that we haven't been shown yet. This reminded me of another good series with Adam Scott - a good place) a very funny parallel.
@anastyiivanova: it is somewhat similar to Maniac (the same beautiful retrofuturism), and in the end it became somewhat similar to Westworld (in terms of plot).
but the series is really great, the best I've seen in recent years
@anastyiivanova: You know, when I first started watching the series, it reminded me of a lot of things, but at the same time nothing. And I found the similarity of the series more with video games like Inside, Control, The Stanley's Parable and the works of writers Philip K. Dick and Frans Kafka + the film adaptation of "The Process" by Wells very much reminded the atmosphere of the series, and also the film by Jacques Taki "Playtime".
All of a sudden, it went very far, usually "sterile" series are not my topic, but fascinating, damn it! And I want more. Especially after such a dynamic last few episodes. Not to mention how many philosophical questions there are in this topic, wow!
Great, I liked it. Style, actors, visual, idea. From the complaints: it's still too slow in places. Nine episodes per hour, it would be possible to bring the season at least to some logical point, with a reserve for the second season. And there it is completely in limbo. I wonder why it was only Irving who had the leak? He was either connected to Lumon initially, or he was investigating what was going on there, but still it doesn't explain why he was the one who saw the paint in the office, and why he could remember the corridor while being outside. I really want to be offered a clear justification for the creation and implementation of such technology to the masses. As an increase in efficiency in office work, this does not stand up to any criticism - a person locked at work around the clock without the possibility of psychological rest cannot be effective. As a justification for solving psychological problems like Mark's, it's also nonsense, he didn't cut off emotions for himself in life, but just working hours. The only jobs where this would be justified are something related to top secret and cruelty - you are guaranteed to cut off memories, a person cannot blab anything (although in this case it is very doubtful from a security point of view to invent a way to activate an inner personality outside the workspace) if he commits murders or illegal/scary things he will not suffer from this, again, he will not go to tell anyone. But this is clearly not the case of Lumon, well, so far with our office heroes. I hope the explanation will be more interesting than another social experiment or the idea of enslaving all of humanity.
@ShaMarinka: I have a theory that the leak only happened to Irving because he was the only one sleeping at work. Sleep is subconscious, so there was a glitch.
After this episode, it seems illogical to me that Inni Helly was treated so badly if Harmony and Milchek knew who she was. Usually, when a big boss tries to stay in the shoes of a simple worker, they still create special sterile conditions for him, but here she was driven to attempt suicide. In theory, it should be in their best interests to show the top management that the innies are happy and feeling great.
@MariaTsvetkova: I'm just betting that the main feature of Helly (anyone) is tenacity and stubbornness. Therefore, both Hells bend their line, try to fight in every possible way. But the external Helly is also spoiled and spoiled, she does not put people in anything - it is very vividly shown how she treats herself internally. To achieve the prosperity of the company no matter what. The external one is most likely perfectly aware of how people are being bullied inside, but it doesn't matter to her, her idea is fixed - market expansion. The idea of internal freedom as the highest priority
This series has all the hallmarks of a masterpiece. Its own style, its own atmosphere, wonderful acting, magical musical theme and screensaver, intrigue. I don't know what the second season will be like, but I was very pleased with the first one. I applaud Ben Stiller. A serious producer was born from an average comedian. A good trend, if you also consider Seth Rogen. I also remembered, looking at Adam Scott, how Ben cosplayed Tom Cruise. Stiller still has a thing for him.
@PanPanich: the trend is good. Another unexpected rediscovery of recent years is the deeply dramatic role of John Hill in Maniac 2018, who was known as the hero of teen comedies from the MTV 00s.
Not a series, but sheer greatness. The diamond idea was packed in the same precious package, where they did not fail anywhere: the drama is outstanding and heartfelt, the tension makes you move closer to the edge of the sofa, there is enough style with these corridors for the whole planet, the actors are brilliant (Arquette and Turturro especially), and the intrigue is so powerful that you do not know how to live up to the trace the season.
In general, Severance is really a very poignant series on my favorite topic — a man needs a man. Moreover, in this series, this means even we are with ourselves. It is impossible for us to survive without a sense of freedom, which manifests itself precisely in our interaction with people around us. Their office is literally built in such a way as to divide people as much as possible and let them focus exclusively on work, but our humanity breaks through any obstacles: love finds its way even through endless spaces of corridors, and friendship gets out of cells. And we cannot live without this human, I repeat, in any way, which is very coolly symbolized by the line of Dylan, who needed one short hug from his son to abandon his usual routine and such loyalty to the company. It's delightfully simple. And each of the characters has a lot of such understandable drama here.
In general, you can read the reel series as you want: both as a comment on the attitude towards employees in general, and as a discussion about our attitude to work, and as a tragedy about traumatized people and an attempt to forget, and as that very drama about the importance of loving and being loved, and as such a great psychological session about relationships with oneself and a lot more. It's really cool, because thinking about this series is no less pleasant than watching it, and this is always admirable.
In general, it is wildly interesting what will happen next, because the groundwork for the masterpiece is huge. I really want to believe that the second season will be no worse. I can't wait
And yes, it just seems to me that the Division of och can go well next to the Office, ahah. They are essentially talking about one topic — work as life and the inextricable connection of these two components. And despite the completely different tonality, they come to the same conclusion: even at work, it is not she who is important, but the people who are with you there, and you should not change because of this office activity in any way. You have to be happy everywhere: as at home, so in the endless white corridors of any corporation
It's only April yet, and the series of the year is already there. A conspiracy thriller in an infernal corporation — and an absolutely humanistic story about the rights of workers.
The local mythology is fascinating, through which the absurdity of "delusional work" is highlighted. The cult of productivity, brought to its logical end. Capitalism as a religion: with a sacred text, rituals and false teaching in the form of a self-development book. With sacrificial goats, the "garden of Eden" and the myth of the barbarism of the optics and design department. And the graceful fusion of this "inner" world building with the "outer" in the refrain of the prayer "Forgive me for the harm I have caused this world", when Helly understands her role in the experiment. Beauty!
But the great thing is that this thriller has the DNA of office comedies! And that the humanity of the characters was not sacrificed to the concept! Well, how wonderful it is from all sides, I'm waiting for the continuation)
In the off-season, The Lexington Letter was published. https://books.apple.com/us/book/severance/id1613220757 ), which reveals another storyline of the macro data processing department, which apparently took place even before Petey. And it also contains an instruction booklet for an employee of this department, telling how to work with numbers correctly.
@MattAlliance: and it turns out that the next second Mark-outie wakes up in the hallway at his sister's, not understanding anything, clutching a wedding photo in his hand. And his sister will only have to guess that he meant his late wife (but in principle, who else if he holds a picture of a dead person and yells She's alive!). I imagine how he will blow his mind, to find out all that he managed to tell his sister + believe about his wife?
The idea is certainly interesting, but it is still not clear why this separation is necessary at all? If he hadn't been there, nothing would have changed much. That extras don't know anything about their work, that intras, in fact, also have no idea what they are doing there...
Вот поэтому-то я и не люблю смотреть подобные сериалы посезонно, до их полного завершения, но тут просто не удержался. Ретро атмосфера офисного пространства, тайны отделов, загадочность производимых действий, все это чем-то даже напомнило DHARMA Initiative. А музыка-то какая! Очень органично вплетается и дополняет сюжет. Разделение сознания хорошо обыграно и напоминает Элиота из "Мистера Робота". Ну, и концовка сезона шикарна. Ждем второй сезон.
@ckpinka: Думаете? Мне казалось, вторую личность просто стерли после родов. Тут именно хорошо рифмуется, что Марк пошел на Разделение, чтобы облегчить душевную боль, а жена сенатора - физическую.
@rhodeoah: та женщина, что встретилась сестре Марка перед родами - была точно так же расслаблена, когда была в последней серии, и там и там говорилось о помощи. Делаю вывод - Это основная личность. Эта основная личность говорила что-то о том, что ей помогли вырастить детей (у неё их 3(?) ) Когда после родов сестра Марка встретила женщину, та была растеряна, или потеряна, и не была столь расслабленной. Чисто имхо - вторая личность, которая для родов и бытовухи.
@id972349034: В комментариях к одной из прошлой серий кто-то сказал, что можно вместо режиссёр Роберт Уйати использовать режиссёр Бен Стиллер для завершения любой непонятной ситуации.
Кстати, сериал еще очень хорошо подымает вопросы проблемы сознания и смерти, а так же обречения своих копий(обычно цифровых, но не в этот раз) на страдания.
Если разделенный увольняется, то его интра, которая никогда до этого не существовала - по сути умрет. Она никогда больше не проживет новый день, по сути вся ее жизнь, с теми радостями и событиями, которые у нее были - закончится. Весь опыт - все "умрет". Экстре от этого легко отмахнуться, если не задумываться, но если задуматься... Ты же по сути своим решением убиваешь другого человека, другое сознание. Или не другое? Тоже не понятно, кем является эта личность: тоже тобой, просто без памяти, или отдельным сознанием, пусть и с такими же вкусами?
А какого отказывать другой личности в запросах на увольнение? Заставлять другого человека, или вообще самого себя страдать? Но, конечно, можно просто отмахнуться и не задумываться. Но вот если задуматься...
@AEE: В этом контексте особенно интересно будет пронаблюдать объедение личностей Хелены: как они обе воспримут опыт друг друга? Как Экстра воспримет страдания Интры? Одно дело, слушать какие-то там жалобы человека, на которого тебе поифиг, и совсем другое ПРОЧУВСТВОВАТЬ ЭТО САМОЙ! Чья личность из них в итоге победит? Одна хочет уничтожить компанию(ну или ее устроит закрытие темы с разделениеями) другой, что же будет выбрано? Среднего варианта тут быть не может: либо разделение остается, либо проект закрывается.
@AEE: а главное - что писать в резюме? я 8 лет работал на позиции главы отдела, но вообще вот хз если честно пацаны что делал, и на вопросы hr отвечать не буду :)
Просто супер, не оторваться! Черное Зеркало, само собой, но вот в последнем эпизоде почему-то вспомнился Westworld... Ну и светлой памяти дядьки Ходора :)
Невероятно жуткий / интригующий / драматический / прекрасный сериал. Цепляет сразу и не отпускает до финальных титров. Здесь все прекрасно: начиная от шикарной начальной заставки,.. продолжая игрой актеров, развитием сюжета, прекрасной музыкальной составляющей, .. и заканчивая прекрасной режиссурой Бена Стиллера (снятые им эпизоды особенно прекрасны).
Окончание сезона просто разрыв сердца, жду с нетерпением продолжение.
