Ads

s01e05 — Judgment Day

3 Body Problem — s01e05 — Judgment Day

My rating

Rate
Rate the shows you've watched and get up-to-date recommendations
4.476
MyShows
(937)
Duration: 58 min.
Released: 21.03.202421.03.2024 15:00
Watched by: 9 02950.06%
1 season
s01e05
s01e01 - Countdown
s01e02 - Red Coast
s01e03 - Destroyer of Worlds
s01e04 - Our Lord
s01e05 - Judgment Day
s01e06 - The Stars Our Destination
s01e07 - Only Advance
s01e08 - Wallfacer

Discussion of the 5 episode of the 1 season
Discuss this episode
147

New2018
New2018
21 Mar 21:56 # Show original
The destruction of the ship is spectacular, but the reason for it is super unrealistic. They wouldn't have found a disc in such a mess. It would have been better if the spy had been put on a ship
Hidji
Hidji
23 Mar 00:08 # Show original
@New2018: the events in the Netflix version are very much accelerated, in the original a lot of scrap metal was dismantled for a long time and the timing is not a problem. They even took into account that the disk can be cut, but this will not affect the integrity of the data, since the nanowires are so thin that it can be restored without loss.
VVs7
VVs7
27 Mar 04:02 # Show original
What a happy traitor's face
ChrisRedfield
ChrisRedfield
28 Mar 14:16 # Show original
@Hidji: If the nanowires are so thin that the disk would remain intact, then everything else would have to remain intact.
Hidji
Hidji
28 Mar 15:04 # Show original
@ChrisRedfield: iii? If the rest of the cut is combined, it will be a complete molecular copy of the original, without loss. The integrity of the information on the media depends on the damage to the clusters. Nanofilaments do not cause damage, they open molecular bonds. In theory, even biological organisms remain alive and die from the fact that bodies disintegrate under the influence of external forces such as gravity. This has been used in science fiction for decades, I read books with similar weapons more than 30 years ago).
br1ella
br1ella
PRO
23 Mar 06:47 # Show original
@New2018: I liked this scene more in the Chinese version, it's more spectacular and realistic.
VVs7
VVs7
27 Mar 04:06 # Show original
If aliens want to destroy science on Earth, then why talk about their plans?
ShaMarinka
ShaMarinka
27 Mar 09:36 # Show original
@VVs7: They don't know how to lie, they say everything directly. And why not, there is nothing to oppose sophons.
KirindasRoman
KirindasRoman
01 Apr 03:51 # Show original
@br1ella: It turned out to be more intense there.
Dark_Punk
Dark_Punk
22 Mar 05:02 # Show original
In the book: we will kill the traitors of humanity and sacrifice a couple of innocent people.
Chinese TV series: We will kill the traitors of humanity, a bunch of maniacs and mercenaries.
Netflix: Let's dismember the children
vk775121
vk775121
23 Mar 20:30 # Show original
@Dark_Punk: I chet so in the voice of this comment ornul 🤣 🤣 🤣
ekrovyakov
ekrovyakov
24 Mar 23:58 # Show original
@Dark_Punk:

Well, they couldn't do without killing children on the Day of Anger.
What was the Indian watching relentlessly
unkle
unkle
04 Apr 14:32 # Show original
@ekrovyakov: What is the day of anger? Are you looking at the Goblin translation?
AtomicTroll
AtomicTroll
04 Apr 14:50 # Show original
@ekrovyakov: Judgment day.
musicliveinus
musicliveinus
08 Apr 01:10 # Show original
@unkle: HDrezka translated it that way for some reason
Rift
Rift
11 Apr 15:55 # Show original
@musicliveinus: I was also surprised by the translation, but "Day of Wrath" was taken from Olga Glushkova's translation, it is printed in a paper book ("The Task of three Bodies", Eksmo/fanzon, 2019).
b1oki
b1oki
17 Apr 22:52 # Show original
@Rift:
The text of the Franciscan monk about the Day of Judgment:

The Day of Wrath is this day, the day of sorrow and crowding, the day of desolation and ruin, the day of darkness and gloom, the day of clouds and mist, the day of trumpets and a shout of abuse against fortified cities and high towers.

