s01e05 — Judgment Day

@New2018: the events in the Netflix version are very much accelerated, in the original a lot of scrap metal was dismantled for a long time and the timing is not a problem. They even took into account that the disk can be cut, but this will not affect the integrity of the data, since the nanowires are so thin that it can be restored without loss.

@New2018: I liked this scene more in the Chinese version, it's more spectacular and realistic.

@Dark_Punk: I chet so in the voice of this comment ornul 🤣 🤣 🤣

@Dark_Punk:

Well, they couldn't do without killing children on the Day of Anger.
What was the Indian watching relentlessly

But, first of all, they compared dynamics, such as from nuclear power to silicon computers, it took us only 50 years, and for them - let's say 500 or thousands of years — it doesn't matter. There was nothing to prevent it from developing with a "snowball" effect. Just because, and secondly, their cataclysms, incessant for years, forced them to sit stupidly in anticipation of a new, so-called era of Order. The most curious thing about the plot, as for me, was that it was impossible to move a single step in the era of Chaos. The author took as a basis a feature from celestial mechanics — the "three-body problem", which scientists tried hard to solve, but managed to find only special cases of solution. Actually, for the reason that there was no general logic to the essence of the matter. Now they have imposed on us these inexplicable conditions of existence, where it is unclear what is "up" and what is "down", for example. Try it, make a discovery, cheeky. Besides, they are unlikely to have gained immortality, since they are looking for a new shelter for themselves, and therefore most are in some kind of cryo-sleep while flying here.

@reddit: in this version, they explained too superficially what dehydration is. In fact, if necessary, this race can fall into long-term suspended animation, completely draining their bodies. So all 400 years will fly by in the form of mummies. And it is unlikely that they will be able to promote science in suspended animation))).

@reddit: The aliens see how fast the technologies of earthlings are advancing by their standards, and in order to remove unnecessary risks, they sabotage science, quite logically.

Oru from the comment 😁

@jensenjar: вахахаха

@jensenjar: Trisolarians are not capable of hiding thoughts from each other. That is, their thoughts are public, that is, they have no thoughts. They were horrified by the fact that people are able to close their thoughts from each other, and carry something else into the general ether. This is how it is said through a fairy tale. A lie about a liar.

@jensenjar: I suspect any fairy tale would make them angry))) the concept itself...

Consider, for example, "The Wolf and the seven little goats." The wolf knocked on the goat's door and TOLD a LIE!)))) He said he was a goat!)))

@Hidji: They 've shortened the fable for nothing . if this series seems overstretched, then I imagine this is a Chinese sleeping pill.. or are there 20-minute episodes?

The Netflix version is like a trailer for a Chinese TV series or book))

@IFaina: I didn't see the cat 😱

@IFaina: It's not a fact that he was offended. The distance between the nanowires was not chosen by chance. Think for yourself, if the goal was to save the discs with recordings, but it is necessary to kill the entire crew, then you need to maintain a distance between the threads. Otherwise, the media will fall under the distribution. This is another regular fakap of the showrunners, everything is thrown at the viewer's thinking.

@sad_targaryen: right here, the motives of the sound are very strongly reminded

@vk775121: The aliens in the book didn't care what people thought at all. They didn't brag about their strength like schoolchildren. People themselves came to the conclusion that they had a scribe, no one told them about it.

Well, yes, that was the end of the first book. I didn't read any more, but I watched a Chinese TV series.

@vk775121: That's right, there was still an example with this thought, Wang Miao + Ye Wenzie returned to the pesto of the first Red Coast

@vk775121: it's strange that bug was translated as a bug. bug is a software error, for me this interpretation is more suitable

@a_banshee: 🤝

Yes! I also caught these flashbacks

@a_banshee: the ghost ship is generally resting))

@a_banshee: and the first part of the Cube?)

@yurkaaaa: some lack action, others are too unreasonably delayed, others have too few details and somehow the narrative was accelerated by holop and somehow too much...
You read the comments and once again you are convinced how much the modern consumer is spoiled by the variety and amount of content, without realizing what he wants and in what proportions

It seems to me that Chinese woman Ye saw the light in the end

@AlexBest115: Ye, to put it mildly, thought short-sighted, and her position did not allow her to be an intellectual. She took contact with aliens at face value and followed only her inner fantasies about them. The reality turned out to be much more unpleasant

@AlexBest115: Grandma purely projected her mental problems onto all of humanity: like it's not able to solve its problems - so you're not able to solve your problems, not humanity.