Короче, финал прекрасен, это уже и так все знают, но , Боже, как же тяжело я сдавала на права, моя похвала Ирвинг , ты и правда , как будто из фантастического сериала😅
Не простой для восприятия сериал. Тяжело начинала смотреть, но все таки дошла до конца! Сказать странный сериал- это ничего не сказать) Главное чтобы создатели потом сами не запутались что к чему), это если будет второй сезон. По итогу сериал понравился! Буду ждать продолжения!
Great ending! The series didn't immediately catch on, but it got more interesting with each episode. The creators managed to convey the necessary, mysterious atmosphere. I would also like to mention the musical screensaver at the beginning of each episode.
Ооооочень долго запрягали. Можно было в первых сериях тогда других персов раскрыть, а не только гг. а так тянули резину несколько серий, и к концу сезона вдруг решили показать ещё троих персов кроме Марка. Я так понял, что ветку с той бабой-доктором, которая объединила Питти, решили оставить на 2 сезон? Сериал необычный, отличный саундтрек и операторская работа; прекрасные актеры. Но хотелось бы во 2 сезоне поменьше тягомотины)))
Просто невероятно, я в восторге от этого сериала. Давно я не видел чего-то настолько качественного и уникального. У меня остались только вопросы по безопасности в Люмене.
Почему весь не разделенный персонал состоит всего из 3 человек (из 1 с учетом смерти того грозного мужика и увольнения бабки)? По сути за порядком следит только Милчек, который естественно не может успеть везде и сразу.
Почему нет камер и прослушки в офисах? Почему в кабинете охраны никто не работает?
Каким образом включили Дилана в том шкафу, если Милчек был с ним, а бабка была не на работе? Тот мужик (уже забыл как его звали) так же враскарячку держал выключатели в одиночку?
Почему когда Ирвинга спалили на том, что он как-то вышел из закрытого кабинета, это не привело к вопросам как он это сделал?
Вообще на эту тему реально куча вопросов и я не знаю как это еще обьяснить кроме как общей шизой происходящего, или что все это на самом деле эксперимент или какая-то другая реальность. Либо же это очень сильное допущение сериала ради развития сюжета в нужном русле.
Ну и еще интересный момент, что Ирвинг оказался не так прост и воспоминания двух его личностей начали смешиваться, иначе он бы не полез за сундуком в котором был тайный отдел с кучей информации.
Как же я рада, что последнюю серию сезона не запороли. Плот твист на твисте.
Я так и знала, что с Хеленой что-то не так: её ни разу отдельно в жизни не показали, в отличии от остальных членов команды. Плюс я всё никак понять не могла, вот какого черта она не уходит, когда её "рабочая" так настойчиво этого требует.
Историю Ирвинга интересно ещё узнать "вне работы". Ведь он помнит получается коридор в чистку, знает, кто там работает. Откуда? От там работал без чипа? Тогда почему его приняли работать уже с чипом?
А тетка-начальница...Боже правый! Чего она лезла то постоянно в личную жизнь Марка? Именно Марка. Фу прям, противно это
Мужик, который с такой охотой и пренебрежением к Марку присвоил себе заслугу нахождения ребёнка, меня лично очень сильно выбесил. До чего же мерзкий и подлый человечек.
@Averssem: странный момент, если честно. Мужик даже не третьеплановый, а еще дальше. И тут эта сцена, то ли ради хохмы, то ли ради чего. Может, как-то выстрелит в следующем сезоне? Но выглядело слегка сюрреалистично.
Не хочу катать простыню, просто скажу, что сериал пушка, держал в напряжении до самого финала, с нетерпением жду следующего сезона. Однозначно буду рекомендовать всем кому только можно.
Патриша Аркетт бесила своим заискивающим голоском ещё в Притворстве, и тут продолжает также вмешиваться в жизнь другого человека, бесит ужасно. Очень переживала за Марка, его бег в сторону сёстры держал в напряжении, очень надеюсь, что они поймут что к чему. Про Хелену было понятно, что она непроста. А тут прям целая наследница всей этой шарашки. Ирвинг оказался чёрной лошадкой)) Надеюсь, второй сезон начнётся с того, чем закончился первый сезон, и нам нормально покажут, сколько раз ребята прочитали свои извиняющиеся записки.
Ахренеть, вот это финал) Давно так не цепляла история. Намного интереснее выходящих сейчас "Колец власти" и "Дома дракона" (не в обиду фанатам). Как же теперь дождаться продолжения, вот в чём вопрос)
Напряжение до последней секунды, вот что значит динамика и вовлечение зрителя. Невероятное смешение эмоций после начала титров: интрига, удивление, надежда, разочарование... Один из немногих сериалов со свежим сюжетом, да были вот эти все великие бесчеловечные монопольные империи зла, но именно такого формата не видела нигде. Здесь не будет раскрыто как на ладони - кто, где и почему. Приходится придумывать и догадываться о настоящих намерениях и положении дел, о настоящих масштабах всего происходящего. Оттого становится ещё интереснее, но и мучительно в ожидании развязки. Гг не выглядят картонными даже когда мы мало о них знаем. Актёры отыграли шикарно.
Недочёты сценария будут всегда и везде, тут уж либо закрывать глаза, либо пытаться объяснить логикой той вселенной, где гг существуют. Например, почему так мало охраны и слежения? Мне кажется что внутренние полностью подконтрольны, они как роботы, им ничего не нужно, они будто запрограммированы и нуждаются только в поработать-сходить в туалет-поесть-поговорить на непринужденные темы. (если судить по первой серии, потом то конечно начались попытки в медленное прозрение) И с чего мы взяли, что в этом здании (кстати большом) много работников? В охранной комнате было не так много переключателей и не так много камер и всего один ген.дир. что тоже странно.
Очень понравилась ассоциация коридоров и движения героев по ним с лабораторными мышами. Каждое движение по этим коридорам уверенное и кажется что герои сразу ориентируются по ним, будто запрограммированные. ___Далее ниже___
@ElinaRai: И что-то мне кажется, что это не работа вовсе, а прикрытие. Человек по какой-то причине хочет разделиться, приходит туда и ему дают видимость работы, ведь они занимаются не пойми чем. Или там действительно какая-то высшая цель для основателей. НО бессмысленность всего происходящего на работе подкрепляется тем, что идёт арка какого-то сектантства и слепого поклонение чему-то что они сами не смогут объяснить, лишь цитируя пустые фразы основателя. О какой великой миссии и великих идеях идёт речь - не ясно, но они свято верят в них. В этом ещё предстоит разобраться.
@ElinaRai: Заранее извиняюсь за некрореплай) > c чего мы взяли, что в этом здании (кстати большом) много работников Несколько раз показали кучу машин на парковке, а потом пустую парковку (когда уезжал/приезжал Марк), то есть люди туда приезжают и оттуда уезжают.
@leoncia_ir: поддерживаю извинения за некрореплай)) В какой-то момент сказали, что в Люмон работает половина города. Судя по всему, вся эта половина трудится в самом здании, и только сотрудники согласившиеся на разделение трудятся в подвале.
То чего я ждала 8 серий!! Очень медленно они подходили к финалу, серии затягивались и не пушили сюжет. Но я рада что в финале герои добились чего-то, если бы авторы снова тут оставили недосказанность, например успеет ли Марк увидеть свою жену, то я бы очень расстроилась. У меня бы не было какого-то удовлетворения интереса от сериала. Но авторы молодцы 😌😌
Супер, отлично. Офигенный сериал. Сначала не очень зашёл, думала нахрена я смотрю эту муть, но как обычно с середины понеслось. Необычно и интригующе. Жду продолжения)
the whole series was howling with tension.. there was one simple task: to transfer the information to a trusted person as quickly as possible, so that when you return you can transfer the extra, like quit. As a result, Mark spent a long time figuring out who was who (he also slept with a Dog like that).. Irving is a loner and seems to know more than his inner self.. and with Helly (the name Helly contains HELL, in support of the theory about the sectarian nature of the family), it's not easy at all. I thought she'd get drunk in public..
@pussydestroyer23: вот да, не могу понять почему он не мог эти тумблеры чем-то привязать, чтобы они держались сами по себе. А сам бы в это время охранял дверь, а в случае прорыва обороны сражался с Мильчаком.
@AlexiaKeltz: а мне ещё -5 накидали на данный коммент, не понимаю чем люди руководствуются. Мне кажется явным что физически неразвитый мужик с лишним весом в таком положении долго не простоит.
@pussydestroyer23: I also think that you can build a loop on the toggle switch and hold them for something to make it easier. BUT here is the moment that they are in the office and they have nothing! There was no time to build the tools at hand, just like there was no time. He tied the door handle with some kind of cord and that was it.
Просто бомба! 💣 Очень надеюсь, что во 2 сезоне дадут объяснение (каким бы абстрактным оно ни было), а то вспоминаются белые медведи и чёрный дым из Лоста, которые так и остались (для меня) загадкой...
@Anna849: Белых медведей в Лосте объяснили тем, что их привезли для экспериментов, в их клетках же потом Кейт и Сойер сидели, и когда Сойер разобрался с кормушкой, кто-то из островитян/тех, кто его посадил в клетку (не помню имя) сказал, что-то вроде "Медведи и те быстрее сообразили, как работает кормушка".
Спасибо за ответ, как раз выше написала, что, пересмотрев сериал в сознательном возрасте, многое стало понятнее). Но всё-таки в плане дыма и "светящегося горшочка" в сердце острова не очень очевидно, видимо, это нужно просто принять как данность.
I was hoping at least this series would be a complete, complete story, but no. Like other current series, they came up with only an interesting mystery, and the answers will be invented by the screenwriters of the next seasons, if there are any. In general, the concept is interesting. The horror of modern office slavery. A job where you don't understand what the result of all this should be, you're just a cog in a big machine.
Я, как человек, который ненавидит открытые финалы и несостыковки в сюжете, готова простить все за идеальность всего остального. Я надеюсь, они знают, что делают и у них реально есть нормальные объяснения всему происходящему на будущие сезоны, иначе это будет разочарование века. Адам Скотт господь бог. Патришия Аркетт великая, я ненавижу ее невероятно. Композитор заслуженно получил свою Эмми. В общем, разъеб.
Очень неожиданно от Бена Стиллера, сценаристам респект! Вся серия в напряжении, давно так не смотрел запоем до 3 ночи, не смотря на рабочий понедельник)
Я так понимаю Дилан не просто так смог так долго продержаться в сложной позе, а именно потому что были уже слова что его экстра может быть связан со спортом видимо, это единственное объяснение, как в принципе толстячок смог так долго продержаться
Елена получается... я видимо была единственной, кто не догадывался что с ней что-то не так, Я думала она такая же простая как все остальные теперь главное чтобы её словам прислушались, что вряд ли ведь компании это не выгодно
Насчёт марка я спокойно всё же он не просто выкрикнул, а у него ещё и фотографии жены была в руках только вот непонятно как они все существовали полностью, и только она... то есть экстра ее в коме после аварии, а интро может выходить но только на какое-то время???