reddit
reddit
22 Mar 11:28 # Show original
I don't quite understand how humans can overtake them in technology and science in 400 years, if the aliens have already advanced so far? Or did the aliens hit the ceiling of their knowledge and "only humans can surpass them"? After all, the aliens have their own intelligent computers and computing power, and in these 400 years they can move even further, in theory.
shiga_boom
shiga_boom
PRO
22 Mar 12:05 # Show original
But, first of all, they compared dynamics, such as from nuclear power to silicon computers, it took us only 50 years, and for them - let's say 500 or thousands of years — it doesn't matter. There was nothing to prevent it from developing with a "snowball" effect. Just because, and secondly, their cataclysms, incessant for years, forced them to sit stupidly in anticipation of a new, so-called era of Order. The most curious thing about the plot, as for me, was that it was impossible to move a single step in the era of Chaos. The author took as a basis a feature from celestial mechanics — the "three-body problem", which scientists tried hard to solve, but managed to find only special cases of solution. Actually, for the reason that there was no general logic to the essence of the matter. Now they have imposed on us these inexplicable conditions of existence, where it is unclear what is "up" and what is "down", for example. Try it, make a discovery, cheeky. Besides, they are unlikely to have gained immortality, since they are looking for a new shelter for themselves, and therefore most are in some kind of cryo-sleep while flying here.
Hidji
Hidji
23 Mar 00:12 # Show original
@reddit: in this version, they explained too superficially what dehydration is. In fact, if necessary, this race can fall into long-term suspended animation, completely draining their bodies. So all 400 years will fly by in the form of mummies. And it is unlikely that they will be able to promote science in suspended animation))).
Redopera
Redopera
28 Mar 23:29 # Show original
@Hidji: Your comment reminded me of the beginning of a completely different book: False Blindness
Hidji
Hidji
29 Mar 00:49 # Show original
@Redopera: I never got to Watts, and now I don't have time with these series all the time).
br1ella
br1ella
PRO
23 Mar 06:59 # Show original
@reddit: The aliens see how fast the technologies of earthlings are advancing by their standards, and in order to remove unnecessary risks, they sabotage science, quite logically.
jensenjar
jensenjar
22 Mar 23:17 # Show original
It's necessary to make the aliens angry with a fairy tale about little red Riding hood. I've never liked her either, but to be so triggered...
ViktoryMartini
ViktoryMartini
27 Mar 15:25 # Show original
Oru from the comment 😁
Lil-Lil
Lil-Lil
27 Mar 20:44 #
@jensenjar: вахахаха
Redopera
Redopera
28 Mar 23:26 # Show original
@jensenjar: Trisolarians are not capable of hiding thoughts from each other. That is, their thoughts are public, that is, they have no thoughts. They were horrified by the fact that people are able to close their thoughts from each other, and carry something else into the general ether. This is how it is said through a fairy tale. A lie about a liar.
Hidji
Hidji
23 Mar 00:50 # Show original
By the way, in the Chinese version, these events are approximately in the 28-29 series of 30))).
jensenjar
jensenjar
23 Mar 01:41 # Show original
@Hidji: They 've shortened the fable for nothing . if this series seems overstretched, then I imagine this is a Chinese sleeping pill.. or are there 20-minute episodes?
Hidji
Hidji
23 Mar 01:47 # Show original
@jensenjar: no, I watched one file for 22 hours.
ShaMarinka
ShaMarinka
25 Mar 19:55 # Show original
@jensenjar: No, 40 each. And I periodically skipped, because it is impossible. The details are detailed, and I, on the whole, liked the way they presented the book, but really, a third could have been thrown out.
zhosman-kinoman
zhosman-kinoman
PRO
31 Mar 01:01 # Show original
The Netflix version is like a trailer for a Chinese TV series or book))
Malsagov
Malsagov
23 Mar 01:43 # Show original
Epic ending)
IFaina
IFaina
23 Mar 01:46 # Show original
Comment has been deleted
Liza
Liza
24 Mar 18:47 # Show original
@IFaina: I didn't see the cat 😱
IFaina
IFaina
25 Mar 09:35 # Show original
He is first mentioned in conversation, and then shown for a second, but thank God, not in the context
McLom
McLom
25 Mar 12:31 # Show original
@Liza: so he had to survive, passed between the fibers as between droplets ))
Redopera
Redopera
28 Mar 23:19 # Show original
@IFaina: It's not a fact that he was offended. The distance between the nanowires was not chosen by chance. Think for yourself, if the goal was to save the discs with recordings, but it is necessary to kill the entire crew, then you need to maintain a distance between the threads. Otherwise, the media will fall under the distribution. This is another regular fakap of the showrunners, everything is thrown at the viewer's thinking.