@RbICbKA: Нетфликс такой Нетфликс: https://disk.yandex.ru/i/KWsEM4ogH6_jTw

@albinka_: apparently someone was killed, but most of them themselves

I would say explosive

@vmerkalin99: so it seems like the script is fine) then everything should be clear)

@vmerkalin99: nanofilaments were stretched over the beams and the ship was cut with them

@ChrisRedfield: The point is that no matter how the aliens looked, they said everything head-on, because they are unfamiliar with such phenomena as lies due to the collective mind. And then they found out that people have individual consciousnesses and, accordingly, they can lie. That's what scared them.

@Redopera: intrigued now. Can you describe in more detail what happened with its creation?

@Iamliam23: but this is metaphorical, and Trisolarians have a collective mindset without any allegories. Sometimes even their wars ended before they started, because one of the sides admitted defeat after seeing the strategy of the other. And the notorious dehydration is carried out instantly by the entire race, on the orders of their leader. They are like a colony of ants, where individuals act separately only away from the collective).

@vlandus: if there is a nanofilament, then there is also a nanotube - they wrapped the rods with it.

@vlandus: in the full version, this point was clarified: at the ends of the thread, they are thickened to such a size that the fastening is not damaged.

@lyubanya_movies: And it sounds even thinner in English)

@sviraman: well, not three days ago, it was invented, but tested yes, apparently, immediately in combat conditions on a ship

Yes, yes, I was also amused by the moment when I miraculously found the surviving disk 😄

@Даня_: still, they were embarrassed. Fortunately, the death of children does not directly get into the frame. in general, I absolutely do not welcome the fact that according to the scenario, a school and a playground were added on board. It's just tin..

These are the weird Netflix screenwriters. In the Chinese series, as in the book, the military was faced with the task of getting whole discs, but so that Evans' team and he did not have time to do anything with them. To do this, they organized a whole brainstorming session to find a solution to the problem. And nanofilaments are just useful for this. That's also why (Wang Miao) Augustine Salazar saw the countdown as a measure of intimidation.

@Crow73: probably because a collision can be avoided, because another ship cannot approach swiftly and invisibly. And a rocket - well, it would be too noisy.

Yes, yes. They mow down their own right and left.

And why did the old man communicate with extraterrestrials without delay?

@Peony__: there are only three books, plus additional fan fiction that closes the topic and answers many questions, but the American version has already been pulled from both the second volume and the third... The Chinese 30-series is completely based on the first volume... and the second one is quite a light and simple fiction, without any such, but with good visionary and two or three good ideas, therefore, there is a sense to read, but even better - watch the Chinese version, and already read the second and third volumes, well, or listen. Igor Knyazev voiced it quite well.
False blindness is a real nuisance with signs of pseudophilosophy, which has little to do with real philosophy.

@Chilipizdrick: on the other hand, compare our 1800 and 2000. Progress in 200 years is greater than in the previous 2000. The second hundred is again much more progressive than the first. It's us who have slowed down over the last quarter of a century, it looks like the Internet is really affecting😅

@Master_Moriarty: so here are the inputs: they don't seem to have any goodwill. Despite this, they can communicate telepathically. It's a little weird for me. I suspect them of lying because they are familiar with the storytelling effect, and that girl on the ship was suspiciously similar to the one in the game. What is this but a lie? And they very quickly picked up on the metaphor of bugs, which broke all their logic that they do not accept lies. But of course, you might think that it just scared them, that people know how to hide their intentions. But it seems, from all of the above, they can do it there too. And then some nonsense happens.

3. Was the 3-body problem born on planet earth? Or is it no longer there? It's just that a scientist was aware of this mystery, and like they have such a task, the complexity of the aliens.. But how did this happen? What kind of coincidence? It was as if they had taken an unsolvable riddle on planet earth to study people's brains so that they could play with them more easily. When they arrive. And so it turns out that the technology is absolutely Fantastic, and they have been flying for 400 years. Also another oddity.

As for the woman who received the signal, it seemed to me that she knew what she was doing, like "Oh, well, you're bad, right? OK, I don't care, I think I'm going to spend my whole life here, so burn everyone here, they don't deserve to live, and then I thought she repented, but no, damn, she managed to think that they could come to an agreement. But.. Okay, okay, we reset the previous decisions, this is life. Everything is changing, it is understandable. But to decide to create a sect outright, knowing that it's still 400 years away. What kind of character and psyche should you have? Why the hell do you need it? If it was originally about anger, resentment. 40 years is too much, you won't have time to see anything, all the offenders will die. It already smells like an idea. It was as if something was maturing inside her. and it blossomed. considering that she was upset when she believed that the aliens were disappointed in this handful of people.