Ирвин мог столько оставить информации своему экстра-видно же что экстра копает под люмен, а на самом деле не сказал ни слова а поехал к Бену Я тоже бы так сделала, но по пути может быть когда надиктовала бы себе в заметки что ли какую-то информацию пока еду, хотя бы как-то так! обидно что вот тот кто мог это всё сделать, такой шанс похерил
Короче, вопросы остались, но очень надеюсь, что 2 сезон будет вот прямо скоро, потому что если он будет в следующем году... даже не знаю как дождаться
@LuckyThirteen: я тоже не догадывалась об Елене. Никаких вообще вроде предпосылок не было, что она какая-то важная птица, да еще и из семьи основателей компании. Казалось странным, что ее экстра несмотря на угрозы отрезать пальцы, если не дадут записать видео об прошении об увольнении, и повешении - такая не, все равно буду работать. Странно, что совет компании и ее отец не были в курсе об инциденте с повешением....ее ведь потом в больницу отвезли. Сама Елена Игон видимо не захотела их посвещать в это тоже.
Когда перешли все в интро, почему никто не додумался записать себе голосое на телефон/сообщение, не пойму?! Походили, пожили, теперь их переключат и начнётся всё заново для экстра. Хоть окружающие что-то скажут, но не всё. Крутая задумка сериала! Что-то новое ☺️
@i_slavna: голосовое? И что оно дало б? Ничего как мне кажется. Марк хочет уволится, Хелена - наследница основателя. Возможно Ирвину могло помочь в его расследовании, но не больше, он бы продолжал работать в Лумине. Тут нужны люди , которым можно доверится, что б поднять кипишь или как минимум просто попросить уволится. Но рассказывая, что происходит в жизни у "рабочего", ставит жизнь под угрозу их близких...
Ну Марк не просто хочет уволится, он начал расследование по Люмен, получил доказательства. Задумался об увольнении. Что бы дало?! Если бы включил аудио, и оно б записывало, он бы хотя бы озвучил что его жена на работе жива. Я думаю что во 2 сезоне, он всё таки будет это подозревать, тк кто ещё на столько важный чтоб он прокричал «она жива» и будет работать в Люмен, чтоб продолжать расследование. Теперь и экстра и интро знают про жену. Основательница (интро то точно) тоже поддержит расследование. Ирвинг вообще загадка, согласна прям! Откуда чертежи, что он знает, предположу у него ведения и воспоминания.
Скажите мне что не я одна смотря сериал думала про Кукольный дом, особенно с Дичен Лакмен в одной из важных ролей) Оно же очень похоже, местами с похожими идеями/поступками.
Сериал шикарный, чем дальше тем интереснее!) В последней серии хотелось кричать "ааа запишите видос на телефон, отправьте куда-нибудь или хотя бы для себя", но как верно отмечали ранее, "внутренние" на работе телефонами не пользуются и даже компьютеры там подчеркнуто старомодные, не факт что они понимают что такое вообще можно было сделать (да ещё и пароль вспомнить, если блокировка не пальцем или лицом). Очень ждем-с второй сезон, приятно был удивлен)
Так круто завернули, наверно, один из последних сериалов, который прям смотрел, не отрываясь!) конечно, подогрели интерес ко 2 сезону!) это потрясающе!)
Реально от напряжения разболелась голова, и кажется я не дышала минут 30 вообще ооохххххххх...)))это капец какое окончание _аааааааааааааааааа еллкккиииииии я хочу ещеееее хоть 5 минуточек! 8 вялотекущих серий стоили этого молниеносного крышесносного завершения
Дааааа, это мощно. Очень понравилась идея сериала и то как ведётся повествование. Очень круто, что на важных моментах сезон закончился. Надеюсь к концу 2023го будет следующий сезон, очень надеюсь.
Тут многие вспоминали на что похоже им, я тоже выскажусь. Не скажу что это очень похоже, но мне сама науч-фанастическая часть отдаёт сериалом Грань. Я почему то такой вайб поймала в голове, когда там Питер понял, что с ним не так в той реальности куда его поместил отец.
В общем сериал очень понравился, прямо буду советовать
Столько символизма в сериале, если бы я смотрела внимательнее, то наверное бы больше заметила, но что бросилось в глаза:
Эксперимент с отделами обработки данных и Дизайнерами - выглядело, как провокация, желание их поссорить из-за вымышленных давних конфликтов и слухов, подтверждения которым не было, только "отсылки" в виде картины и слухи, видимо хотели проверить на сколько люди подвергнутые "пропаганде" будут готовы к каким-то действиям при реальной встрече с этими отделами (обзывательства, драки и тп), либо хотели отпугнуть, чтобы они не шатались друг к другу слоняясь по коридорам, но отделы все равно нашли способ подружиться, это прямо здорово - очень по доброму сделали, человечно).
Вся работа внутри компании очень напоминает религиозный культ, их заповеди ака правила, наказания, фигура "отца" основателя, любовь которого они пытаются заслужить хорошей работой, даже когда Хейли выполнила 100% работы, ее наградой было "я тебя люблю" от компьютерного основателя компании. Его дом там стоит как музей, которым они должны восхищаться и ходят туда на "перезарядку" как в церковь.
Второй момент - козлята, они что-то значат для компании, раз из разводят прямо в офисе, плюс опять же религиозные ассоциации с агнецом божьим (овечка\коза, очень похоже) и на продолжении "вафельной вечеринки" было 4 танцовщицы в масках, и одна из масок была маской козла, что странно, но интересно. Еще тут такой интересный момент, до конца не показали, что значит эта вафельная вечеринка и к чему она должна привести, но на сколько "интре" этично на таком присутствовать, если он даже не знает женат ли он "снаружи".
Третье, это наличие "священной книги" которая для реального мира просто очередная книга на полку, а для мира "интр" она оказалась ключом к перевороту и очень сильно повлияла на их мировоззрение и привела к интересным последствиям.
Еще очень интересно, что за галлюцинации ловил Ирвин с черной краской (по-моему у Марка один раз тоже была такая галлюцинация) и почему вечерами он рисует дверь, в которую ушла "мисс Кейси", как ее мог видеть Ирвин и вспомнить в своей реальной жизни. Интересно, что он очень интересовался живописью на работе и в реальной жизни оказался связан с ней)
@Liza: думаю, еда, вафельные вечеринки, танцы, стриптизерши и прочие дофаминовые радости - способ поощрения сотрудников. Зачем обеспечивать стимулы для выработки дофамина, когда можно поощрять ими сотрудников за хорошую работу?
Вся серия получилась отличной, напряжение можно было хоть ножом резать, но не могу не написать, какой прекрасной получилась сцена с "покаянной молитвой" Хелли перед зеркалом. Её линия здесь вообще радовала своими диалогами, но этот момент - просто выше всяких похвал.
Люмон свои эксперименты с разделением довели до страшной ситуации. Два разных сознания заперты в одном теле. И изначально это не было проблемой тела, не было психического расстройства. А теперь оно есть. И чтобы эти сознания разделить необходимо лишнее тело или клон тела. В любом случае, двум разным теперь уже людям, нужно как то договориться в будущем делить это тело, либо одному сознанию исчезнуть навсегда, либо в клона переселяться. Главное, чтобы Люмон не пошел в сторону истории с Билли Миллиганом и не начал штамповать несколько сознаний в одном теле. Очень интересный сериал. Спасибо создателям и Киру)))
Прочитала, что у создателей сериала большие разногласия относительно нового сезона, и сьемки до сих пор не начали. Есть риск что конфликт отразится на качестве, либо актеры просто разбегутся по другим проектам, по которым уже заключили контракты и сроки никто сдвигать не будет(
Интересно вот что - когда психологиню Кейси жену Марка отправляли по коридору, к лифту, над ним была стрелка вниз. А они же и так в подвале! Значит там есть этаж ещё ниже, где скрывается что-то интересное. И на картинах Ирвинга тоже стрелка вниз, возможно, у него есть воспоминание, как туда отправляют его отца, или он сам там побывал.
Отличный сериал, по-хорошему некомфортный, есть в нем какая-то цепляющая жуть) Но ооочень много вопросов к "технической" части и есть опасение, что все уведут в мелодраму и тему восстания угнетенных интро-версий. А хочется хоть примерно понять, как это устроено, каким образом можно разделить сознание так, что интро помнят что такое семья, дети, дом, кровать, вечеринка, книга и другие предметы внешнего мира, но не помнят всего остального. Зачем оставлять в памяти то, что не имеет непосредственного отношения к работе. Еще показалось, что уничтожили то, что удалось сохранить от сознания жены Марка после аварии - опять же - зачем? Эксперимент вроде не окончен, вдруг пригодится? Почему иногда интра ведут себя именно как "урезанные" версии без жизненного опыта - как в истории вражды между отделами со странными картинами и легендами. А иногда - как полноценные адекватные люди, которых просто заперли в комнате и не выпускают. В целом темы поднимаются схожие с Миром дикого запада - что такое личность, человек, как устроено сознание. Но в МДЗ с теоретической частью переборщили, а тут вроде как наоборот - недовес. Ну и в целом есть чувство, что основная мораль - люди готовы на все, лишь бы не работать) Но интересно, жду продолжения.
Ох*еть. Все что я смогла выдать после просмотра этой серии. Рада что все-таки со, второго раза, добралась до этого сериала 🤩 Это пушка. Это очень интересно и переживательно. С нетерпением жду следующего сезона
Восхитительно гениальный сериал! Нельзя так заканчивать сезон, у меня одни восторженные эмоции от просмотра! 😍 С каким скепсисом начинала смотреть первую серию, сериал пролежал в отложенных больше года, и вот он просмотрен взахлеб - потрясающе и браво всем, кто участвовал при его создании! Разгадка происходящего уже практически на поверхности, ждем с нетерпением второй сезон
@Devlinn: нескоро, производство было приостановлено из-за забастовки сценаристов. Сейчас может возобновилась работа, но я такого не слышал. Так что 1,5-2 года как минимум придется ждать:(
Шикарный сериал! Даже не думала, что так понравится. С первых серий не понимаешь, что происходит и пытаешься разгадать загадки. Оставляет за собой столько вопросов, что явно требуется продолжение!
Когда сериал только вышел, мне почему-то не зашел, начала и отложила.
Сейчас же другое настроение, проглотила за 1 вечер, насколько тонко обыгрываются все эти корпоративные проблемы, у меня не раз была мысль, что да, сейчас на работе некомфортно и ищу другое место, но я хотя бы помню! И есть свобода действий.
Черт это было охрененно.!!! Вся серия в напряжении. Узнает ли он про жену.? Успеет ли она выступить. ? Интересно, Кто такой Ирвинг и откуда он знает про лифт вниз?