Damassk
Damassk
29 Mar 01:24 # Show original
@Redopera: so even here, commentators say that the series is sometimes too slow and events do not develop, and this is provided that 5 episodes of Netflix fit into 29 episodes of Chinese. And you want to explain everything like the Chinese. Nowadays people are not ready to watch for so long) They need it to be spectacular, not logical
Hidji
Hidji
29 Mar 02:37 # Show original
@Damassk: I watched both and for me this version is no less tedious, but at the same time it is also annoying because of the jamb adaptation)
Damien
Damien
05 Apr 11:38 # Show original
Did I understand correctly that the entire first season is the 1st book, and Netflix has 8 episodes, and the Chinese has 30?
KirindasRoman
KirindasRoman
06 Apr 03:30 # Show original
@Damien: Netflix has 5 episodes for the first book, the rest are already for the Second Books
sad_targaryen
sad_targaryen
PRO
23 Mar 17:12 # Show original
The music is just a flame at the end
peculiarcharm
peculiarcharm
26 Apr 02:18 # Show original
@sad_targaryen: right here, the motives of the sound are very strongly reminded
vk775121
vk775121
23 Mar 20:30 # Show original
Doesn't my memory change that on the stage with you all bugs, the first book is over?
SmilePS
SmilePS
23 Mar 22:01 # Show original
@vk775121: The aliens in the book didn't care what people thought at all. They didn't brag about their strength like schoolchildren. People themselves came to the conclusion that they had a scribe, no one told them about it.

Well, yes, that was the end of the first book. I didn't read any more, but I watched a Chinese TV series.
sanaeva
sanaeva
24 Mar 13:51 # Show original
@vk775121: That's right, there was still an example with this thought, Wang Miao + Ye Wenzie returned to the pesto of the first Red Coast
egzo86
egzo86
Yesterday, 01:01 # Show original
@vk775121: it's strange that bug was translated as a bug. bug is a software error, for me this interpretation is more suitable
Hidji
Hidji
Yesterday, 02:44 # Show original
@egzo86: because mistakes have nothing to do with it, it was the insects that were meant. And then there's the Chinese author. Your example is relevant only for English.
a_banshee
a_banshee
24 Mar 00:35 # Show original
Kurva, I spent 22 years recovering my psyche after the opening scene of the "Ghost Ship". And now it's all over again!!
Liza
Liza
24 Mar 18:41 #
@a_banshee: 🤝
ViktoryMartini
ViktoryMartini
27 Mar 15:28 # Show original
Yes! I also caught these flashbacks
roman_belyaev
roman_belyaev
04 Apr 04:57 # Show original
@a_banshee: the ghost ship is generally resting))
yurkaaaa
yurkaaaa
24 Mar 02:29 # Show original
Here, a good series, but again not very thorough, all in a holopod, a lot of conventions and simplifications..
id972349034
id972349034
04 Apr 18:50 # Show original
@yurkaaaa: some lack action, others are too unreasonably delayed, others have too few details and somehow the narrative was accelerated by holop and somehow too much...
You read the comments and once again you are convinced how much the modern consumer is spoiled by the variety and amount of content, without realizing what he wants and in what proportions
id17385088
id17385088
18 Apr 08:50 # Show original
@id972349034: The best comment. And it applies to almost any series. I'm shaking your hand!
Liza
Liza
24 Mar 18:43 # Show original
It was tough with the ship, but then when I remembered who the creators were... Well, yes, everything is logical
I wonder how Auggie will bear this burden.
EmilD
EmilD
24 Mar 23:02 #
Comment has been deleted
AlexBest115
AlexBest115
PRO
25 Mar 02:42 # Show original
Grandma will destroy them because of her hatred of people, the alien told her not to answer
VVs7
VVs7
27 Mar 04:08 # Show original
It seems to me that Chinese woman Ye saw the light in the end
Redopera
Redopera
28 Mar 23:11 # Show original
@AlexBest115: Ye, to put it mildly, thought short-sighted, and her position did not allow her to be an intellectual. She took contact with aliens at face value and followed only her inner fantasies about them. The reality turned out to be much more unpleasant
MarkRaffer
MarkRaffer
31 Mar 21:15 # Show original
@Redopera: Where does intelligence come from anyway? There was a village, then they were sent to the backwoods for logging and back to the Chinese sharaga base. There is no intelligence and just mediocrity (well, if we talk about the global level). And resentment against all mankind, about which she knew nothing at all and could not know, since she judged by the Red guards.