Огонь, последние минуты сериала прям переживаешь за героев, лишь бы все успели Ещё подумала, что после того, как уволят начальницу Марка, то она тоже пойдет против системы ,но видимо слишком предана своей работе Надеюсь ждать следующего сезона придется не долго
На самом интересном как говорится, финал, то что надо, 2 сезон обещает быть насыщенным и энергичным. Очень понравилось наблюдать переключение героев и их познания, конечно можно придираться к мелочам типо, что мешает сделать так и вот так, но это лишь придирки, основной сюжет построен супер. Есть как по мне и скучные сюжеты, как например с Ирвигом(нет, ориентация тут не причем) просто она обычная, и сам персонаж мне не симпатизирует, зато удивила Хелли, да можно было догадываться, что она какой-то репортер, но внучку основателя я не ожидал. Кто больше всего раздражает это Кобэл, такая противная бабка, везде сунет свой нос. Ещё хотелось бы узнать историю Милчика, мне кажется он не такой уж и «злодей» Вся суть и деятельность корпорации Люмен так и остается загадкой, можно лишь гадать, что зачем и почему,а новости о скором выходе 2 сезона лишь подогревают интерес
Весьма неплохо. Последняя серия слегка приоткрыла карты, появилось, конечно, ещё больше вопросов, чем ответов. Теперь понятно, почему руководство закрывали глаза на бунтующий характер Хелли. Жаль ее интру, такую правду о самой себе узнать.. Ещё один отличный проект от Apple TV. С нетерпением жду продолжения, заинтриговали 😃
At the beginning of the second episode, Milchik leads Helen and talks about the profile of the man on the wall, they say, he drank 3 eggs in the morning, and she answers: "I know." Even then it became clear that she was from this family, but the name of Helly R. was confusing. But how they twisted it, a very cool series!
I wonder if the boss is divided herself? What if she's separated but in the same incarnation all the time? She is such a bright adept of the company, even after she was fired. And she had a hospital bracelet with a tube on her altar at home; I believe that she was a patient herself, through which she got into the Lumon. As I suppose, Mark's wife. Perhaps she went to the hospital after the car accident, and the death was already arranged by the company. Or she herself. Suddenly she's just like Hayley, she did it herself. Apparently, her appearance in the testing department, is she a test subject or is she conducting experiments herself, that's the question. I kept hoping that the old guys in love in real life were also connected, it would be nice. But no. It looks like the artist is investigating Lumon, and knows about the elevator where Mark's wife was taken. Perhaps he is connected with people against the company of speakers. The fact that Lumon is a cult is already clear, but it seems that the real Halle is not very aware of what is happening there. If she had known that they were torturing there (the recreation room), she would have gone there. And her father uses her daughter for political purposes. In short, no answer has been found to any question🥴 Although it's a huge relief that Mark did see a picture of his wife and realized that she was alive!
Unrealistically cool! The finale is just 10/10, I sat in wild tension the whole series and thought that everyone would turn off together at the most important moment and would not have time to say / do anything. When Mark said "Miss Kobel" I just screamed out of surprise and overexertion. I really liked Hallie's monologue in the toilet. In general, I love such appeals to the audience " and here Lower played smartly, there was some sincerity in the words. It was a separate thrill to watch Mark-from-the-real-world turn into a working-class Mark and vice versa, as if they really were two completely different people.
Pzdc! There are no words, I can only console myself with the fact that, unlike those who watched in real time, it took longer to wait for the second season than for me... There is half a year left before the release
Thanks a lot to all the commenters! I enjoyed not only watching the series, but also the discussions)
I looked at it in one gulp, even the noodle was not upset in places. There is a lot of incomprehensible, a lot of assumed, and I really want to look further!
Gorgeous visual and music - especially in contrast, when Metallica and Motorhead burst into the sterile picture 🤘
I don't understand why everyone likes it so much when there are a lot of questions and no answers. Most likely, they will not be at all, they will twist the plot while the ratings are there, and then they will make some kind of crumpled ending
Listen, I was just thinking before going to bed... What if Irving and Bert were lovers before the split? This will explain why it is marked on the map, as well as why he is constantly drawn to it.
Well, then we have: Mark and Casey, Irving and Bert, Dylan and...???
At the same time, we know for sure that Mark's reaction to Casey was checked. Maybe this is the essence of the macro data department? It would be interesting to revisit Irving's scene with Casey in this context.
What's Helly doing there? All this sounds like a non-dusty job, so the director's daughter or whoever this grandfather is was sent to her.
I'm also looking forward to the next season of the divided ones who never come home.
Petey mentioned this in passing at the very beginning, and before I started watching the series, I thought that everyone would be like that in the series)
If everyone in Lumen is drowned for separation and even separated themselves, then maybe Milchek and the Dog and the man from security are separated around the clock? Especially the last one. He was smiling outside the building!
@MokridzeMokridze: By the way, for about the same reason, I think Irving has that elevator down in his memories. It has already been rebooted before. Was he too violent?
Also, if we assume that Irving-extra digs under the Lumen, then I have an assumption that he paints pictures not because of troubles with his head, but because he is waiting (or calling?) the appearance of his intro, and somehow this image slipped from intro to extra - probably a consequence of the reboot.
I'm surprised that Bert turned out to be free, one of my theories was that the dismissed were transferred to round-the-clock work, all this, of course, on another floor.
Most importantly, he looks exactly like Cyrus: beard, suit, LAMBS.
(I can't get rid of associations with Bioshock Infinity)
Accordingly, there is a feeling as if he in some form performs the ritual functions of the local prophet-God, where the sheep are, of course, Lumen's employees, not only separated.
Someone is coming for them. Isn't this a hint that they will come for the heroes sooner or later? Well, sheep are either sheared or eaten. So the prospects are not bright.
Also, regarding departments, I think each of them should comply with one of the principles:
Vision - design department, 100% Verve Wit Cheer Humility - sheep. That man looked quite humble in his attempts to feed this bleating horde Benevolence Nimbleness Probity - macro data. The numbers are looking for "how do you feel", and the way you feel is the most honest thing that can be. Wiles
But we don't have much knowledge about the rest of the departments yet, so the distribution is still questionable, except for design.
What if it's all a matrix? With a 99% probability this is not the case, because for this you need to beat the screenwriters with rebar on the fingers in 2022. Nevertheless, there may be some similar vibes. Then there are no arguments for it, but only what prompted me to do it.
- Death of Mark's wife. You can't die in the matrix. - The series hardly mentions places outside of Cyrus, there are only two exceptions. The first is one of the questions on the table. The answer was Denver. The second is in the book by Mark's sister's husband, he claims to have traveled the world. - If Cyrus cannot be left, and Rikken left him, then this explains the incredible popularity of him and his book. There is also a banal infocyganism, who would be led to such a thing in their RIGHT mind? So the intras just fell for it. - What are non-corporations doing in a corporate city anyway? Mark's sister, relatives of the other employees. There is no feeling that they came to this city specifically to work, they have already lived there. Why? - University. Clearly belonging to Lumen. What is he even doing there? Why doesn't Mark know anything about Lumen if he taught there? We've already seen enough to know that Lumen is a sect. And what, no, even modest edits to the Story? - If there is a matrix, then there must be an agent Smith. Milchek, of course. We've seen all the main characters outside of work except him. Besides, he really acts like a robot. - The address on Irving's envelope. The PE staff is indicated there, it doesn't seem to exist. - There is no state, but there is a Senator. What did a senator forget in a provincial town of a non-existent state? He's playing tricks with Lumen, yes, but it seems strange to me, the town is small, you need to be closer to your constituents. - The chip is centrally controlled, while no infrastructure is visible in the city, no pile of antennas, and after all, the implant, among other things, also transmits information about the state of the carrier. You can write it off as a fantastic assumption, but I don't want that.
@MokridzeMokridze: now I remember that the midwife seemed to be visiting. I have nothing to cover, except to assume that this is another evil employee of Lumen))
@MokridzeMokridze: - The absurd size of the Lumens office. They have a whole two-storey house with a garden underground (or not under?) for the sake of the museum. And that's just what they showed us. -Switching "to a lesser extent and recording sensors to a greater extent. How is it even possible to do this, except to program reality? - With this level of technology (and presumably the staff), there is an actual absence of a security service. Either we don't know something about how the Security Council really works, or it just doesn't make sense - truly destructive actions are impossible and programmatically limited. - Petey is Neo. He was able to get out of the matrix, although in fact he only got into the Zion - the outer matrix. - The name. Separation. We don't have a divided floor, we have a whole city, or even a state, separated from the rest of the world.
It's probably worth evaluating the series based on the release of all seasons, because we almost didn't get any answers, and the first half was too boring and stretched. The second one went faster, the last episode is of course a delight 🔥 so far 7/10, but I hope the second season will make the story more complete
We started for health, we finished... as best they could. The finale is action-packed, dynamic and... about nothing. The initial idea is fire, and then - prolonged chewing. A bunch of mysterious mysteries and mysterious riddles. Remember all the questions that arose in your head in the first episodes of the season and answer: have they been answered? It is clear that the riddles should remain for further plotting, but, damn, the original idea needs to be revealed somehow, and not just throw new riddles on top. And here - apart from the quite predictable disclosure of Hallie's personality, there is a practical lack of distinct development.
This is probably some kind of comment on the topic of late stage capitalism. You can't finish anything, otherwise people won't renew their subscription to Apple Tv. We need to continue the series in order to continue the series. You can't quit the series either, because at least nine hours have already been invested in it (see sunk cost fallacy). Hmm, why does criticism of large corporations sound so unconvincing in a work created by a large corporation?
@Kseonis: So they had originally said that they needed to find someone they could trust and tell him everything. So it's understandable why he went looking for Bert.
In the first episodes, I wanted to quit watching the series, but in the end I watched the whole season in one day! The series swings into a very fascinating and exciting story. The last episode ended very abruptly! It showed everything you need for a logical end to the season and did not stretch everything like gum - this is a huge plus! I'm looking forward to continuing. Stories!
Have you noticed that everyone who works at Lumon Industries is essentially single? Mark lives alone and his wife most likely does not leave the Lumon building. Helly is also alone, otherwise her partner would have been present at the evening where she performed. Irving is, of course, alone. Here's what's interesting about Dylan. Milchik did not tell him about his wife, he said that he had only 3 sons. The wife either left or died most likely, but not the fact. It's not clear about Bert either. Whether it was his partner or not. But it's interesting about Harmony. When she was carrying the altar at the end, you can see the attributes from the hospital there. It looks like a breathing apparatus and the name is Charlotte Kobel. I think it's her daughter who died or was sacrificed. And judging by many religious signs, it could have been of a ritual nature. I think it is because of the loss of her daughter that she is so sensitive to children and has such a great experience of motherhood, which she taught Mark's sister.