And what is good about the Chinese thirty-hour version - that there is no, no, and the flawed Chinese-communist worldview and way of life is shown in passing... and it's like the saying about the girl and the village, so - it's impossible to deduce even now, in 2024, a village from a Chinese, but they're still under conceit. Such are the realities.
Redopera
Redopera
03 Apr 21:16 # Show original
@MarkRaffer: Red socks, why are you systematically ignored? Is there any background?
MarkRaffer
MarkRaffer
03 Apr 22:13 #
@Redopera: без понятия... но за последнюю неделю какой-то неуёмный фанатик с вот этих вот акков по минус сотне с каждого коврово прошёлся по моим комментариям и сколько он усилий на это потратил - мне даже сложно представить, но чем бы дитё не тешилось.
https://myshows.me/LibMind
https://myshows.me/Ololoshkas
https://myshows.me/RedBullking
https://myshows.me/qwertys
https://myshows.me/Klow
https://myshows.me/delux
https://myshows.me/Squo
https://myshows.me/Stirh
https://myshows.me/defdef
https://myshows.me/LinaFoxx
https://myshows.me/Mark_Miner
https://myshows.me/poiuyts
https://myshows.me/Yajuro
https://myshows.me/SagenSagen
id972349034
id972349034
04 Apr 18:54 # Show original
@MarkRaffer: Lol, what kind of crazy assholes there are.
MarkRaffer
MarkRaffer
04 Apr 22:44 # Show original
@id972349034: it turns out that there are... I wouldn't have believed it myself if anyone had said it, but the facts, as they say, are on the face!
Kentavr
Kentavr
07 Apr 05:09 # Show original
@MarkRaffer: ahaha, I wanted to like it, and it was only thanks to you that I learned that if you block someone, you can't rate them at all. Although I have no idea where we crossed paths, it became curious and I even looked on purpose to see if you were among those fools who massively minus all comments (one Vasya Kurolesov and a Drunken Hedgehog with a bunch of akks), because of which I had to close my profile so as not to interfere, and along the way I looked over the last year, the benefit of comments I don't have much, but there are no minuses or pluses, even in the comments there were no mutual answers.
MarkRaffer
MarkRaffer
07 Apr 15:50 # Show original
@Kentavr: so earlier, for absolutely no reason (in my opinion), you ignored my comments. Usually, if someone leaves a minus four or five, then I just send him to ignore, because where there are five, there may be a hundred. But if you are a decent user, then ok - unblocked.
Iamliam23
Iamliam23
30 Mar 03:35 # Show original
@AlexBest115: Grandma purely projected her mental problems onto all of humanity: like it's not able to solve its problems - so you're not able to solve your problems, not humanity.
Ytzin
Ytzin
PRO
25 Mar 05:36 #
Какой-то запредельный уровень бессмысленной но пафосной жестокости.
EmilD
EmilD
25 Mar 11:49 #
Не знал, что на майшоус удаляют комментарии с матом, ну ок, продублирую.
Сцена с кораблем просто жесть, давненько такого не видел на ТВ.
shelgunov
shelgunov
25 Mar 20:56 # Show original
I liked the Chinese series more. It's closer to the book and tastier."
RbICbKA
RbICbKA
26 Mar 13:20 # Show original
It was too cruel, and they also showed a severed child's leg. There were very little ones there. pzdc
ekrovyakov
ekrovyakov
26 Mar 20:37 #
@RbICbKA: Нетфликс такой Нетфликс: https://disk.yandex.ru/i/KWsEM4ogH6_jTw
albinka_
albinka_
26 Mar 21:17 # Show original
It seems to me that the motivations of the aliens are generally poorly clear from this series, it's just that the woman from the game told everything. In the book and even in the Asian version, the pumping was more interesting and the reasons for what was happening were better understood. In the Asian version, I also liked the visualization with billiards in one of the first series.
And it turns out that all the scientists were killed here and not they themselves were killed, or what?
RbICbKA
RbICbKA
27 Mar 10:02 # Show original
@albinka_: apparently someone was killed, but most of them themselves
Candramelekh
Candramelekh
PRO
27 Mar 11:22 # Show original
This series is still the best, straight bomb
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
28 Mar 06:48 # Show original
What happened to the ship in Russian?
yurkaaaa
yurkaaaa
28 Mar 10:13 # Show original
@vmerkalin99: so it seems like the script is fine) then everything should be clear)
RbICbKA
RbICbKA
28 Mar 10:27 # Show original
@vmerkalin99: nanofilaments were stretched over the beams and the ship was cut with them
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
28 Mar 14:43 # Show original
@RbICbKA: nanowires ? Clear
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
28 Mar 14:44 # Show original
@RbICbKA: thank you
Даня_
Даня_
03 Apr 02:35 # Show original
@vmerkalin99: Auggie has developed a nanofiber that cuts through objects at the molecular level, it was shown in the laboratory when she stopped her project to stop the timer.
The guys took advantage of the aliens' confusion, resumed the project, created a trap that cut the ship and everything on it into even slices. But because the incision is so precise, the ship's hull remained intact until the collision, and then just crumbled into these slices.
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
05 Apr 01:11 # Show original
@Даня_: I do not understand why people dislike, they are degenerates, I, as a person who does not know this universe, realized to me that it was fiber, later, because I do not think that such a technology exists, at least public knowledge, so it did not immediately reach me, and people are cretins dislike, I I've already figured out what it was
Даня_
Даня_
05 Apr 01:14 # Show original
@vmerkalin99: it just reads like outright sarcasm in response to a valid answer :)
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
05 Apr 01:16 # Show original
@Даня_: I'm in aher, I didn't say anything bad, plus, I'm watching a Chinese TV series now, the narration is smoother there, and in netflex, holopam across Europe
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
05 Apr 01:17 # Show original
@Даня_: Well, tell me, does such a technology exist? To immediately understand what is at stake, especially since little time was devoted to it, I do not deny, maybe I did not look carefully, but I get the impression that asking questions is taboo
Redopera
Redopera
09 Apr 18:07 # Show original
@vmerkalin99: I did not dislike you and did not enter into a dialogue with you. But you walked over me and touched me. Now tell me why.
yurkaaaa
yurkaaaa
09 Apr 18:40 # Show original
@Redopera: this is different)
Crow73
Crow73
09 Apr 20:41 # Show original
@Redopera: this "vmerkalin99" actually went through all the posts in a row in this discussion with cons)) So it's probably nothing personal... just an idiot)
albinka_
albinka_
10 Apr 15:38 # Show original
@vmerkalin99: The heroine develops nanowires from the most durable material on earth. We are shown her experiments, the aliens put pressure on her for several episodes to close the project, because this is a dangerous development for them. Then, for several episodes, the girl is persuaded to use these threads for the benefit of the state.
In the end, she agrees. It is located right on the ground where the ship is being cut by something. Hmmm. Let me think about it. What is it?? Perhaps by the power of her mind? Why didn't we say this point clearly in the film in the style of: Well, now we will cut the ship with these durable nanofilaments that you have developed, thank you;
Redopera
Redopera
10 Apr 18:02 # Show original
@yurkaaaa, @Crow73
Now this character has come to my page and has highlighted all my comments. Instead of a simple answer, throwing shit at strangers turned out to be the best defense. Oh, how! Take care of your honor.
P.S. by the way, it also seemed strange to me that this guy was bombarded with cons for the question. As a reader of the book, I noticed too quick summaries of the facts and omission of details in the series.
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
10 Apr 20:27 # Show original
@Redopera: first of all, it's obvious that you don't want to listen and hear and you, I mean, not specifically you. First of all, and secondly, what is the point? If any opinion that does not coincide with yours is ignored, so I decided it was pointless, since your worldview is based on grades, obviously I acted perhaps recklessly, but for that I made my dissatisfaction clear, and your jerking off to numbers remained more important, banal politeness at least not to offend another person. Again, it's not just about you.
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
10 Apr 20:28 # Show original
@Redopera: by the way, thank you for supporting me, even after I've liked you, I immediately see that your mind prevails. I will remove the dislikes and apologize to you personally.
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
10 Apr 20:32 # Show original
@Redopera: if it is forbidden to ask questions in our world in order to explore this world. And apparently it's better to pretend to be a person who knows the answer to everything. I don't want to live in such a world, and I will do anything to ruin at least the day of a person who thinks so.
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
10 Apr 20:33 # Show original
@Redopera: and the answer to your question sounds like this. When I tried to explain my position, I found disadvantages all the time. Accordingly, the strategy turned in a different direction.
Redopera
Redopera
10 Apr 21:46 # Show original
@vmerkalin99: Well, you did a great job coming out of the shadows! Your position is clear, thank you for responding. The rating was introduced by the developers, and the users have to solve everything. It's like in Yandex taxi, where you can't remove the rating, and then you think to whom your "hello, thank you for the trip and have a nice day " crossed the road.