Imagine how jealous I am of myself right now I watched this masterpiece for the first time, and I have only a month and a half to wait for the second season
Well, it's not like netflix to drop the whole season
But the pleasure will stretch. as much as 2 months
I guess I should have started watching a week before the second season was released...Now I just can't wait. I kept postponing this series, as the description seems to be normal, but like: so what?" But it exceeded all my expectations!
This is one of the best TV shows I've watched, and I've watched quite a few.
@ermigurt17: Similarly, I put it off for a long time, and then I looked at the whole thing in 2 days and it was lucky that I didn't have to wait long for the sequel.
@Arigato_Samurai: It's interesting to see that I'm not the only one who started watching a week before the release of season 2 (which I didn't know about at first), but finished literally right in time for its release)))
It seems like it's not bad, but everything will depend on season 2, whether the authors had a ready-made script or just a concept, it's too early to give an assessment. There are a lot of hooks, they will be interested if they do not start revealing their cards, but continue to beat around the bush... it can be stretched for 10 seasons, then everyone will get bored and the project will be closed without explaining anything. 99% what if: She's alive... Yes, your niece is fine... Yeah, that's what I meant."You can give up, they had an idea, they shot the pilot, it seemed to go in, but they don't know how to finish it properly.
The series opens my eyes to this world, and I really saw the light. It's a pity that three years ago I stopped at the first episode. I'm sure my life won't be the same. The latest episodes inspire the search for truth and give strength in the fight against evil. This is mind—blowing fiction without computer graphics - a real art that can change this world.
A very spectacular ending! I didn't expect myself to be so captivated by this series... And once again I fell into the trap of onboarding😅 I want to watch such series without dragging it out, but now I have to wait a week 😭 and then probably at least a year, at best...
At first, the series was very tedious and slow for me, so despite the interesting concept, I had to watch it with acceleration, but by the season finale, the series gained momentum and I watched the latest episodes with interest) Well, we'll keep looking)
I didn't expect anything from the series, and it was all the more pleasant to get such emotions from an interesting concept, a perfectly written script, excellent acting and a production where light, color and space are of great importance.
The last episode kept me in suspense until the last second. Very well done. But, traditionally for such a project, questions have increased, not decreased. I'm looking forward to the second season with curiosity.
I was watching the episode and came across some interesting information that Irving had obtained. When he looks at the list of employees at home, there is a line in it "Griffin, Dylan Age: 58". 58?! Our Dylan?)
But besides that, it's handwritten next to it: "Who else is 58?" Irving's extra obviously doesn't know who Dylan is (and can't marvel with me at his cool preservation), but the birth years of the separated employees are important to him nonetheless. Years of birth and dates of separation.
This is not a series, but just a fuck-up on all fronts!
Just out loud: show me your wife's photo! Well, I was afraid that Mark would address the Dog by name, and that's how it happened. It's great that he thought to bring this to his sister and they can do something together in the future. Mark was about to leave himself, and then this!
The icing on the cake is Helly and Helen!! It's just a bomb) The cruelty with which she talked to the working version when she was not working made it clear that this was more important than just work.
I was surprised that the Dog came to this event so easily. She was fired, and besides, she was an ordinary employee in theory, and there was a party with the very top.
I watched the first season in one gulp. It was a bit boring in the middle because everything was so strange in this company. It took a long time to come to an end. There were a lot of questions. But the ending is just a fire. I'm starting the second one...
@Choly_Cavel: It's too long, sho kapets, yes, it seems to me that 2 seasons could have been combined into one and fewer episodes could have been made, but no.
This is an Apple, I bought his phone to buy a charger, a wire, headphones - all separately - cal in general is an apple.
The series is interesting and intriguing, but of course the plot holes are confusing, the elevator finds notes, but there are no 2 passes. After the disappearance of the guard, a new one was not installed, why? + a man stayed late at work, it's also strange, yes, I'm aware that he celebrated the closing of the quarter, but everything is fine.
Honestly, it was a tough start, I first watched the first 3 episodes and they didn't really come in, I even dropped Sirik for a couple of days, but after watching the 4th episode, I was kind of dragged out, I watched the rest of the season in one sitting!!
It's a very intriguing end to the season. I was completely sure that Helly was undercover in the company to extract any information, because she had a very strong resistance. But the fact that she turned out to be the founder's granddaughter was also suspected by many, not bad either. Maybe they'll twist out this internal conflict of hers later in an interesting way. Let's go watch the second season!
A powerful series! From the very beginning, right up to the end. When the boss hugged Mark, it was already clear that she would figure it out quickly. And then Mark actually addressed her by her work name, Miss Kabela. Mark (Extra) also referred to her as "Mrs. Elvi". The snake immediately saw through everything. Damn, I thought I was going to help Mark, but she's still fighting for the campaign to the end, even after she's fired. The old witch! I was waiting for Helly to hit her, but harder. As for the Extra Helly, it's much worse. She raises her ratings, and apparently, she will be the next head of Lumon. I am very happy for our heroes that they managed to annoy everyone at last. Helly said what needed to be said. Mark told his sister about everything and found out about his wife that she was alive. In general, everything turned out well for them. I'm sure the boss will be returned in season 2, and the noose will be tightened for the employees. But even those, in turn, will not give up after what they have seen. It's also worth paying tribute to Dylan. I didn't bend under the suggestion of the guard about the children, well done!
Separation is a masterpiece... if we consider white walls, maze boxes, and Retrofuturism to be a masterpiece? Rather, it's retro-boring. The acting is so deep that all the feelings fit into one facial expression. Bravo! Apparently, the budget was spent on light bulbs in these endless corridors.
In the end, of course, the epicness of the moment was created. I watched, holding my breath, when the count had already started for a few seconds: from the moment when Milchik almost cut his belt with a knife, to the moment when Mark ran out to yell "she's alive", and the musical concoction beat so in time with consciousness, gaining the effect of apotheosis, that I just wanted to continue watching But then the credits rolled abruptly.
It's a great series! It's been a long time since anything has been so addictive, the only thing is, the Irving line is too stretched, it doesn't catch at all. The rest have a very interesting motivation and story! I'm happy to continue the second season.
Why does the Boy have such a blunt knife?! I think I could have kicked it out faster.
And the Dog probably understood everything from Mark's face. Their faces were stretched out in the elevator, and here she noticed that Mark's face was stretched out.
And Mark screams, "She's alive." It's not a fact, it's been lowered somewhere else. Maybe she's not even alive anymore.
Discussion: Season 1, Episode 9 Join the Discussion
441It's not a fact that Lumen even knows about this plan.
1) She was always "awakened" for half an hour, as she told Mark herself. And the day where she followed Heli was "the longest day"
2) The scene with her "Dismissal" was shown in too suspiciously detailed detail, and this black corridor through which she passed, and which Irving always draws, well, it looks very much like some kind of cremation chamber, or something like that. The visual and audio accompaniment clearly hinted at its destruction or death. Maybe the clone was destroyed because he failed?
3) Why should Mark's wife participate in this experiment? First to get acquainted, have a relationship, get married, then to imitate death, to introduce yourself a little bit into Mark's activities in Lumen. Check that the separation is working and he doesn't remember her? that's it? There are other, simpler ways to conduct such an experiment, without simulating death.
4) A company with so much money and such technologies can easily conduct genetic experiments and grow clones. Maybe this is exactly what our heroes are doing in processing macro data, looking for numbers based on their emotions, and sorting them, thus creating "souls" for future clones, or, if not clones, then for new divided ones. (but this is a completely fantastic version). Why would they do that? It's all about the company's charter. Aegon wanted to create an ideal society, obedient, utopian, and blindly following his views. In the last episode, Heli's father said that "Soon everyone will be separated." That is, they will implant implants for everyone, and switch to the "ideologically correct version of themselves."
Milchek once said that employees "cannot die on the severed floor" (they cannot die on a divided floor"), that is, the chip can support some kind of human activity - physical or only brain activity, it is not known. Perhaps this was the secret of Helly's recovery after suicide.
Now the whole legacy of Egan is entirely unknown. There was a theory that they were working on a procedure for transferring consciousness.
In general, in the first episode, they loaded several phrases that were fired only in the last one, such as about Prometheus sacrificing himself for people - in the last one, Dylan sacrificed himself frozen in a pose that chained Prometheus to a mountain. Only Prometheus was doomed to eternal suffering...
So I would not dismiss this version.
I thought the last episode was a cliffhanger, but it's generally simple here.. the explosion of the head.
How to wait after that.
There were guesses about Helen, so there was no strong surprise, but still it turned out cool!
But for some reason, Irving's line did not create wild interest.
Because the inner man didn't even know how to drive a car. He wouldn't have been able to figure out the phone in any way.
As for Mark, it also seems to me that deep down he loves and respects Rikken. Oh this situation when Rikken almost showed Gemma's photo to Mark made me nervous) I am very glad that Mark's innie found out that that psychologist is his wife! But unfortunately, it's a pity that hardly anyone will understand his cry (
Irving was clearly doing his own research and it's very interesting where he got the contact sheet of these people? I'm glad Bert is doing well, but I'm sorry for Irving (
For Mark, Irv and Helly, this was the first step towards the destruction of this empire. I think that their actions in this series will not be taken seriously, but at least they now have more information and Mark's sister will begin to help in some way.
I also want to note a comment from the last series, where they said that perhaps separation helps people cope with stress, loss, etc. I think that the main task lies in this and there are a huge number of workers there in different countries. But at what cost?
In general, the actors are super, the script is excellent (although there are some questions about why there is no security in the company, etc.), the idea is fresh and original. I'm going to watch Ben Stiller's other projects)
Maybe the chip was originally created for the army? You recruit soldiers, they carry out the most cruel orders without question, only they have no memories, and they do not suffer from PTSD after the tour ends. And everyone is happy. After all, there are so many protocols in the functions of the chip, they can't all be for office work. And Helen's father confirmed that their company has been messing with chips for a long time, if the prototype was created in her childhood. Most likely, they started for health, but it turned out as always.
The series is great. I wish there were more of them.
Let's close now and become the greatest sadists in the world.
The only point that I didn't fully understand is the technical detail of the separation: I kept thinking that "separation" (despite the term) is closer to "isolation", i.e. this piece of you, memories, etc. it is isolated, not separated, and when Dylan started overtime, the whole trio It was supposed to merge and recover into a single person who remembers both work and himself outside of work, then Mark did not reveal himself to the boss.
But while I was writing, I remembered that Dylan, despite not "turning on", did not remember either the child's name or the fact that there are three of them.
@furSy: Yes, I understood that, it's just that the whole series thought that when they were turned on, they would become like Petey - they would remember both lives.