Comrades @y0u @fleriana @ShaMarinka @Wils @AtomicTroll @altruist921 @unkle @Kookaburra @Halva33 @Darkproper88 @Weslian @scarcelyinside @forastero_83 @wowjugger @yurkaaaa @Dipset
Please review your grades taking into account all that has been said. We have an exactly solvable precedent here. As Da Shi said: I demand parity!
MarkRaffer
MarkRaffer
11 Apr 00:11 # Show original
@Redopera: that yes... You just have a wonderful list drawn up and everything is just as it should be.
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
11 Apr 04:01 # Show original
@Redopera: And yes, thank you, of course, but it wasn't necessary. And at the expense of getting lost, I come here exclusively to use the application for its intended purpose in terms of TV series / movies.
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
11 Apr 15:51 # Show original
@Redopera: You see, I answered, and again the cons flew, that's what I was talking about.
Crow73
Crow73
11 Apr 18:03 # Show original
@vmerkalin99: You know that you can see who is +/- betting here, right? And you've been giving dizs to everyone here, so the return is flying))

P.S. You can not remove diss from my posts, it's generally purple for this rating.
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
11 Apr 18:04 # Show original
@Crow73: from the xs phone, how to see, again, I announced what functionality I use
MarkRaffer
MarkRaffer
11 Apr 21:02 # Show original
@vmerkalin99: that is, you come in to give birth... Well, clearly! Zashim - in Igor, pzhlsta!
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
11 Apr 21:03 # Show original
@MarkRaffer: Making up facts is a disease, get treated
RbICbKA
RbICbKA
12 Apr 01:15 # Show original
@Redopera: for some reason, he slapped me with a minus for answering his question))
Redopera
Redopera
12 Apr 09:07 # Show original
@RbICbKA: That's it, I tried, but something went wrong..
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
12 Apr 17:35 # Show original
@Redopera: after our dialogue, I did nothing, I apologized only to you, it does not concern others
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
12 Apr 19:31 # Show original
@Redopera: What did you try? After our dialogue, I didn't do anything, but your colleagues continued, that's all
yurkaaaa
yurkaaaa
12 Apr 20:27 # Show original
@Redopera: I demand to demolish this amazing conference and send psychiatry to the organizer. There are already more posts here than on the topic.
The character was given a couple of cons, and then he slapped everyone, even those who are trying to answer his, frankly, debilitating question. As they say, if you spit at the team, the team will settle down. If the team spits at you, you'll drown.)
vmerkalin99
vmerkalin99
12 Apr 23:12 # Show original
Comment has been deleted
ChrisRedfield
ChrisRedfield
28 Mar 15:00 #
Тоесть инопланетяне, принявшие подобу людей, чтобы их не триггерить - это нормально, а переодевшийся волк - мы не понимаем, мы боимся!

Че?
Iamliam23
Iamliam23
30 Mar 03:39 # Show original
@ChrisRedfield: The point is that no matter how the aliens looked, they said everything head-on, because they are unfamiliar with such phenomena as lies due to the collective mind. And then they found out that people have individual consciousnesses and, accordingly, they can lie. That's what scared them.
Redopera
Redopera
28 Mar 22:56 # Show original
As stated, I will not compare the book with the serial adaptation, I will only touch on the general points. In this series, as many as 2 (!) important events were touched upon. The destruction of Doomsday is shown to be bloody and cruel. But they did not show a more terrible thing - how people came to such a conclusion. Da Shi is almost an extra in this series, castrated, sterilized. But it was his contradictory methods that could lead to such a decision in an intelligent society: "You won't like it."
The second and perhaps more important point is the creation of a sophon. I'm sorry, viewers, but you couldn't even enjoy the sophon creation process one iota. You've just been deprived of it. From my point of view, this is a disastrous fact, as opposed to the details of the dismemberment of the ship. The series meticulously shows how godlessly and forcibly the entire crew of the ship is destroyed. But it is not shown, sorry, the creation of sophon is fucked up. You can think about the fact that the Trisolarians just invented it on the fly. No, my friends, the games with Sophon's measurements led almost to the end of trisolaris, and it was important to show this.
flaxman
flaxman
02 Apr 09:37 # Show original
@Redopera: intrigued now. Can you describe in more detail what happened with its creation?