Dylan woke up from work in the closet of his extra personality and, if not for the child who caught his eye, he would have continued to know nothing about "his" marital status. This is not a merger, but a switching of extras to intras in opposite conditions. Therefore, when intra-Dylan turned on at work again, he remembered what happened to him, intra, in the skin of the "original".
According to this logic, Irv, Helly and Mark, once back in the office, will remember their "extra" experience: a trip to Bert, a speech at the Lumon gathering and recognizing the psychologist's wife. For the main personalities, this will be a memory lapse, because the extras did not participate in this reality at all.
But definitely, the inclusion of intras in any conditions does not provoke a fusion of personalities, either one or another personality acts in a regular situation. And merging them, like Pitti's, is an emergency situation caused by outside (non-Lumen) interference.
Synonyms were summed up. I used them so that I would not "drive intra through intra, see intra, in extra intra..." 😅
It's easier to take out the chips and that's it. Although they said that it seemed impossible to go back, but maybe they meant something else.
before the news went out that they had renewed for a second season, I was hoping that it would be a tight mini-movie, but okay, now let's continue. beautiful
his character had good potential - he's been sniffing around there for years, trying to get into the subconscious. it would seem, hooray, you can help yourself and tell everything you know - no, he itched and he went to his love. I felt so sorry for Dylan at that moment: he was standing there, poor, in a very unfortunate position, and not for a couple of minutes, but for dozens of minutes! literally torture. and all for the sake of those three doing something useful. and this idiot again spat on his team for personal purposes.
absolutely incompetently leaked Irv, it's even a pity.
The only thing that is not clear is how Helly's father, who is the founder, did not think twice when his daughter tried to hang herself. Either he is such a cruel fanatic of his business, or he himself firmly believes that the doppelgangers live a happy life there. Rather the first, because he doesn't look stupid.
I hope the second season will be released sooner, because this one will not go away from memory now at all.
It was nice to note in the course of the series that many assumptions turned out to be correct, especially the unexpected twist eventually came out with the exhibition. Of course, I understood that there is a conflict of personalities, but to turn myself out, just to prove to my father and the world that everything is fine - it's terrible.
The brain explodes.
Now it's a year to wait for season 2
I was personally disappointed that the most interesting place....and what to expect next.
I hope that the writers and producers will not spoil the next season and generally answer all the questions in the end....There are enough TV shows without answers and decent endings.
The final episode was the most intense, so I wanted everyone to have time....I hope that Mark's sister will understand everything from his cry that his wife is alive, the photo is in his hand with his wife.
I really hope that the next season will start from about the same place where this one ended, and the creators will do without unnecessary timescips. I would like to consider all the details of the consequences of what happened here.
We are looking forward to the second season!
Helly is not on stage, but is lying under it with Natalie. Which is good, because after such a performance, no one should have any doubt that it was NOT a joke)
Disappointed in Harmony, as soon as she got on the right path, she was happy (kind of sincerely) for Mark that he decided to leave and then, hoping to restore his position in the company, ran to ruin their plans.
In general, Apple TV+ series delight with their gorgeous visual images, filming, actors, and attention to detail.
>Disappointed in Harmony, but she got on the right path, was happy (kind of sincerely) for Mark that he decided to leave
I think she was glad that after Mark's dismissal, his inner self would die and stop interfering.
I don't know if it has anything to do with the incident with his wife, but the theory is clearly good, worthy of a living.
And, by the way, if she really faked the accident, then it would fit perfectly into her not-so-kind character.
P.S. Don't worry about Mark, he didn't just shout, he was holding a photo in his hand, so the sister should understand everything.
P.P.S. Did you pay attention to the woman who said that she had a wound on her head from a bird? This is not for nothing. Apparently, she had a separation operation. And the man who started screaming that he had found the child? Strange behavior. There are muddy people around my sister's husband.
I watched it in the first episode, when it came to the separation of Mark - she did not say a word during this discussion, only at the end, after Rickon's speech, she said that she "also supports his decision."
According to the plot... It is simply impossible to imagine what bleating goats will be thrown at us next season. And how nice it is to understand that you can't really predict anything =)
I continued to write a review and realized that I would just get everyone with my delight. I'll limit myself to this. It's just that such series are so rare... This is very valuable.
, I would unscrew the relay to the maximum and generally erase everything completely 😭
...
In the sense of "this is the season finale"? What's the ending?! So that there will be an episode in a week, as usual! :<
And if you put aside the joke, then there are simply no words, the series is a TOWER. This is how you need to build a story, this is how you need to make characters fall in love and write plot twists - do not take them from the ceiling, but serve them quite logically. I believe that Helena is an important person, because throughout the season we were shown that she would not bend under the "worker", even under threat of death, she would not engage in dialogue. And I really like how everyone has their own story arc- Halle has a conflict with herself, Mark has a trauma about the "death" of his wife, and Irving has feelings for Bert.
And, of course, my respect for Dylan in this episode. I wouldn't have lasted 10 minutes in this position, but he's just a mountain man! It took as much as a whole Mr. Milcheck HDD to get the switches to release
I started watching, not expecting anything at all, in the end I just liked it to the point of insanity. Let's have a second season, my body is ready.
P.S. I went to "split up"! While my first half is waiting for the continuation, the second half will live and not suspect anything! Wake up by the beginning of season 2...
It is not allowed to discuss politics on myshous, which means that both comments will be deleted, I suppose. And yet: Glory to Ukraine.
Personal messages on VK and Twitter are open, their accounts are linked to myshous - feel free to write.
It is a pity that your idea of Ukraine boils down to Nazism and sadism. The country is wonderful, as are its people.
I wonder how events will develop, because something like this appears between Mark and Helly at the end of the season, and this farewell kiss...
Episode 8:
Mark: What if we don't wake up? Or are our extras scoundrels?
Helly: Well, it's all clear with me...
Mark: You know, I... hope there's at least something I care about. Something important.
Helly: You've been taking great care of me, Mark.
Mark: It's just... I want to take care of you.
HELLY: Thank you. It's mutual.
Mark: Thank you.
And such a touching scene at Miss Casey's session, I so wanted them to remember everything, looking at each other:
Miss Casey: I've only lived 107 hours. I only know these half-hour sessions. The most beloved part of my life is the 8 hours I spent with you...I've never lived so long at a time...
Mark: We have to do something to help.
Miss Casey: Why are you worried about me?
Mark: Because we are people, not someone's appendage. These are our lives, this is all we have. No one has the right to take it away from us.
Miss Casey: Thank you, Mark.
...
Miss Casey: Your extra loves to do...
honey: It's great. They don't remember each other.
That's what the series turned out to be, that's what he managed to awaken such a range of emotions! The immersion into the atmosphere of the series was maximum. Pausing, I wanted to come back and come back again. The eyes are streaming aquamarine, the heart is tearing into millions of particles (it needs to be patched up for the next season), curiosity and the desire to get to the bottom of the deep and secret meanings of this series cannot be tamed.
I really want to see the sequel! Hold on, guys!
but the series is really great, the best I've seen in recent years
And I found the similarity of the series more with video games like Inside, Control, The Stanley's Parable and the works of writers Philip K. Dick and Frans Kafka + the film adaptation of "The Process" by Wells very much reminded the atmosphere of the series, and also the film by Jacques Taki "Playtime".
From the complaints: it's still too slow in places. Nine episodes per hour, it would be possible to bring the season at least to some logical point, with a reserve for the second season. And there it is completely in limbo.
I wonder why it was only Irving who had the leak? He was either connected to Lumon initially, or he was investigating what was going on there, but still it doesn't explain why he was the one who saw the paint in the office, and why he could remember the corridor while being outside.
I really want to be offered a clear justification for the creation and implementation of such technology to the masses. As an increase in efficiency in office work, this does not stand up to any criticism - a person locked at work around the clock without the possibility of psychological rest cannot be effective. As a justification for solving psychological problems like Mark's, it's also nonsense, he didn't cut off emotions for himself in life, but just working hours. The only jobs where this would be justified are something related to top secret and cruelty - you are guaranteed to cut off memories, a person cannot blab anything (although in this case it is very doubtful from a security point of view to invent a way to activate an inner personality outside the workspace) if he commits murders or illegal/scary things he will not suffer from this, again, he will not go to tell anyone. But this is clearly not the case of Lumon, well, so far with our office heroes. I hope the explanation will be more interesting than another social experiment or the idea of enslaving all of humanity.
Therefore, both Hells bend their line, try to fight in every possible way.
But the external Helly is also spoiled and spoiled, she does not put people in anything - it is very vividly shown how she treats herself internally. To achieve the prosperity of the company no matter what. The external one is most likely perfectly aware of how people are being bullied inside, but it doesn't matter to her, her idea is fixed - market expansion.
The idea of internal freedom as the highest priority
For what....
I applaud Ben Stiller. A serious producer was born from an average comedian. A good trend, if you also consider Seth Rogen.
I also remembered, looking at Adam Scott, how Ben cosplayed Tom Cruise. Stiller still has a thing for him.
In general, Severance is really a very poignant series on my favorite topic — a man needs a man. Moreover, in this series, this means even we are with ourselves. It is impossible for us to survive without a sense of freedom, which manifests itself precisely in our interaction with people around us. Their office is literally built in such a way as to divide people as much as possible and let them focus exclusively on work, but our humanity breaks through any obstacles: love finds its way even through endless spaces of corridors, and friendship gets out of cells. And we cannot live without this human, I repeat, in any way, which is very coolly symbolized by the line of Dylan, who needed one short hug from his son to abandon his usual routine and such loyalty to the company. It's delightfully simple. And each of the characters has a lot of such understandable drama here.
In general, you can read the reel series as you want: both as a comment on the attitude towards employees in general, and as a discussion about our attitude to work, and as a tragedy about traumatized people and an attempt to forget, and as that very drama about the importance of loving and being loved, and as such a great psychological session about relationships with oneself and a lot more. It's really cool, because thinking about this series is no less pleasant than watching it, and this is always admirable.
In general, it is wildly interesting what will happen next, because the groundwork for the masterpiece is huge. I really want to believe that the second season will be no worse. I can't wait
Now it's just agonizing to wait for the second season.
The local mythology is fascinating, through which the absurdity of "delusional work" is highlighted. The cult of productivity, brought to its logical end. Capitalism as a religion: with a sacred text, rituals and false teaching in the form of a self-development book. With sacrificial goats, the "garden of Eden" and the myth of the barbarism of the optics and design department. And the graceful fusion of this "inner" world building with the "outer" in the refrain of the prayer "Forgive me for the harm I have caused this world", when Helly understands her role in the experiment. Beauty!
But the great thing is that this thriller has the DNA of office comedies! And that the humanity of the characters was not sacrificed to the concept! Well, how wonderful it is from all sides, I'm waiting for the continuation)
PDF: https://www.docdroid.net/j3S4GuV/1-converted-pdf
Ретро атмосфера офисного пространства, тайны отделов, загадочность производимых действий, все это чем-то даже напомнило DHARMA Initiative.
А музыка-то какая! Очень органично вплетается и дополняет сюжет. Разделение сознания хорошо обыграно и напоминает Элиота из "Мистера Робота".
Ну, и концовка сезона шикарна. Ждем второй сезон.
Эта основная личность говорила что-то о том, что ей помогли вырастить детей (у неё их 3(?) )
Когда после родов сестра Марка встретила женщину, та была растеряна, или потеряна, и не была столь расслабленной. Чисто имхо - вторая личность, которая для родов и бытовухи.
Господи, я аж подпрыгнул в конце
Если разделенный увольняется, то его интра, которая никогда до этого не существовала - по сути умрет. Она никогда больше не проживет новый день, по сути вся ее жизнь, с теми радостями и событиями, которые у нее были - закончится. Весь опыт - все "умрет". Экстре от этого легко отмахнуться, если не задумываться, но если задуматься... Ты же по сути своим решением убиваешь другого человека, другое сознание. Или не другое? Тоже не понятно, кем является эта личность: тоже тобой, просто без памяти, или отдельным сознанием, пусть и с такими же вкусами?
А какого отказывать другой личности в запросах на увольнение? Заставлять другого человека, или вообще самого себя страдать? Но, конечно, можно просто отмахнуться и не задумываться. Но вот если задуматься...
Окончание сезона просто разрыв сердца, жду с нетерпением продолжение.
Сказать странный сериал- это ничего не сказать)
Главное чтобы создатели потом сами не запутались что к чему), это если будет второй сезон.
По итогу сериал понравился!
Буду ждать продолжения!
У меня остались только вопросы по безопасности в Люмене.
Почему весь не разделенный персонал состоит всего из 3 человек (из 1 с учетом смерти того грозного мужика и увольнения бабки)? По сути за порядком следит только Милчек, который естественно не может успеть везде и сразу.
Почему нет камер и прослушки в офисах?
Почему в кабинете охраны никто не работает?
Каким образом включили Дилана в том шкафу, если Милчек был с ним, а бабка была не на работе? Тот мужик (уже забыл как его звали) так же враскарячку держал выключатели в одиночку?
Почему когда Ирвинга спалили на том, что он как-то вышел из закрытого кабинета, это не привело к вопросам как он это сделал?
Вообще на эту тему реально куча вопросов и я не знаю как это еще обьяснить кроме как общей шизой происходящего, или что все это на самом деле эксперимент или какая-то другая реальность. Либо же это очень сильное допущение сериала ради развития сюжета в нужном русле.
Ну и еще интересный момент, что Ирвинг оказался не так прост и воспоминания двух его личностей начали смешиваться, иначе он бы не полез за сундуком в котором был тайный отдел с кучей информации.
.. я на измене.. сколько теперь ждать? когда продолжение?
Я так и знала, что с Хеленой что-то не так: её ни разу отдельно в жизни не показали, в отличии от остальных членов команды. Плюс я всё никак понять не могла, вот какого черта она не уходит, когда её "рабочая" так настойчиво этого требует.
Историю Ирвинга интересно ещё узнать "вне работы". Ведь он помнит получается коридор в чистку, знает, кто там работает. Откуда? От там работал без чипа? Тогда почему его приняли работать уже с чипом?
А тетка-начальница...Боже правый! Чего она лезла то постоянно в личную жизнь Марка? Именно Марка. Фу прям, противно это
ну просто он такой улыбашка с вкусняшками и музычкой))
Люмон: а давайте запихнём в каждую черепушку по ещё одному сознанию.
И не знаю как кому, а мне сериал очень напомнил Dollhouse. И идейно, и, конечно, сюжетной линией Дичен Лакмэн!
Актеры (хоть мне и не нравится Скотт, но тут он хорош), картинка, музыка
Очень хорошо!
Очень переживала за Марка, его бег в сторону сёстры держал в напряжении, очень надеюсь, что они поймут что к чему.
Про Хелену было понятно, что она непроста. А тут прям целая наследница всей этой шарашки.
Ирвинг оказался чёрной лошадкой))
Надеюсь, второй сезон начнётся с того, чем закончился первый сезон, и нам нормально покажут, сколько раз ребята прочитали свои извиняющиеся записки.
Как же теперь дождаться продолжения, вот в чём вопрос)
Я бы не выдержала столько времени зажимать эти рычаги)
Ладно, не одно.
Сериал реально крутой! Давно не смотрела ничего такого классного.
Очень надеюсь на достойные продолжение и финал.
Один из немногих сериалов со свежим сюжетом, да были вот эти все великие бесчеловечные монопольные империи зла, но именно такого формата не видела нигде. Здесь не будет раскрыто как на ладони - кто, где и почему. Приходится придумывать и догадываться о настоящих намерениях и положении дел, о настоящих масштабах всего происходящего. Оттого становится ещё интереснее, но и мучительно в ожидании развязки. Гг не выглядят картонными даже когда мы мало о них знаем. Актёры отыграли шикарно.
Недочёты сценария будут всегда и везде, тут уж либо закрывать глаза, либо пытаться объяснить логикой той вселенной, где гг существуют.
Например, почему так мало охраны и слежения? Мне кажется что внутренние полностью подконтрольны, они как роботы, им ничего не нужно, они будто запрограммированы и нуждаются только в поработать-сходить в туалет-поесть-поговорить на непринужденные темы. (если судить по первой серии, потом то конечно начались попытки в медленное прозрение) И с чего мы взяли, что в этом здании (кстати большом) много работников? В охранной комнате было не так много переключателей и не так много камер и всего один ген.дир. что тоже странно.
Очень понравилась ассоциация коридоров и движения героев по ним с лабораторными мышами. Каждое движение по этим коридорам уверенное и кажется что герои сразу ориентируются по ним, будто запрограммированные. ___Далее ниже___
И что-то мне кажется, что это не работа вовсе, а прикрытие. Человек по какой-то причине хочет разделиться, приходит туда и ему дают видимость работы, ведь они занимаются не пойми чем. Или там действительно какая-то высшая цель для основателей.
НО бессмысленность всего происходящего на работе подкрепляется тем, что идёт арка какого-то сектантства и слепого поклонение чему-то что они сами не смогут объяснить, лишь цитируя пустые фразы основателя. О какой великой миссии и великих идеях идёт речь - не ясно, но они свято верят в них.
В этом ещё предстоит разобраться.
> c чего мы взяли, что в этом здании (кстати большом) много работников
Несколько раз показали кучу машин на парковке, а потом пустую парковку (когда уезжал/приезжал Марк), то есть люди туда приезжают и оттуда уезжают.
В какой-то момент сказали, что в Люмон работает половина города. Судя по всему, вся эта половина трудится в самом здании, и только сотрудники согласившиеся на разделение трудятся в подвале.
Прозвучала хорошая фраза: они (эти их версии) не просили, чтобы их создавали и приводили сюда. Как и все мы, не просили.
Я все еще жду объяснения про числа и козлят 😠
Очень надеюсь, что во 2 сезоне дадут объяснение (каким бы абстрактным оно ни было), а то вспоминаются белые медведи и чёрный дым из Лоста, которые так и остались (для меня) загадкой...
In general, the concept is interesting. The horror of modern office slavery. A job where you don't understand what the result of all this should be, you're just a cog in a big machine.
А сериал отличный, на одном дыхании, открытие года.
Бен Стиллер удивил.
видимо, это единственное объяснение, как в принципе толстячок смог так долго продержаться
Елена получается... я видимо была единственной, кто не догадывался что с ней что-то не так, Я думала она такая же простая как все остальные
теперь главное чтобы её словам прислушались, что вряд ли ведь компании это не выгодно
Насчёт марка я спокойно всё же он не просто выкрикнул, а у него ещё и фотографии жены была в руках
только вот непонятно как они все существовали полностью, и только она... то есть экстра ее в коме после аварии, а интро может выходить но только на какое-то время???
Ирвин мог столько оставить информации своему экстра-видно же что экстра копает под люмен, а на самом деле не сказал ни слова а поехал к Бену
Я тоже бы так сделала, но по пути может быть когда надиктовала бы себе в заметки что ли какую-то информацию пока еду, хотя бы как-то так! обидно что вот тот кто мог это всё сделать, такой шанс похерил
Короче, вопросы остались, но очень надеюсь, что 2 сезон будет вот прямо скоро, потому что если он будет в следующем году... даже не знаю как дождаться
Крутая задумка сериала! Что-то новое ☺️
Я думаю что во 2 сезоне, он всё таки будет это подозревать, тк кто ещё на столько важный чтоб он прокричал «она жива» и будет работать в Люмен, чтоб продолжать расследование. Теперь и экстра и интро знают про жену.
Основательница (интро то точно) тоже поддержит расследование.
Ирвинг вообще загадка, согласна прям! Откуда чертежи, что он знает, предположу у него ведения и воспоминания.
Оно же очень похоже, местами с похожими идеями/поступками.
В последней серии хотелось кричать "ааа запишите видос на телефон, отправьте куда-нибудь или хотя бы для себя", но как верно отмечали ранее, "внутренние" на работе телефонами не пользуются и даже компьютеры там подчеркнуто старомодные, не факт что они понимают что такое вообще можно было сделать (да ещё и пароль вспомнить, если блокировка не пальцем или лицом).
Очень ждем-с второй сезон, приятно был удивлен)
Очень понравилась идея сериала и то как ведётся повествование. Очень круто, что на важных моментах сезон закончился. Надеюсь к концу 2023го будет следующий сезон, очень надеюсь.
Тут многие вспоминали на что похоже им, я тоже выскажусь. Не скажу что это очень похоже, но мне сама науч-фанастическая часть отдаёт сериалом Грань. Я почему то такой вайб поймала в голове, когда там Питер понял, что с ним не так в той реальности куда его поместил отец.
В общем сериал очень понравился, прямо буду советовать
Эксперимент с отделами обработки данных и Дизайнерами - выглядело, как провокация, желание их поссорить из-за вымышленных давних конфликтов и слухов, подтверждения которым не было, только "отсылки" в виде картины и слухи, видимо хотели проверить на сколько люди подвергнутые "пропаганде" будут готовы к каким-то действиям при реальной встрече с этими отделами (обзывательства, драки и тп), либо хотели отпугнуть, чтобы они не шатались друг к другу слоняясь по коридорам, но отделы все равно нашли способ подружиться, это прямо здорово - очень по доброму сделали, человечно).