Redopera
Redopera
02 Apr 11:25 # Show original
@flaxman: I'll try not to spill spoilers here. The fact that sophons are in a state of quantum entanglement was told in the series. Sophon is an artificial intelligence, and for its functioning it was necessary to deploy an elementary particle (proton) into a 2-dimensional space so that some kind of circuitry could be created in it. Since a proton is an elementary particle, it is impossible to simply cram ready-made solutions into it. Trisolaris exists in the macrocosm, and the proton is deployed in the microcosm. Then the software is debugged and you can run the Sophon operating system. But before that, there were a number of unsuccessful experiments. In the particle accelerator, the proton was deployed to a different number of dimensions. From the perspective of Trisolaris, it was still the same proton, but from the internal perspective of the proton itself, the number of measurements complicated its structure and, roughly speaking, the proton already ceased to be an elementary particle, which means it could affect the macrocosm. The Trisolarians had a fly swatter for this case :)
And Sophon, as I wrote, already works under the operating system and can be deployed in any studied number of dimensions without consequences. At the same time, it remains an elementary particle with the mass of a proton. We created several Sophons and synchronized them.
ElenaPrekrasnaya
ElenaPrekrasnaya
29 Mar 01:41 # Show original
It is very difficult to watch the series, being one of the fans of the book ...
I condemn netflix for abandoning historical and scientific facts in favor of quick emotions, and even over children's corpses... There are no words, of course. To fit 13 hours into 5 episodes is powerful. But accepting that it was just fanfiction calmed me down a bit. The visual and the actors are very beautiful and only 2 stars for them.
The stupefaction of humanity is already too strong, if we encourage it, no one will have to take over 🙏
Iamliam23
Iamliam23
30 Mar 04:23 # Show original
If we consider the Trisolernian collective mind metaphorically, then the human mind is also in a sense collective: for example, if some human action acquires great success, it begins to exist not only as a thing in itself only for the author, but also for others, and at the same time the author does not control the fate of his creation in time at all (it can become popular for several years, maybe for decades, maybe for centuries). Authorship for popular things is generally erased: if you don't specifically study the issue, you don't know who created the tires or the microwave. Inventions simply become achievements of brands and culture in general.
Hidji
Hidji
30 Mar 04:38 # Show original
@Iamliam23: but this is metaphorical, and Trisolarians have a collective mindset without any allegories. Sometimes even their wars ended before they started, because one of the sides admitted defeat after seeing the strategy of the other. And the notorious dehydration is carried out instantly by the entire race, on the orders of their leader. They are like a colony of ants, where individuals act separately only away from the collective).
vlandus
vlandus
30 Mar 15:25 # Show original
I showed my colleague the moment of cutting the ship.
The first thing he asked was: what are these rods made of, that their nano-thread does not take?
jensenjar
jensenjar
30 Mar 17:25 #
@vlandus: если есть нанонити то есть и наноткань - ею обмотали штанги
ingwarr
ingwarr
04 Apr 10:33 # Show original
@vlandus: in the full version, this point was clarified: at the ends of the thread, they are thickened to such a size that the fastening is not damaged.
lyubanya_movies
lyubanya_movies
31 Mar 16:06 # Show original
The joke about Mexican tequila is the best 🤣
GonReborn
GonReborn
01 Apr 11:37 # Show original
Events are moving faster than I thought, this series was very interesting. I wonder how they will try to hide from these safons, on the other hand, everything that was in the previous series has always been known to aliens, they just look at people's attempts to somehow protect themselves and laugh from this.
sviraman
sviraman
PRO
01 Apr 15:19 # Show original
The mission: steal critical data from the ship, which is stored in unknown places and in what form

solution: on the move, cut the entire ship into pasta using quantum nanomagy invented three days ago, which has never been tested on such a scale, and find a miraculously surviving hard drive among the wreckage

Brilliant, for God's sake
Даня_
Даня_
03 Apr 02:37 # Show original
@sviraman: well, not three days ago, it was invented, but tested yes, apparently, immediately in combat conditions on a ship
00rainbow00
00rainbow00
PRO
05 Apr 02:15 # Show original
Yes, yes, I was also amused by the moment when I miraculously found the surviving disk 😄
Даня_
Даня_
03 Apr 02:40 # Show original
Madam, how cool the scene with the ship was shot. They showed everything, they didn't hesitate at all. It's very tough, but this combination is just amazing.
sensodellavita
sensodellavita
28 Apr 23:56 # Show original
@Даня_: still, they were embarrassed. Fortunately, the death of children does not directly get into the frame. in general, I absolutely do not welcome the fact that according to the scenario, a school and a playground were added on board. It's just tin..