Вся работа внутри компании очень напоминает религиозный культ, их заповеди ака правила, наказания, фигура "отца" основателя, любовь которого они пытаются заслужить хорошей работой, даже когда Хейли выполнила 100% работы, ее наградой было "я тебя люблю" от компьютерного основателя компании. Его дом там стоит как музей, которым они должны восхищаться и ходят туда на "перезарядку" как в церковь.
Второй момент - козлята, они что-то значат для компании, раз из разводят прямо в офисе, плюс опять же религиозные ассоциации с агнецом божьим (овечка\коза, очень похоже) и на продолжении "вафельной вечеринки" было 4 танцовщицы в масках, и одна из масок была маской козла, что странно, но интересно. Еще тут такой интересный момент, до конца не показали, что значит эта вафельная вечеринка и к чему она должна привести, но на сколько "интре" этично на таком присутствовать, если он даже не знает женат ли он "снаружи".
Третье, это наличие "священной книги" которая для реального мира просто очередная книга на полку, а для мира "интр" она оказалась ключом к перевороту и очень сильно повлияла на их мировоззрение и привела к интересным последствиям.
Еще очень интересно, что за галлюцинации ловил Ирвин с черной краской (по-моему у Марка один раз тоже была такая галлюцинация) и почему вечерами он рисует дверь, в которую ушла "мисс Кейси", как ее мог видеть Ирвин и вспомнить в своей реальной жизни. Интересно, что он очень интересовался живописью на работе и в реальной жизни оказался связан с ней)
Очень интересный сериал. Спасибо создателям и Киру)))
Ждем второй!
Рада что все-таки со, второго раза, добралась до этого сериала 🤩
Это пушка. Это очень интересно и переживательно. С нетерпением жду следующего сезона
С каким скепсисом начинала смотреть первую серию, сериал пролежал в отложенных больше года, и вот он просмотрен взахлеб - потрясающе и браво всем, кто участвовал при его создании!
Разгадка происходящего уже практически на поверхности, ждем с нетерпением второй сезон
Даже не думала, что так понравится. С первых серий не понимаешь, что происходит и пытаешься разгадать загадки. Оставляет за собой столько вопросов, что явно требуется продолжение!
Нельзя так заканчивать на самом интересном😅
Теперь будем ждать второй сезон☺️
Сейчас же другое настроение, проглотила за 1 вечер, насколько тонко обыгрываются все эти корпоративные проблемы, у меня не раз была мысль, что да, сейчас на работе некомфортно и ищу другое место, но я хотя бы помню! И есть свобода действий.
Интересно, Кто такой Ирвинг и откуда он знает про лифт вниз?
Ещё подумала, что после того, как уволят начальницу Марка, то она тоже пойдет против системы ,но видимо слишком предана своей работе
Надеюсь ждать следующего сезона придется не долго
Вся суть и деятельность корпорации Люмен так и остается загадкой, можно лишь гадать, что зачем и почему,а новости о скором выходе 2 сезона лишь подогревают интерес
Ещё один отличный проект от Apple TV. С нетерпением жду продолжения, заинтриговали 😃
I kept hoping that the old guys in love in real life were also connected, it would be nice. But no. It looks like the artist is investigating Lumon, and knows about the elevator where Mark's wife was taken. Perhaps he is connected with people against the company of speakers.
The fact that Lumon is a cult is already clear, but it seems that the real Halle is not very aware of what is happening there. If she had known that they were torturing there (the recreation room), she would have gone there. And her father uses her daughter for political purposes. In short, no answer has been found to any question🥴
Although it's a huge relief that Mark did see a picture of his wife and realized that she was alive!
I really liked Hallie's monologue in the toilet. In general, I love such appeals to the audience " and here Lower played smartly, there was some sincerity in the words.
It was a separate thrill to watch Mark-from-the-real-world turn into a working-class Mark and vice versa, as if they really were two completely different people.
a teaser at the same time.
Pipeeee, even more than six months ;____; yes, how so
I looked at it in one gulp, even the noodle was not upset in places. There is a lot of incomprehensible, a lot of assumed, and I really want to look further!
Gorgeous visual and music - especially in contrast, when Metallica and Motorhead burst into the sterile picture 🤘
Well, then we have: Mark and Casey, Irving and Bert, Dylan and...???
At the same time, we know for sure that Mark's reaction to Casey was checked. Maybe this is the essence of the macro data department? It would be interesting to revisit Irving's scene with Casey in this context.
What's Helly doing there? All this sounds like a non-dusty job, so the director's daughter or whoever this grandfather is was sent to her.
Petey mentioned this in passing at the very beginning, and before I started watching the series, I thought that everyone would be like that in the series)
If everyone in Lumen is drowned for separation and even separated themselves, then maybe Milchek and the Dog and the man from security are separated around the clock? Especially the last one. He was smiling outside the building!
Also, if we assume that Irving-extra digs under the Lumen, then I have an assumption that he paints pictures not because of troubles with his head, but because he is waiting (or calling?) the appearance of his intro, and somehow this image slipped from intro to extra - probably a consequence of the reboot.
I'm surprised that Bert turned out to be free, one of my theories was that the dismissed were transferred to round-the-clock work, all this, of course, on another floor.
Most importantly, he looks exactly like Cyrus: beard, suit, LAMBS.
(I can't get rid of associations with Bioshock Infinity)
Accordingly, there is a feeling as if he in some form performs the ritual functions of the local prophet-God, where the sheep are, of course, Lumen's employees, not only separated.
Someone is coming for them.
Isn't this a hint that they will come for the heroes sooner or later? Well, sheep are either sheared or eaten. So the prospects are not bright.
Also, regarding departments, I think each of them should comply with one of the principles:
Vision - design department, 100%
Verve
Wit
Cheer
Humility - sheep. That man looked quite humble in his attempts to feed this bleating horde
Benevolence
Nimbleness
Probity - macro data. The numbers are looking for "how do you feel", and the way you feel is the most honest thing that can be.
Wiles
But we don't have much knowledge about the rest of the departments yet, so the distribution is still questionable, except for design.
The eighth principle (department number 08) is just Honesty🤔🤔🤔
What if it's all a matrix? With a 99% probability this is not the case, because for this you need to beat the screenwriters with rebar on the fingers in 2022. Nevertheless, there may be some similar vibes. Then there are no arguments for it, but only what prompted me to do it.
- Death of Mark's wife. You can't die in the matrix.
- The series hardly mentions places outside of Cyrus, there are only two exceptions. The first is one of the questions on the table. The answer was Denver. The second is in the book by Mark's sister's husband, he claims to have traveled the world.
- If Cyrus cannot be left, and Rikken left him, then this explains the incredible popularity of him and his book. There is also a banal infocyganism, who would be led to such a thing in their RIGHT mind? So the intras just fell for it.
- What are non-corporations doing in a corporate city anyway? Mark's sister, relatives of the other employees. There is no feeling that they came to this city specifically to work, they have already lived there. Why?
- University. Clearly belonging to Lumen. What is he even doing there? Why doesn't Mark know anything about Lumen if he taught there? We've already seen enough to know that Lumen is a sect. And what, no, even modest edits to the Story?
- If there is a matrix, then there must be an agent Smith. Milchek, of course. We've seen all the main characters outside of work except him. Besides, he really acts like a robot.
- The address on Irving's envelope. The PE staff is indicated there, it doesn't seem to exist.
- There is no state, but there is a Senator. What did a senator forget in a provincial town of a non-existent state? He's playing tricks with Lumen, yes, but it seems strange to me, the town is small, you need to be closer to your constituents.
- The chip is centrally controlled, while no infrastructure is visible in the city, no pile of antennas, and after all, the implant, among other things, also transmits information about the state of the carrier. You can write it off as a fantastic assumption, but I don't want that.
- The absurd size of the Lumens office. They have a whole two-storey house with a garden underground (or not under?) for the sake of the museum. And that's just what they showed us.
-Switching "to a lesser extent and recording sensors to a greater extent. How is it even possible to do this, except to program reality?
- With this level of technology (and presumably the staff), there is an actual absence of a security service. Either we don't know something about how the Security Council really works, or it just doesn't make sense - truly destructive actions are impossible and programmatically limited.
- Petey is Neo. He was able to get out of the matrix, although in fact he only got into the Zion - the outer matrix.
- The name. Separation. We don't have a divided floor, we have a whole city, or even a state, separated from the rest of the world.
The initial idea is fire, and then - prolonged chewing. A bunch of mysterious mysteries and mysterious riddles.
Remember all the questions that arose in your head in the first episodes of the season and answer: have they been answered? It is clear that the riddles should remain for further plotting, but, damn, the original idea needs to be revealed somehow, and not just throw new riddles on top.
And here - apart from the quite predictable disclosure of Hallie's personality, there is a practical lack of distinct development.
Hmm, why does criticism of large corporations sound so unconvincing in a work created by a large corporation?
*времени мало*
Все: заняты чем-то полезным
Дед: едет искать своего деда гея xD
I can't imagine how people have been waiting for a new season for 2 years after such a finale
I watched this masterpiece for the first time, and I have only a month and a half to wait for the second season
Well, it's not like netflix to drop the whole season
But the pleasure will stretch. as much as 2 months
But it exceeded all my expectations!
This is one of the best TV shows I've watched, and I've watched quite a few.
There are a lot of hooks, they will be interested if they do not start revealing their cards, but continue to beat around the bush... it can be stretched for 10 seasons, then everyone will get bored and the project will be closed without explaining anything.
99% what if: She's alive... Yes, your niece is fine... Yeah, that's what I meant."You can give up, they had an idea, they shot the pilot, it seemed to go in, but they don't know how to finish it properly.
The last episode kept me in suspense until the last second. Very well done. But, traditionally for such a project, questions have increased, not decreased. I'm looking forward to the second season with curiosity.
58?! Our Dylan?)
But besides that, it's handwritten next to it: "Who else is 58?" Irving's extra obviously doesn't know who Dylan is (and can't marvel with me at his cool preservation), but the birth years of the separated employees are important to him nonetheless.
Years of birth and dates of separation.
Just out loud: show me your wife's photo! Well, I was afraid that Mark would address the Dog by name, and that's how it happened.
It's great that he thought to bring this to his sister and they can do something together in the future. Mark was about to leave himself, and then this!
The icing on the cake is Helly and Helen!! It's just a bomb)
The cruelty with which she talked to the working version when she was not working made it clear that this was more important than just work.
This is an Apple, I bought his phone to buy a charger, a wire, headphones - all separately - cal in general is an apple.
And the series is not bad.
That's a twist)
Let's watch season 2.
And the Dog probably understood everything from Mark's face. Their faces were stretched out in the elevator, and here she noticed that Mark's face was stretched out.
And Mark screams, "She's alive." It's not a fact, it's been lowered somewhere else. Maybe she's not even alive anymore.
puffy fecal epl