AtomicTroll
AtomicTroll
04 Apr 01:39 # Show original
Pure vibes, the movie Ghost ship
JohnnyWick
JohnnyWick
PRO
06 Apr 14:25 # Show original
Perhaps this episode is the most spectacular of the entire series! 💥
Overall, the series is good! 👍
Crow73
Crow73
06 Apr 15:13 # Show original
To put it mildly, a strange decision with the cutting of the ship. Imho, even if a missile hit, the chance that the data carrier would survive would be higher. And it was possible to organize a random collision with another ship without any nanowires at all, so that Judgment Day would get a hole and slowly begin to sink. The sectarians would have evacuated their tablets first of all, and then they would have been accepted.
MDHouse
MDHouse
08 Apr 22:31 # Show original
These are the weird Netflix screenwriters. In the Chinese series, as in the book, the military was faced with the task of getting whole discs, but so that Evans' team and he did not have time to do anything with them. To do this, they organized a whole brainstorming session to find a solution to the problem. And nanofilaments are just useful for this. That's also why (Wang Miao) Augustine Salazar saw the countdown as a measure of intimidation.
Даня_
Даня_
09 Apr 01:50 # Show original
@MDHouse: But it was exactly what you described here.
albinka_
albinka_
10 Apr 15:42 # Show original
@Crow73: probably because a collision can be avoided, because another ship cannot approach swiftly and invisibly. And a rocket - well, it would be too noisy.
Crow73
Crow73
10 Apr 18:28 # Show original
@albinka_: Depending on which ship, tankers and bulk carriers have bad speed and sooo bad maneuverability. Collisions sometimes occur on the high seas. And the ship may run aground, including due to pilot error. As for missiles, they are also very different.
But you can't argue that the crash scene turned out to be spectacular.
Juvora
Juvora
07 Apr 16:15 # Show original
So far, people look like barbarians against the background of aliens
I understand E.
Iradakzlv
Iradakzlv
25 Apr 11:50 # Show original
Yes, yes. They mow down their own right and left.
S0N0FMAN
S0N0FMAN
07 Apr 17:34 # Show original
I knew that the whole dramatic resumption of the project is to press 1 button!
146% added a bunch of kids to be killed in this episode, which proves that the directors of Game of Thrones have mental deviations. You are the bugs yourself!
Darkproper88
Darkproper88
08 Apr 01:32 # Show original
The whole series is gorgeous. It's just a fairy tale with the ship, just like with the story about protons!
squark
squark
PRO
08 Apr 19:38 #
Эпичное уничтожение танкера. Было интересно, как экранизируют эту часть книги, справились достойно.
MDHouse
MDHouse
08 Apr 22:34 # Show original
A beautiful, bloodthirsty adaptation of Netflix and at the same time galloping across Europe, without explaining actions and deeds. It's good that I watched the Chinese version of the film adaptation first.
Gordey
Gordey
11 Apr 10:43 # Show original
Yeah.. the tanker was beautifully fucked up!! and their computers are cool, they should also have teeth and look like Langoliers!!
Master_Kyni
Master_Kyni
11 Apr 20:05 # Show original
A tin scene on a ship, reminiscent of a scene from a childhood movie "The Ghost Ship"
peculiarcharm
peculiarcharm
26 Apr 02:35 # Show original
What a drug-addicted face this girl has in the last scene.
ermigurt17
ermigurt17
28 Apr 01:13 # Show original
Each episode just keeps you on your toes 🔥
sensodellavita
sensodellavita
28 Apr 23:48 # Show original
Is the first book over for the 5th series?
They're walking briskly. It became fascinating straight away, but because of the speed, impressions are blurred.
Yes, we are bugs, but will anyone mention locusts?)
Ariassa
Ariassa
01 May 00:02 #
Нет времени объяснять, ты должна мне верить! Подумаешь, тыщу людей в процессе порезали. Огги дура или клиническая дура?
KostyaSib
KostyaSib
05 May 08:47 # Show original
What kind of disks what kind of carrier did it come from on the ship?
KostyaSib
KostyaSib
05 May 13:08 # Show original
And why did the old man communicate with extraterrestrials without delay?
KostyaSib
KostyaSib
05 May 13:35 # Show original
And I watched the whole episode.
Add a comment:
Ads